Fat Paulie's Delicatessen Menu

4.5

(325+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Beverages Online Deli Salads Breakfast Sandwiches Served All Day on Anthony and Sons Kaiser Roll Fresh Bagels Bagel Sandwiches Deli Salad Platters Sliced Lox and Salmon Cold Heroes Served on Anthony and Sons Italian Hero Roll Daily Specials Freshly Sliced House Roasted and Imported Deli Meat Green Salads and Soups Hot Heroes Served on Anthony and Sons Italian Hero Roll Sides Freshly Sliced Cheese Mozz Made Fresh Daily-NEVER Refrigerated Snacks Grocery

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Sausage Egg and Cheese
  Breakfast sausage patty, two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese
  $8.00
- Italian Mix
  Nitrate-free ham, spicy cappy, Genoa salami, imported mortadella, imported prosciutto, sharp provolone, shaved red onion, lettuce, oregano, oil & vinegar, extra-virgin olive oil
  $15.00
- Bacon, Egg and Cheese
  Two local fried eggs over medium, crispy bacon, American cheese
  $8.00
- Make Your Own Hero
  Customizable cold hero on Italian roll. Choose from hero, kaiser, rye, or no bread. Selection of meats including turkey, roast beef, ham, and more. Variety of sauces like dijon, pesto, hot sauce.
  $14.00
- Chicken Cutlet Hero
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried chicken cutlet, bacon, aged cheddar, mayo, lettuce
  $14.00
- BLTG
  Bacon, lettuce, tomato (local tomatoes when in season), mayo, served on a garlicky toasted hero roll
  $12.00
- Rare Roast Beef Hero
  House-roasted garlic and herb-rubbed roast beef, shaved red onion, mayo, lettuce, S&P
  $15.00
- Chicken Parm
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried chicken cutlet, tomato passata, house-made fresh mozz
  $15.00
- Hot and Crispy Doritos Fried Chicken Hero
  Hand trimmed chicken breast coated in crushed Doritos, panko, spices and parm-reggiano, Cabot sharp cheddar, Hot and Crispy sauce, pickles and pickled red onion
  $14.00
- Fat Paulie Special
  House-roasted garlic and herb-rubbed roast beef, ladles of au jus, house-made fresh mozz. MESSY!!
  $15.00
Beverages
- 2 Liter Starry
  A 2-liter bottle of Starry, a caffeine-free soda known for its crisp and clear lemon-lime flavor.
  $3.50
- Arizona Half and Half
  20 oz
  $2.00
- Arizona Green Tea Tallboy
  20 oz.
  $2.00
- Arizona Arnold Palmer Lite
  20 oz
  $2.00
- Arizona Strawberry Arnold Palmer
  22 Fl oz
  $2.00
- Celsius Peach Vibe
  Sparkling soda infused with a refreshing peach flavor, offering a vibrant and energizing beverage option.
  $3.50
- Celsius Galaxy Vibe
  Sparkling Strawberry Watermelon
  $3.50
- Celsius Sparking Orange
  Celsius Sparkling Orange is a carbonated beverage, blending the zest of orange flavor with energy-boosting ingredients.
  $3.50
- Celsius Cosmic Vibe
  Sparkling Fruit Punch
  $3.50
- Gatorade Water
  1 Liter
  $3.25
- Propel Berry Fitness Water
  Berry-flavored water enhanced with vitamins and minerals for hydration.
  $2.75
- Propel Kiwi Strawberry Fitness Water
  Kiwi strawberry flavored fitness water, typically includes a blend of vitamins and minerals to support hydration and replenishment during physical activities.
  $2.75
- Mug Root Beer
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Coffee Large
  16 fl oz
  $2.50
- Coffee Medium
  12 fl oz
  $2.00
- Aquafina 20 oz water
  Pure, refreshing still water in a 20 oz bottle.
  $2.25
- Eternal Spring Water
  600ml naturally alkaline spring water
  $2.25
- Starbucks Coffee Frappuccino
  13.7 ounce
  $5.00
- Starbucks Mocha Frappuccino
  13.7 ounce
  $5.00
- Starbucks Vanilla Frappuccino
  13.7 ounce
  $5.00
- Diet Pepsi
  Carbonated beverage with a crisp, refreshing taste and zero calories.
  $2.25
- A Siciliana Limonata Soda
  Sicily lemon soda
  $2.50
- A Siciliana Aranciata Soda
  Sicily blood orange soda
  $2.50
- Stappi White Bitter
  Imported from Italy. Bitter herbs infused in mineral water. Non-alcoholic.
  $1.75
- Stappi Gassosa
  Sweet and tart lemon soda imported from Italy. Enjoy over ice or use as a mixer.
  $1.75
- Goslings Ginger Beer
  12 fl oz
  $2.25
- RC Cola
  16.9 fl oz
  $1.75
- Pepsi Wild Cherry and Cream
  12 oz can
  $1.75
- Pepsi Zero Wild Cherry and Cream
  12 oz can
  $1.75
- Dole Lemonade
  A refreshing beverage made with the distinct taste of Dole lemons.
  $2.25
- Dole Strawberry Lemonade
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Mela Watermelon Coconut Water
  A refreshing beverage that typically includes the natural sweetness of watermelon and the hydration benefits of coconut water.
  $3.50
- Mela Coconut Water
  Naturally hydrating coconut water, typically featuring the subtle sweetness and refreshing benefits of fresh coconuts.
  $3.50
- Mela Passionfruit Coconut Water
  Coconut water blended with passionfruit and apple, offering natural hydration and a tropical twist.
