Goodfellas Pizzeria - Baxter Ave. Menu
$Pizza, Bar, Cocktail bar
642 Baxter Ave Suite 102, Louisville, KY 40204
Pizza
- 12 PieBuild your own 12 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way$14.00
- 12 Half & Half PieCan't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 12 half pie all to yourself.$14.00
- 16 PieBuild your own 16 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way$19.00
- 16 Half & Half PieCan't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16 half pie all to yourself.$19.00
- 22 PieBuild your own 22 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way$25.00
- 22 Half & Half PieCan't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 22 half pie all to yourself.$25.00
Calzones
- CalzoneThis half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!- toppings $2.00 each (limit 3)$11.00
Sides
- BreadstickA single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce$4.00
- Cheese BreadOur original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.$13.00
- Buff Chicken Cheese BreadNeed we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch$16.00
- MeatballsOur world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our house made marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia!*soy,milk,gluten,egg$11.00
- Sun Dried Tomato BreadA New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.$10.00
- Pesto BreadA New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.$10.00
- Extra SauceMarinara, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese, Buffalo Ranch$1.00
Subs
- Al PacinoAn extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!$11.00
Salads
- Caprese SaladA simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned$4.50
- Spring Mix SaladA small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.$4.50
- Pasta SaladA tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.$4.50
Desserts
- CannoliA housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips$4.00
- Chocolate Chip CookieAn extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate$4.00
- Black And White CookieSeinfeld's favorite... a New York staple$4.00
- CheesecakeHands down the best you've ever had!$4.00
Beverages
- SodaCoca-cola products in a reusable Goodfellas stadium cup$3.25
- Water
Bourbon Whiskey - #
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Dangerous Dram$14.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Dangerous Dram 1 Oz$9.00
- 291 Bourbon$25.00
- 291 Bourbon 1 Oz$15.00
- 1792 BiB Wiseguy Mr. Blue$14.00
- 1792 BiB Wiseguy Mr. Blue 1 Oz$8.00
- 1792 Sweet Wheat$18.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Blonde 1 Oz$8.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Blonde$14.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Orange$14.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Orange 1 Oz$8.00
- 1792 Small Batch$10.00
- 1792 Full Proof 'Nice Guy Eddie'$13.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. White$14.00
- 1792 Full Proof$16.00
- 1792 Full Proof 'Nice Guy Eddie' 1 Oz$8.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. White 1 Oz$8.00
- 1792 Single Barrel$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - A
- Angel's Envy Bourbon$15.00
- Angel's Envy Cask Strength 2022 1 Oz$45.00
- Angel's Envy Finished Rye$30.00
- Angel's Envy Wiseguy Vito Genovese$12.00
- Ancient Age$6.00
- Angel's Envy Wiseguy Vito Genovese 1 Oz$7.00
- Angel's Envy Finished Rye 1 Oz$18.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Ba
- Basil Hayden Toast$18.00
- Basil Hayden 10yr 1 Oz$15.00
- Barrell Seagrass Rye$25.00
- Barrell Seagrass Rye 1 Oz$14.00
- Basil Hayden Subtle Smoke$17.00
- Barrell Bourbon Batch 33$26.00
- Barrell Bourbon Batch 33 1 Oz$14.00
- Bardstown Founders Collab$45.00
- Bardstown Founders Collab 1 Oz$25.00
- Bardstown Plantation Rum Finish$45.00
- Basil Hayden$8.00
- Bardstown Plantation Rum Finish 1 Oz$25.00
- Basil Hayden Dark Rye$12.00
- Barrell Vantage$25.00
- Bardstown Discovery$32.00
- Barrell Vantage 1 Oz$15.00
- Barrell Bourbon Dovetail$22.00
- Bardstown Bourbon West Virginia Barrel Collab 1 Oz$27.00
- Basil Hayden 10yr$27.00
- Bardstown Bourbon West Virginia Barrel Collab$45.00
- Bakers 7yr Small Batch$18.00
