Gotham's Deli Menu

224 E Market St, Smithfield, NC 27577

Customer Favorites Breakfast Sides Breakfast Breakfast Sandwiches Breakfast Plates Fresh Made Salads Turkey Sandwiches Ham Sandwiches Veggie Sandwiches Chicken Sandwiches Roast Beef Sandwiches Signature Sandwiches Italian Sandwich Hot Dogs Boxed Lunches Sides Kids Menu Desserts Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Reuben Sandwich
  Corn beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, mustard or Russian on rye. Hot.
  $10.61
- 2 Eggs, Hash Brown with Toast Plate
  Choice of bacon or sausage.
  $10.39
- Scotti Sandwich
  3 eggs, sausage, bacon, American cheese.
  $8.44
- 2 Oakley's French Toast Plate
  Pan Fried bread.
  $8.44
- 2 Bodie's Pancakes Plate
  Not small.
  $8.44
- Mr Met Sandwich
  Turkey, roast beef, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Cold.
  $10.36
- Side Salad
  Freshly made salads are made daily.
  $5.00
- Marco Polo Sandwich
  2 eggs, bacon, American cheese.
  $7.14
- Brooklyn Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, bacon, Muenster, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Sadie Sandwich
  2 eggs, turkey, Swiss cheese.
  $7.14
Breakfast Sides
- Hashbrowns
  Grated potatoes pan-fried until crispy, typically seasoned with salt and pepper.
  $4.99
- Side of Sausage
  Cooked sausage, often made from pork or beef, typically includes seasoned ground meat wrapped in a casing.
  $3.99
- Side of Bacon
  Smoked and crispy strips of bacon, typically served as a savory breakfast side.
  $4.99
Breakfast
All bagels come toasted.
- Lexly Bagel
  Ham and American cheese.
  $7.14
- Bryce Bagel
  Comes with cream cheese. Jelly available upon request. White plain bagel.
  $4.67
- Jimbo Bagel
  Peanut butter and jelly.
  $5.84
- Eli Bagel
  Ham, cream cheese, onions.
  $7.14
- Ashley Bagel
  Turkey, avocado, Swiss.
  $7.14
- Cash Bagel
  Bacon and cheese.
  $7.14
- Jake Bagel
  Pastrami, Swiss, mustard.
  $7.14
- Celeste Bagel
  Turkey, cream cheese, tomalo.
  $7.14
Breakfast Sandwiches
Served on a toasted kaiser roll with butter, salt and pepper (can put on wrap, toast, or hero). Add drink for an additional charge.
- Mikayla Sandwich
  2 eggs, American cheese.
  $7.14
- Dallin Sandwich
  2 eggs, ham, American cheese.
  $7.14
- Marco Polo Sandwich
  2 eggs, bacon, American cheese.
  $7.14
- Jessica Sandwich
  2 eggs, roast beef, pepper Jack cheese.
  $7.14
- Uptown Sandwich
  2 eggs, sausage, American cheese.
  $7.14
- Sadie Sandwich
  2 eggs, turkey, Swiss cheese.
  $7.14
- 102 Sandwich
  2 egg, pastrami, pepper Jack cheese.
  $7.14
- Arianna Sandwich
  2 eggs, sausage, gr. Chili pepper Jack.
  $7.14
- Buffalo Egg Sandwich
  2 eggs, chicken, pepper Jack, hot sauce.
  $7.14
- Scotti Sandwich
  3 eggs, sausage, bacon, American cheese.
  $8.44
- Emily Sandwich
  2 eggs, onions, peppers, tomato, American cheese.
  $7.14
Breakfast Plates
Eggs cooked anyway except poached.
- 2 Bodie's Pancakes Plate
  Not small.
  $8.44
- 2 Oakley's French Toast Plate
  Pan Fried bread.
  $8.44
- 2 Eggs, Hash Brown with Toast Plate
  Choice of bacon or sausage.