  $3.50
- Mela Watermelon Pineapple Coconut Water
  A blend of watermelon, pineapple, and coconut water, offering a refreshing and hydrating beverage.
  $3.50
- Dels Diet Lemonade
  Made with freshly squeezed lemon juice and a sugar substitute for a refreshing, low-calorie beverage.
  $2.75
- Dr Pepper
  Unique blend of 23 flavors, carbonated soft drink.
  $2.25
- Diet Dr Pepper
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Grape Crush
  A refreshing soda infused with the essence of grapes, offering a sweet and slightly tart taste.
  $2.25
- Hot Tea
  Lipton 12 or 16 fl oz
  $1.50
- Manhattan Special Orginal Espresso
  Espresso flavored soda 12 fl oz
  $3.25
- Manhattan Special Black Cherry Soda
  12 fl oz
  $3.25
- Manhattan Special Vanilla Cream Soda
  12 fl oz
  $3.25
- Mountain Dew
  Bright green soda with a citrus flavor.
  $2.25
- Diet Mountain Dew
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Orange Crush
  Tantalizing carbonated beverage bursting with refreshing citrus flavor.
  $2.25
- Pepsi
  A refreshing carbonated drink with a unique blend of cola flavors.
  $2.25
- Squirt
  12 ounce can
  $1.50
- Wild Cherry Pepsi
  20 ounce
  $2.25
- Hawaiian Punch
  12 Oz Can
  $2.00
- Orange Crush Zero
  12 Oz Can
  $2.00
- Nani s Sweet Mint Ice Tea
  Freshly brewed iced tea infused with sweet mint, offering a refreshing twist to a classic beverage.
  $3.75
- Nani s Lemonade Ice Tea
  A refreshing blend of freshly brewed iced tea and tangy lemonade, typically served chilled.
  $3.75
- Nani s Raspberry Limone
  House lemonade infused with raspberry and a hint of lemon zest, inspired by traditional lemonade recipes.
  $3.75
- Dr. Browns Black Cherry
  A carbonated beverage with a rich black cherry flavor.
  $2.25
- Dr. Browns Cream Soda
  A classic cream soda offering a rich vanilla cream essence.
  $2.25
- Leelanau Cherry Sweet Tea
  16 oz.
  $3.50
- Pepsi Zero Sugar
  A carbonated soft drink offering the classic Pepsi taste with no sugar, for a refreshing and crisp beverage experience.
  $2.25
- Polar Seltzer Black Cherry
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Bubly Blackberry
  16 ounce can
  $2.25
- Bubly Lime
  16 ounce can
  $2.25
- Bubly Cherry
  16 Fl. Oz.
  $2.25
- Bubly Grapefruit
  16 Fl.Oz.
  $2.25
- Key-Key Lime Sparkling Water
  Key-key lime sparkling water is infused with the zest of key limes for a refreshing and bubbly beverage experience.
  $2.25
- Key-Blood Orange Cherry Sparkling Water
  Sparkling water infused with the essence of key lime, blood orange, and cherry for a refreshing and effervescent beverage experience.
  $2.25
- Key-Pineapple Passion Fruit Sparkling Water
  Sparkling water infused with the essence of key lime, pineapple, and passion fruit, offering a refreshing and tropical twist.
  $2.25
- Polar Seltzer Lemon
  20 fl oz
  $2.25
- Red Bull Energy Drink
  8.4 fl oz
  $3.50
- Ghost Swedish Fish Energy-Zero Sugar
  Ghost Swedish Fish energy drink, sugar-free, typically includes a unique blend of caffeine and flavors inspired by the Swedish Fish candy, offering a sweet taste without sugar.
  $3.50
- Ghost Welchs Grape Energy-Zero Sugar
  16 fl oz
  $3.50
- Red Bull Sugar Free Energy Drink
  8.4 fl oz
  $3.50
- Saranac Root Beer
  Crafted root beer featuring a blend of natural root beer extract, organic vanilla, and a hint of licorice and anise.
  $2.50
- Saratoga Sparkling Water Bottle
  12 fl oz
  $2.25
- Life Water 700ml
  700 ml
  $3.75
- Essentia Water
  1 L
  $3.50
- Saratoga Water
  24 fl oz
  $2.25
- Life Water 20oz
  Pure, refreshing water typically sourced from natural springs, perfect for hydration.
  $2.25
- Schweppes Ginger Ale
  Effervescent Schweppes Ginger Ale with a Refreshing Zing and Smooth Finish
  $2.25
- Pure Leaf Brewed Tea-Unsweetened
  18.5 fl. oz.
  $2.75
- Pure Leaf Raspberry Tea
  18.5 ounce
  $2.75
- Pure Leaf Lemon Tea
  Pure Leaf Lemon Tea is a refreshing blend of brewed tea leaves with a hint of lemon, typically served chilled.
  $2.75
- Pure Leaf Peach Tea
  Brewed from real tea leaves with a hint of natural peach flavor.
  $2.75
- Pure Leaf BlackberryTea
  18.5 fl oz
  $2.75
- 2 Liter Pepsi
  Refreshing 2-Liter Pepsi: Crisp, Effervescent Classic Cola
  $3.50
- Starry
  20 Fl. oz.
  $2.25
- 2 Liter Diet Pepsi
  A 2-liter bottle of Diet Pepsi, offering a refreshing and crisp taste with fizzy bubbles, without the calories.
  $3.50
- Tropicana Orange Juice
  12 oz
  $3.00
- V8 Vegetable Juice
  A blend of various vegetables, V8 vegetable juice typically includes tomatoes, carrots, celery, beets, parsley, lettuce, watercress, and spinach.
  $2.50
- Tropicana Apple Juice
  12 fl oz.
  $3.00
- Tropicana Cranberry Juice
  Tropicana cranberry juice is a high-quality beverage crafted from select cranberries, offering a crisp and refreshing taste.
  $3.00
- Yoo-hoo Chocolate Drink
  15.5 fl oz
  $2.25
Online Deli Salads
- Roasted Cauliflower Salad
  Oven-roasted cauliflower florets, extra-virgin olive oil, lemon zest, capers, parsley, mint, Aleppo pepper
  $1.50+
- Dried Cherry and Toasted Walnut Chicken Salad
  Chicken salad mixed with dried cherries, toasted walnuts with celery and mayo
  $2.00+
- Bacon and Scallion Potato Salad
  Russet potatoes, bacon, scallions, celery, red onion, capers, mayo, Dijon, parsley
  $1.50+
- Italian Tuna Salad
  Yellowfin tuna mixed with extra-virgin olive oil, celery, lemon zest, Aleppo pepper, parsley
  $3.50+
- Farro and Tuscan Kale Salad
  Farro, Tuscan kale, dried cherries, toasted walnuts, goat cheese, basil, lemon-orange vinaigrette
  $2.00+
- Egg Salad
  Local eggs mixed with cornichon, shallot, mayo, mustard, herbs
  $2.00+
- Macaroni Salad
  The classic Long Island sweet and sour style mac salad
  $1.25+
- Coleslaw
  Classic deli coleslaw
  $1.25+
- Sun-Dried Tomato Pesto Pasta Salad
  Bowtie pasta, Tuscan kale, house-made fresh mozz, pine nuts, Parmigiano-Reggiano, sun-dried tomato pesto, basil, extra-virgin olive oil
  $1.75+
Breakfast Sandwiches Served All Day on Anthony and Sons Kaiser Roll
- Breakfast Barge
  Three local fried eggs, thick sliced bacon, nitrate-free ham, debris,* American cheese, served on an Italian hero. Bring your appetite!
  $12.00
- Bacon, Egg and Cheese
  Two local fried eggs over medium, crispy bacon, American cheese
  $8.00
- Sausage Egg and Cheese
  Breakfast sausage patty, two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese
  $8.00
- Taylor Ham, Egg and Cheese
  Fried pork roll, two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese
  $8.00
- Egg and Cheese
  Two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese
  $6.00
- Debris, Egg and Cheese
  Debris (burnt ends and pan drippings from our roasted meats), two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese
  $7.00
- Ham, Egg and Cheese El Eme
  Nitrate-free ham, two local fried eggs over medium, El Eme sauce (slightly spicy house-made sauce), American cheese
  $8.00
- Potato, Egg and Cheese
  Roast potatoes pan fried in bacon drippings, two local fried eggs over medium, American cheese, mayo
  $7.00
- Coffee Large
  16 fl oz
  $2.50
- Bacon-Side
  2 slices of our thick cut 10/14 bacon
  $2.00
- Coffee Medium
  12 fl oz
  $2.00
- Hot Tea
  Lipton 12 or 16 fl oz
  $1.50
- Potatoes-Side
  Thin sliced potatoes cooked in bacon drippings
  $2.50
- Brisket, Egg and Cheese
  Our house red wine braised brisket, 2 local Thomas Poultry farm fresh eggs and Cooper Sharp American on an Anthony and Sons kaiser roll
  $9.00
- Blueberry Muffin
  A blueberry muffin typically includes a blend of sweet blueberries, baked into a soft, moist muffin, served on a toasted Anthony and Sons Kaiser Roll.
  $2.25
- Chocolate Chip Muffin
  A chocolate chip muffin typically includes a blend of flour, eggs, sugar, and chocolate chips, served on an Anthony and Sons Kaiser Roll.
  $2.25
- Croissant
  $2.25
Fresh Bagels
- Single Bagel
  Choice of Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, Blueberry, Cinnamon Raisin, Egg, French Toast, Garlic, Onion, or Pumpernickel bagel.
  $1.95
- Half Dozen Bagels
  Half dozen variety of bagels including plain, everything, sesame, blueberry, and more.
  $11.95
- Dozen Bagels
  Assorted bagels including plain, everything, sesame, poppy, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, egg, egg everything, French toast, garlic, onion, pumpernickel.
  $22.95
- Bagel with Butter
  A variety of options including plain, everything, savory, and sweet flavors.
  $2.95
- Bagel with Cream Cheese
  Your choice of bagel with a selection of cream cheeses including options like garlic herb, honey walnut, smoked salmon, and more.
  $3.95
- Cream Cheese Plain Half Pound
  Plain cream cheese typically used as a spread, provided in a half-pound portion.
  $6.99
- Cream Cheese Gourmet Half Pound
  Veggie, bacon scallion, garlic herb, smoked salmon, and more.
  $7.99
Bagel Sandwiches
- Avocado Toast
  Choice of bagel including plain, everything, sesame, poppy, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, garlic, onion, pumpernickel.
  $6.95
- Bagel CC Salmon Onion Capers
  Bagel with plain cream cheese, house smoked salmon, red onion, and capers
  $12.95
- Bagel CC Tomato Bacon
  Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, and more. Variety of cream cheese: plain, veggie, bacon scallion, brown sugar cinnamon, and more.
  $8.95
- Chicken Salad on Bagel
  Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, egg, French toast, garlic, onion, or pumpernickel.
  $11.95
- Egg Salad on Bagel
  Creamy egg salad on your choice of bagel. Options include classic favorites like Plain, Everything, Sesame, and more.
  $8.95
- Tuna Melt on Bagel
  Tuna melt with cheese choice on various bagels including plain, flavored, and specialty options.
  $11.95
- Tuna Salad on Bagel
  Plain, everything, sesame, poppy, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, egg, egg everything, French toast, garlic, onion, or pumpernickel.
  $9.95
Deli Salad Platters
- Chicken Salad Platter
  Chicken salad served with choice of various bagels and deli salads including cole slaw, mac, pasta, or potato salad.
  $13.95
- Egg Salad Platter
  Creamy blend of eggs with a choice of cole slaw, mac salad, pasta salad, or potato salad, served with any bagel variety.
  $10.95
- Tuna Salad Platter
  Tuna Salad Platter Served with your choice of bagel (Plain, Everything, Sesame, Poppy, and more) and deli salad (Cole Slaw, Mac Salad, Pasta Salad, Potato Salad).
  $11.95
Sliced Lox and Salmon
- Smoked Salmon Sliced by Pound
  Delicate smoked salmon slices, available in 1/4, 1/2, or 1-pound portions.
  $9.49+
- Lox Sliced by Pound
  1/4, 1/2, or 1 LB of sliced lox by the pound.
  $8.74+
Cold Heroes Served on Anthony and Sons Italian Hero Roll
- Italian Mix
  Nitrate-free ham, spicy cappy, Genoa salami, imported mortadella, imported prosciutto, sharp provolone, shaved red onion, lettuce, oregano, oil & vinegar, extra-virgin olive oil
  $15.00
- Herb-Rubbed Turkey Hero
  House-roasted herb-rubbed turkey, havarti, coleslaw, special sauce, S&P
  $15.00
- Rare Roast Beef Hero
  House-roasted garlic and herb-rubbed roast beef, shaved red onion, mayo, lettuce, S&P
  $15.00
- Ham El Eme
  Nitrate-free ham, El Eme sauce (slightly spicy house-made sauce), mayo, lettuce
  $12.00
- Fresh Mozz Hero
  Thick-sliced house-made fresh mozz topped with tomato jam, pesto Genovese, arugula, lemon zest, extra-virgin olive oil, S&P NOTE: Contains pine nuts
  $14.00
- Chicken Salad Sandwich - Dried Cherry and Toasted Walnut
  Chicken salad mixed with dried cherries, toasted walnuts, celery and mayo. Served on rye bread with shaved red onion
  $12.00
- Pressed Italian Tuna
  Select yellowfin tuna mixed with extra-virgin olive oil, celery, lemon zest, Aleppo pepper and parsley. Topped with shaved red onion, arugula and served on a pressed Italian hero
  $10.00
- Egg Salad Sandwich
  Local eggs mixed with cornichon, shallot, mayo, mustard, herbs and topped with lettuce on a kaiser roll
  $8.00
- Make Your Own Hero
  Customizable cold hero on Italian roll. Choose from hero, kaiser, rye, or no bread. Selection of meats including turkey, roast beef, ham, and more. Variety of sauces like dijon, pesto, hot sauce.
  $14.00
- Make Your Own Veggie Hero
  Customizable veggie submarine on an Italian hero roll. Choose from rye, kaiser, or no bread. Mix and match veggies like tomato, arugula, artichokes, and avocado. Multiple cheeses and sauces available.
  $9.00
Daily Specials
- Brisket, Egg and Cheese
  Our house red wine braised brisket, 2 local Thomas Poultry farm fresh eggs and Cooper Sharp American on an Anthony and Sons kaiser roll
  $9.00
- Family Dinner-Heroes
  4 heroes, choice of 2-liter soda and choice of 1 lb. Macaroni Salad or Bacon and Scallion Potato Salad. No substitutions please.
  $64.95
- Chicken Parm Family Dinner
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried chicken parm cutlet, tomato passata, house-made fresh mozz served over spaghetti. Comes with salad and garlic bread.
  $48.00
- Pork Cutlet Parm Hero
  Hand cut and breaded pork cutlet topped with our tomato passata and our fresh mozz
  $11.00
- Spaghetti and Meatballs
  Hand crushed San Marzano tomato, garlic and basil sauce with our beef, veal and pork meatballs made at the deli by hand.
  $9.95
- Chicken Parm over Spaghetti
  Our hand cut, hand breaded chicken parm with San Marzano tomato sauce and our fresh mozz made daily served over spaghetti
  $12.00
- Brisket Dinner
  Red wine braised beef brisket served over buttered egg noodles. Served with broccoli rabe.
  $15.00
- Family Dinner-Brisket
  Red wine braised beef brisket served over buttered egg noodles with broccoli rabe. -Serves 4
  $54.95
- Family Dinner-Spaghetti and Meatballs
  Serves 4 and comes with salad and garlic bread
  $34.95
- Porchetta Hero with Mozz
  Thinly sliced Porchetta, our fresh mozz, arugula, extra-virgin olive oil, lemon zest and Calabrian long hot chile peppers served on a fresh Anthony & Sons hero roll
  $12.00
- Italian Cured Beef Hero
  Imported bresaola, parm-reggiano, arugula, extra virgin olive oil, lemon zest served on a hero roll
  $14.00
- Golfetta Salami and Fresh Mozz
  Italian imported Golfetta (mild salami), our fresh mozz, shredded lettuce, red wine vinaigrette
  $14.00
- Tuna Melt on Bagel
  $11.95
Freshly Sliced House Roasted and Imported Deli Meat
- Porchetta per LB
  House-roasted porchetta, sliced. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb.
