Greiner's SubShop Menu

4.1

(800+ Reviews)

$Sandwich shop

Customer Favorites SWEETS Hot Cold Pizza Wings and Things Fries Bread Sticks Mac Genie Mac & Cheese

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Fries
  One size fits all.
  $4.75
- Owen's Philly Cheese Steak
  Our Famous Philly Cheese Steak , the same since 1969.
  $13.95
- Ray's 1969 Hoagie
  Genoa salami, beef salami, ham and provolone cheese. We recommend that you get this fixed up “old school” - lettuce, onion, tomato, pepperoncini, oregano, oil + vinegar, salt, and pepper. Oh, snap.
  $14.95
- The Hot Toddy
  Momma was hungry when she made this one . Meat,Meat and more Meat. Turkey , Pepperoni, Ham, Cappicola, Cheddar Cheese and Jalapeno Cheese toasted on house made bread. Not for the weak of heart You're welcome.
  $13.95
- Mr. Turkey
  Our hand sliced turkey with provolone – not complicated. adding bacon is extra. This lovely ensemble is put on our house made bread. You won't forget this sammie. We promise.
  $13.95
- Baker's BLT
  This is a BLT that you will remember to get from us and not make at home. GENEROUS amounts of bacon, lettuce and tomato. We suggest mayo, but ... the choice is yours.
  $13.95
- Meat Head's Meatball
  Meat Balls and Cheese, how can you go wrong? ALL ON OUR HOUSE MADE BREAD AND HOT FROM THE OVEN!
  $14.95
- The Original Genie
  crumbs, sour cream, bacon.
  $9.50
- Hot Wilbur's Ham and Cheese
  Our fresh sliced ham and provolone all melted on our homemade bread. This is one Piggy you want to come home
  $13.95
- Stuffed Breadsticks-Fennel Sausage or Pepperoni (3 Pieces)
  Stuffed breadsticks, choice of fennel sausage or pepperoni. Served in threes.
  $13.99
SWEETS
- SCOUT'S SEA SALT BROWNIE
  Okay. Let's talk. This is the locally famous Scout's Sea Salt Brownie. If it were the girl at school, she would receive Miss Congeniality. If it was the guy on the football team, he would be the team captain. Rumor is, there is a cult following with this piece of sweet treasure. It's on your bucket list. You just didn't know.
  $5.00
Hot
- Owen's Philly Cheese Steak
  Our Famous Philly Cheese Steak , the same since 1969.
  $13.95
- Truman's Mushroom Steak
  Our Steak with home made Mushroom Gravy VOTED #1 CHEESESTEAK IN INDIANA BY BLACKSTONE GRILLS. This served on our locally famous and toasted house made bread.
  $14.95
- Lucy's Pizza Steak
  Our Steak and Cheese with marinara sauce On our Fresh Bread. VOTED #1 CHEESESTEAK IN INDIANA BY BLACKSTONE GRILLS.
  $14.95
- BBQ Chicken
  Shredded Chicken Breast covered in BBQ Sauce and all warmed up and toasted to greatness. TOASTED IN OUR OVEN WITH PROVOLONE MOZZARELLA CHEESE!
  $13.95
- Meat Head's Meatball
  Meat Balls and Cheese, how can you go wrong? ALL ON OUR HOUSE MADE BREAD AND HOT FROM THE OVEN!
  $14.95
- Not Your Hot Pocket Stromboli
  Fresh Ham and Sausage together with our marinara sauce on our house made bread made fresh daily! THERE IS NO SHORTAGE OF PROVOLONE MOZZARELLA CHEESE ON THIS BAD BOY!
  $14.95
- Bridget's Pizza Burger
  An old GREINER'S classic from 1969. Fresh burger mixed with our marinara sauce and our secret spices. Toasted with provolone mozzarella to absolute perfection. And yes, it comes on our fresh baked housemade bread. We suggest very few toppings... but suit yourself!
  $13.95
- Not Your Totino's Pepperoni & Cheese
  Lots of Pepperoni and Cheese covered in our marinara sauce. Not shy on pepperoni. Baked on our house made fresh bread.
  $12.95
- Luke's Country Sausage & Cheese
  This is an old classic from 1969. Country Sausage finely chopped and topped with provolone mozzarella cheese. Baked in the oven on our locally famous house made GREINER'S bread... like no other. Dressed how ever you want it.
  $13.95
- Audrey's Gyro
  Lamb and beef on pita bread. Topped with lettuce, onion, tomato, and a generous amount of tsaziki sauce.
  $12.95
- Baker's BLT
  This is a BLT that you will remember to get from us and not make at home. GENEROUS amounts of bacon, lettuce and tomato. We suggest mayo, but ... the choice is yours.
  $13.95
- Mother Clucker Chicken
