Gaetano's Sub Shop

Legit NY deli style sandwiches. You cannot go wrong here.

Danger dog was on point! Fries were crispy. The poppers were a bit cold. But still tasty. I love the little side of peppers that arrives with the sandwich. Service was great. Place was clean. They have tons of options. Parking isn't the greatest. But this place is definitely worth it.

Normally great food, so this review is for one sandwich specifically. Today, I decided to try something different & get the Fungi Philly which ended up being a mistake. Other mushroom Phillies I've had in the past have come LOADED with mushrooms, I bet my sandwich today had less than 5 slices of mushrooms in total and ultimately made for a very small and underwhelming sandwich. Pretty disappointing to have such a sad veggie sandwich option.

Got the Wasatch Burger sub "chop cheese" style and it was so good!!! If I closed my eyes I could be fooled that I was at a bodega in NYC. But no.... right down in SLC. Their menu is deep, their ingedients are fresh, the place is CLEAN and the service is on point. I cant wait to go back!

Kasey here! Embarking on this review is like trying to capture the essence of a sublime Italian sub that's been haunting my daydreams. Picture the finest capicola in the state, cozying up with hard salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, provolone, impeccably cut white onions, mayo, and a dash of sub dressing – all chilling on a cold sub. It's a masterpiece. Quick shoutout to Gaetano's "Inferno Sauce" – a revelation for a saucy aficionado like me. Seriously, when you swing by for one of their sandwiches, don't sleep on asking for a side of this chipotle heaven. Your taste buds will thank you. Now, let's dive into the experience. Every time I waltz into this joint, it's like a warm welcome party. Multiple team members dish out the friendliness, making the whole experience of grabbing my food downright delightful. The owner is a local legend – well-known, respected, and a massive supporter of other small businesses in the area. Meeting someone this awesome? Pure thrill. If you're into heavenly subs, killer sauces, and an all-around good vibe, this spot's your haven. Here's to mouthwatering bites and meeting the cool cats behind the counter!

Great food!Service even better!

Love their cheeseburger subs. Good fries & plenty of fry sauce.

I’ve loved their subs since the 1980s, and I was overjoyed to learn they now opened up shop in Murray. They are still the top! I got a Firebird sandwich (hold the onions) and it was moderately spicy and 100% delicious. A 6-inch will fill you up! And the fries and fry sauce are exactly how I remembered them…so very very good. The service was wonderfully friendly, pleasant, delightful, and personable, and super quick. The shop in Murray is now my go-to for all my sandwich needs and desires. Five stars across the board.