  $4.00+
- All Natural Ham No Nitrates/Nitrites per LB
  All natural ham, free from nitrates/nitrites. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes.
  $2.75+
- Coppa Hot per LB
  Traditional coppa, Volpi brand slow aged pork shoulder, raised responsibly, no nitrates or nitrites added except those naturally occurring in sea salt and celery powder
  $5.25+
- Uncured Capocollo Hot per LB
  Daniele brand uncured sweet capocollo, no nitrates or nitrites added except those naturally occurring in sea salt and cultured celery juice
  $4.00+
- Uncured Capocollo per LB
  Daniele brand uncured sweet capocollo, no nitrates or nitrites added except those naturally occurring in sea salt and cultured celery juice
  $4.00+
- Coppa Sweet per LB
  Traditional coppa, Volpi brand slow aged pork shoulder, raised responsibly, no nitrates or nitrites added except those naturally occurring in sea salt and celery powder
  $5.25+
- Genoa Salami per LB
  Genoa salami, freshly sliced, choice of 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb. House-roasted, imported quality.
  $1.75+
- House Roast Beef per LB
  House-roasted beef, sliced fresh. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options.
  $3.75+
- House Roast Turkey per LB
  House-Roasted, Herb-Rubbed Turkey. No antibiotics ever natural turkey breast
  $3.25+
- Roast Pork
  Roasted in house with our garlic and herb rub
  $3.00+
- Mortadella per LB
  Sliced mortadella, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb options. House roasted.
  $3.00+
- Pepperoni
  Hormel pepperoni Leone
  $2.25+
- Pancetta Rolled per LB
  Pancetta rolled, available in quarter, half, or full pound. House roasted and imported.
  $3.75+
- Golfetta Salami
  Salame il Golfetta imported from Parma
  $5.00+
- Golfera Salame Piccante
  Spicy salami imported from Italy
  $4.25+
- Prosciutto (Imported Italy)
  Imported Italian prosciutto, thinly sliced. Available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb sizes. Pork.
  $3.75+
- Speck per LB
  The famous Recla speck imported from Italy
  $4.50+
- Guanciale
  Dry cured pork jowl imported from Italy
  $4.25+
- Prosciutto di Parma per LB
  Sliced Prosciutto di Parma, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options. House roasted, imported pork delicacy.
  $5.00+
- Smoked Pancetta per LB
  House-roasted smoked pancetta, available in sizes 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb.
  $4.00+
- Soppressata Hot w/ Mold per LB
  Soppressata hot with mold; available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb options.
  $4.50+
- Soppressata Sweet w/ Mold per LB
  Soppressata sweet with mold, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb sizes. House roasted and imported deli selection.
  $4.50+
- Taylor Ham per LB
  Taylor ham, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb slices from our selection of house-roasted and imported deli meats.
  $3.50+
Green Salads and Soups
- Chef Salad
  Leaf lettuce, house-roasted herb-rubbed turkey, nitrate-free ham, Genoa salami, house-made fresh mozz, hard-cooked egg, shaved red onion, cucumber, grape tomato, sunflower seeds, red wine vinaigrette (comes on side)
  $15.00
- Michigan Cherry Salad
  Leaf lettuce, cucumber, dried cherries, toasted walnuts, goat cheese, basil green goddess dressing (comes on side)
  $15.00
- House Salad
  Leaf lettuce, cucumber, tomato, red onion, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, blue cheese crumble, red wine vinaigrette
  $12.00
- Cobb Salad
  Leaf lettuce, grilled chicken breast, hard-cooked egg, bacon, avocado, grape tomato, cucumber, Danish blue cheese, red wine vinaigrette (comes on side)
  $15.00
- Seared Steak Salad
  Leaf lettuce, marinated and seared steak, shaved red onion, cucumber, grape tomatoes, toasted walnuts, Danish blue cheese, red wine vinaigrette (comes on side)
  $15.00
- That Good Salad
  Leaf lettuce, shaved red onion, cucumber, grape tomato, goat cheese, garlicky croutons, basil green goddess dressing (comes on side)
  $12.00
- Side Salad
  Leaf lettuce, shaved red onion, cucumber, grape tomato, red wine vinaigrette (comes on side)
  $6.00
- French Onion Soup - Cup
  The classic beef and onion broth with a Gruyère crostini
  $4.50
- French Onion Soup - Bowl
  The classic beef and onion broth with a Gruyère crostini
  $6.00
- Cream of Tomato Soup-Cup
  A smooth blend of ripe tomatoes and cream, gently simmered with a selection of herbs.
  $4.50
- Cream of Tomato Soup- Bowl
  A smooth blend of ripe tomatoes and cream, seasoned with a hint of garlic and basil, served in a bowl.
  $6.00
- Quart of Soup
  Quart size of any of our soups (unheated). Let us know your selection in the modifications section
  $14.00
Hot Heroes Served on Anthony and Sons Italian Hero Roll
- Eggplant Parm
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried eggplant, tomato passata, house-made fresh mozz
  $12.00
- Chicken Parm
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried chicken cutlet, tomato passata, house-made fresh mozz
  $15.00
- Roast Pork Special
  Thinly sliced house roast pork, hour-and-a-half broccoli rabe, pork au jus, sharp provolone
  $12.00
- Fat Paulie Special
  House-roasted garlic and herb-rubbed roast beef, ladles of au jus, house-made fresh mozz. MESSY!!
