GoodFellas Pizza Menu

3.6

(875+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Hot Wings Pizza Appetizers Burgers Fried Chicken French Fries Salad & Wraps Subs & Calzones Desserts Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Regular Fries
  Crispy golden fries, salted to perfection.
  $4.99
- Don Pepperoni
  For pepperoni lovers only! Maximum pepperoni allowed by law!
  $17.99
- Large Cheese Pizza
  Classic mozzarella with homemade marinara on a crispy crust.
  $12.99
- Our Awesome Boneless Wings
  Forget the bone, chow down on these tender wings with one of our 11 great sauces.
  $10.50
- Our Famous Regular Wings (10 Wings)
  10 classic wings with a choice of sauces: garlic, BBQ, honey BBQ/mustard, hot varieties, Jack Daniels, spicy garlic, or Thai chile.
  $15.00
- Bucket of Fries
  $5.99
- Our Famous Regular Wings (5 Wings)
  Five wings with an array of sauces ranging from Original BBQ, Honey BBQ, Spicy Garlic, to Hot 'n' Tangy options including "Death sauce" and Jack Daniels.
  $7.50
- Mozzarella Stix
  Golden fried mozzarella served with a savory marinara sauce.
  $7.75
- Steak & Cheese
  Our steak is sliced thin and piled high, grilled to perfection with caramelized onions and melted cheese.
  $9.99
- Cinnamon Pizza Frites
  A local favorite with a Goodfellas taste! Freshly fried dough with cinnamon sugar served hot with vanilla icing for dipping
  $6.50
Hot Wings
You've had the rest, now try the best! Our tender chicken wings are cooked to perfection in heart health conola oil and drenched in one of our twelve signature wing sauces.
- Our Awesome Boneless Wings
  Forget the bone, chow down on these tender wings with one of our 11 great sauces.
  $10.50
- Our Famous Regular Wings (5 Wings)
  Five wings with an array of sauces ranging from Original BBQ, Honey BBQ, Spicy Garlic, to Hot 'n' Tangy options including "Death sauce" and Jack Daniels.
  $7.50
- Our Famous Regular Wings (10 Wings)
  10 classic wings with a choice of sauces: garlic, BBQ, honey BBQ/mustard, hot varieties, Jack Daniels, spicy garlic, or Thai chile.
  $15.00
- Our Famous Regular Wings (50 Wings)
  Range from mild BBQ to spicy Thai Chile.
  $75.00
- Our Famous Regular Wings (100 Wings)
  100 regular wings with a selection of sauces: garlic, BBQ, classic hot, honey variants, fiery options, Jack Daniels, spicy garlic, Thai chile.
  $150.00
- Blue Cheese & Celery
  $1.50
Pizza
Our dough made fresh daily with the best Mozzarella cut daily and never frozen.
- Mini-Pizza Topped Your Way
  $7.99
- Slice
  $2.50
- Small Cheese Pizza
  $11.99
- Large Cheese Pizza
  Classic mozzarella with homemade marinara on a crispy crust.
  $12.99
- Extra Large Cheese Pizza
  Generously topped with mozzarella cheese, black olives, broccoli, mushrooms, and pepperoni on a classic pizza crust.
  $16.99
- Small White Pizza
  $12.99
- Large White Pizza
  $13.99
- Cheeser Pleaser Square Pizza
  $17.99
- Specialty Pizza
  $17.99
- Meat Lovers Pizza
  Piled high with ham, pepperoni, and sausage.
  $17.99
- Veggie Delight
  Loaded with fresh tomatoes, mushrooms, onions, olives, and peppers.
  $17.99
- Don Pepperoni
  For pepperoni lovers only! Maximum pepperoni allowed by law!
  $17.99
- Hot Wing Pizza
  Bada-Bing! We've spread our famous hot wings all over this pizza!
  $17.99
- Chicken Parmesan
  New! Out of this world! Topped with our own tender chicken parmesan.
  $17.99
- Double Crusted Broccoli & Cheese
  Two crispy crusts stuffed with broccoli and melted cheese.
  $17.99
- Double Crusted Steak & Cheese
  Two crispy crusts bursting with steak and melted cheese.
  $17.99
- Double Crusted Sausage & Cheese
  New! Sausage and melted cheese between two crispy crusts.
  $17.99
- Hawaiian Pizza
  Aloha! Our newest entry topped with a generous helping of baked ham and sweet pineapple.
  $17.99
Appetizers
Crank up your appetite goodfellas style! Hot, fresh and made to order. Yo, order some for the whole table!