  $10.39
- Western Omelet with Toast Plate
  Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
  $9.22
- Veggie Omelet with Toast Plate
  Beaten eggs that are folded over a filling.
  $8.44
Fresh Made Salads
Comes with choice of dressing.
- Greek Salad
  Romaine, tomato, red onion, olives, cucumber, feta, Italian spices with side Greek vinaigrette.
  $11.69
- Hail Caesar Salad
  Romaine, shaved Parmesan, chicken.
  $12.34
- Ty Cobb Salad
  Romaine, chicken, bacon, feta, red onion, tomato, cucumber.
  $12.34
- Chef Salad
  Romaine, turkey, ham, provolone, tomato, cucumber, red onion, mushroom.
  $12.34
- The Big Apple Salad
  Romaine, chicken, tomato, red onion, pecans, feta, apple.
  $12.34
- East Hampton Salad
  Romaine, chicken, avocado, Swiss, tomato, cucumber.
  $12.34
- The Island Salad
  Romaine, chicken, red onions, roasted red peppers, pepper Jack and cheddar cheese, avocado, tomatoes.
  $12.34
- Grand Central Salad
  Romaine mozzarella, tomato, cucumbers, provolone, ham capicola, salami, sun-dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers and pepperoncini.
  $12.34
- Soho Salad
  Chicken salad, romaine, tomato.
  $12.34
- Tuna Salad
  Tuna, romaine, tomato, cheddar.
  $12.34
Turkey Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Brooklyn Sandwich
  Turkey, bacon, Muenster, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- Brooklyn Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, bacon, Muenster, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Hampton Bays Sandwich
  Turkey, avocado, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo (hot or cold).
  $9.11
- Hampton Bays Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, avocado, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Gotham Sandwich
  Turkey, mushrooms, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- Gotham Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, mushrooms, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Rachel Sandwich
  Turkey, sauerkraut, Swiss, Russian, or mustard on rye. Hot.
  $9.11
- Rachel Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, sauerkraut, Swiss, (Russian or mustard) on rye. Hot.
  $14.73
- Gimbels Sandwich
  Turkey, smoked provolone, onion, lettuce, tom, honey mustard. Hot.
  $9.11
- Gimbels Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, smoked provolone, onion, lettuce, tom, honey mustard. Hot.
  $14.73
- Sky King Sandwich
  Turkey, Muenster, coleslaw, BBQ, hot sauce, tomato. Hot.
  $9.36
- Sky King Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, Muenster, coleslaw, BBQ, hot sauce, tomato. Hot.
  $14.98
- Maria Sandwich
  Turkey, chicken, green chilies, pepper Jack, salsa or ranch, lettuce, tomato on wheat.
  $10.11
- Maria Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, chicken, green chilies, pepper jack, salsa or ranch, lettuce, tomato on wheat.
  $15.73
- The 7 Line Sandwich
  Turkey, breaded chicken, cream cheese, provolone, lettuce, tomato.
  $10.11
- The 7 Line Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, breaded chicken, cream cheese, provolone, lettuce, tomato.
  $15.73
Ham Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Tri-City Sandwich
  Ham, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- Tri-City Sandwich Combo
  Ham, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Yanks Sandwich
  Ham, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- Yanks Sandwich Combo
  Ham, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo (hot or cold).
  $14.61
- The 5th Sandwich
  Ham, mushrooms, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- The 5th Sandwich Combo
  Ham, mushrooms, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot or cold.
  $14.73
- Broadway Joe Sandwich
  Ham, turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot.
  $9.11
- Broadway Joe Sandwich
  Ham, turkey, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot.
  $14.73
Veggie Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- The Garden Sandwich
  Lettuce, tomato, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, cucumbers, avocado, mayo on wheat bread.
  $8.73
- The Garden Sandwich Combo
  Lettuce, tomato, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, cucumbers, avocado, mayo on wheat bread.
  $14.36
- Cyclones Sandwich
  Swiss, cheddar, smoked provolone, lettuce, avocado, tomato, mayo.