- Bardstown Bourbon Chateau De Laubade$45.00
- Bardstown Discovery 1 Oz$20.00
- Bardstown Bourbon Chateau De Laubade 1 Oz$27.00
- Barrell Bourbon Dovetail 1 Oz$13.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Be
- Belle Meade Cognac Cask$20.00
- Benchmark No.8$6.00
- Benchmark BiB$6.00
- Belle Meade Cognac Cask 1 Oz$12.00
- Belle Meade Madeira Cask$20.00
- Belle Meade Madeira Cask 1 Oz$12.00
- Benchmark Small Batch$7.00
- Benchmark Top Floor$7.00
- Bernheim Wheat$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Bl
- Blade & Bow$18.00
- Blue Run Golden Rye Whiskey 1 Oz$18.00
- Blue Run Golden Rye Whiskey$30.00
- Blackwood Toasted Bourbon$45.00
- Blackwood Toasted Bourbon 1 Oz$27.00
- Black Saddle 12yr$20.00
- Blue Run High Rye$30.00
- Blue Run High Rye 1 Oz$18.00
- Black Saddle 12yr 1 Oz$12.00
- Blanton's Wiseguy Omerta 1 Oz$11.00
- Blanton's Gold$55.00
- Blanton's Wiseguy Omerta$19.00
- Blanton's Gold 1 Oz$33.00
- Blanton's 1 Oz$12.00
- Blanton's SFTBStraight From The Barrel$75.00
- Blue Run Reflection I$42.00
- Blanton's SFTB 1 Oz$45.00
- Blue Run Reflection I 1 Oz$27.00
- Sazerac Rye Wiseguy Bugsy Siegel$14.00
- Blanton's$16.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Bo
- Bomberger's Declaration 2023$32.00
- Bowman Brother's Small Batch$10.00
- Bomberger's Declaration 2023 1oz$19.00
- Boone County Small Batch$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Bu
- Bulleit 10yr$14.00
- Bulleit Rye$8.00
- Buffalo Trace$6.00
- Buzzard's Roost Char #1 Rye$12.00
- Bulleit Bourbon$8.00
Bourbon Whiskey - C
- Colonel EH Taylor Single Barrel$50.00
- Coopers Craft$10.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Straight Rye$45.00
- Castle & Key Small Batch Bourbon$14.00
- Cream Of Kentucky Straight Rye BiB$30.00
- Calumet Single Rack Black 16yr$35.00
- Cream Of Kentucky Straight Rye BiB 1 Oz$18.00
- Calumet Single Rack Black 16yr 1 Oz$21.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Barrel Proof$39.00
- Castle & Key Wheated Bourbon$17.00
- Clyde Mays 6yr Special Reserve$19.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Small Batch$15.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Barrel Proof 1 Oz$23.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Single Barrel 1 Oz$30.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Single Barrel 'Tailor Made' Wiseguy Pick$19.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Straight Rye 1 Oz$27.00
- Colonel EH Taylor Single Barrel 'Tailor Made' Wiseguy Pick 1 Oz$11.00
- Castle & Key Restoration Rye$13.00
Bourbon Whiskey - D
- Daviess County Cab Sauv Finish$14.00
- David James 1843$10.00
- Duke Small Batch$13.00
- Duke Founders Reserve$30.00
- David Nicholson Reserve$9.00
- Duke Founders Reserve 1 Oz$18.00
Bourbon Whiskey - E
- Ezra Brooks Wiseguy Killer Peacock$14.00
- Eagle Rare Wiseguy Power Trip$15.00
- Eagle Rare Wiseguy Power Trip 1 Oz$9.00
- Ezra Brooks Wiseguy Killer Peacock 1 Oz$8.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy Mic Drop 1 Oz$6.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy Arson$16.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy Arson 1 Oz$10.00
- Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof B521$20.00
- Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof C921$20.00
- Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof B521 1 Oz$12.00
- Elijah Craig 12 Yr Barrel Proof C921 1 Oz$12.00
- Evan Williams Black$5.00
- Evan Williams BIB$6.00
- Ezra Brooks 90$6.00
- Elijah Craig Small Batch$9.00
- Eagle Rare Wiseguy Put Em On Ice$15.00
- Evan Williams 1783$7.00
- Eagle Rare Wiseguy Put Em On Ice 1 Oz$9.00
- Evan Williams Single Barrel$12.00
- Eagle Rare$14.00
- Elijah Craig 18yr$60.00
- Elmer T. Lee$20.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy John Dillinger$16.00
- Elmer T. Lee 1 Oz60% Priced 1 oz Pour$12.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy John Dillinger 1 Oz$10.00
- Early Times BIB$6.00
- Elijah Craig 18yr 1 Oz$36.00
- Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Joe Profaci Wiseguy$26.00
- Ezra Brooks 99$8.00
- Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Joe Profaci Wiseguy 1 Oz$15.00
- Elijah Craig Wiseguy Mic Drop$10.00
