Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
Chicken Alfredo
Made To Order, Traditional Italian Fettuccine Pasta, Served With Our House Made Alfredo Sauce & House Marinated Grilled Chicken.
$20.10
10" Personal Pizza
10 " Pizza Made To order With Fat Tony's Signature Hand Made Dough, Traditional Mozzarella, With Your Choice Of Toppings Below. Regular Toppings & Premium for an additional charge
$11.50
Cheese / Build Your Own
Traditional New York Style 18" Pizza Topped With Fresh Mozzarella, House Made Marinara. Add Any Toppings Below For The Amount Shown.
$23.40
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried To Order & Served With Our House Made Marinara Sauce.
$12.08
House Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine Topped With Fresh Cheese, Carrots, Croutons, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Red Onions. Served With Your Choice Of House Made Dressing. Add: chicken, shrimp for an additional charge
$6.75
Calzones Made to Order
Fat Tony's Signature Hand Made Dough, Traditional Mozzarella & Premium Ricotta. Toppings extra.
$15.25
Chicken Wings
Six Jumbo Fried wings, Tossed With Your Choice Of One Of Our house made Sauces. Garlic Buffalo, Bourbon BBQ or Sweet and Spicy Thai Chili. Side of Celery, House made Blue Cheese Or Ranch.
$14.00
Caesar Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine, Fresh Pecorino Romano Cheese, Croutons With House Made Caesar Dressing. Add: chicken, shrimp for an additional charge
$7.25
Blue Crab Dip
Blend Of Fresh Backfin Crab, Cream cheese, Shallots. With A Hint Of Horseradish & Worcestershire. Baked Off & Served With Pita Chips
$16.00
Side of Ranch
Side of our freshly prepared ranch dressing, made in-house.
$0.75
Hand Made 18" New York Pizzas
Build your own or choose a house classic below
Cheese / Build Your Own
Traditional New York Style 18" Pizza Topped With Fresh Mozzarella, House Made Marinara. Add Any Toppings Below For The Amount Shown.
$23.40
Carnivore
Traditional New York Style 18" Pizza Topped With Fresh Mozzarella, House Made Marinara, Italian Pepperoni, Italian Sausage & House Made Meatballs.
$31.47
Fat Tony's Supreme
Traditional New York Style 18" Pizza Topped With Fresh Mozzarella, House Made Marinara, Italian Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, White Onion, Bell Peppers, Green & Black Olives.
$31.47
BBQ Chicken
Traditional New York Style 18" Pizza Topped With Fresh Mozzarella, House Made Marinara, House Marinade Grilled Chicken, Thick Cut Bacon, Red Onion & Our House Made Bourbon BBQ Sauce.
$30.25
Personals
10" Personal Pizza
10 " Pizza Made To order With Fat Tony's Signature Hand Made Dough, Traditional Mozzarella, With Your Choice Of Toppings Below. Regular Toppings & Premium for an additional charge
$11.50
Soups, Salads, Sides
Clam Chowder
Traditional New England Style, Fresh Clams, Potatoes & Thick Cut Bacon.
$8.96
House Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine Topped With Fresh Cheese, Carrots, Croutons, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumbers & Red Onions. Served With Your Choice Of House Made Dressing. Add: chicken, shrimp for an additional charge
$6.75
Caesar Salad
Fresh Cut Romaine, Fresh Pecorino Romano Cheese, Croutons With House Made Caesar Dressing. Add: chicken, shrimp for an additional charge
$7.25
Caprese Salad
Fresh Layered Campari Tomatoes With Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Chiffonade Basil, House Made Balsamic Reduction & Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Add: chicken, shrimp for an additional charge
$14.50
Side of Ranch
Side of our freshly prepared ranch dressing, made in-house.
$0.75
Small Greek Salad
Romaine, Feta, Olives, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, and Greek Dressing
$7.84
Large Greek Salad
Romaine, Feta, Olives, Red Onion, Cucumbers, Tomatoes, Banana Peppers, and Greek Dressing
$15.40
Black and Bleu Steak Salad
Romaine, Cucumbers, Red Onion, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Tomatoes, and Blackened Steak with Balsamic Reduction
$17.86
Appetizers
Calamari
Lightly Floured, Fried Crispy To Order & Tossed In Fresh Parmesan Cheese. Served With House Marinara, Sweet Thai Chili Sauce, Or Both.
$17.60
Basket of French Fries
Perfectly Crispy Fries Tossed In Our Delicious House Dry Seasoning.
