Hillary's Chicago Pizza Menu

4.6
(325+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Cheese/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our signature thin crust, cut in squares. One size, 12 inch only BYO- choose your own toppings
      $16.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, sauce and crispy crust. Sharing size cut in 6 slices. BYO add your own toppings, no half toppings.
      $25.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese in our signature crispy crust. Personal size
      $16.00
    • Italian Beef Sandwich

      Our house made Italian beef, sliced thin, french roll and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers or both.
      $14.00
    • Hillarys Hot Honey - Thin Crust Pizza

      A mash up of Chicago and St. Augustine Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, provolone , finished with house made datil honey
      $22.00
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      Warm, crusty bread topped with garlic and cheese. Available in half or full order.
      $6.00+
    • The Chicago - Thin Crust Pizza

      The Chicago- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion
      $22.00
    • Greek Salad - Full

      Romaine, tomato, sweet peppers, artichoke, cucumbers, kalamata olives, feta cheese
      $15.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion personal size
      $19.00
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine, croutons, fresh shaved parmesan, and our key lime caesar dressing
      $6.00+
  • Chicago Style - 12Inch Thin Crust Pizza

    • Cheese/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our signature thin crust, cut in squares. One size, 12 inch only BYO- choose your own toppings
      $16.00
    • The Chicago - Thin Crust Pizza

      The Chicago- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion
      $22.00
    • Italian Beef - Thin Crust Pizza

      Thin sliced Italian beef, green peppers and spicy giardiniera
      $22.00
    • White Pie - Thin Crust Pizza

      Garlic oil ricotta base, mozzarella, provolone, parmesan
      $20.00
    • Hillarys Hot Honey - Thin Crust Pizza

      A mash up of Chicago and St. Augustine Pepperoni, goat cheese, mozzarella, provolone , finished with house made datil honey
      $22.00
    • Meat Lover's - Thin Crust Pizza

      Marinara Base, Pepperoni, Sausage, Italian Beef, Ham, bacon
      $25.00
    • Pesto's Favorite - Thin Crust Pizza

      Pesto base, spinach, cherry tomatoes, provolone/mozzarella blend, topped with a balsamic glaze.
      $25.00
    • Fancy Fungi - Thin Crust Pizza

      Garlic oil base, goat cheese, mozzarella, provolone, cremini mushrooms, prosciutto and finished with arugula and truffle oil
      $25.00
    • Salt Run BBQ Brisket - Thin Crust Pizza

      Local Salt Run BBQ smoked brisket, bbq sauce base, blue cheese crumbles, crimini mushrooms, caramelized onions, mozzarella, provolone
      $25.00
    • Spicy Pineapple - Thin Crust Pizza

      chicken, pineapple, jalapeno, bacon, red onion, Sea witch pepper potion drizzle
      $25.00
    • Vegan Cheese/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our signature vegan dough rolled out thin, 12 inch size only, vegan cheese BYO - add your own toppings.
      $18.00
    • Gluten Free Cheese/BYO - Thin Crust Pizza

      Our 10 "gluten free crust is cauliflower-based. There is a small amount of parmesan, so it is not vegan. BYO - add your own toppings.
      $14.00
  • Chicago Style - Deep Dish Pizza

    • Heart Pizza

      The Sweetheart special, sharing size deep dish.
      $25.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone cheese in our signature crispy crust. Personal size
      $16.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      Our blend of spinach and ricotta, topped with mushrooms
      $18.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion personal size
      $19.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      MFW- Italian sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, green pepper, onion
      $20.00
    • Italian Sub - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      A layer of mozzarella + provolone, salami, ham, pepperoni, topped with more mozzarella and provolone, giardianara baked in our deep dish crust then finished with lettuce, tomato, banana peppers and house vinaigrette dressing
      $18.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, sauce and crispy crust. Sharing size cut in 6 slices. BYO add your own toppings, no half toppings.
      $25.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, layered with a spinach ricotta mix, toped with baby bella mushrooms and our house sauce.
      $35.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion - Sharing size feeds 2-3 cut in 6 slices
      $33.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Sharing Size

      The MFW- Italian Sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, green pepper, onion. Sharing size, feeds 2-3 cut in 6 slices
      $35.00
    • Vegan BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Personal Size

      Our signature vegan crust, Violife cheese, house sauce. BYO- choose toppings
      $16.00
    • Cheese/BYO - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, sauce and crispy crust. Family size, feeds 3-6, cut in 8 slices. BYO add your own toppings, no half toppings.
      $30.00
    • Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      A blend of mozzarella and provolone, layered with a spinach ricotta mix, toped with baby bella mushrooms and our house sauce. Family size feeds 3-6, cut in 8
      $40.00
    • The Works - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      The Works- Italian sausage, mushroom, green pepper, onion - Family size feeds 3-6 cut in 8 slices
      $38.00
    • MFW - Deep Dish Pizza: Family Size

      The MFW- Italian sausage, pepperoni mushroom, green pepper, onion. Family size feeds 3-6, cut in 8 slices.
      $40.00
  • Sandwiches

