Fatman's Pizza Menu

4.5

(275+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Drinks Additional Items Appetizers & Sides Salads Subs Speciality Subs Pizza Specialty Pizza Calzones Wings, Fingers & Boneless Wings Everyday Combos & Specials Desserts

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Large
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $22.99
- Chicken Wings
  Served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
  $18.99
- Small
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $17.79
- Personal
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $10.99
- Fresh-Cut French Fries
  Crisp, golden fresh-cut french fries, lightly seasoned for a classic taste.
  $5.69
- Chicken Fingers
  Served with fresh cut French fries, homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
  $17.49
- Slice
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $3.19
- Extra Bleu Cheese
  $1.75
- 2-Liter
  $3.99
- Can Pop
  Selection of canned sodas including classic and diet options, featuring Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Dr Pepper, and specialty flavors like Wild Cherry and Orange Crush.
  $2.50
Drinks
Available in Cans and 2-Liters, in Pepsi Products
- Can Pop
  Selection of canned sodas including classic and diet options, featuring Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Dr Pepper, and specialty flavors like Wild Cherry and Orange Crush.
  $2.50
- 2-Liter
  $3.99
Additional Items
- Extra Bleu Cheese
  $1.75
- Extra Ranch
  $1.00
- Extra Semi Sweet Sauce
  Semi-sweet sauce ideal for dipping or drizzling, crafted to complement a variety of dishes with a balanced sweetness.
  $1.00
- Extra Garlic Marinara Sauce
  $1.00
- Extra Wing Sauce
  Variety of wing sauces: from classic plain to exotic spicy lemon pepper, including BBQ, cajun, garlic variations, honey-infused options, and unique blends like maple bacon BBQ.
  $1.00
- Extra Sour Cream
  $1.00
- Extra Caramel Sauce
  $1.00
Appetizers & Sides
- Fresh-Cut French Fries
  Crisp, golden fresh-cut french fries, lightly seasoned for a classic taste.
  $5.69
- Deli Style Potato Chips
  Original or Cajun.
  $5.69
- Onion Rings
  Crispy, golden-brown onion rings with a light, crunchy batter.
  $8.09
- Mozzarella Sticks
  (5).
  $8.09
- Pizza Logs
  (5).
  $9.99
- Taco Logs
  (5) served with sour cream.
  $9.99
- Homemade Mac-N-Cheese
  Tender rotini pasta enveloped in a creamy, rich cheese sauce.
  $11.99
- Bread Sticks
  Served with dipping sauce.
  $11.99
- Stuffed Hungarian Peppers
  (3) topped with melted mozzarella cheese.
  $14.99
- Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers
  Juicy chicken mixed with spicy buffalo sauce, stuffed into bell peppers and topped with melted cheese.
  $14.99
- Potato Skins
  Crispy potato skins topped with melted cheddar cheese.
  $10.79
- Jalapeño Poppers
  Crispy, breaded jalapeños stuffed with creamy cheese, served with a side of tangy dipping sauce.
  $8.29
- Sweet Potato Fries
  Crispy sweet potato fries with a golden-brown exterior and tender interior, lightly seasoned for a balanced taste.
  $8.29
Salads
Dressings will be served on the side, served with garlic toast. Dressings: Bleu cheese, golden Italian, ranch, sweet Italian, Greek, caesar, lite Italian, French, oil and vinegar Add chicken for an additional charge. Extra meat, extra dressing for an additional charge.
- Chef Salad (Small)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese.
  $7.79
- Chef Salad (Large)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese.
  $10.99
- Greek Salad (Small)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black and green olives, feta cheese, and pepperoncini; served with pita.
  $8.09
- Greek Salad (Large)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, black and green olives, feta cheese, and pepperoncini; served with pita.
  $11.99
- Antipasto Salad (Small)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese.
  $11.99
- Antipasto Salad (Large)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni, and mozzarella cheese.
  $15.39
- Julienne Salad (Small)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, turkey, and mozzarella cheese.
  $11.99
- Julienne Salad (Large)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, ham, turkey, and mozzarella cheese.
  $15.39
- Caesar Salad (Small)
  A bed of romaine lettuce topped with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.
  $8.09
- Caesar Salad (Large)
  A bed of romaine lettuce topped with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.
  $10.79
- Buffalo Chicken Salad (Small)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese with fingers.
  $11.99
- Buffalo Chicken Salad (Large)
  A bed of lettuce topped with tomatoes, onions, banana peppers, and mozzarella cheese with fingers.
  $15.39
Subs