$5.60
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried To Order & Served With Our House Made Marinara Sauce.
$12.08
Bruschetta
Diced Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers, Fresh Basil & Minced Garlic Topped With Our House Made Balsamic Reduction. Served With Our House Made Delectable Garlic Bread.
$12.25
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
Traditional Hot Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Served With Pita Chips.
$12.88
Blue Crab Dip
Blend Of Fresh Backfin Crab, Cream cheese, Shallots. With A Hint Of Horseradish & Worcestershire. Baked Off & Served With Pita Chips
$16.00
Meatball Sundae
Four House Made Meatballs, Served With Our House Made Marinara, And Fresh Scoop Of Premium Ricotta Cheese. With A Side Of Our House Made Delectable Garlic Bread.
$14.00
Chicken Wings
Six Jumbo Fried wings, Tossed With Your Choice Of One Of Our house made Sauces. Garlic Buffalo, Bourbon BBQ or Sweet and Spicy Thai Chili. Side of Celery, House made Blue Cheese Or Ranch.
$14.00
Sandwiches
Your choice of fries, house made pasta salad, potato salad, side salad or caesar for an additional charge
Guinness Brisket Reuben
Guinness Brisket Layered With Fresh Sauerkraut, House Made Russian Dressing, Baby Swiss Cheese On Fresh Marble Rye.
$16.75
Chicken Parmigiana
Breaded & Fried Fresh To Order, With House Seasoned Chicken Breast, Topped With Fresh Mozzarella & House Made Marinara. Served On A Fresh Hoagie Roll.
$14.50
Meatball Sandwich
House Made Meatballs On A Fresh Italian Baguette, Topped With Fresh Mozzarella Cheese & Our House Made Marinara Sauce.
$14.54
The Classic Burger
In House Seasoned 1/2 Pound Burger. Charcoal Grilled To Your Liking. Served On A Fresh Burger Bun With Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Pickle. Add: Your Choice Of Cheese: American, Cheddar, Provolone, Swiss for an additional charge. Add bacon for an additional charge
$16.52
Steak and Cheese
Tender steak, onion, mushrooms, and bell peppers, topped with Provolone Cheese and served on a hoagie roll.
$18.98
Classic BLT
Crispy Bacon served piled high on toasted Sourdough bread with fresh romaine and tomato slices. Served with Mayo
$12.00
Entrées
Baked Ziti
Delicious Ziti Made To Order With Our House Made Marinara, Premium Ricotta Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella & Italian Sausage. (Can Sub Sausage With Chicken. Can Make Without Either)
$19.60
Meatball Marinara
Made To Order With Our House Made Meatballs, House Made Marinara, Over Traditional Italian Spaghetti.
$15.96
Chicken Alfredo
Made To Order, Traditional Italian Fettuccine Pasta, Served With Our House Made Alfredo Sauce & House Marinated Grilled Chicken.
$20.10
Beef Lasagna
Fresh Layered Pasta With House Seasoned Beef, Premium Ricotta Cheese, Fresh Mozzarella & House Made Marinara Sauce.
$21.00
5 Cheese Tortellini & Pesto Sauce
Freshly Grated Parmesan Reggiano, Ricotta, Mozzarella, Mascarpone, & Pecorino Romano Cheese Tortellini, With Sautéed Cherry Tomatoes In Bright House Made Pesto Sauce.
$17.36
Spaghetti & Meat Sauce
Classic Italian Combination Of Seasoned House Made Meat Sauce Over Delicious Made To Order Spaghetti. Add: Italian Sausage. Add: Marinated Grilled Chicken for an additional charge
$16.25
Fish & Chips
Fresh Line Caught Haddock, Dipped In A House Made Yuengling Beer Batter, Fried to Perfection. Served Over House Fries. Side Of House Made Tar-Tar.
$17.86
Fresh From the Oven
Don's Famous Stromboli
Delicious Italian Sausage, Salami, Ham, Fresh Mozzarella & American Cheese. A Little Bit Of House Yellow Mustard. Rolled By Hand In Our House Made Dough. Served Over House Marinara. *** No modifications ***
$17.65
Calzones Made to Order
Fat Tony's Signature Hand Made Dough, Traditional Mozzarella & Premium Ricotta. Toppings extra.
$15.25
House Made Desserts
Cannoli
Flaky pastry filled with a delightful creamy filling, perfect for satisfying your sweet tooth.
$7.28
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
Know a great happy hour or special for this location?