Frosty Falls Ice Cream Menu

4.7

(275+ Reviews)

Novelties Signature Sundaes Hard Dipped Ice Cream Soft Serve Ice Cream Water Ice Drinks and Munchies Passport 2025 Merch

Novelties
- Chippers
  So many to choose from, all delicious!
  OG Chipper Chocolate
  $8.50
  OG Chipper Twist
  $8.50
  OG Chipper Vanilla
  $8.50
  BPB Chipper
  $8.50
  Cookies n Cream
  $8.50
  Gluten Free Chipper Vanilla
  $8.50
  Rainbow Chipper Vanilla
  $8.50
  Life By Chocolate
  $8.50
  Red Velvet
  $8.50
  River Trail
  $8.50
  Baby BPB Chipper
  $9.00
  Baby Chippers
  $9.00
  Baby Life by Chocolate
  $9.00
  Baby. Rainbow
  $9.00
  Baby Red Velvet
  $9.00
  Baby River Trail
  $9.00
  6Pk Variety Baby Chipper
  $18.00
- Cutie Pies
  Cutie Pies are individual versions of our Frosty Freeze Pies! Varieties will be rotating so grab your favorite while you can!BPB- Twist ice cream/Reeses cups and pieces/ fudge and PB drizzleHoly Moly Cannoli- Chocolate ice cream/cannoli cream swirl/mini choco chips/ topped w/ mini cannoli
  BPB
  $5.00
  Oreo Cheesecake
  $5.00
  Choco Strawberry
  $5.00
  Hershey Pie
  $5.00
  Sampler
  $18.00
- Frozen Nana
  Frozen banana's dipped in our vegan chocolate dip.Try with peanuts or peanut butter dipped for $.50 more.
  Regular
  $3.50
  P-Nut Butter
  $4.50
  Peanut
  $4.50
- Character Pops
  Your (kids) favorite cartoon characters in a delicious pop! Character option varies!
  Batman
  $4.00
  Sonic
  $4.00
  TMNTurtles
  $4.00
  Miraculous Ladybug
  $4.00
  Tweety
  $4.00
  Powderpuff
  $4.00
- S’Mores Sticks
  1 stick
  $5.00
  2 sticks
  $9.00
  5 sticks
  $18.00
- Ice Cream Sandwich (Vanilla)
  Perfect for any occasion, our house made ice cream sandwiches are always a hit!
  6 pack
  $15.00
  Single
  $3.00
Signature Sundaes
- Frosty Filler Bowl
  Start with a waffle cone bowl. Pick your soft serve: Vanilla, Chocolate or twistWe give it a face and fill it with your choice of drip: Hot Fudge-Caramel Marshmallow-PB Sauce Milk or Dark Chocolate Syrup Butterscotch-Strawberry SauceThen we seal it all in with a hard chocolate shell and top it with a topping of your choice!
  $9.00
- Half-Baked Sundae
  Your choice of either a brownie, hot pretzel, waffle, funnel cake or 2 choc chop cookies topped with any 2 scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream and a cherry.**Upgrade with a David’s Gluten/Dairy/Nut Free chocolate chip brownie for $2.5
  $11.00
- Kinda Baked Parfait
  Brownie bites & hot fudge on the bottom. Twist soft serve. Middle layer cookie dough bites & caramel. Finished with twist soft serve, fudge & caramel, hot funnel cake pieces, whipped & cherry.
  $10.50
- Holy Moly Cannoli
  Crushed up cannoli shells and cannoli cream under chocolate soft serve. Finished with more cream, more crushed shells and mini chocolate chips
  $10.00
- I Don't Know What I Want
  Feeling brave? Hand this to the experts Choose a theme: “Peanut Butter”, “Chocolate”, “Fruity” and now “Seasonal”. Leave the rest to us. Each sundae comes with a fortune cookie just because
  Chocolate
  $9.50
  Peanut Butter
  $9.50
  Fruity
  $9.50
  Dealers Choice
  $9.50
- Non Dairy Half baked
  Your choice of dairy free ice cream on top of a gluten/dairy free David’s brownie. Finished with 2 regular toppings of your choice.
  $11.50
- OK, Monster Man
  Bottom scoop cookie monster, top scoop mint chocolate chip. Topped with hot fudge, M&M’s, Cookie dough bite eyes, sugar cone hat, Kit Kat antennas and whipped cream hair.
  $9.50
- Peanut Butter Rocky Mountain
  Bottom scoop moose track, middle PB ripple and topped with vanilla soft serve. Finished with a PB cone dip river, PB sauce trails, Reese’s puff boulders, chopped Reese’s cups rocks and a whole Reese’s cup sun spear.
  $11.00
- Purple Rain (Shirts vs Blouses)
  Dark chocolate and black raspberry ice cream topped with hot fudge, butterscotch, brownie bites, chocolate waffle cone pieces, whipped & cherry
  $9.50
- Strawberry Cruncher ON
  Bottom scoop vanilla, middle strawberry and topped with vanilla soft serve. Two layers of our house made strawberry crunch, strawberry syrup then finished with whipped cream and cherry.
  $10.00
- Save Dorothy’s Day (ON)
  A small Frosty freeze blended with twist ice cream thin mint fudge cookies, chocolate limmies and finished with a fresh chocolate chip cookie spear.
  $11.00
- Roly Moly Cannoli ON
  Crushed up cannoli shells and raspberry cannoli cream under vanilla soft serve. Finished with more cream, more crushed shells, mini chocolate chips and a cannoli spear
  $10.50
- The BPB
  A Frosty Falls classic! Vanilla, Chocolate and Peanut Butter ice cream topped with Reese's Pieces, Reese's cups, hot fudge, peanut butter drizzle, whipped cream and a cherry.
  $10.00
- The 59
  Vanilla and chocolate hard ice cream topped with twist soft. Draped in peanut butter cone dip, caramel sauce and peanuts. Finished with whipped cream, green jimmies and the final score. Go Birds!
  $10.50
- The Fiery Turtle
  Hot Fudge, Caramel & Candied Spicy pecans on the bottom. Twist ice cream topped with chocolate cone dip, more fudge, caramel & candied spicy pecans.
  $10.00
- Tropical Staycation
  Banana, Strawberry & Vanilla ice cream topped w/toasted coconut, pineapple, chopped almonds, whipped cream & cherry.
  $9.50
Hard Dipped Ice Cream
- Milkshake
  Our hard dipped ice cream of your choice blended to perfection.
  Small
  $7.00
  Regular
  $8.00
  Large
  $9.00
- Vegan Milkshake
  Our hard dipped vegan ice cream of your choice blended to perfection with almond milk.
  Small
  $8.75
  Medium
  $10.25
  Large
  $11.25
- 1 Scoop Hard Ice Cream
  Your choice of 1 scoop of our delicious hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $5.50
- 1 Scoop VEGAN Ice Cream
  Your choice of 1 scoop of our delicious vegan hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $7.25
- 2 Scoops Hard Ice Cream
  Your choice of 2 scoops of our delicious hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $6.50
- 2 Scoops VEGAN Ice Cream
  Your choice of 2 scoops of our delicious vegan hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $9.00
- 3 Scoops Hard Ice Cream
  Your choice of 3 scoops of our delicious hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $8.00
- 3 Scoops VEGAN Ice Cream
  Your choice of 3 scoops of our delicious hard ice cream.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  $10.75
- 5 Mini Scoop Flight
  $12.00
- Toppings
  $1.25
- Quart Hard Ice Cream
  Our hard dipped ice cream of your choice ready to go.
  $13.50
- Cones
  Cake cone
  $0.50
  Gluten Free Cake
  $1.00
  Sugar Cone
  $0.50
  Waffle cone
  $1.25
  Choco Waffle
  $1.50
  Waffle Cone Bowl
  $1.50
  JUMBO Waffle cone
  $2.00
  Pretzel cone
  $1.50
  Fancy Waffle/Rainbow Jimmies
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Chocolate Jimmies
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Peanuts
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Fruity Pebbles
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Barbie
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Space Jam
  $2.25
Soft Serve Ice Cream
- Soft Serve Ice Cream
  Our creamy soft serve with your choice of a cup or a cone.****All cones ordered will be placed on the side for safest transportation****
  Kid
  $4.50
  Small
  $5.50
  Medium
  $6.50
  Large
  $7.50
  Quart
  $11.50
- Frosty Filler Bowl
  Start with a waffle cone bowl. Pick your soft serve: Vanilla, Chocolate or twistWe give it a face and fill it with your choice of drip: Hot Fudge-Caramel Marshmallow-PB Sauce Milk or Dark Chocolate Syrup Butterscotch-Strawberry SauceThen we seal it all in with a hard chocolate shell and top it with a topping of your choice!
  $9.00
- Frosty Freeze
  Our creamy soft serve blended with a topping of your choice!
  Small
  $7.00
  Large
  $8.00
- The CTC
  Cinnamon Toast Crunch layered with marshmallow sauce and a caramel drizzle in-between vanilla soft serve.
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- Pebbles and Slam
  Fruity Pebbles and marshmallow sauce layered with vanilla soft serve. Topped with a cherry hat!
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- CoCo LoCo
  Coco Pebbles & hot fudge layered with chocolate soft serve and topped with a choco dip hat!
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- Love of Puff
  Reeses Puffs and Reeses PB sauce layered with vanilla soft serve and topped with a chocolate hat!
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- Silly Rabbit
  Trix cereal & strawberry syrup layered with vanilla soft serve.
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- OhEmGee
  Oreo O’s & marshmallow sauce layered with vanilla soft serve topped with hot fudge, more marshmallow and cereal.
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- Cap’n Killa
  Captain crunch layered with marshmallow sauce and vanilla soft serve. Finished with a caramel drizzle.
  Large
  $8.50
  Small
  $7.50
- Toppings
  $1.25
- Pup sundae
  **Please have dogs with you if you can because I like to see them :)***
- Cones
  Cake cone
  $0.50
  Gluten Free Cake
  $1.00
  Sugar Cone
  $0.50
  Waffle cone
  $1.25
  Choco Waffle
  $1.50
  Waffle Cone Bowl
  $1.50
  JUMBO Waffle cone
  $2.00
  Pretzel cone
  $1.50
  Fancy Waffle/Rainbow Jimmies
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Chocolate Jimmies
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Peanuts
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Fruity Pebbles
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Barbie
  $2.25
  Fancy Waffle/Space Jam
  $2.25
Water Ice
- Gelati
  Your choice of Philadelphia Water Ice served with a top and bottom layer of our creamy soft serve.
  Small
  $5.50
  Medium
  $6.50
  Large
  $7.50
- Kid Water Ice
  One scoop of any flavor of your choice.
  $3.50
- Small Water Ice
  $4.00
- Med Water Ice
  Your choice of up to 2 flavors.
  $5.00
- Lg Water Ice
  Your choice of up to 3 flavors.
  $6.50
- Quart Water Ice
  A quart of your choice of water ice.
  $10.00
Drinks and Munchies
- Hot dog
  $2.50
- Brownie
  Our house made brownie served warm.
  Regular
  $6.00
  Salted Caramel Brownie
  $7.00
  BPB
  $8.50
  Fiery Turtle
  $8.00
- Pretzels
  Hot and made to order!
  $3.50
- Cookies
  Baked fresh in house daily
  1 Chocolate Chip
  $2.50
  3 Chocolate Chip
  $7.00
  1 Peanut Butter
  $2.50
  3 Peanut Butter
  $7.00
  1 PB 2 CC
  $7.00
  1 CC 2 PB
  $7.00
- Waffle
  Our delicious sugar crystal waffle, toasted and served.
  $4.25
- Za Rolls
  Delicious, hot and gooey. Yes, they're pizza rolls.
  $5.00
- Korndog
  Honey battered and cooked to a crispy perfection.
  $3.50
- Funnel Cake
  Yummy hot funnel cake topped with powdered sugar
  $5.00
- Mozzarella Sticks
  Regular Sticks
  $5.00
  Gluten Free Sticks
  $6.00
- Corn Poppers
  Corn Nuggets
  $6.00
- Mac & Cheese Bites
  Macaroni & cheese wedges
  $5.50
Passport 2025
- 2025 Frosty Falls Passport
  It's time for the 2025 passports!! Here’s how they work: Spend $50 today and get a punch card that can be used to get 1 item up to $10 in value each month from March to December of 2025. We hope you use your passport to try a variety of items on the menu or take the chance to build the sundae of your dreams! Passports make GREAT gifts that last the whole year! This year we are excited to offer a limited amount of special Passport Packs for only $60 that includes some great items for the ice cream lover in your life. We appreciate your support and thank you so much for the most amazing 2024 season we could have hoped for! Looking forward to the next!
  $50.00
Merch
- Frosty Button
  2 1/4” pin back button
  $3.00
- F*ing Love Ice Cream Bumper Sticker
  We know that you do, so why not let everyone else know how much you love ice cream!
  $3.00
- 2025 Frosty Falls Passport
  It's time for the 2025 passports!! Here’s how they work: Spend $50 today and get a punch card that can be used to get 1 item up to $10 in value each month from March to December of 2025. We hope you use your passport to try a variety of items on the menu or take the chance to build the sundae of your dreams! Passports make GREAT gifts that last the whole year! This year we are excited to offer a limited amount of special Passport Packs for only $60 that includes some great items for the ice cream lover in your life. We appreciate your support and thank you so much for the most amazing 2024 season we could have hoped for! Looking forward to the next!
  $50.00
- Gray Haunted Falls Shirts 2024’
  Small
  $15.00
  Medium
  $15.00
  Large
  $15.00
  XL
  $15.00
  XXL
  $15.00
  XXXL
  $15.00
- Orange Haunted Falls shirts 2024
  Small
  $15.00
  Medium
  $15.00
  Large
  $15.00
  XL
  $15.00
  XXL
  $15.00
  XXXL
  $15.00