All rolls are toasted. Subs come with choice of lettuce, tomatoes, onions. Subs come with choice of mayonnaise or oil. Subs come with choice of swiss-american cheese, provolone, or yellow-american cheese. (Unless specified otherwise). Extra toppings, extra meat, bacon for an additional charge.
- Ham Sub (8")
  Served cold.
  $9.99
- Ham Sub (12")
  Served cold.
  $12.99
- Turkey Sub (8")
  Served cold.
  $9.99
- Turkey Sub (12")
  Served cold.
  $12.99
- Assorted Sub (8")
  Served cold.
  $10.79
- Assorted Sub (12")
  Served cold.
  $14.09
- Roast Beef (8")
  Thinly sliced roast beef, cooked in-house! Quantities will be in limited supply weekly.
  $9.99
- Roast Beef (12")
  Thinly sliced roast beef, cooked in-house! Quantities will be in limited supply weekly.
  $12.99
- BLT Sub (8")
  With cheese.
  $13.09
- BLT Sub (12")
  With cheese.
  $17.29
- Grilled Chicken Sub (8")
  8" Grilled Chicken Sub with options for customization: lettuce, tomatoes, onions, choice of dressings (mayo, oil, both, light or extra variations), ketchup, mustard options, and cheese (Swiss American, Provolone, Yellow American). Toast preference available.
  $12.99
- Grilled Chicken Sub (12")
  12" grilled chicken sub with customizable options including veggie choices (lettuce, tomatoes, onions, or none), mayo, oil, ketchup, mustard variations, cheese (Swiss American, provolone, yellow American), and toast preference.
  $16.99
- Steak Sub (8")
  8" steak sub with options for customizing with veggies such as lettuce, tomatoes, onions, or combo. Choice of mayo, oil, ketchup, mustard variations; cheese like Swiss American, provolone, or American yellow. Toast preference available.
  $11.29
- Steak Sub (12")
  12" steak sub with options for customizing with veggies such as lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Choose sauces from mayo, oil, ketchup, mustard variants. Cheese selections include Swiss American, provolone, American yellow.
  $14.99
- Sausage Sub (8")
  Made with Italian sausage patties.
  $11.29
- Sausage Sub (12")
  Made with Italian sausage patties.
  $14.99
- Cheeseburger Sub (8")
  Made with fresh 4 oz. burger patties.
  $11.29
- Cheeseburger Sub (12")
  Made with fresh 4 oz. burger patties.
  $14.99
Speciality Subs
- Stinger (8")
  (Steak and chicken fingers) with melted provolone cheese your choice of fingers your choice of mayo, oil, bleu cheese or ranch.
  $12.99
- Philly (8")
  (Steak, chicken, or sausage) with sautéed green peppers, onions, mushrooms, and melted yellow American cheese.
  $12.99
- Chicken Finger (8")
  Your choice of fingers your choice of mayo, oil, bleu cheese or ranch your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion.
  $11.59
- Royal (8")
  (Steak, chicken, or sausage) with capicola. Your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion your choice of mayo, oil or both.
  $12.99
- Bologna and Onion (8")
  Diced fried bologna with sautéed onions and melted yellow American cheese.
  $11.59
- Meatball Parm (8")
  Made with your choice of sauce, don't forget to load it up!
  $11.59
- Chicken Parm (8")
  Made with your choice of sauce, don't forget to load it up!
  $11.59
- Sausage Parm (8")
  Made with your choice of sauce, don't forget to load it up!
  $11.59
- Pizza Sub (8")
  Includes one topping, with your choice of sauce.
  $11.59
- Stuffed Pepper Parm (8")
  Made with your choice of sauce.
  $12.49
- Stinger (12")
  12" stinger sub - Choice of sauces ranging from plain to spicy, sweet, and savory options. Customize with a variety of veggies, mayo, oil, and dressings.
  $17.99
- Philly (12")
  12" submarine sandwich with choice of steak, chicken, or sausage. Philly customization includes condiments, toast level, veggies, and cheese options like provolone, cheddar, or mozzarella.
  $17.99
- Chicken Finger (12")
  12" chicken finger submarine; options of sauces including mild to inferno, BBQ variants, and more. Customizable with veggies, condiments, ranging from light to extra toppings.
  $15.99
- Royal (12")
  12" sub with choices of steak, chicken, or sausage. Options include lettuce, tomatoes, onions, various dressings, toast levels, ketchup, mustard, horseradish variations. Customize with preferred extras or lights.
  $16.99
- Bologna and Onion (12")
  12" bologna and onion sub, options: variety of veggies, sauces (mayo, oil, combinations, or horseradish variants), cheese choices (American to mozzarella), and toast preference.
  $14.99
- Meatball Parm (12")
  Tender meatballs, choice of semi-sweet or garlic marinara. Selections of mozzarella, various American cheeses, provolone, cheddar. Options: no/light/extra cheese, toast variations, onions, green/banana peppers, or loaded.
  $14.99
- Chicken Parm (12")
  Chicken parmesan sub, 12 inch. Options: semi-sweet to garlic marinara sauces, variety of cheeses including mozzarella to cheddar. Customizable with onions, green or banana peppers. Toast options available.