  $9.36
- Cyclones Sandwich Combo
  Swiss, cheddar, smoked provolone, lettuce, avocado, tomato, mayo.
  $14.98
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich
  Provolone, American on toasted sourdough. Hot.
  $8.11
- Grilled Cheese Sandwich Combo
  Provolone, American on toasted sourdough. Hot.
  $13.73
Chicken Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Parm Sandwich
  Breaded Chicken, Mozzarella, Marinara, Butter, Garlic Salt on toasted Roll.
  $8.61
- Parm Sandwich Combo
  Chicken cutlet, mozzarella, butter marinara sauce, garlic salt. Hot.
  $14.23
- The Joker Sandwich
  Chicken cutlet, turkey, pepper jack, onions, jalapeño, Sriracha, mayo, lettuce, tomato.
  $10.61
- The Joker Sandwich Combo
  Chicken cutlet, turkey, pepper jack, onions, jalapeño, Sriracha, mayo, lettuce, tomato.
  $16.23
- Buffalo Sandwich
  Chicken cutlet, cream cheese, pepper jack, ranch or blue cheese, hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, sourdough. Hot.
  $9.86
- Buffalo Sandwich Combo
  Chicken cutlet, cream cheese, pepper jack, ranch or blue cheese hot sauce, lettuce, tomato, sourdough. Hot.
  $15.48
- Amazin's Sandwich
  Chicken cutlet, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo or ranch. Hot.
  $10.61
- Amazin's Sandwich Combo
  Chicken cutlet, bacon, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo or ranch. Hot.
  $16.23
- Soho Sandwich
  Chicken salad, lettuce, tomato on sourdough. Cold.
  $10.61
- Soho Sandwich Combo
  Chicken salad, lettuce, tomato on sourdough. Cold.
  $16.23
- Cabbie Sandwich
  Grill chicken, roast peppers, lettuce, American, tomato, mayo. Hot.
  $9.98
- Cabbie Sandwich Combo
  Grill chicken, roast peppers, lettuce, American, tomato, mayo. Hot.
  $15.61
- Urban Legend Sandwich
  Chicken cutlet, turkey, cream cheese, pepper Jack, bacon, BBQ, lettuce, tomato.
  $11.23
- Urban Legend Sandwich Combo
  Chicken cutlet, turkey, cream cheese, pepper jack, bacon, BBQ, lettuce, tomato.
  $16.86
Roast Beef Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Nets Sandwich
  Roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, bell pepper, mayo, oil and vinegar or mustard. Hot or cold.
  $9.11
- Nets Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, bell pepper, mayo, oil and vinegar or mustard. Hot or cold. Served with chips.
  $14.73
- BBQ Sandwich
  Roast beef, cheddar, BBQ sauce, tomato, mayo, pickles. Hot.
  $9.11
- BBQ Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, cheddar, BBQ sauce, tomato, mayo, pickles. Hot.
  $14.73
- The Jorgensen Sandwich
  Roast beef, mushroom, onion, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot.
  $9.11
- The Jorgensen Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, mushroom, onion, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Hot.
  $14.73
- NYC Sandwich
  Roast beef, pepper jack, feta, onions, bell pepper, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil and vinegar. Hot.
  $9.98
- NYC Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, pepper jack, feta, onions, bell pepper, lettuce, tomato, mayo, oil and vinegar. Hot.
  $15.61
- G-Men Sandwich
  Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, horseradish. Cold.
  $8.98
- G-Men Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, Swiss, lettuce, tomato, horseradish. Cold.
  $14.61
- Jersey Shore Sandwich
  Roast beef, provolone, mustard on rye. Cold.
  $8.98
- Jersey Shore Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, provolone, mustard on rye. Cold.
  $14.61
Signature Sandwiches
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Brass Knuckle Sandwich
  Pastrami, cheddar, mozzarella, mushrooms, olives, lettuce, tomato, mayo on sourdough toasted. Hot.
  $10.73
- Brass Knuckle Sandwich Combo
  Pastrami, cheddar, mozzarella, mushrooms, olives, lettuce, tomato, mayo on sourdough toasted. Hot.
