Fatty's Fish Shack Menu

Your Choice 1/2 pound or full pound of large key west pinks. we cook you peel. Steamed in Old Bay. Served with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

Center cut Mahi Mahi cooked to perfection served over our pineapple salsa. With your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

New Orleans styled red fish seasoned with our southern inspired blackening seasoning and grilled to perfection. Served with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

Beer Battered Filet of fresh grouper served with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

12- 14 ounces of cold-water snow crab cluster steamed in old bay with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

Two 6 ounce chicken breasts with salt, pepper, and garlic seasoned to perfection served with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

Five of our tenders served with your choice of side and our daily vegetable.

1/4lb of Cod, 1/4lb Clam Strips, 3 Hush Puppies, 6 Shrimp, and your choice of side and our daily vegetable. (This meal is only served battered & fried)

12 large shrimp battered and fried to perfection served with our daily vegetable, side of tartar, lemon wedge, and your choice of side.

1/2lb Hogfish filet baked skin on with a ginger lime butter. Served over rice with our veggie of the day.

1/2lb Hog Fish Filet baked and then topped with Sweet Chili Sauce. Served Over Rice with our daily veggie.

Chicken Breast grilled and put in a flour tortilla with cabbage, blend of cheese, house pineapple pico, and our housemade remi sauce served with tortillas and tomato pico.

Grilled Chicken stuffed into a large tortilla with a Monterey/Cheddar blend, and house pico. Served with black beans & rice.

Grilled lobster claw & knuckle meat stuffed into a large tortilla with a Monterey/Cheddar blend, and house pico. Served with black beans & rice.

Grilled Mahi Mahi served in two flour tortillas with cabbage, remi sauce, and cheese blend topped with pineapple pico. Served with black beans and rice.

Grilled Red fish served in two flour tortillas with cabbage, remi sauce, and cheese blend topped with pineapple pico. Served with black beans and rice.

Grilled Shrimp blackened then stuffed into a large tortilla with a Monterey/Cheddar blend, and house pico. Served with black beans & rice.

Grilled blackened shrimp served in two flour tortillas with cabbage, remi sauce, and cheese blend topped with pineapple pico. Served with black beans and rice.

Ribeye steak, Chicken, and Shrimp grilled to perfection in a 12inch tortilla with a blend of cheeses and house pico. Side of pic, side of sour cream, peppers, and lettuce. With Black Beans and Rice or change to another side for a small charge.

Two beef Tacos with blend of cheeses, southwest sauce, lettuce, and tomato Pico. With fried tortilla chips and side.

Filet mignon cut and grilled in tips layered in flour tortillas with southwest sauce, pico, lettuce, and a blend of cheeses.

Filet Mignon cut into tips grilled and stuffed in a flour tortilla with a blend of cheeses, and house pico. served with black beans and rice and a side of jalepenos, lettuce, and sour cream.

Filet tips and grilled shrimp stuffed and grilled in a flour tortilla with a blend of cheeses and house pico. Served with black beans and rice, a side of sour cream, lettuce, and jalepenos.

BBQ Brisket , stuffed in a flour tortilla with our pineapple pico, a blend of cheeses, served with Black Beans & Rice and side of pineapple pico & Sour cream.

Our House Mac Baked with fresh grilled shrimp. Served with our daily vegetable.

Our House Mac Baked with lump crab meat. Served with our daily vegetable.

Our House Mac Baked with fresh steamed lobster claw and knuckle pieces. Served with our daily vegetable.

Half Pound of Cod battered English style served with fries and our daily vegetable.

Our first mates meals come with French Fries and kids juice box.

Our House Macaroni and cheese served with a side of fries and kids juice box.

Two tenders, with fries and a kids juice box.

Our grilled chicken breast tossed in buffalo topped with blue cheese crumble, veggies on a brioche bun served with fries.

Cold water lobster knuckle & claw meat steamed in old bay served on a challah roll with fries. Side of drawn butter included and a lemon wedge.

Fatty's Prime Burger 1/2lb on a brioche bun served with fries.

Grouper cooked your choice. Please select grilled, blackened, or fried with veggies on a brioche bun served with fries.

Lump Crab cake lightly breaded fried with veggies on a brioche bun served with fries.

Lobster salad made to order with cold water lobster knuckle and claw meat served on a challah roll with fries. Mayo and fresh veggies can not be modified.

One pound of Prince Edward Island mussels cooked in shallots, garlic, butter, white wine, and lemon juice. Served with side of French Bread

Iceberg warning in these waters at Fatty's Fish Shack. It's a wedge from the past fresh piece of iceberg, blue cheese crumbles, two slices of bacon, two tomatoes. Comes with our house balsamic glaze drizzled on top, and blue cheese dressing on the side.

Yes we are in Palm Harbor but our roots of Greek culture in our area come from Tarpon Springs. Fresh Iceberg, a hidden scoop of potato salad, anchovies, and fresh vegetables. Comes with our house Greek dressing.

A side salad served with our house Greek dressing.

Fresh Mixed Greens topped with cucumber, strawberries, hickory smoked feta, and a mix of cranberries, honey roasted pecans, walnuts & almonds with a side of Raspberry vinaigrette or lemon poppy seed dressing. 

Seven of our house hush puppies.

A side of our house rice topped with black beans and sprinkled with our house cheese blend.

Parmesan and Gruyere blended with heavy cream mixed with house pasta. Sprinkled with a Monterey Cheddar Blend.

Six of Captain Rio's finest sea creatures served with house cocktail sauce.

This gator can't bite anymore. Comes with our spicy ranch dressing which can pack a small bite.

Nassau style fritters with fresh conch and vegetables deep fried to perfection served with our house dipping sauce and a wedge of lemon.

Bite sized grouper nuggets 1/3 pound lightly breaded flash fried and served with tartar and a wedge of lemon.

Half pound of rings, and tentacles lightly floured , seasoned and quickly fried served with wasabi mayo and a lemon wedge.

Six large Tampa shrimp coated in coconut and seasoning fried to perfection served with our Thai Chili Sauce.

Half pound of clam strips breaded and deep fried served with tartar sauce.

Two choices southwest beef or mango chicken loaded with toppings and baked to perfection we even fry our own corn tortilla chips.

Half Pound of North Atlantic Cod Nuggets made in house breaded and deep fried to order. Served with a lemon wedge and tartar for dipping.

1 Pound of baked then fried wings. In your choice of sauce 1 sauce per order please. Comes with celery and then your choice of blue cheese or ranch or both for a small charge.

Smoked mahi, pickled jalapeños, pickled onions, diced tomato, and fried pita bread.

Freshly smoked salmon, typically mixed with dill, capers, and red onion, served with crostini.

Smoked salmon and mahi dip served with crostinis, crackers, lemon, red onion, capers, and fresh jalapeños.

A southern inspired favorite at Fatty's Fish Shack loaded with corn, potatoes, vegetables, and shrimp. May pack a slight kick with our house Cajun Seasoning. Served with saltine crackers.