- Eagle Rare Extortion Wiseguy Pick$15.00
- Elijah Craig Rye$10.00
- Eagle Rare Extortion Wiseguy Pick 1 Oz$9.00
- Elijah Craig Toasted Barrel$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - F
- Four Roses 80 Proof$8.00
- Four Roses Single Barrel 100$14.00
- Four Roses Small Batch$11.00
- Four Gate 7yr Saint Charente$55.00
- Fighting Cock$6.00
- Four Gate 7yr Saint Charente 1 Oz$33.00
- FEW Bourbon$13.00
- Four Roses Wiseguy OESK (KY)$30.00
- FEW Rye$13.00
- Four Roses Wiseguy OESK (Ky) 1 Oz$18.00
- Four Roses Small Batch Select$18.00
Bourbon Whiskey - G
- George Dickel Rye$8.00
- Gentleman Jack$10.00
- Green River$12.00
- George Remus Bourbon$14.00
- George Dickel 17yr Wiseguy Anthony Corallo$18.00
- George Dickel 8yr$10.00
- George Dickel 17yr Wiseguy Anthony Corallo 1 Oz$11.00
- George Dickel 13yr BIB$15.00
- George T. Stagg$100.00
- George T. Stagg 1 Oz$60.00
Bourbon Whiskey - H
- High West Double Rye$9.00
- Heaven Hill White Label - Old Style$5.00
- Heaven Hill 7yr BiB$15.00
- Henry McKenna 10yr BiB$15.00
- Henry McKenna 80$4.00
- High West American Prairie$12.00
- High West Campfire 1 Oz$12.00
- Hirsch Small Batch$14.00
- Hardin's Creek Col. James B. Beam 2yr$25.00
- High West Campfire$20.00
- Hardin's Creek Col. James B. Beam 2yr 1 Oz$15.00
- High West Bourye$50.00
- High West Yippee-Ki-Yay$50.00
- Hudson Do The Rye Thing$13.00
- Hotel Tango Bourbon$8.00
- Hudson Bright Lights, Big Bourbon$13.00
- Horse Solider Bourbon$15.00
- High West Yippee-Ki-Yay 1 Oz$30.00
- High West Bourye 1 Oz$30.00
- Heaven Hill 6yr BiB$12.00
- Heaven Hill 7yr BiB 1 Oz$12.00
Bourbon Whiskey - J
- Jim Beam Whole Rolled Oat$16.00
- Jim Beam Six Row Barley$15.00
- Jim Beam Red Wheat$20.00
- Jim Beam Quarter Cask$16.00
- Jefferson's Rye Cognac Cask$20.00
- Jefferson's Rye Cognac Cask 1 Oz$12.00
- Jim Beam Quarter Cask Finished 1 Oz$10.00
- Jim Beam Whole Rolled Oat 1 Oz$10.00
- Jim Beam Six Row Barley 1 Oz$9.00
- Jack Daniel's BiB$15.00
- Jim Beam Brown Rice$25.00
- Jim Beam Brown Rice 1 Oz$15.00
- Jim Beam Single Barrel$12.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 19$30.00
- Jim Beam Black$8.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 19 1 Oz$18.00
- Jim Beam Rye$8.00
- Jefferson's Reserve$16.00
- Jim Beam$6.00
- Jack Daniel's$8.00
- James E. Pepper 1776 Bourbon$10.00
- JTS Brown BIB$5.00
- Johnny Drum Private Stock$10.00
- James E. Pepper 1776 Rye$8.00
- Jim Beam High Rye$30.00
- Jim Beam Triticale$25.00
- Jefferson's Wiseguy Tom 1 Oz$10.00
- Jack Daniel's Twice Barreled Single Malt$20.00
- Jack Daniel's Rye$8.00
- Jack Daniel's Twice Barreled Single Malt 1 Oz$12.00
- Joseph Magnus$26.00
- Jefferson's Wiseguy Tom$16.00
- Joseph Magnus Cigar$75.00
- Joseph Magnus 1 Oz$17.00
- Jefferson's Marian McClain$100.00
- Joseph Magnus Cigar 1 Oz$27.00
- Jefferson's Marian McClain 1oz$60.00
- Jeptha Creed RWB Kentucky Spirit BBN$20.00
- Jeptha Creed RWB Kentucky Spirit BBN 1oz$12.00
- Jim Beam Red Wheat 1 Oz$12.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 28$25.00
- Jim Beam Triticale 1 Oz$15.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Voyage 28 1 Oz$15.00
- Jim Beam High Rye 1 Oz$18.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Cask Strength Wiseguy Al Capone$30.00
- Jefferson's Rye Cognac$20.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Cask Strength Wiseguy Al Capone 1 Oz$18.00
- Jefferson's Rye Cognac 1 Oz$12.00
World Whiskey - Scotch
- Glenlivet 12yr Single Malt$9.00
- Monkey Shoulder$9.00
- Johnnie Walker Black$12.00
- Dewar's White Label$9.00
- Glenfiddich 15yr$14.00
World Whiskey - Irish
- Redbreast PX$30.00
- Redbreast Kentucky Oak$30.00
- Redbreast PX 1 Oz$18.00
- Gold Spot 9yr Anniversary$50.00
- Redbreast Kentucky Oak 1 Oz$17.00
- Gold Spot 9yr Anniversary 1 Oz$30.00
- Midleton Irish Vintage 2020$75.00
- Midleton Irish Vintage 2020 1 Oz$45.00
- Jameson$9.00
- Redbreast 12yr 1 Oz$13.00
- Redbreast 12yr$22.00
World Whiskey - Asia
- Suntory AO$25.00
- Suntory Toki$10.00
Bourbon Whiskey - K
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Heist$10.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Heist 1 Oz$6.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Secret Stash$13.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Secret Stash 1 Oz$8.00
