Great American Cookies and Marble Slab Creamery Menu

4.8

(24 Reviews)

Customer Favorites Limited Time Only Create Your Own Cookie Cake Birthday Winter & Holidays & New Years Thanksgiving & Fall Sports School & Grad Ice Cream Classic Favorites Cookies & Brownies Shakes Sundaes Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Double Doozies® (1 Doozie®)
  The Double Doozie® is made with our delectable icing sandwiched between your favorite cookies.
  $6.39
- Cookie Cake by the Slice
  A slice of our signature Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake topped with your choice of chocolate or vanilla icing.
  $6.39
- Fudge Brownie Sundae
  Vanilla Ice Cream with fudge brownie pieces and fudge, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
  $9.73
- Ice Cream Cups
  Our small batch Ice Cream, made fresh in-store daily. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
  $7.69
- Dude, You're Old - B1041
  $54.56
- Balloons - B1030
  $54.56
- Hand-Packed Pints
  Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
  $12.98
- Coffee Shake
  Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and coffee mixture topped with whipped cream and Hershey’s® chocolate syrup.
  $9.73
- Cookies & Cream Shake
  Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Oreo® cookie pieces, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and crushed Oreo® cookies.
  $9.73
- Cotton Candy Shake
  Marshmallow cream swirl and Blue Cotton Candy Ice Cream topped with whip cream and mini M&M’s®.
  $9.73
- Brownies (1 Brownie)
  $5.09
- Create Your Own Cookie Cake
  Create your perfect cookie cake! Choose your favorite cookie cake shape and flavor, then customize your message with any of our icing colors. For an additional charge, add a design or extras!
  $54.56
Limited Time Only
- Red Velvet Hot Cocoa Cookie
  A classic red velvet cookie with a hint of hot cocoa and topped with fluffy mini marshmallows.
  $3.24
- Chocolate Chip Cookie with Red & Green M&M’S
  Our classic original chocolate chip cookie made with M&M'S candies, featuring the holiday red & green M&M'S.
  $3.24
Create Your Own Cookie Cake
- Create Your Own Cookie Cake
  Create your perfect cookie cake! Choose your favorite cookie cake shape and flavor, then customize your message with any of our icing colors. For an additional charge, add a design or extras!
  $54.56
Birthday
- Island Birthday - B1045
  $54.56
- Tractor - B1046
  $54.56
- Unicorn - B1048
  $54.56
- Happy Birthday Dump Truck - B1036
  $54.56
- Balloons - B1030
  $54.56
- Dude, You're Old - B1041
  $54.56
Winter & Holidays & New Years
- Happy New Year - HW2903
  $54.56
Thanksgiving & Fall
- Thankful Grateful Blessed - HF2659
  $54.56
Sports
- Go Team Helmet - S3506
  $41.99
- Goal! - S3505
  $41.99
- Football Field - S3504
  $41.99
- Score Basketball - S3509
  $41.99
- Good Luck Team Baseball - S3508
  $41.99
School & Grad
- Congratulations Grad! - S3005
  $54.56
- Back To School - S3404
  $54.56
- Grad Class of 2024 - S3024
  $54.56
- Hats off to the Grad! - S3009
  $54.56
- We Love Elementary - S3405
  $54.56
- Class of 2024 Diploma - S3023
  $54.56
Ice Cream
- Hand-Packed Pints
  Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
  $12.98
- Ice Cream Cups
  Our small batch Ice Cream, made fresh in-store daily. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
  $7.69
- Hand-Packed Quarts
  Take the ice-cream experience home with you. Choose your favorite Ice Cream Flavor and FREE Mix-Ins to create infinite Ice Cream possibilities!
  $21.99
Classic Favorites
- Cookies & Cream
  Sweet Cream Ice Cream, Oreo® Cookie Pieces & Mallo Creme.
  $7.69
Cookies & Brownies
- Double Doozies® (1 Doozie®)
  The Double Doozie® is made with our delectable icing sandwiched between your favorite cookies.
  $6.39
- Cookie Cake by the Slice
  A slice of our signature Original Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake topped with your choice of chocolate or vanilla icing.
  $6.39
- Regular Cookies (1 Cookie)
  $3.24
- Brownies (1 Brownie)
  $5.09
Shakes
- Cotton Candy Shake
  Marshmallow cream swirl and Blue Cotton Candy Ice Cream topped with whip cream and mini M&M’s®.
  $9.73
- Cookies & Cream Shake
  Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Oreo® cookie pieces, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and crushed Oreo® cookies.
  $9.73
- Coffee Shake
  Hershey’s® chocolate swirl, Sweet Cream Ice Cream and coffee mixture topped with whipped cream and Hershey’s® chocolate syrup.
  $9.73
- Snickers Shake
  Caramel swirl, Snickers®, and Sweet Cream Ice Cream topped with whipped cream, Hershey’s® chocolate syrup, and crushed Snickers ® bar.
  $9.73
- Strawberry Shake
  Marshmallow cream swirl and Strawberry Ice Cream topped with whipped cream and garnished with a strawberry.
  $9.73
- Create Your Own Shake
  Create your own Ice Cream Shake. Choose your favorite Ice Cream and Mix-Ins like fruit, candy bars, fudge, cookies, nuts, and more.
  $9.73
Sundaes
- Strawberry Shortcake Sundae
  Sweet Cream Ice Cream, yellow cake pieces, and strawberry syrup, topped with whipped cream and fresh strawberries.
  $9.73
- Fudge Brownie Sundae
  Vanilla Ice Cream with fudge brownie pieces and fudge, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
  $9.73
- Classic Sundae
  Vanilla ice cream with choice of fudge or caramel, topped with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, and a cherry.
  $9.73
Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
- Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich
  $8.22