Search
Five Pennies Creamery Menu
4.8
(425+ Reviews)
Scoops
- Large Scoop (1-3 flavors)Ice cream of choice in cup (select 1-3 flavors)$7.67
- Small Scoop (1 flavor)Ice cream of choice in cup (select 1 flavor)$5.52
- Medium Scoop (1-2 flavors)Ice cream of choice in cup (select 1-2 flavors)$6.75
Five Pennies Sundae
- Large Sundae (1-3 flavors)Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry (select 1-3 flavors and 2 toppings)$9.82
- Small Sundae (1 flavor)Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry (select 1 flavor and 2 toppings)$6.75
- Medium Sundae (1-2 flavors)Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry (select 1-2 flavors and 2 toppings)$8.59
Specialty Items
- Milkshake (1-2 flavors)Blended ice cream with milk (select 1-2 flavors)$11.04
- Malted Milkshake (1-2 flavors)Blended ice cream with milk and malted milk powder (select 1-2 flavors)$11.66
- Ice Cream Flight (4 flavors)Selection of 4 mini ice creams (select 4 flavors)$10.43
- Banana Split (1-3 flavors)Fresh banana with three scoops of ice cream, 3 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry (select 1-3 flavors and 1-3 toppings)$11.04
- Pint (1-2 flavors)Hand-packed pint of ice cream (select 1-2 flavors)$11.66
Extras & Sides
- Sugar Cone$0.37
- Waffle Cone$1.23
- Topping Side Cup$1.23
- Wafer Cone$0.37
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