- Knob Creek Rye Wiseguy Kobe Ryeant$13.00
- Knob Creek Rye Wiseguy Kobe Ryeant 1 Oz$8.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy The Bookie 1 Oz$6.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy The Bookie$10.00
- Knob Creek 18yr 1 Oz$30.00
- Knob Creek 18yr$50.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Shakedown$12.00
- Knob Creek Rye$14.00
- Kentucky Owl Confiscated 1 Oz$21.00
- Kentucky Vintage$9.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Shakedown 1 Oz$7.00
- Koval Single Barrel Bourbon$15.00
- Koval Single Barrel Rye$14.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Witness Protection 1 Oz$9.00
- Kentucky Owl Confiscated$35.00
- Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition$100.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Witness Protection$14.00
- Kentucky Owl Takumi Edition 1 Oz$60.00
- Knob Creek 2001 LE$60.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Lucky Luciano$15.00
- Knob Creek Cask Strength Rye$20.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Lucky Luciano 1 Oz$9.00
- Knob Creek 9yr$10.00
- Knob Creek Cask Strength Rye 1 Oz$12.00
- Kentucky Par$32.00
- Kentucky Par 1 Oz$19.00
- Knob Creek Rye Wiseguy John Gotti$16.00
- Knob Creek 12yr Cask Strength$20.00
- Knob Creek Rye Wiseguy John Gotti 1 Oz$10.00
- Knob Creek Chop Shop Wiseguy Pick$18.00
- Knob Creek 12yr Cask Strength 1 Oz$12.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Frank Costello$14.00
- Knob Creek Chop Shop Wiseguy Pick 1 Oz$10.00
- Knob Creek 2001 LE 1 Oz%60 Priced 1 0z pour$36.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Frank Costello 1 Oz$9.00
Bourbon Whiskey - L
- Lucky Seven Jokester 6yr$16.00
- Left Bank Bourbon$16.00
- Larceny Wiseguy Zero Time Served 1 Oz$5.00
- Little Book Chapter 6: To The Finish$50.00
- Larceny$10.00
- Little Book Chapter 6: To The Finish 1 Oz$30.00
- Legent$9.00
- Larceny Barrel Proof$12.00
- Larceny Wiseguy Zero Time Served$9.00
Bourbon Whiskey - M
- Michter's Sour Mash$14.00
- Maker's Mark FAE-02$20.00
- Maker's Mark FAE-02 1 Oz$12.00
- Mellow Corn BIB$5.00
- Michter's Rye$14.00
- Michter's Small Batch$13.00
- Maker's Mark Cask Strength$18.00
- Monk's Road 6yr$22.00
- Maker's Mark 46$10.00
- Monk's Road 6yr 1 Oz$13.00
- Maker's Mark$9.00
- Monk's Road Wheated$14.00
- Michter's American Whiskey$14.00
- MB Roland Barkers Mill BiB$14.00
- Minor Case Sherry Finish$14.00
- Michter's 10yr Rye$40.00
- Maker's Mark Cellar Aged 2023$44.00
- Murray Hill Club$12.00
- Maker's Mark Cellar Aged 2023 1oz$26.00
- MB Roland Rye$16.00
- Maker's Mark 46 Cask Strength$19.00
- Michter's 10yr Rye 1 Oz$24.00
- Michter's Toasted Rye Barrel Strength$35.00
- Michter's Toasted Rye Barrel Strength 1 Oz$21.00
- Maker's Mark 101$10.00
Bourbon Whiskey - N
- Nelson Bros Reserve$16.00
- Noah's Mill$14.00
- New Riff 6yr Malted Rye$18.00
- Nashville Barrel Co. Rye Cask Strength$28.00
- New Riff BiB$14.00
- Nashville Barrel Co. Rye Cask Strength 1 Oz$17.00
- New Riff Rye BiB$14.00
- Nashville Barrel Co. Bourbon Trifecta$28.00
- New Riff Balboa Rye$55.00
- Nashville Barrel Co. Bourbon Trifecta 1 Oz$17.00
- Nelson's Green Brier$10.00
- New Riff Wiseguy Anthony Salerno$10.00
- New Riff Balboa Rye 1 Oz$33.00
- New Riff Wiseguy Anthony Salerno 1 Oz$6.00
- New Riff Single Barrel$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - O
- Old Granddad BIB$7.00
- Old Crow$4.00
- Old Granddad 80$6.00
- Old Overholt Rye$5.00
- Old Forester Signature$7.00
- Old Forester 86$6.00
- Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr 1072 oz pour$50.00
- Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye Wiseguy Easy Ryeder$12.00
- Old Charter 8$8.00
- Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye Wiseguy Easy Ryeder 1 Oz$7.00
- Old Bardstown BiB$7.00
- Old Pepper FKO Rye Wiseguy Knockout 1 Oz$11.00
- Old Tub BIB$10.00
- Old Bardstown Estate Bottled 101$12.00
- Old Forester 1870$12.00
- Old Forester 1897$16.00
- Old Forester 1920$16.00
- Old Grand-Dad 114$9.00
- Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 22yr$50.00
- Old Bardstown 90$6.00
- Old Fitzgerald Prime$4.00
- Old Forester Statesman2 oz pour$14.00