  $15.00
- Hot and Crispy Doritos Fried Chicken Hero
  Hand trimmed chicken breast coated in crushed Doritos, panko, spices and parm-reggiano, Cabot sharp cheddar, Hot and Crispy sauce, pickles and pickled red onion
  $14.00
- Chicken Cutlet Hero
  Hand-breaded and pan-fried chicken cutlet, bacon, aged cheddar, mayo, lettuce
  $14.00
- Pork Cutlet Parm Hero
  Hand cut and breaded pork cutlet topped with our tomato passata and our fresh mozz
  $11.00
- Meatball Parm
  Beef, veal and pork meatballs with our breadcrumb and imported Pecorino-Romano cheese, house tomato sauce, house-made fresh mozz
  $14.00
- Brisket Hero
  Red wine braised beef brisket, horseradish sauce, arugula
  $15.00
- Pork Schnitzel
  Thinly sliced pork cutlet that has been hand-breaded and pan-fried, arugula, lemon-caper aioli
  $12.00
- Mother's Special
  House-roasted garlic and herb-rubbed roast beef, house roast pork, debris,* Swiss cheese, pickles, shredded cabbage, Dijon sauce
  $14.00
- BLTG
  Bacon, lettuce, tomato (local tomatoes when in season), mayo, served on a garlicky toasted hero roll
  $12.00
- Hot Pastrami
  Steamed pastrami sliced to order and served on rye bread with mustard
  $12.00
- Reuben
  NYS National corned beef sliced thin and piled high on grilled rye with melted Swiss, sauerkraut and our Russian dressing
  $14.00
Sides
- Garlic Bread
  Toasted bread, fresh chopped garlic and parsley, European style butter
  $4.00
- Breakfast Sausage Patty-Side
  Ember Farms 2oz. Breakfast sausage patty
  $1.00
- Hot Meatballs - Side
  Beef, veal and pork meatballs made at the deli by hand with our breadcrumbs and imported Pecorino-Romano cheese, simmered in our house tomato sauce and topped with Parmigiano-Reggiano. Two meatballs per order.
  $6.50
- 8-ounce Container of Salad Dressing
  8-ounce container of our salad dressing made at the deli
  $5.00
- Meatballs For Later-Side (Cold)
  Beef, veal and pork meatballs made at the deli by hand with our breadcrumbs and imported Pecorino-Romano cheese, simmered in our house tomato sauce and topped with Parmigiano-Reggiano. Two meatballs per order.
  $6.50
- Hour-and-a-Half Broccoli Rabe - Side
  Rapini braised in extra-virgin olive oil, garlic and Aleppo pepper, finished with freshly grated imported Parmigiano-Reggiano
  $5.00
- Buttered Kaiser Roll
  Anthony & Sons Italian Bakery Kaiser Roll with Plugrá European style butter
  $2.75
- Bacon-Side
  2 slices of our thick cut 10/14 bacon
  $2.00
- Potatoes-Side
  Thin sliced potatoes cooked in bacon drippings
  $2.50
- Hero Roll
  Anthony & Sons Italian Bakery Hero Roll
  $1.00
- Kaiser Roll
  Anthony and Sons Italian Bakery Kaiser Roll
  $0.75
Freshly Sliced Cheese
- Aged Cheddar per LB
  Aged cheddar cheese available in various cuts: 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, 1 lb. Ideal for breakfast.
  $2.50+
- American per LB
  Freshly sliced American cheese available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb options. Ideal for breakfast accompaniments.
  $1.75+
- Swiss per LB
  Swiss cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb slices.
  $2.38+
- Havarti per LB
  Havarti cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb slices.
  $3.00+
- Mild Provolone per LB
  Mild provolone cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb slices. Fresh, versatile for breakfast pairings.
  $2.00+
- Parmigiano-Reggiano per LB
  Parmigiano-Reggiano, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or full lb slices. Freshly sliced cheese selection.
  $4.50+
- Pecorino-Romano
  Freshly sliced Pecorino Romano cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, or 1 lb portions.
  $3.00+
- Sharp Provolone per LB
  Sharp provolone cheese, available in 1/4 lb, 1/2 lb, and 1 lb slices.
  $3.00+
Mozz Made Fresh Daily-NEVER Refrigerated
- Fresh Mozzarella-The Mutz
  Milky, tender, mild mozz made fresh everyday. AVAILABLE BY 10:00 AM DAILY UNTIL SOLD OUT
  $10.00
Snacks
- Community Sea Salt Chips 2 oz
  Thinly sliced potatoes, lightly seasoned with sea salt, offering a crisp and satisfying crunch.
  $2.00
- Community Honey BBQ Chips 2oz
  Kettle-cooked chips glazed with a honey BBQ flavoring, offering a sweet and smoky taste.
  $2.00
- Community Salt & Vinegar Chips 2 oz
  Crisp potato chips seasoned with a tangy blend of salt and vinegar, offering a classic snack option.
  $2.00
- Community Sweet Maui Onion Chips 2oz
  Thinly sliced Maui onions lend a sweet, savory flavor to these 2oz potato chips, offering a delightful crunch in every bite.
  $2.00
- Community All Mixed Up Chips 2oz
  A 2oz mix of various chips, combining different flavors and textures for a diverse snacking experience.
  $2.00
- Community Chili Lime Fuego Chips 2oz
  Organic tortilla chips seasoned with a tangy blend of chili and lime.
