Fat Witch Bakery Menu

75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011
  • Gift Boxes & Tins

    • 8 Baby Witch Gift Box (All Chocolate Brownies)

      Contains 8 Fat Witch Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each). ***if you would like to include a message card, please put your message in the "extra instructions" box located in checkout***
      $28.99
    • 8 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment 2 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Walnut Babies, 2 Caramel Babies (approx. 1.5"x 1.5" each).
      $28.99
    • 16 Baby Witch Gift Box (All Chocolate Brownies)

      Contains 16 Fat Witch Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $53.99
    • 16 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment: 7 Fat Babies, 3 Blonde Babies, 3 Walnut Babies, 3 Caramel Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $53.99
    • 18 Baby Witch Gift Box (All Chocolate Brownies)

      Contains 18 Fat Witch Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $62.99
    • 18 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment 8 Fat Witch Babies, 2 Blonde Babies, 2 Walnut Babies, 2 Caramel Babies, 2 Snow Babies, 2 Double Chocolate Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $62.99
    • 27 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment 12 Fat Witch Babies, 3 Blonde Babies, 3 Walnut Babies, 3 Snow Babies, 3 Caramel Babies, 3 Double Chocolate Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $87.99
    • 36 Baby Witch Gift Box (All Chocolate Brownies)

      Contains 36 Fat Witch Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $114.50
    • 36 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment 16 Fat Witch Babies, 4 Blonde Babies, 4 Walnut Babies, 4 Caramel Babies, 4 Snow Babies, 4 Double Chocolate Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $114.50
    • 75 Baby Assorted Witch Gift Box (Assorted Brownies)

      Assortment 15 Fat Witch Babies, 12 Blonde Babies, 12 Walnut Babies, 12 Caramel Babies, 12 Snow Babies, 12 Double Chocolate Babies (approx. 1.5"x1.5" each).
      $219.99
    • Big Witch Favs (Assorted Brownies)

      Contains 2 Fat Witch Brownies, 1 Blonde Witch, 2 Walnut Witches, 2 Caramel Witches, 1 Double Chocolate Witch (approx. 2.5"x2.5" each).
      $47.50
    • 8 Big Witch Sampler Tin (Assorted Brownies)

      Contains 1 Fat Witch Brownie, 1 Coffee Witch, 1 Double Chocolate Witch, 1 Blonde Witch, 1 Snow Witch, 1 Walnut Witch, 1 Caramel Witch, 1 Emerald City Witch (approx. 2.5"x2.5" each) individually.
      $47.50
  • Individually Wrapped Brownies

    • Fat Witch Original Brownie

      The Fat Witch is a chocolatey brownie with an intense taste. You'll think they are magical. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Snow Witch Brownie

      Discover white chocolate magic. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Double Chocolate Witch Brownie

      Semi-sweet chocolate chunks have been added to the batter. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Caramel Witch Brownie

      Has a layer of caramel tricked into its middle. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Red Witch Brownie

      Chocolate-y Brownie studded with delicious tart-dried cherries. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Walnut Witch Brownie

      Has the fattest and most luscious walnuts mixed into the batter. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Coffee Witch Brownie

      Chocolate Brownie infused with strong coffee and mini dark chocolate chips stirred into the batter. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Emerald City Witch Brownie

      This wicked witch comes with a sprinkle of magic mint. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Blonde Witch

      A bombshell of chocolate chip cookie tastes in a bar form. 3.5oz. each.
      $5.85
    • Breakfast Witch

      A creative combination of oatmeal, brown sugar, walnuts, and coffee on top of a little bit of brownie. 4oz. each.
      $5.85
  • Other Items

    • Fat Witch Brownie Mix

      Have fun baking and enjoy every magical morsel!
      $7.99
    • Witch Ends Combo

      Witch Ends are the parts of brownies that are on the edge of the pan. Witch Ends are great crumbled over ice cream or fruit. Item includes 1 bag of our Original Fat Witch Ends and 1 bag of our Caramel Witch Ends (1 pound each). Combo.
      $28.50

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms