Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Hoagies and Hops Butler-Tarkington Menu

$Hoagie, Cheesesteak, Deli
4155 Boulevard Pl, Indianapolis, IN 46208
Order Online

  • Authentic PA Hoagies

    • Keystone

      d&w london broil, provolone, house horseradish mayo, lto.

    • Hog Island

      d&w black forest ham, salami, prosciutto, capicola, provolone, ltoo.

    • Brotherly Love

      d&w turkey & black forest ham, salami, provolone, ltoo.

    • Zern's

      sliced ring bologna, house red beet pickled egg, muenster, mayo, whole grain beer mustard, l.

    • Pitt Twist

      d&w black forest ham, provolone, house slaw, herr's chips, mayo.

    • Dutch Country

      seltzer's lebanon bologna, muenster, whole grain beer mustard, lt.

    • Market St

      d&w turkey & black forest ham, house slaw, muenster, 1000 island.

    • Shipyard

      house tuna salad, peppadew peppers, provolone, ltoo.

    • Reading Terminal

      italian marinated tomatoes, banana peppers, parmesan, provolone, ltoo.

    • Lancaster

      creamy cucumber dill, bacon bits, muenster, lt.

    • The "Always Sunny"

      bacon bits, d&w turkey, muenster, horseradish mayo, banana peppers, peppadew peppers, lt.

    • Ham

      d&w turkey, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, lt.

    • Turkey

      d&w turkey, choice of cheese, choice of sauce, lt.

  • Cheesesteaks

    • The Traditional Cheesesteak

      with or without fried onions, whiz, american, provolone. add sharp provolone for extra.

    • The Traditional Chicken Cheesesteak

      with or without fried onions, whiz, american, provolone. add sharp provolone for extra.

    • Cheesesteak Hoagie

      provolone or american, mayo, lto.

    • Chicken Cheesesteak Hoagie

      provolone or american, mayo, lto.

    • The Very Best

      house spicy sauce made with american cheese & onion.

    • Philly Special

      sharp provolone, banana peppers, onion, tomatoes, hint of house spicy sauce, parmesan.

  • Nathan's all Beef Hot Dogs

    • Nathan's Hot Dog

      includes: ketchup, yellow mustard, relish.
      $5.85

    • Very Best Dog

      house spicy sauce, american, fried onions.
      $7.80

    • Whiz Dog

      cheez whiz, pepper relish.
      $7.80

    • Dutch Dog

      smoked lebanon bologna, muenster, horseradish mayo, pickle.
      $8.18

    • Phreedom Dog

      nathan's hot dog topped with ribeye, fried onions, cheez whiz & pepper relish.
      $10.13

    • Chilly Dawg

      beer chili & cheese made with chilly water brew - built to last pilsner
      $8.70

  • Vegetarian/Vegan Options

    • Vegan Italian "Sausage" On A Sausage Bun

      soy & plant based sausage with italian seasonings, grilled onions & sweet peppers topped with our house spicy sauce.
      $9.74

    • Vegan Spinach Wrap

      house blood orange ipa hummus, broccoli rabe, pepper relish, tomatoes, raw onions.
      $10.39

    • Little It's Veggie

      sauteed broccoli rabe, onions, pepper relish, sharp provolone, house italian oil, parm.
      $11.04

  • PA Sides & Snacks

    • Herr's Chips

      regular, bbq, sour cream & onion, jalapeno kettle, habanero ranch.
      $2.85

    • Nan's Red Skin Potato Salad

      grandmothers recipe.
      $2.59

    • Crinkle Cut Fries (Side)

      $4.02

    • Crinkle Cut Fries (Basket)

      $7.14

    • Bacon & Beer Cheese Fries

      $9.09

    • Veggie Crinkle Cut Fries

      tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, beer cheese.
      $9.09

    • Cheesesteak Crinkle Cut Fries

      sliced ribeye, whiz and fried onions.
      $11.56

    • Chili Cheese Fries

      $9.74

    • D & W Whole Deli Pickle

      $3.37

    • House Coleslaw

      $2.59

    • Creamy Cucumber Dill

      $2.59

    • PA Dutch Box

      ring bologna, lebanon bologna, muenster cheese, bread, salted butter, whole grain beer mustard, pickled red beet egg.
      $18.19

    • Onion Rings (Side)

      $5.19

    • Onion Rings (Basket)

      $8.18

    • Peppadew Pepper Shooters (2)

      prosciutto & provolone, splash of balsamic.
      $1.68

    • House Red Beet Pickled Eggs (2)

      $3.50

    • Blood Orange IPA Hummus Basket

      chilly water brewing blood orange ipa hummus, cucumbers, garlic toast and cheese cubes.
      $9.74

  • Shredded Salads

    • Valley Forge Salad

      shredded lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, onion, peppadew peppers or banana peppers, parmesan.
      $7.09

    • Mr Nittany Salad

      shredded lettuce, tomato, cucumber, tuna and parmesan.
      $10.13

  • Extras

    • Peppadew Peppers

      $1.16

    • Banana Peppers

    • Fried Long Hot Peppers

      $1.16

    • Whole Cherry Peppers

    • Sweet Pickled Beets

      $1.03

    • Cheese

      $1.03

    • Sharp Provolone

      $1.29

    • Bacon Bits

      $1.68

  • Beverages

    • Fountain Drinks

      $3.11

    • Flavored Craft Sodas - Glass Bottles

      $3.90

    • Pellegrino

      $4.55

  • Plates & Plasticware

    • Paper Plate

    • Plastic Utensils

    • Plate & Utensil Setup

  • Kids Menu

    • Grilled Hot Dog

      comes with fries & kids fountain drink.
      $8.05

    • Turkey & Cheese Hoagie

      american cheese, comes with fries & kids fountain drink.
      $8.05

    • Ham & Cheese Hoagie

      american cheese, comes with fries & kids fountain drink.
      $8.05

    • Grilled Cheese With American

      comes with fries & kids fountain drink.
      $8.05

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms