Guerriero Gelato & Cakes Menu

4.5

(475+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Cheesecakes Cups, Pints & Quarts Novelties and Sandwiches Shakes and Drinks Ice Cream Cakes Ice Cream Pies

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
  Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
  $4.99
- Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
  Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
  $10.99
- Italian Ice (Cups)
  $4.29
- Build Your Own Breezy
  Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
  $7.49
- (Ice Cream) Milkshake
  Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
  $7.49
- Gelato (Cups)
  2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
  $5.35
- Soft Serve Cups
  Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
  $4.68
- Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
  2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
  $12.99
- Brownie Sundae
  A warm David's Brownie with 2 scoops of your choice, one topping, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $6.99
- Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
  $8.99
Cheesecakes
- Stock Cheesecakes (same day)
  6" or 8" cheesecakes. Choice of Pumpkin, Strawberry, or Vanilla Bean (The OG).
  $19.95
Cups, Pints & Quarts
- Build Your Own Breezy
  Layered Soft Serve with toppings in a shake cup.
  $7.49
- Cookie Monster Breezy
  Vanilla soft serve ice cream layered with Oreos and cookie dough.
  $7.49
- FAT TUESDAY: Italian Ice Pint
  $8.99
- GG Mystery Box (4 Pints) *
  4 Random Pints of Limited Specialty Flavorings. Featuring flavors like Grapenut, Passionfruit Cheesecake, Cereal Milk, and more. The 4 pints are completely random, no choices or notes will be accepted! What fun is the mystery if you know what's coming!
  $25.00
- Gelato (Cups)
  2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
  $5.35
- Gelato (Pints and Quarts)
  2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
  $12.99
- Hard Ice Cream (Cups)
  Our classic homemade hard ice cream.
  $4.99
- Hard Ice Cream (Pint and Quart)
  Slow churned, high butterfat ice cream. Winner of Best Ice Cream in Morris & Essex County.
  $10.99
- Italian Ice (Cups)
  $4.29
- Italian Ice (Pints and Quarts)
  $8.99
- Mystery Pint
  A Random Pint of one of our limited time flavors.
  $5.99
- Oreo Fudge Breezy
  Vanilla soft serve ice cream layered with fudge and Oreo topping.
  $7.49
- SF (Cups)
  Our same recipe, but made with Splenda.
  $5.35
- SF (Pints and Quarts)
  2019 Winner Best Gelato in North America. #7 Ranked Gelato in the world recognized in Italy by the official Gelato Festival.
  $11.50
- Snicker Breezy
  Chocolate soft serve ice cream layered with Caramel & PB cups.
  $7.49
- Soft Serve Cups
  Soft Serve Ice Cream in a cup,
  $4.68
- Stanley (40oz)
  Creamy vanilla ice cream with rich chocolate swirls and crunchy cookie pieces.
  $10.00
- Triple Chocolate Breezy
  Chocolate soft serve layer with fudge and crunches.
  $7.49
- Twisted M&M Breezy
  Chocolate & Vanilla Swirl soft serve ice cream layered with fudge and M&M's.
  $7.49
- Verdi Bulk
  This Gelato is Creamy, Smooth, and just a delicious as our regular ice cream but completely plant based, dairy free, and vegan. We call it "Verdi" which means green in italian! Made with Ripple Plant Milk.
  $9.99
Novelties and Sandwiches
- 6 Pack IC Sandwich
  6 pack of ice cream sandwiches made with soft serve ice cream.
  $11.50
- Brownie Sundae
  A warm David's Brownie with 2 scoops of your choice, one topping, whip cream, and a cherry.
  $6.99
- Mini Chips (dozen)
  One Dozen Mini Chip sandwiches featuring our nut free house baked chocolate chips.
  $18.95
- Mini Cones (15 pk)
  A package of 15 mini Vanilla, Chocolate, and Strawberry Cones dipped in White, Dark, and Ruby Chocolate.
  $19.95
- Mini Monsters (dozen)
  A package of one dozen mini sandwiches made with cookie monster ice cream.
  $18.95
- Mini Oreos (one dozen)
  One Dozen Mini Oreo Cookie Sandwiches.
  $16.95
Shakes and Drinks
- (Ice Cream) Milkshake
  Classic Milkshakes made with ice cream.
  $7.49
- Bottle of Water
  16.9oz bottle of water
  $1.50
Ice Cream Cakes
- Baci Cake (Same Day)
  These cakes come in Hazelnut and Chocolate Hazelnut but are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
  $38.95
- Cookie Monster Cake (Same Day)
  These cakes come in Cookie Monster and are just one flavor with no middle filling, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
  $38.95
- Mint Oreo Cake (Same Day)
  Mint Oreo ice cream, with Oreos in the middle, sweet mint whip cream, decorated to match the flavor. 8" cake serves 12-14.
  $38.95
- Prepacked Quarts
  Quarts packed directly from our batch freezer to preserve the highest quality,
  $9.99
- Stock Cakes (Same Day)
  Nut Free - Vanilla & Chocolate with Fudge and Crunchies, decorated the way you would like! (flavors cannot be changed)
  $28.95
- Strawberry Shortcake (Same Day)
  4 layers. ice cream, preserves, pound-cake, and vanilla ice cream. 8" cake serves 12-14.
  $38.95
Ice Cream Pies
- Coffee Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
  Coffee Oreo Ice Cream, house-made brownie bottom, ltopped with fresh chocolate whip cream, Oreos, espresso pillows, and chocolate drizzle.
  $24.95
- Death by Peanut Butter Pie
  Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of peanut butter, layer of choc. peanut butter ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, peanut butter cups, peanut butter, and chocolate drizzle.
  $24.95
- Mint Oreo Explosion Brownie Pie
  Our new Pies start with a fresh baked brownie bottom, layer of fudge, layer of ice cream, topped with fresh whip cream, Oreos, and chocolate drizzle. Available in Vanilla or Mint.
  $24.95