- Chicken Quesadilla
  New! Chicken grilled to perfection with our 3 cheese blend in a fresh tortilla, served with salsa and sour cream.
  $10.99
- Nachos
  New! A beaping portion of crisp tortilla chips topped with spicy beef sauce, jalapeños, 3 cheese blends, tomatoes, onions, sour cream, and black olives.
  $11.99
- The Munch Box
  A goodfellas favorite is back! Two mozzarella stix, 2 jalapeño poppers, 2 chicken fingers, and fries.
  $11.99
- Jalapeño Poppers
  Hot jalapeño poppers and a creamy Cheddar cheese center breaded and fried to perfection.
  $8.75
- Hot Wing Shrimp
  Our popular butler-fried shrimp kicked up with our signature hot wing sauce.
  $11.99
- Onion Rings
  Large Sweet Vidalia onion rings, beer-battered and fried to golden brown perfection.
  $8.99
- Mozzarella Stix
  Golden fried mozzarella served with a savory marinara sauce.
  $7.75
- Perogies 3pc
  Served with butter and onions.
  $6.50
- Perogies 6pc
  Served with butter and onions.
  $8.50
- Dipping Stix
  A tasty assortment of pizza sticks. Broccoli & Cheese, Pepperoni & Cheese, and Steak & Cheese. Served with marinara and a delicious garlic butter sauce for dipping.
  $9.50
- Bread Stix
  Made with fresh dough and oven baked. Served with marinara sauce for dipping.
  $7.99
- Cheesy Stix
  Served with marinara and a delicious garlic butter sauce for dipping.
  $8.50
- Broccoli Cheese Bites
  Breaded nuggets stuffed with broccoli and melted cheese.
  $8.50
- Chicken Fries
  Ultra-slender chicken strips breaded and French fries to crispy perfection.
  $7.50
Burgers
Our burgers made fresh daily from lean top sirlion, hand-packed and cooked to order. No pre-formed frozen burgers here!
- Our 100% Fresh Ground Beef Hand-Packed 1/2 lb Hamburger
  100% fresh ground beef, hand-packed, 1/2 lb. Choose meat temperature: medium, rare, to well done.
  $7.25
- Cheeseburger (1/2 lb)
  Our 100% Fresh Ground Beef Hand-Packed Hamburger with Cheese.
  $8.50
- Bacon Cheeseburger (1/2 lb)
  Our 100% Fresh Ground Beef Hand-Packed Hamburger with Cheese & Bacon.
  $9.75
- Texas Chile Cheeseburger
  Yee-hah! A two-fisted burger (1/2 lb) with Texas chile sauce, onions, mustard and cheese.
  $9.75
- The Banzai Burger
  A high-kicking burger (1/2 lb) with cheese, onions, and our amazing bonzai sauce!
  $9.75
- Open-Face Burger
  The burger that eats like a meal. Burger (1/2 lb) served with fries smothered in gravy, mushrooms, onions, and our famous cheese sauce.
  $11.99
- Chicken Sandwich
  Crispy chicken nestled in a warm bun
  $8.50
- The "Feast of the Boss" Chicken Sandwich
  The boss's own recipe: char-broiled chicken patty with lettuce, tomato, hickory smoked bacon, and the boss's secret sauce on a fresh baked sesame seed bun.
  $8.75
- Texas Weiner
  The local classic with grilled weiner, Texas weiner sauce, onions and mustard.
  $3.50
Fried Chicken
The most mouth-watering southern-fried chicken in the north, deepfried to a perfect golden brown and served with an order of crisp golden fries.
- Chicken Fingers & Fries
  $9.99
French Fries
Top our golden crisp fries your way - any way! With our famous cheese sauce, texas chili sauce or our smokin' savory gravy... in any combination!
- Regular Fries
  Crispy golden fries, salted to perfection.
  $4.99
- Bucket of Fries
  $5.99
Salad & Wraps
All of our salads, wraps, and sandwiches are made from only the very freshest produce, meats, breads, and dairy products! Guaranteed!
- Side Salad
  Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers and olives.
  $5.50
- Garden Salad
  Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, olives, cooked ham and provolone.
  $9.99
- Garden Salad with Sliced Breast of Chicken
  Fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, olives and grilled chicken.
  $10.99
- Rancho Chicken Wrap
  Chicken fingers wrapped with crisp lettuce, fresh tomatoes, and creamy ranch dressing.
  $9.99
- Chicken Caesar Wrap
  Tender chicken grilled to perfection and wrapped in fresh romaine lettuce and our signature caesar dressing.
  $9.99
- Turkey Wrap
  Fresh deli-style turkey, lettuce, cheese, tomatoes and light mayo rolled in a soft tortilla.
  $9.50
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Crisp romaine, tender grilled chicken, shaved Parmesan, and croutons, all drizzled with classic Caesar dressing.
  $9.99
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  $9.99
Subs & Calzones
- Cheeseburger Sub
  An American classic done submarine-style! Our 100% fresh top sirloin burger is topped with melted cheese and all the Fixin's.
  $9.99
- Steak & Cheese
  Our steak is sliced thin and piled high, grilled to perfection with caramelized onions and melted cheese.
  $9.99
- Chicken Steak
  Prefer chicken to beef? Our steak-sliced chicken is excellent!
  $9.99
- Meat Ball Parmesan
  Fresh sub roll stuffed with our perfectly seasoned meatballs and topped with our own marinara sauce and melted cheese.
  $9.99
- Chicken Finger Sub
  A great selection with our own fried chicken strips, lettuce, tomato and light mayo.
  $9.99
- Sausage & Peppers
  Your choice of hot or sweet sausage and fresh grilled peppers and onions on a fresh-baked roll.
  $9.99
- Hot Wing Sub
  Our awesome boneless hot wings in a sub, blended with your choice of one of our 11 signature hot wing sauces.
  $9.99
- Turkey Sub
  Delicious fresh sliced turkey and cheese with all your favorite fixings.
  $9.99
- Turkey Club Sub
  Deli-sliced turkey and cheese with all your favorite fixings.
  $9.99
- Italian Sub
  Our classic Italian hoagie with fresh sliced deli meats and cheese, onions, lettuce, tomato and peppers (hot or sweet), dressed any way you like.
  $9.99
- Ham & Cheese
  Ham and American cheese or our hot slammin' hammin' and cheese topped your way!
  $9.99
- Oven Baked Steak & Cheese
  Our famous steak and cheese baked to melted goodness in a thin crispy golden-brown crust.
  $10.99
- Oven Baked Ham & Cheese
  Fresh deli ham and melted cheese never tasted this good!
  $10.99
- Oven Baked Chicken & Cheese
  Our great thin-sliced chicken steak and creamy melted cheese in one of our most popular oven subs.
  $10.99
- Oven Baked Chicken Parmesan
  An Italian classic in an oven-baked crust. Tender chicken, marinara sauce and melted cheese.
  $10.99
- All Regular Hot or Cold Subs
  Submarine sandwiches, available hot or cold.
  $9.99
- Wraps
  Our fresh-made pizza and dough stuffed with your favorite ingredients and baked to perfection!
  $9.99
- All Oven Baked Subs
  $10.99
- Traditional Calzone
  $11.99
- Steak & Cheezer Calzone
  Stuffed with tender steak and melted cheese, this calzone features a golden, crispy crust.
  $11.99
- Steak Parmesan Calzone
  $11.99
- Italian Calzone
  $11.99
- Broccoli & Cheese Calzone
  $11.99
- Ham & Cheezer Calzone
  $11.99
- Hot Wing Calzone
  $11.99
- BBQ Chicken Calzone
  Qtr chicken served with black beans, and fried mac and cheese.
  $11.99
- Gyros
  The classic mediterranean sandwich! Gyro with lamb or chicken, lettuce, tomato, Tzeki sauce and onion in a soft pita wrap.
  $9.00
Desserts
- Cinnamon Pizza Frites
  A local favorite with a Goodfellas taste! Freshly fried dough with cinnamon sugar served hot with vanilla icing for dipping
  $6.50
- Cookie Craver
  Fresh baked chocolate chip cookie smothered with vanilla ice cream and topped with whipped cream & cherries.
  $7.50
- Kids Munch box
  $4.50
- Kids Hot Dog with Fries
  $7.50
- Kids Burger with Fries
  $7.50
- Kids Chick Fingers with Fries
  $7.50
- Chicken Lamb & Rice
  $12.99
- Chicken & Rice
  $12.99
- Lamb & Rice
  $12.99
Beverages
- 20 Oz. Bottle
  20 oz. bottle soda; options include Cherry Coke, Coke, Diet Coke, Ice Tea, Orange, Root Beer, Sprite, and Vitamin Water.
  $2.00
- 2 Liters
  2 liters of soda available in Coke, Diet Coke, Orange, Sprite.
  $3.50
- MilkShake
  $4.50