    • Italian Beef Sandwich

      Our house made Italian beef, sliced thin, french roll and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers or both.
      $14.00
    • Italian Sausage Sandwich

      An Italian sausage link, and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers, or both.
      $10.00
    • Combo Sandwich

      3oz of our house made Italian beef, thinly sliced, an Italian sausage link, and your choice of hot giardiniera, sweet peppers, or both.
      $16.00
    • Meatball Sub

      3 3oz scratch made pork and beef meatballs, our marinara, provolone and mozzarella cheese on a toasted Turano french roll, served with chips
      $14.00
  • Appetizers

    • Pretzel and Beer Cheese

      Shareable pretzel with a side of our homemade beer cheese.
      $11.00
    • Pretzel and Mustard

      Soft pretzel typically served with house-made mustard.
      $11.00
    • Bruschetta Crostini

      Tomatoes tossed in vinaigrette, served on crostini (tiny toasts), topped with feta and a balsamic glaze.
      $9.00
    • Goat Cheese and Marinara

      Our marinara with dollops of goat cheese. Served warm with a side of crostini (tiny toasts)
      $10.00
    • Meatballs

      3 ounce house made meatballs, pork and beef, marinara
      $9.00+
    • Charcuterie Board

      Small board 3 cured meats, 3 premium cheeses, and additional accompaniments
      $18.00
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      Warm, crusty bread topped with garlic and cheese. Available in half or full order.
      $6.00+
  • Salads And Soup

    • Garden Salad

      Romaine, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, sweet peppers
      $6.00+
    • Caesar Salad

      Romaine, croutons, fresh shaved parmesan, and our key lime caesar dressing
      $6.00+
    • Greek Salad - Full

      Romaine, tomato, sweet peppers, artichoke, cucumbers, kalamata olives, feta cheese
      $15.00
  • Desserts

    • Pistachio Cheesecake

      Rich chocolate and peanut butter cheesecake typically includes layers of creamy cheesecake, chocolate ganache, and peanut butter cups.
      $8.00
  • Sides And Extras

    • Chips (Plain Lays)

      Classic Lay's potato chips, lightly salted for a simple, satisfying crunch.
      $2.00
    • Side of Giardiniera

      Mixed fresh vegetables and jalapeño peppers marinated in white wine vinegar, olive oil, and Italian spices.
      $1.00
    • Side of Red Sauce

      Rich tomato sauce. Available in small or large size.
      $0.50+
    • Side of Hot Honey

      A sweet and spicy honey typically infused with chili peppers, perfect for adding a kick to your favorite dishes.
      $2.00
    • Side of Truffle Oil

      Truffle oil, ideal for drizzling over dishes, typically adds an earthy aroma and rich flavor.
      $2.00
    • Side of Pepper Potion

      Sautéed mixed peppers with a blend of Italian herbs and spices.
      $2.00
    • Extra Side Of Jus

      Rich, savory jus for enhancing your meal.
      $2.00
    • Extra Salad Dressing

      Choice of vinaigrette, ranch, creamy garlic, or key lime Caesar dressing for your salad.
      $0.75
    • Extra Wing Sauce (On The Side)

      A tangy and spicy wing sauce typically made with hot peppers, vinegar, and garlic. Perfect for adding an extra kick to your meal.
    • Extra Crostini

      Crostini bread typically served with olive oil and herbs.
      $1.00
    • Extra Beer Cheese

      A creamy cheese dip typically made with beer, offering a rich and tangy flavor.
      $1.00
  • Specials And Event Tickets

    • Brushes n Brews

      Typically includes an art session paired with a selection of Italian appetizers and beverages.
      $35.00
  • Charcuterie Board

    • Cheese + Fruit Tray (8-10)

      Assortment of cheeses and seasonal fruits, typically accompanied by nuts and crackers.
      $50.00
    • Meat Tray (8-10)

      Assortment of cured Italian meats, typically including prosciutto, salami, and coppa, complemented by olives and condiments.
      $60.00
    • Sweet + Savory Board (8-10)

      Assortment of cured meats and cheeses, complemented with olives, seasonal fruits, nuts, fig jam, and crostini.
      $150.00
  • Salad

    • Garden Salad - Small (8-12)

      Mixed greens with choice of vinaigrette, creamy garlic, Caesar, or ranch dressing. Optional 4oz chicken breast addition or no dressing choice. Suitable for 8-12 people.
      $45.00
    • Garden Salad - Large (15-20)

      Vinaigrette, Creamy Garlic, Caesar, Ranch. Optional 4oz chicken breast or no dressing.
      $60.00
    • Chopped Salad W/ Chicken - Small (10-12)

      Chopped salad with chicken breast, serves 10-12. Includes options for vinaigrette, creamy garlic, Caesar, ranch dressings, or no dressing.
      $60.00
    • Chopped Salad W/ Chicken - Large (15-20)

      Vinaigrette, creamy garlic, Caesar, ranch, or none. Option to add extra chicken breast. Serves 15-20.
      $75.00
    • Caesar Salad - Small (8-12)

      Romaine lettuce, croutons, Parmesan cheese. Choice of dressing and optional 4oz chicken breast.
      $45.00
    • Caesar Salad - Large (15-20)

