Goodfellas Pizzeria - Baxter Ave. Menu

4.3

(700+ Reviews)

$Pizza, Bar, Cocktail bar

Customer Favorites Pies Classic Sides Subs Calzones Salads Desserts Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Breadstick - D2D
  A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce
  $5.50
- 16" Half & Half Pie - D2D
  Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16" half pie all to yourself.
  $25.50
- Calzone - D2D
  This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!
  $14.75
- Cannoli - D2D
  A house made Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips
  $5.50
- Buff Chicken Cheese Bread - D2D
  Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch
  $21.50
- Al Pacino - D2D
  An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!
  $14.75
- Cheese Bread - D2D
  Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.
  $17.50
- 20 Oz Soda
  Bottled Coca-cola products
  $4.50
- 12" Pie - D2D
  Build your own 12" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
  $18.75
- 16" Pie - D2D
  Build your own 16" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
  $25.50
Pies
- 12" Half & Half Pie - D2D
  Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 12" half pie all to yourself.
  $18.75
- 12" Pie - D2D
  Build your own 12" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
  $18.75
- 16" Half & Half Pie - D2D
  Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16" half pie all to yourself.
  $25.50
- 16" Pie - D2D
  Build your own 16" pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... "Your Way"
  $25.50
Classic
- Pink Squirrel
  $10.00
Sides
- Breadstick - D2D
  A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce
  $5.50
- Buff Chicken Cheese Bread - D2D
  Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch
  $21.50
- Cheese Bread - D2D
  Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.
  $17.50
- Extra Sauce - D2D
  Marinara, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese, Buffalo Ranch
  $1.50
- Meatballs - D2D
  Our world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our house made marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia! *soy,milk,gluten,egg
  $14.75
- Pesto Bread - D2D
  A New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of house made pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.
  $13.50
- Sun Dried Tomato Bread - D2D
  A New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.
  $13.50
Subs
- Al Pacino - D2D
  An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!
  $14.75
Calzones
- Calzone - D2D
  This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!
  $14.75
Salads
- Caprese Salad - D2D
  A simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned
  $6.00
- Pasta Salad - D2D
  A tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.
  $6.00
- Spring Mix Salad - D2D
  A small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.
  $6.00
Desserts
- Black and White Cookie - D2D
  Seinfeld's favorite... a New York staple
  $5.50
- Cannoli - D2D
  A house made Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips
  $5.50
- Cheesecake - D2D
  Hands down the best you've ever had!
  $5.50
- Chocolate Chip Cookie - D2D
  An extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate
  $5.50
Beverages
- 20 Oz Soda
  Bottled Coca-cola products
  $4.50
- Bottled Water - D2D
  Goodfellas very own bottled spring water
  $2.50