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

GoodFellas Pizza Menu

Customer Favorites

Regular Fries

Don Pepperoni

Large Cheese Pizza

Our Awesome Boneless Wings

Our Famous Regular Wings (10 Wings)

Bucket of Fries

Our Famous Regular Wings (5 Wings)

Mozzarella Stix

Steak & Cheese

Cinnamon Pizza Frites

Hot Wings

Our Awesome Boneless Wings

Our Famous Regular Wings (5 Wings)

Our Famous Regular Wings (10 Wings)

Our Famous Regular Wings (50 Wings)

Our Famous Regular Wings (100 Wings)

Blue Cheese & Celery

Pizza

Mini-Pizza Topped Your Way

Slice

Small Cheese Pizza

Large Cheese Pizza

Extra Large Cheese Pizza

Small White Pizza

Large White Pizza

Cheeser Pleaser Square Pizza

Specialty Pizza

Meat Lovers Pizza

Veggie Delight

Don Pepperoni

Hot Wing Pizza

Chicken Parmesan

Double Crusted Broccoli & Cheese

Double Crusted Steak & Cheese

Double Crusted Sausage & Cheese

Hawaiian Pizza

Appetizers

Chicken Quesadilla

Nachos

The Munch Box

Jalapeño Poppers

Hot Wing Shrimp

Onion Rings

Mozzarella Stix

Perogies 3pc

Perogies 6pc

Dipping Stix

Bread Stix

Cheesy Stix

Broccoli Cheese Bites

Chicken Fries

Burgers

Our 100% Fresh Ground Beef Hand-Packed 1/2 lb Hamburger

Cheeseburger (1/2 lb)

Bacon Cheeseburger (1/2 lb)

Texas Chile Cheeseburger

The Banzai Burger

Open-Face Burger

Chicken Sandwich

The "Feast of the Boss" Chicken Sandwich

Texas Weiner

Fried Chicken

Chicken Fingers & Fries

French Fries

Regular Fries

Bucket of Fries

Salad & Wraps

Side Salad

Garden Salad

Garden Salad with Sliced Breast of Chicken

Rancho Chicken Wrap

Chicken Caesar Wrap

Turkey Wrap

Chicken Caesar Salad

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Subs & Calzones

Cheeseburger Sub

Steak & Cheese