  $2.00
- Community Sour Cream and Onion Chips-2oz
  Crispy potato chips flavored with sour cream and onion, packed in a convenient 2oz size for a quick snack.
  $2.00
- Community Sea Salt and Vinegar 5 oz
  5 oz
  $4.25
- Community All Mixed Up Chips-5oz
  5oz
  $4.25
- Community Sour Cream and Onion-5oz
  5oz
  $4.25
- Community Simply Sea Salt-5oz
  Kettle-cooked potato chips lightly seasoned with sea salt, offering a crisp and satisfying snack.
  $4.25
- Saratoga Chips Original
  1oz
  $1.50
- Saratoga Chips 2.5 oz
  Thinly sliced potatoes, typically fried until crispy and lightly seasoned with salt.
  $2.50
- Saratoga Chips Family Size
  8oz
  $5.25
- Hals Buffalo Ranch Kettle Chips
  2 oz kettle cooked chip made in Maspeth, NY
  $1.50
- Hals Sweet Chili
  Sweet chili kettle cooked chips made in Maspeth, NY
  $1.50
- Port City Pretzels Feisty Hot
  Spicy seasoned pretzels, offering a bold twist on the traditional snack with a kick of heat.
  $3.25
- Port City Pretzels Cinnamon Sugar
  Soft pretzel coated in a blend of cinnamon and sugar.
  $3.25
- Lays Classic Potato Chips
  1 oz
  $1.00
- Doritos Nacho Cheese
  1.75 oz
  $1.25
- Doritos Cool Ranch
  1.75 oz
  $1.25
- Cannoli-Large
  Piped to order with ricotta and chocolate chip filling
  $3.50
- Stella s Freeze Dried Berry Bites
  Stella's Freeze Dried Berry Bites typically include a mix of various freeze-dried berries, offering a crunchy and sweet snack option.
  $4.50
- Black and White Cookies
  Classic New York-style black and white cookies, featuring a soft, cake-like base, half glazed with vanilla icing and the other half with chocolate icing.
  $2.75
- Raspberry Thumbs Cookies
  6 pieces per bag
  $6.00
- Stella s Freeze Dried Nerd Gummies
  Freeze-dried gummy candies typically featuring a crunchy outer layer with a chewy, fruity center, combined with Nerds candy for a sweet and tangy snack.
  $6.50
- Stella s Freeze Dried Ice Cream Sandwhiches
  Freeze-dried ice cream sandwiched between two cookies, offering a unique, crunchy twist on the traditional ice cream sandwich.
  $6.50
- Blueberry Muffin
  Freshly Baked Blueberry Muffin, Bursting with Juicy Berries
  $2.25
- Chocolate Chip Muffin
  Decadent muffin baked with rich chocolate chips for a delightful treat.
  $2.25
- 2 Chocolate Hazelnut Biscotti
  Biscotti Bros. Individually wrapped biscotti
  $1.50
- 2 Lemon Drop Cookies
  2 individually wrapped lemon drop cookies.
  $2.00
- Lemon Drop Cookies
  Lemon drop cookies are sweet treats made with a zesty lemon flavor, typically including a hint of vanilla and finished with a light sugar dusting.
  $8.25
- Whoopie Pie Original
  6 oz
  $2.75
- Whoopie Pie Peanut Butter
  6 oz.
  $2.75
- Cabot Wickedly Habanero and Cheddar
  7oz
  $6.50
- Cabot Cheddar Cheese Popcorn
  Popcorn typically coated with Cabot cheddar cheese, offering a savory and cheesy snack experience.
  $6.50
- Baci Dark Chocolate Truffle
  5 oz
  $12.00
- Baci Milk Chocolate Truffle
  5 oz
  $12.00
- Loacker Quadratini Lemon Wafer Cookie
  Layers of crisp wafer filled with a tangy lemon cream, offering a light and refreshing bite.
  $7.00
- Loacker Quadratini Chocolate Wafer Cookies
  Bite sized wafers 8.82 oz
  $7.00
- Clemente Taralli Original Plain
  Crunchy ring-shaped Italian biscuits made with flour, olive oil, and fennel seeds.
  $6.50
- Clemente Taralli Fennel
  Crunchy taralli rings infused with aromatic fennel seeds, offering a delightful blend of savory and slightly sweet flavors.
  $5.25
- Clemente Taralli Red Pepper
  Crispy taralli rings infused with fennel seeds and a hint of red pepper, providing a delightful blend of subtle spice and aromatic flavor.
  $5.25
- Sweet Street GF Brownie
  Gluten Free 2.8 oz
  $2.00
- Sweet Street Salted Caramel Cookie
  2.8 oz
  $2.00
- Mitica Orange Delights
  Hand-dipped dark chocolate candied oranges made in Valencia, Spain
  $9.25
- Asti Panettone
  2#
  $10.00
- Fabbri Panettone with Amarena
  Italian Christmas bread
  $22.00
Grocery
- Giuseppe Cocco Pappardelle
  Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $6.00
- Giuseppe Cocco Mezzi Rigatoni
  Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $5.25
- Giuseppe Cocco Fettuccine
  Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $6.25
- Giuseppe Cocco Rigatoni
  Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $5.25
- FP Tee
  60% Cotton, 40% Polyester
  $25.00
- Acini di Pepe no. 78
  De Cecco 1lb
  $2.75
- Giuseppe Cocco Linguine
  Artisanal linguine produced in Fara San Martino, known as "the home of pasta". This pasta is among the exclusive selections supplied to the Pope in Rome.