- Old Carter Rye Batch 10$60.00
- Orphan Barrel Entrapment 25yr$60.00
- Old Carter Rye Batch 10 1 Oz$36.00
- Old Forester 1910$15.00
- Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25yr$55.00
- Old Forester Rye$8.00
- Old Elk$16.00
- Old Pepper Wiseguy 19L5 Stars$27.00
- Old Rip Van Winkle 10yr 107 1 Oz$30.00
- Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 22yr 1 Oz$30.00
- Orphan Barrel Rhetoric 25yr 1 Oz$33.00
- Old Carter Bourbon Batch 6$50.00
- Old Carter Bourbon Batch 6 1 Oz$30.00
- Orphan Barrel Entrapment 25yr 1 Oz$36.00
- Old Pepper Wiseguy 19L5 Stars 1 Oz$16.00
- Old Carter American Whiskey #12 1oz$36.00
- Old WM Tarr 7yr$20.00
- Old Carter American Whiskey #12$60.00
- Old WM Tarr 7yr 1 Oz$12.00
- Old Forester 1924 10yr Bourbon$35.00
- Old Pepper FKO Rye Wiseguy Knockout$18.00
- Old Forester 1924 10yr Bourbon 1 Oz$21.00
Bourbon Whiskey - P
- Pinhook Rye Rye Munny$12.00
- Pinhook 7yr Bourbon War$25.00
- Pinhook 7yr Bourbon War 1 Oz$15.00
- Peerless Rye$20.00
- Peerless Rye 1 Oz$12.00
- Pursuit United Rye$18.00
- Pappy Van Winkle 15yr$160.00
- Pappy Van Winkle 20yr$220.00
- Pikesville Rye$14.00
- Penny Packer$5.00
- Peerless Small Batch$16.00
- Penelope Toasted Barrel Finish$22.00
- Pappy Van Winkle 15yr 1 Oz$95.00
- Penelope Toasted Barrel Finish 1 Oz$13.00
- Pappy Van Winkle 20yr 1 Oz$132.00
- Pursuit Toasted American & French Oak$22.00
- Pursuit Toasted American & French Oak 1oz$13.00
Bourbon Whiskey - R
- Rossville Union Wiseguy 95/5$5.00
- Rossville Union Wiseguy 95/5 1 Oz$3.00
- Russell's Wiseguy Pleasant Surprise$20.00
- Russell's Wiseguy Pleasant Surprise 1 Oz$12.00
- Rebel Yell Small Batch$6.00
- Redemption Rye BIB$8.00
- Rittenhouse Rye BIB$10.00
- Russell's Reserve 10yr Bourbon$12.00
- Redemption Rye$8.00
- Rowans Creek$12.00
- Red Line Honey Cask$30.00
- Redemption High Rye Bourbon$8.00
- Red Line Honey Cask 1 Oz$18.00
- Rabbit Hole Dareringer PX Sherry$22.00
- Red Line Orange Curacao$30.00
- Rock Hill Farm$55.00
- Red Line Orange Curacao 1 Oz$18.00
- Rabbit Hole Heigold Bourbon$16.00
- Remus Repeal Reserve VI$30.00
- Rabbit Hole Boxergrail Rye$16.00
- Remus Repeal Reserve VI 1 Oz$18.00
- Redemption Bourbon$10.00
- Remus Gatsby Reserve 15yr$75.00
- Rossville Union Barrel Proof$20.00
- Remus Gatsby Reserve 15yr 1 Oz$45.00
- Remus Repeal Reserve II$22.00
- Russell's Reserve Wiseguy Recreational Cough Syrup$20.00
- Rabbit Hole Cavehill Bourbon$16.00
- Russell's Reserve Wiseguy Recreational Cough Syrup 1 Oz$12.00
- Remus Repeal Reserve II 1 Oz$13.00
- Rossville Union Barrel Proof 1 Oz$12.00
- Rabbit Hole Dareringer PX Sherry 1 Oz$12.00
- Rock Hill Farm 1 Oz$33.00
- Russell's Reserve 6yr Rye$14.00
- Redwood Empire Emerald Giant Rye$11.00
- Russell's Reserve Wiseguy 'Solitary Confinement'$26.00
- Russell's Reserve 13yr Barrel Proof$75.00
- Russell's Reserve Wiseguy 'Solitary Confinement' 1 Oz$16.00
- Russell's Reserve 13yr Barrel Proof 1 Oz$45.00
- Russell's Reserve 15yr$80.00
- Russell's Reserve 15yr 1 Oz$48.00
Bourbon Whiskey - S
- Stagg Jr Wiseguy Extinct$60.00
- Stagg Jr Wiseguy Extinct 1 Oz$36.00
- Smoke Wagon Straight$10.00
- Savage And Cooke Guero 14yr$55.00
- Savage And Cooke Guero 14yr 1 Oz$33.00
- Smoke Wagon Malted Rye$25.00
- Stagg$40.00
- Smoke Wagon Malted Rye 1 Oz$15.00
- Sazerac Rye$12.00
- Sagamore Rye Sherry Finish$24.00
- Smooth Ambler Wiseguy Gambler$15.00
- Sagamore Rye Sherry Finish 1 Oz$14.00
- Smooth Ambler Contradiction Bourbon$12.00
- Smooth Ambler Big Level$16.00
- Smooth Ambler Wiseguy Gambler 1 Oz$9.00
- Stagg 1 Oz$24.00
- Smooth Ambler Contradiction Rye$12.00
- Sweetens Cove$55.00
- Smooth Ambler Old Scout Single Barrel Rye 5yr$15.00
- Sweetens Cove 1 Oz$33.00
- Sazerac Rye Wiseguy Bugsy Siegel 1 Oz$8.00
- Smooth Ambler Old Scout$10.00
Bourbon Whiskey - T
- Thomas S Moore Sherry Cask$24.00
- Tin Cup 10yr$18.00
- Thomas S Moore Cognac Cask$21.00
- Templeton 6yr$15.00
- Thomas S Moore Sherry Cask 1 Oz$14.00
- Thomas Handy Sazerac$80.00
- Thomas Handy Sazerac 1 Oz60% Priced 1 oz Pour$48.00
- Templeton 4yr$8.00
- Thomas S Moore Cognac Cask 1 Oz$13.00
- Thomas S Moore Chardonnay$24.00
- Thomas S Moore Cabernet Casks$24.00
- Thomas S Moore Port Casks$24.00