      Crispy romaine, Parmesan, croutons. Choice of dressing or add 4oz chicken breast. Serves 15-20.
      $60.00
    • Greek Salad - Small (8-12)

      Feta, olives, cucumber, tomatoes, red onion. Optional add-ons like Vinaigrette, Creamy Garlic, Caesar, Ranch dressings, or 4 oz chicken breast.
      $55.00
    • Greek Salad - Large (15-20)

      Vinaigrette, Creamy Garlic, Caesar, Ranch, or no dressing. Option to add chicken breast.
      $70.00
    • Add Chicken - Small

      Vinaigrette, Creamy Garlic, Caesar, Ranch, or No Dressing.
      $20.00
    • Add Chicken - Large

      Vinaigrette, Creamy Garlic, Caesar, Ranch. Add 4oz Chicken Breast if desired.
      $35.00
  • Soup

    • Italian Wedding Soup Quart

      Mini meatballs, spinach, carrots, and pastina in a savory chicken broth.
      $12.00
  • Sandwich Trays

    • Italian Beef - Small (10-20)

      10 Full size sandwiches 4 lbs of sliced Italian beef, jus sweet peppers or giardinieria 10 Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      $120.00
    • Italian Beef - Large (15-30)

      15 Full size sandwiches 6 lbs of sliced Italian beef, jus sweet peppers or giardinieria 15 Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      $220.00
    • Italian Sausage + Peppers - (Small 10-20)

      12 Full size sandwiches 7 inch Italian sausage links, sweet peppers Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      $120.00
    • Italian Sausage + Peppers - Large (15-30)

      17 Full size sandwiches 7 inch Italian sausage links, sweet peppers Turano rolls Can be ordered assembled or served in aluminum pan
      $220.00
    • Italian Cold Cut on Focaccia - Small (10-12)

      Assorted Italian cold cuts, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, and Italian dressing on focaccia bread.
      $120.00
    • Italian Cold Cut on Focaccia - Large (15-20)

      Assorted Italian cold cuts, provolone cheese, tomatoes, and arugula on focaccia bread.
      $220.00
  • Pasta

    • Spaghetti and 15 Meatballs - Small (8-10)

      Spaghetti pasta with 15 meatballs in marinara sauce, topped with parmesan cheese and fresh basil.
      $45.00
    • 3 Meat Lasagna - Small

      Layers of pasta, veal, beef, and pork, combined with ricotta and marinara sauce, then baked with a topping of parmesan cheese.
      $85.00
    • 3 Meat Lasagna - Large

      Layers of pasta, veal, beef, and pork, combined with ricotta, parmesan, and marinara sauce.
      $170.00
    • Vegetarian Lasagna - Small

      Layers of pasta, spinach, mushrooms, zucchini, and ricotta cheese, topped with marinara sauce and baked.
      $75.00
    • Vegetarian Lasagna - Large

      Layers of pasta, spinach, mushrooms, zucchini, ricotta, and tomato sauce, topped with melted cheese.
      $150.00
    • Spinach - Ricotta Stuffed Shells (24 pieces)

      Spinach and ricotta stuffed pasta shells, typically baked in marinara sauce and topped with cheese.
      $60.00
  • Merchandise

    • HCP Koozie

      Handy drink holder for beverages. Available in single or double quantity.
      $3.00+
    • Bottle of Sea Witch Pepper Potion #4

      A unique pepper sauce, typically includes a blend of spices and peppers. Ideal for adding a kick to your favorite Italian dishes.
      $9.00
    • Sweeter Seat (Single)

      A single seat cushion, typically plush and comfortable, designed for a sweeter dining experience.
      $25.00
    • Sweeter Seat (Two for $40)

      A delightful set of two seats for $40, typically includes a cozy ambiance for enjoying your Italian dining experience.
      $40.00

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

McDonald's
McDonald's
3.2
(1,777 Reviews)
Breakfast, Coffee shop, Hamburger
D'Aleo Italian Deli
D'Aleo Italian Deli
4.8
(563 Reviews)
Deli
End Zone Sports Bar & Billiards
End Zone Sports Bar & Billiards
4.3
(236 Reviews)
Bar, Dart bar, Dive club
STA Nutrition
STA Nutrition
4.9
(131 Reviews)
Juice shop, Health food
Ned's Southside Kitchen
Ned's Southside Kitchen
4.7
(2,280 Reviews)
American, Seafood, Southern
Huey Magoo's Chicken Tenders - St. Augustine
Huey Magoo's Chicken Tenders - St. Augustine
4.4
(536 Reviews)
Chicken, Family
Mi Carnal Restaurant
Mi Carnal Restaurant
4.6
(574 Reviews)
Mexican, Latin American, Salvadoran
Brazas chicken Peruvian restaurant
Brazas chicken Peruvian restaurant
4.7
(210 Reviews)
Peruvian
Wawa
Wawa
4.0
(43 Reviews)
Breakfast, Cafe, Coffee shop
Kaliburger
Kaliburger
4.7
(398 Reviews)
Restaurant, Vegan

(904) 209-5960

1974 US1, St. Augustine, FL 32086


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms