Most Popular
- Finagle's Famous Egg SandwichFried egg & cheddar cheese on your favorite bagel with your choice of bacon, sausage, smoked ham, tomato, or avocado. You can substitute the fried egg for a cholesterol-free egg.$6.99
Breakfast
- Finagle's Famous Egg SandwichFried egg & cheddar cheese on your favorite bagel with your choice of bacon, sausage, smoked ham, tomato, or avocado. You can substitute the fried egg for a cholesterol-free egg.$6.99
- Veggie OmeletteEgg & cheddar cheese mixed with seasonal vegetable on a bagel.$6.99
- Phoenix PressFried egg, black bean salsa, tomato, avocado & cheddar cheese grilled on a jalapeno bagel. You can substitute the fried egg for a cholesterol-free egg.$7.99
- Traditional PressFried egg, bacon, ham & cheddar cheese on a grilled bagel. You can substitute the fried egg for a cholesterol-free egg.$7.99
- The Patriot SandwichGrilled steak, fried egg & habanero cheese on a bagel. You can substitute the fried egg for a cholesterol-free egg.$7.99
- Finagle Scrambled Breakfast PlateScrambled eggs, bacon, hash browns & your favorite bagel with cream cheese.$11.99
- Tomato & Avocado Scrambled Egg PlateScrambled eggs, tomato, avocado, small fruit salad & your favorite bagel with cream cheese.$11.99
- Smoked Salmon & Scrambled Egg BreakfastSmoked salmon, scrambled eggs, hash browns & your favorite bagel with choice of cream cheese.$13.99
- Huevos Rancheros WrapScrambled eggs, bacon, spicy black beans, avocado, cheddar & creamy hot sauce drizzled on a wrap & pressed.$9.99
- Steak & Egg WrapFresh scrambled eggs, steak, hash browns, cheddar cheese and a special sauce on a wrap.$9.99
- Bagel With Cream Cheese$4.49
- Bagel With Peanut Butter$4.49
- Bagel With Butter$3.99
- Bagel With Strawberry Jelly$3.99
- Side Of Hash Browns2 pcs.$2.99
- Side Of Bacon$4.99
Our Bagels
- Naked Bagel$2.99
- Baker's Dozen BagelsChoose from a variety of Finagle's Artisan bagels, pick a mixed assortment, or choose to select in-store when you arrive for pick-up. 13 pieces.$18.99
- Half Dozen BagelsChoose from a variety of Finagle's Artisan bagels, pick a mixed assortment, or choose to select in-store when you arrive for pick-up.$11.99
Sandwiches
- Finagle's Famous Smokehouse Club SandwichTurkey, bacon, cheddar, lettuce, tomato & our signature chipotle mayo.$12.99
- Smoked Salmon & Cream Cheese SandwichSmoked salmon, tomato, capers, red onion & cream cheese on the World's Best Bagel.$12.99
- Tuna Melt SandwichTuna salad, tomato, cheddar cheese & avocado.$12.99
- Chipotle Chicken Bacon Melt SandwichChicken breast, bacon, tomato, cheddar cheese & our signature chipotle mayo.$12.99
- Santa Fe Melt SandwichTurkey, avocado, black beans, cheddar cheese & pepperberry sauce on a jalapeno bagel.$12.99
- Pastrami Reuben SandwichFirst-cut, lean pastrami, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese & Russian dressing pressed on a marble bagel & served with a dill pickle.$11.50
- First Street Chicken Salad SandwichChicken salad, bacon, cheddar cheese, lettuce & our special sauce on a plain bagel.$12.99
- Classic Chicken SandwichMarinated chicken breast, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo & honey mustard.$12.99
- The Basics SandwichServed with tomato & lettuce.$10.99
- Tomato Cheddar Melt SandwichTomato, avocado, honey mustard & cheddar cheese on a bagel of your choice.$10.99
- Cheesesteak Melt SandwichSauteed steak, caramelized red onions, yellow & red peppers, and provolone cheese pressed on white bread.$12.99
Soups & A Bagel
- Creamy Tomato SoupBowl of soup served with a buttered bagel.$9.99
- Beef Chili SoupBowl of soup served with a buttered bagel.$9.99
Pizza Bagels
- Cheese Pizza BagelTopped with marinara sauce & mozzarella cheese.$6.49
Beverages
- Hot Coffee$2.99
- Hot Tea$2.99
- Iced Coffee$3.99
- Hot ChocolateRich & creamy milk chocolate.$4.19
- Iced Tea$3.99
- Lemonade$3.99
- Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice$4.98
- Box Of Coffee$24.99
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.