- The Wiseman Kentucky Owl$13.00
- Thomas S Moore Cabernet Casks 1 Oz$14.00
- Thomas S Moore Chardonnay 1 Oz$14.00
- Thomas S Moore Port Casks 1 Oz$14.00
Bourbon Whiskey - U
- Uncle Nearest 1856$16.00
- Uncle Nearest Rye 100$16.00
- Uncle Nearest 1884$13.00
Bourbon Whiskey - V
- Very Olde St. Nick Rye Summer Cask$46.00
- Very Olde St. Nick Rye Summer Cask 1 Oz$27.00
- Very Old Barton 90$6.00
- Van Winkle Lot B 12yr$85.00
- Van Winkle Family Reserve Rye 13yr$200.00
- Very Olde St Nick Harvest Rye$47.00
- Van Winkle Lot B 12yr 1 Oz$51.00
- Very Olde St Nick Harvest Rye 1 Oz$28.00
- Van Winkle Family Reserve Rye 13yr 1 Oz$120.00
Bourbon Whiskey - We
- Weller Full Proof Wiseguy Jackpot$50.00
- Weller Full Proof Wiseguy Jackpot 1 Oz$30.00
- Weller Antique$16.00
- Weller Special Reserve$10.00
- Wenzel Wiseguy Cov Bar #1$15.00
- Wenzel Wiseguy Cov Bar #1 1 Oz$9.00
- Weller Single Barrel$45.00
- Weller 12yr$30.00
- Weller C.Y.P.B$60.00
- Weller 12yr 1 Oz$18.00
- Weller C.Y.P.B. 1 Oz$36.00
- Weller Antique 107 Organized Crime$16.00
- Weller Full Proof$30.00
- Weller Full Proof 1 Oz$18.00
- Weller Single Barrel 1 Oz60% Priced 1 oz Pour$27.00
- Weller Antique 107 Organized Crime 1 Oz$10.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Wi
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed$16.00
- Wild Turkey Diamond$60.00
- Wild Turkey 101 Rye$10.00
- Willett IND/KY Blend$35.00
- Wild Turkey 101$8.00
- Willett IND/KY Blend 1 Oz$21.00
- Willett Pot Still Reserve$16.00
- Wilderness Trail Single Barrel Rye$16.00
- Willett 4yr Rye$20.00
- Willett Rye 4yr$20.00
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye 1 Oz$12.00
- Wild Turkey Longbranch$12.00
- Willett 8yr Wheated$65.00
- Wild Turkey Masters Keep Revival$45.00
- Willett 8yr Wheated 1 Oz$40.00
- Wilderness Trail BiB Single Barrel$16.00
- Wilderness Trail Rye Wiseguy NKY Collab$16.00
- Wild Turkey Diamond 1 Oz$36.00
- Wilderness Trail Rye Wiseguy NKY Collab 1 Oz$10.00
- Wild Turkey Masters Keep Revival 1 Oz$27.00
- Wilderness Trail 8yr BiB$25.00
- Widow Jane 10 Yr 1 Oz$15.00
- Wilderness Trail 8yr BiB 1 Oz$15.00
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye$20.00
- Wilderness Trail Rye Small Batch BiB$16.00
- Willett 8yr #160$54.00
- Wild Turkey Master's Keep Voyage$80.00
- William Larue Weller$70.00
- Wild Turkey Master's Keep Voyage 1oz$48.00
- Willett 8yr #160 1 Oz$40.00
- Wild Turkey 'Kentucky Spirit' Wiseguy 'Hijacked'$22.00
- Willett 4yr Rye 1 Oz$12.00
- Wild Turkey 'Kentucky Spirit' Wiseguy 'Hijacked' 1 Oz$14.00
- William Larue Weller 1 Oz$42.00
- Willett Rye 4yr 1 Oz$12.00
- Widow Jane 10 Yr$25.00
Bourbon Whiskey - Wo
- Woodford Rye$14.00
- Woodford Double Oaked$16.00
- Woodford Double Double Oaked$50.00
- Woodford Batch Proof$35.00
- Woodford Straight Malt$12.00
- Woodinville Bourbon Port Finish$15.00
- Woodford Oat Grain$45.00
- Woodford Wheat Whiskey$11.00
- Woodford Honey Barrel Finish$33.00
- Woodford Batch Proof 1 Oz$21.00
- Woodford Honey Barrel Finish 1 Oz$20.00
- Woodford Oat Grain 1 Oz$27.00
- Woodford Double Double Oaked 1 Oz$30.00
- Woodford Reserve$10.00
Retail Bottles
- Rossville Union Wiseguy 95/5 Package$50.00
- Old Pepper Single Barrel Rye Wiseguy Easy Ryeder Package$50.00
- Wilderness Trail Rye Wiseguy NKY Collab Package$60.00
- Wenzel Wiseguy Cov Bar #1 Package$65.00
- Smooth Ambler The Gambler Package$56.00
- Buffalo Trace/Benchmark BiB Package1 Bottle - Buffalo Trace - 1L - (regular, non-barrel pick)1 Bottle - Benchmark BiB - 1L$60.00
- Angel's Envy Wiseguy Vito Genovese Package$80.00
- George Dickel 17yr Wiseguy Anthony Corallo Package$70.00
- Buffalo Trace Bourbon Package$50.00
- 1792 BiB Wiseguy Mr. Blue Package$75.00
- New Riff Wiseguy Anthony Salerno Package$65.00
- Russell's Reserve Wiseguy 'Solitary Confinement'$75.00
- Corazon Extra Anejo - Aged In Buffalo Trace Barrel Package$65.00
- Wild Turkey 'Kentucky Spirit' Wiseguy 'Hijacked'$65.00
- Corazon Reposado - Aged In Stagg Barrel Package$45.00
- Knob Creek Rye Wiseguy John Gotti Package$60.00
- Raffle Winner Jackpot$65.00
- Elijah Craig John Dillinger Package$75.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Blonde Package$75.00
- Knob Creek Chop Shop Wiseguy Package$55.00