  $16.36
- King City Sandwich
  Pastrami, Swiss, coleslaw, Russian. Hot.
  $10.48
- King City Sandwich Combo
  Pastrami, Swiss, coleslaw, Russian. Hot.
  $16.11
- The Post Sandwich
  Pastrami, cheddar, coleslaw, BBQ on toasted rye. Hot.
  $10.48
- The Post Sandwich Combo
  Pastrami, cheddar, coleslaw, BBQ on toasted rye. Hot.
  $16.11
- Mr Met Sandwich
  Turkey, roast beef, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Cold.
  $10.36
- Mr Met Sandwich Combo
  Turkey, roast beef, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Cold.
  $15.98
- Reuben Sandwich
  Corn beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, mustard or Russian on rye. Hot.
  $10.61
- Reuben Sandwich Combo
  Corn beef, sauerkraut, Swiss, mustard or Russian on rye. Hot.
  $16.23
- Tuna Sandwich
  Tuna fish, lettuce, tomato.
  $10.61
- Tuna Sandwich Combo
  Tuna fish, lettuce, tomato.
  $16.23
- Tuna Melt Sandwich
  Tuna fish, provolone, lettuce, tomato, on toasted rye. Hot.
  $10.61
- Tuna Melt Sandwich Combo
  Tuna fish, provolone, lettuce, tomato, on toasted rye. Hot.
  $16.23
- BLTA Sandwich
  Whole. Bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo on toasted sourdough.
  $9.98
- BLTA Sandwich Combo
  Whole. Bacon, lettuce, tomato, avocado, mayo on toasted sourdough.
  $15.61
- Hudson Sandwich
  Ham, turkey, Muenster, bacon, slaw, Russian, toasted rye. Hot.
  $10.23
- Hudson Sandwich Combo
  Ham, turkey, Muenster, bacon, slaw, Russian, toasted rye. Hot.
  $15.86
- Dr. K Sandwich
  Pastrami, turkey, cheddar, onion, mayo, mustard, on rye. Hot or cold.
  $10.23
- Dr. K Sandwich Combo
  Pastrami, turkey, cheddar, onion, mayo, mustard, on rye. Hot or cold.
  $15.86
- Dark Knight Sandwich
  Roast beef, turkey, ham, pastrami, Muenster, onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Cold.
  $12.11
- Dark Knight Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, turkey, ham, pastrami, Muenster, onions, pickles, lettuce, tomato, mayo, mustard. Cold.
  $17.73
Italian Sandwich
Sandwiches made on a Hero roll, unless specified. Combo includes drink and choice of side.
- Italian Sandwich
  Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, onions, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato,mayo, oil and vinegar. Cold.
  $9.98
- Italian Sandwich Combo
  Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, onions, banana peppers, lettuce, tomato,mayo, oil and vinegar. Cold.
  $15.61
- Torpedo Sandwich
  Ham, capicola, salami, provolone, American, butter, garlic salt, toasted. Hot.
  $9.98
- Torpedo Sandwich Combo
  Ham, capicola, salami, provolone, American, butter, garlic salt, toasted. Hot.
  $15.61
- Bauer Ave Sandwich
  Roast beef, capicola, pepper jack, feta, onions, banana pepper, lettuce, tomato,mayo, oil and vinegar. Hot or cold.
  $10.48
- Bauer Ave Sandwich Combo
  Roast beef, capicola, pepper jack, feta, onions, banana pepper, lettuce, tomato,mayo, oil and vinegar. Hot or cold.
  $16.11
- Pizza Sub
  Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, onions, mushrooms, marinara, butter. Hot.
  $10.48
- Pizza Sub Combo
  Ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, onions, mushrooms, marinara, butter. Hot.
  $16.11
- Meatball Sandwich
  Meatball, mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, marinara. Hot.
  $9.48
- Meatball Sandwich Combo
  Meatball, mozzarella, cheddar, Parmesan, marinara. Hot.