  $14.99
- Pizza Sub (12")
  12" submarine sandwich with a variety of free toppings: meats, vegetables, and cheeses. Additional options include sauce choices, toast level, and extra ingredients.
  $14.99
- Stuffed Pepper Parm (12")
  12" submarine sandwich with stuffed pepper parm, choice of semi-sweet or garlic marinara sauce. Options for mozzarella, provolone, Swiss American, yellow American, cheddar. Customize with cheese levels, sauce quantity, and toast preference.
  $16.99
- Sausage Parm (12")
  12" sausage parm submarine sandwich; options include semi-sweet, garlic marinara, assorted cheeses, with choices for toast level and added vegetables or loaded.
  $14.99
Pizza
Now offering our original semi-sweet sauce, or garlic add a marinara garlic crust to any pizza! Sauce. Semi-sweet will be served unless requested otherwise.
- Slice
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $3.19
- Personal
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $10.99
- Small
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $17.79
- Large
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $22.99
- 1/2 Tray
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $30.99
- Tray
  Toppings for an additional charge.
  $39.49
Specialty Pizza
- White Tomato and Onion
  With our homemade white sauce.
  $22.99
- White Veggie
  Choice of up to four (4) toppings with our homemade white sauce.
  $22.99
- Poor Man's Lasagna
  Chopped meatballs, fresh ricotta and mozzarella on our garlic marinara sauce.
  $24.49
- Honey Sriracha
  Choice of pepperoni or sausage on our garlic marinara sauce with a honey sriracha drizzle and fried basil finish.
  $24.49
- Chicken Finger
  Fingers, with bleu cheese sauce.
  $25.49
- Meat Lovers
  With pepperoni, sausage, ham and bacon.
  $25.49
- Stuffed Hungarian Pepper
  With homemade stuffed Hungarian peppers and a garlic butter sauce.
  $25.49
- Hawaiian
  Chopped pineapple and ham, with our semi-sweet sauce, topped with melted. Mozzarella and provolone cheeses.
  $25.49
- Pizza of the Month
  Pizza will change monthly. Can be found on pizza specials menu tab on website (www.fatmanpizzawny.com)
  $25.99
- Philly
  (Steak or chicken) with green peppers, mushrooms, and onions, plus a three cheese blend on our homemade white sauce.
  $27.69
- Mac-N-Cheese Pizza of the Month
  Check out mac-n-cheese pizza of the month tab for what's available! Available on our website (www.fatmanpizzawny.com)
  $26.49
- The Works
  With pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, banana peppers, black olives, and green olives. *No substitutions.
  $29.99
Calzones
Served with sides of pizza sauce unless specified otherwise.
- Cheese Calzone
  With ricotta and mozzarella.
  $10.49
- Cheese and One-Item Calzone
  See pizza section for toppings.
  $12.49
- Chicken Finger Calzone
  Choice of sauce, served with bleu cheese.
  $15.99
- Stuffed Hungarian Pepper Calzone
  With our homemade stuffed peppers.
  $15.99
- Calzone of the Month
  Calzone will change monthly, can view on calzone of the month specials tab.
  $17.49
Wings, Fingers & Boneless Wings
- Chicken Wings
  Served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
  $18.99
- Chicken Fingers
  Served with fresh cut French fries, homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
  $17.49
- Boneless Wings
  Served with homemade bleu cheese, carrots and celery.
  $16.99
Everyday Combos & Specials
- Slices (2) and Drink
  Choice of cheese or cheese and pepperoni with your choice of Pepsi products.
  $9.99
- Small (1) Topping Pizza, 10 Wings
  One-topping pizza with choice of original or garlic marinara sauce. Accompanied by 10 wings, various sauces including spicy, BBQ, honey-flavored, and specialty mixes.
  $34.99
- Small (1) Topping Pizza, Single Finger or (12) Boneless Wings
  Small one topping pizza with your choice of a single chicken finger dinner with fries or (12) boneless wings.
  $32.99
- Large (1) Topping Pizza, 20 Wings
  Large pizza with one topping choice and 20 wings. Sauce options include original or garlic marinara. Wings come with a variety of sauces - from plain to spicy, sweet, or savory blends.
  $53.99
- Large (1) Topping Pizza, Double Fingers or (24) Boneless Wings
  Large (1) topping pizza with your choice of double order of chicken fingers or (24) boneless wings.
  $49.99
- 1/2 Tray (1) Topping Pizza, 30 Wings
  Half tray single topping pizza with choice of original or garlic marinara sauce. Includes 30 wings with an array of sauces from plain to spicy lemon pepper.
  $75.99
- Tray (1) Topping Pizza, 50 Wings
  Tray pizza with choice of original or garlic marinara sauce. Served with 50 wings, options ranging from plain to spicy, including BBQ, cajun, and honey flavors.
  $106.99
Desserts
- Apple Pie Logs
  (5) served with caramel sauce.
  $10.69
- Cinnamon Sticks
  Topped with vanilla icing.
  $8.29