- PBT Bottle$50.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. Orange Package$75.00
- 1792 Full Proof Wiseguy Mr. White Package$75.00
- Blanton's Package$90.00
- Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Joe Profaci Package$90.00
- Old Pepper Knockout FKO Rye Package$75.00
- Knob Creek Wiseguy Frank Costello Package$55.00
- Corazon Reposado - Aged In Eagle Rare Package$45.00
- Weller 12yr Package$120.00
- 1792 Full Proof 'Nice Guy Eddie' Package$75.00
- Russell's Reserve 15yr Package$200.00
- Raffle Winner Elmer T. Lee$80.00
- Elijah Craig Arson Package$75.00
- Raffle Winner Weller 12yr$75.00
- Raffle Winner EH Taylor Single Barrel$125.00
- Raffle Winner Stagg Jr$125.00
- Jefferson's Ocean Cask Strength Wiseguy Al Capone Package$100.00
Specialty Pies
- WiseguyStraight from the garden with green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives, and tomatoes
- The BootleggerNucky Thompson approved with spinach, mushroom, sundried tomatoes, and pesto (try it with chicken)
- Taste Of NaplesTravel back to the old country with this margherita pie made with our signature marinara sauce, basil and fresh mozzarella
- GoodfellaA meaty pie suitable for any gangster with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, and bacon.
- Paulie's FavoritePaulie's passion for cooking sausage inspired this pie with spicy sliced Italian sausage, garlic sausage crumble, green peppers, onions, a roasted garlic
- The DonThe choice for any head of the family with pepperoni, Italian rope sausage, ground beef, bacon, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and black olives
- FuhgetaboutitEvery available topping... Fuhgetaboutit!
- The Vinnya friend of the family's traditional white pie made with olive oil, ricotta, roasted garlic, and mozzarella (try it with sausage)
- Tommy Two TimesTwo times the amount of pepperoni!
- The BossCalling the shots with chicken, tomatoes, onions, bacon, and drizzled ranch
- Nonna's PieJust how Nonna used to make pasta, except as a pizza. Meatballs, red onion, ricotta, garlic, and basil. Mangia!
Calzones
- CalzoneThis half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share! - toppings $2.00 each (limit 3)$11.00
Sides
- BreadstickA single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce$4.00
- Cheese BreadOur original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.$13.00
- Buff Chicken Cheese BreadNeed we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch$16.00
- MeatballsOur world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our housemade marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia!$11.00
- Sun Dried Tomato BreadA New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.$10.00
- Pesto BreadA New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.$10.00
Subs
- Al PacinoAn extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!$11.00
Salads
- Spring Mix SaladA small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.$4.50
- Pasta SaladA tri-colored rontini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.$4.50
- Caprese SaladA simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned$4.50
Desserts
- CannoliA housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips$4.00
- Black And White CookieSeinfeld's favorite... a New York staple$4.00
- Chocolate Chip CookieAn extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate$4.00
- Cheesecake$4.00
Beverages
- BOTTLED WATER$1.75
- 20 OZ SODA$3.25
Dressings
- ITALIAN DRESSING$1.00
- RANCH DRESSING$1.00
- BALSAMIC DRESSING$1.00
Sauces
- MARINARA$1.00
- GARLIC BUTTER$1.00
- NACHO CHEESE$1.00
- BUFFALO RANCH$1.00
- HABANERO RANCH$1.00
NY STYLE PIZZA
- 12 Pie$14.00
- 12 Half & Half Pie$14.00
- 16 Pie$19.00
- 16 Half & Half Pie$19.00
- 22 Pie$25.00
- 22 Half & Half Pie$25.00
CALZONES
- CALZONE$11.00
DESSERTS
- CANNOLI$4.00
- BLACK & WHITE COOKIE$4.00
- CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE$4.00
- NEW YORK CHEESECAKE$4.00
BEVERAGES
- BOTTLED WATER$1.75
- 20 OZ SODA$3.25
ONLINE SIDES
- BREADSTICKGarlic butter, parmesan, oregano, with your choice of sauce$4.00
- CHEESE BREADGarlic butter, mozzarella, oregano$13.00
- BUFFALO CHICKEN CHEESE BREADServed with house made ranch$16.00