  $15.11
- Balboa Sandwich
  Capicola, chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot.
  $9.98
- Balboa Sandwich Combo
  Capicola, chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato, mayo. Hot.
  $15.61
Hot Dogs
- Mookie Hot Dog
  Sauerkraut, onions, secret sauce or mustard.
  $6.07
- Windy City Hot Dog
  Celery salt, jalapeño, tomato, pickle, relish, yellow mustard.
  $6.07
- Spartans Hot Dog
  Bacon, cheddar, onion, secret sauce.
  $6.07
- The Babe Hot Dog
  Coleslaw, secret sauce.
  $6.07
- Simple Hot Dog
  Comes with ketchup.
  $6.07
- Bacon Hot Dog
  Bacon, cream cheese, mustard.
  $6.23
- P Dawg Hot Dog
  Pastrami, mustard.
  $6.23
Boxed Lunches
Lunches includes 6" sandwich, big bag of chips, big cookie (fresh baked) and can drink.
- Brooklyn Sandwich Lunch Box
  Turkey.
  $14.36
- Hampton Bays Sandwich Lunch Box
  Turkey. Served with Lay's Potato chips.
  $14.36
- Yanks Sandwich Lunch Box
  Ham.
  $14.36
- The Garden Sandwich Lunch Box
  Veggie.
  $14.36
- Cyclones Sandwich Lunch Box
  Veggie.
  $14.36
- Nets Sandwich Lunch Box
  Roast beef.
  $14.36
- Italian Sandwich Lunch Box
  Mix - 3 meat.
  $14.98
- Mr Met Sandwich Lunch Box
  Mix - signature.
  $14.98
Sides
- Chips
  Thinly sliced crispy potato.
  $2.57
- Pickles
  Pickled cucumber that has been preserved.
  $2.57
- Side Salad
  Freshly made salads are made daily.
  $5.00
- Side of Bacon
  Crispy, savory strips of cured pork.
  $3.75
- Side of Feta Cheese
  Feta cheese, typically crumbled and served as a refreshing complement to your meal.
  $2.50
- Avocado
  Fresh and creamy fruit with a rich taste, perfect for adding a touch of luxury to any dish.
  $1.25
- Side of Cream Cheese
  A portion of smooth cream cheese, often paired with bagels or used as a spread.
  $1.87
- Side of Dressing
  Choice of dressings, including classic ranch, balsamic vinaigrette, Greek, and blue cheese, or explore fat-free options and oil and vinegar.
  $0.62
- Breakfast Sausage
  Sausage patty.
  $3.75
- Gluten Free Bread
  Gluten-free bread made from alternative flours, typically enjoyed as a side or substitute for traditional bread.
  $2.00
Kids Menu
Comes with 4" sandwich, chips and drink.
- Kids Ham and Cheese Sandwich
  Kids ham and cheese sandwich served with choice of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, or Sierra Mist.
  $7.98
- Kids Roast Beef Cheese Sandwich
  Kids Roast Beef Cheese Sandwich with choice of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, or Sierra Mist.
  $7.98
- Kids Turkey and Cheese Sandwich
  Kids turkey and cheese sandwich. Options for drink choice include Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist.
  $7.98
- Kids Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich
  Kids' Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich served with a choice of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, or Sierra Mist.
  $7.98
Desserts
- Mousse Cake
  Rich layers of chocolate sponge cake with creamy chocolate mousse filling and topping.
  $6.23
- Cheese Cake
  Rich creamy cake.
  $6.23
- Cookie
  Baked sweet dough. Chocolate Chip.
  $2.81
Beverages
- Can of Soda
  Choice of Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Mt Dew, or Diet Mt Dew in a can.
  $2.18
- Fountain Drink
  Choice of 20 oz or 32 oz fountain drinks with options including Pepsi varieties, Sierra Mist, Mt. Dew, Dr. Pepper, Powerade, and Lemonade.
  $2.80
- Water
  Clear, refreshing bottled water.
  $1.95