Menu Photos

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Fatman's Pizza Menu

Customer Favorites

Large

Chicken Wings

Small

Personal

Fresh-Cut French Fries

Chicken Fingers

Slice

Extra Bleu Cheese

2-Liter

Can Pop

Drinks

Can Pop

2-Liter

Additional Items

Extra Bleu Cheese

Extra Ranch

Extra Semi Sweet Sauce

Extra Garlic Marinara Sauce

Extra Wing Sauce

Extra Sour Cream

Extra Caramel Sauce

Appetizers & Sides

Fresh-Cut French Fries

Deli Style Potato Chips

Onion Rings

Mozzarella Sticks

Pizza Logs

Taco Logs

Homemade Mac-N-Cheese

Bread Sticks

Stuffed Hungarian Peppers

Buffalo Chicken Stuffed Peppers

Potato Skins

Jalapeño Poppers

Sweet Potato Fries

Salads

Chef Salad (Small)

Chef Salad (Large)

Greek Salad (Small)

Greek Salad (Large)

Antipasto Salad (Small)

Antipasto Salad (Large)

Julienne Salad (Small)

Julienne Salad (Large)

Caesar Salad (Small)

Caesar Salad (Large)

Buffalo Chicken Salad (Small)

Buffalo Chicken Salad (Large)

Subs

Ham Sub (8")

Ham Sub (12")

Turkey Sub (8")

Turkey Sub (12")

Assorted Sub (8")

Assorted Sub (12")

Roast Beef (8")

Roast Beef (12")

BLT Sub (8")

BLT Sub (12")

Grilled Chicken Sub (8")

Grilled Chicken Sub (12")

Steak Sub (8")

Steak Sub (12")

Sausage Sub (8")

Sausage Sub (12")

Cheeseburger Sub (8")

Cheeseburger Sub (12")

Speciality Subs

Stinger (8")

Philly (8")

Chicken Finger (8")

Royal (8")

Bologna and Onion (8")

Meatball Parm (8")

Chicken Parm (8")

Sausage Parm (8")

Pizza Sub (8")

Stuffed Pepper Parm (8")