- MEATBALLSPork and beef meatballs, marinara, ricotta, and basil$11.00
- SUN DRIED TOMATO BREADA New York Tribeca baguette, garlic infused olive oil, sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and basil$10.00
- PESTO BREADA New York Tribeca baguette, pesto, and mozzarella$10.00
- CAPRESE SALADFior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, with olive oil and seasoning$4.50
- PASTA SALADA tri-colored rotini pasta salad, roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, broccoli, with Italian dressing$4.50
- SPRING MIX SALADSpring mix, red onions, tomatoes, button mushrooms, with Italian, Ranch, or Balsamic dressing$4.50
- DOUGH BALL
DRESSING
- ITALIAN$1.00
- RANCH$1.00
- BALSAMIC$1.00
SAUCE
- MARINARA$1.00
- GARLIC BUTTER$1.00
- NACHO CHEESE$1.00
- BUFFALO RANCH$1.00
- HABANERO RANCH$1.00
Signature Cocktails
- Sun-Kissed SweetheartWheatley Vodka, Peach, Dragon Fruit, Raspberry, Strawberry, Lemon$9.00
- Broken HatchetFour Roses Bourbon, Orange, Hazelnut, Black Walnut, Rye Bitters, Cinnamon, Creme Brulee$13.00
- Wooden NickelOld Grand Dad BiB Bourbon, Blueberry, Blue Maple Agave, Aromatic Bitters, Allspice Dram, Leather and Tobacco Bitters, Maple Smoke$11.00
- Mexican ShakedownMonte Alban Tequila, Cucumber, Raspberry, Rosemary, Lemon, Raw Egg White*$12.00
- Dirty SmashBenchmark Bourbon, Demarara Gomme, Lemon, Mint$9.00
- A Mother's LoveGin, Strawberry, Dry Vermouth, Lime, Simple, Angostura Bitters$12.00
Seasonal Cocktails
- Easy As PieBourbon, Butterscotch, Apple Cider, Orange, Black Walnut Bitters, Egg White$10.00
- Much ObligedGin, Pinot Noir, Pear, Cassis, Honey, Lemon, Bitters, Cream$10.00
- Not The Buttons!Bourbon, Butter, Ginger, Molasses, Cinnamon, Clove, Vanilla, Orange, Bitters$10.00
- Cleary DangerousRum, Applejack, Swedish Punsch, Batavia-Arrack, Lemon, English Toffee Black Tea, Milk$12.00
- A Date With PersephoneAmaro, Applejack, Lime, Date, Egg White*$12.00
- Diamond DustPisco, Falermun, Spearmint, Eucalyptus, Blueberry, Bitters, Luster Dust$12.00
- Sugar & Spice, And Everything NiceRum, Scotch, Honey, Fig, Apricot, Spice, Heavy Cream, Egg*, Cranberry Bitters, Cardamom Bitters$10.00
Classic Cocktails
- Old FashionedBourbon, Simple, Angostura Bitters, Orange Zest, Brandied Cherry$8.00
- ManhattanRittenhouse Rye, Sweet Vermouth, Angostura Bitters, Brandied Cherry$10.00
- SidecarCognac, Dry Curacao, Lemon$13.00
- Vieux CarreRye Whiskey, Cognac, Sweet Vermouth, Benedictine, Peychaud's and Angostura Bitters$12.00
- NegroniBeefeater Gin, Campari, Sweet Vermouth$12.00
- MuleChoose your Spirit, Lime, Ginger Beer$8.00
- SazeracRittenhouse Rye, Simple, Peychaud's Bitters$12.00
- Amaretto SourAmaretto, Simple, Lemon, Raw Egg White*$10.00
- The GodfatherWiseguy Lounge Private Selection Bourbon, Sazerac Rye, Demerara Gomme, Jerry Thomas & Orange Bitters, Bourbon Barrel Smoke$15.00
- Corazon MargaritaBourbon Barrel Aged Corazon Reposado, Dry Curacao, Agave Nectar, Lime$12.00
Martinis
- Marilyn MonroeVodka, Limoncello, Peach, Agave, Sour, Rhubarb Bitters$8.00
- Audrey HepburnVodka, Pomegranate, Rhubarb, Sour, Lemon Bitters$8.00
- BonnieGin, Elderflower, Lime, Cucumber Basil$8.00
- Espresso MartiniPinnacle Vodka, Vanilla, Coffee, Espresso$13.00
- PBC MartiniPeanut Butter Tequila, Cafe Coffee, Creme de Cacao, Chocolate Bitters, Espresso$14.00
Shots
- PBTHousemade Peanut Butter Infused Tequila$6.00
Drafts
- Blue Moon Brewing Belgian WhiteBelgian Style White Ale - 5%$6.00
- NarragansettLager - 5%$4.00
- PeroniAmerican-Style Lager -5%$6.50
- Sierra NevadaRotating
- New BelgiumRotating
- Country BoyRotating
- RhinegeistRotating
- Three FloydsRotating
- Bell'sRotating
- FoundersRotating
Mocktails
- Blood Orange RisingSan Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa, Vanilla Demerara, Honey, Lime, Tonic
- Citrus GardenSan Pellegrino Pompelmo, Mint, Lime, Ginger Beer, Tonic$7.00
- Berry BloomSeedlip Garden 108, Blueberry Puree, Honey, Basil, Lemon$8.00
Non-Alcoholic
- San Pellegrino500 mL$8.00
- San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa11.15 fl oz$6.00
- San Pellegrino Pompelmo11.15 fl oz$6.00
- Red BullRegular, Sugar Free, Tropical$3.75
- EspressoTry with one of our house made syrups$4.00