  Baked shredded chicken breast and provolone cheese melted on top of fresh baked bread. We suggest mayo... but you decide. Perhaps top with lettuce and tomato...?
  $13.95
- Madeline's Italian Beef
  Sliced Roast Beef soaked in a Au jus with Provolone cheese toasted to perfection on our House Made Bread.
  $13.95
- The Hot Toddy
  Momma was hungry when she made this one . Meat,Meat and more Meat. Turkey , Pepperoni, Ham, Cappicola, Cheddar Cheese and Jalapeno Cheese toasted on house made bread. Not for the weak of heart You're welcome.
  $13.95
- Hot Wilbur's Ham and Cheese
  Our fresh sliced ham and provolone all melted on our homemade bread. This is one Piggy you want to come home
  $13.95
Cold
- Ray's 1969 Hoagie
  Genoa salami, beef salami, ham and provolone cheese. We recommend that you get this fixed up “old school” - lettuce, onion, tomato, pepperoncini, oregano, oil + vinegar, salt, and pepper. Oh, snap.
  $14.95
- Mary's Chicken Salad
  Lovely chicken breasts, red onion, celery, our special seasonings with a secret mayo. Enjoy this on our house made bread with provolone cheese.
  $13.95
- The Tina Tuna
  Named after our beloved Tina that has worked here since 1970 something. Albacore tuna mixed with a deluxe mayo, celery, red onion + special seasoning. And, oh... this goes on our locally famous house made bread with provolone cheese. Oh. Yum.
  $12.95
- Claire's Veggie Head
  Provolone cheese, lettuce, onions, olives, banana peppers, mushrooms, tomatoes, cucumbers, vinegar + oil, salt + pepper. This lovely ensemble is made with our house made bread.
  $13.95
- Mr. Turkey
  Our hand sliced turkey with provolone – not complicated. adding bacon is extra. This lovely ensemble is put on our house made bread. You won't forget this sammie. We promise.
  $13.95
- Fat Head Salami
  Hand slice salami with provolone – not complicated. This lovely combo is on our locally famous house made bread. You. Will. Love. It. Sometimes simple is best. Suggest lettuce, olive oil, salt an pepper. But you can pick your own toppings.
  $13.95
- Wilbur's Ham
  Remember that ham at some Aunt's house for Easter dinner? Well, this is a throwback. Hand sliced with provolone cheese. You can get this sammie hot or cold. The choice is yours. You will love it either way.
  $12.95
- Delicious Rob's Roast Beef
  The highest grade thin sliced roast beef topped with provolone cheese. This little wonder is on our locally famous house made bread. Doesn't need much in the name of toppings. We suggest mayo. You choose. Either way. You will live happily ever after.
  $13.95
Pizza
Please allow 5 minutes ( and maybe a little more).
- 4 Cheese
  a generous blend of mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, and parmesan cheese seasoned with oregano.
  $12.95
- Double Pepperoni
  juicy pepperoni and lots of it.
  $12.95
- Italian Sausage
  some of indy’s best fennel sausage covered with provolone and mozzarella cheese.
  $12.95
- Veggie
  mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives with provolone, and mozzarella cheese.
  $12.95
- BBQ
  grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, onions, jalapeños, mozzarella, provolone, and cheddar cheese.
  $12.95
- Deluxe
  fennel sausage, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, green peppers, onions, olives, provolone, and cheddar cheese.
  $12.95
Wings and Things
- Chicken Wings
  Choose from 5, 10, 20, or 40. Available in Naked and Afraid, Pepperoncini Chipotle Buffalo Honey BBQ Teriyaki Blue Cheese EXTRA coins. Ranch EXTRA coins.
  $9.95
Fries
- Fries
  One size fits all.
  $4.75
Bread Sticks
- Stuffed Breadsticks-Fennel Sausage or Pepperoni (1 Piece)
  Stuffed breadsticks filled with either fennel sausage or pepperoni.
  $3.98
- Stuffed Breadsticks-Fennel Sausage or Pepperoni (3 Pieces)
  Stuffed breadsticks, choice of fennel sausage or pepperoni. Served in threes.
  $13.99
Mac Genie Mac & Cheese
- The Original Genie
  crumbs, sour cream, bacon.
  $9.50
- Buffalo Genie
  crumbs, chicken, in a buffalo sauce + blue cheese.
  $9.50
- Naked and Afraid
  From the locally famous food truck, The Mac Genie Truck Est. 2012, enjoy our locally famous mac+cheese! Once you meet and eat, you will live happily ever after.
  $9.50