  $5.25
- La Fede Sun Dried Tomatoes
  8 oz
  $5.00
- Masseria Mirogallo Sundried Tomatoes
  Artisanal product imported from Italy. 6.34 oz.
  $8.50
- Backyard Brine Everything Pickle Slices
  Handmade artisan pickles made on Long Island, NY
  $9.00
- Three Little Pigs Cornichons
  Traditional pickled sour baby gherkins. 12.4 oz.
  $6.00
- Polenta Valsugana
  Imported Italian polenta ( instant)-13.7 oz
  $5.00
- Moretti Bramata Coarse Ground Cornmeal for Polenta
  Imported from Italy. 1.1 lb.
  $4.50
- As do Mar Imported Tuna
  Solid light tuna in olive oil entirely produced in Italy 7.05 oz
  $8.00
- Fabbri Amarena Cherries in Syrup
  Pitted Amarena wild cherries in syrup. Imported from Italy, 230 grams
  $21.00
- Brioschi Original Blue Effervescent
  Lemon flavor refreshing effervescent digestive aid from Italy. Get rid of the agita with this 100 year old Italian formula
  $7.00
- Divina Fig Spread
  Made with Aegean figs and imported from Greece. Rich and complex with notes of honey and caramel. Pair with cheese. 9 oz.
  $5.00
- Pixies Preserves Apple Crisp Jam
  Handmade, local jam from Waterford, NY
  $6.00
- Pixies Preserves Strawberry Rhubarb Jam
  Handmade, locally produced jam from Waterford, NY
  $6.00
- Pixies Preserves Hot Pepper Jelly
  Handmade, locally produced jelly from Waterford, NY. Great on a cheese board or drizzled over cream cheese and served with crackers.
  $6.00
- Bagged Ice
  8 lb bag
  $2.50
- Barilla Ditalini
  Small, tube-shaped pasta ideal for soups and salads, made from enriched durum wheat semolina.
  $3.25
- Barilla Pastina
  The little stars for Italian Penicillin
  $3.25
- Barilla Elbow Macaroni
  Dry, elbow-shaped pasta, typically used as a base for creating various pasta dishes.
  $3.75
- Barilla Penne Pasta
  A grocery staple, made with 100% Italian wheat, often enjoyed for its versatility and ability to pair with a variety of sauces.
  $3.25
- Bread Crumbs
  Crumb made at the deli using Anthony and Sons Italian Bakery Italian bread (4 cups)
  $1.50
- D Amico Sliced Courgettes in oil
  Sliced zucchini capri style
  $5.50
- D Amico Sliced Champignon in oil
  Sliced champignon mushrooms preserved in oil, offering a convenient and versatile ingredient for various dishes.
  $5.50
- Caravaglio Capers in Salt
  Cultivated on Salina, one of the Aeolian Islands in Italy and preserved in Sicilian sea salt. This is a floral and flavorful caper. 3.17 oz
  $7.50
- D’Amico Naples Style Eggplant Strips in Oil
  9.9 oz
  $3.00
- Partanna Extra Virgin Olive Oil Tin
  500 ml
  $19.50
- Giuseppe Cocco Orecchiette
  Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $6.00
- Giuseppe Cocco Tagliatelle
  Egg tagliatelle. Artisanal pasta produced in Fara San Martino, known as “the home of pasta”. One of a select few pastas supplied to the Pope in Rome
  $5.50
- Kenny B Mi So Honey Hot Sauce
  A unique blend of fresh crispy garlic, shallots and hot chili peppers. Mild in heat. Made local!
  $10.00
- Saratoga Garlic Homestead Aioli
  Locally made garlic aioli
  $7.50
- HCO Hot Sauce-Original Chili Garlic
  5 oz
  $9.00
- Grill Pantry Hickory Apple Tanhy BBQ Sauce
  12 oz, made locally in Gansevoort, NY
  $10.00
- Grill Pantry Wiplash BBQ/Wing Sauce
  12 oz, made locally in Gansevort, NY
  $10.00
- Grill Pantry Spicy BBQ Sauce
  12 oz, made locally in Gansevort, NY
  $10.00
- Hot Crispy Oil - Extra Hot
  A unique blend of fresh crispy garlic, shallots and hot chili peppers. Made local!
  $9.75
- Hot Crispy Oil
  A unique blend of fresh crispy garlic, shallots, and hot chili peppers. mild in heat. made local
  $9.75
- HCO Aioli
  A blend of garlic, olive oil, and herbs, typically used as a spread or dip.
  $9.50
- LaMonica Petite Scungilli
  Sliced small conch 29 ounces
  $24.00
- Chopped Hot Cherry Peppers
  Chopped hot cherry peppers, typically includes a selection of spicy, piquant cherry peppers, finely chopped for a burst of heat and flavor.
  $4.25
- Napoli Hot Chopped Peppers
  12 fl. oz.
  $4.25
- Napoli Flat Fillets of Anchovies
  2 oz. in olive oil
  $4.25
- Napoli Hot Sliced Banana Peppers
  16 fl oz
  $4.25
- Masseria Mirogallo Artichokes
  Artisinal artichokes in extra virgin olive oil imported from Italy. 9.88 oz.
  $12.50
- Carnegie Deli Sour Pickles
  32oz
  $8.99
- Carnegie Chocolate covered Cheesecake Bites
  6 oz
  $10.99
- Carnegie Dusseldorf Mustard
  12 oz
  $6.99
- Chile de Arbol
  4 ounces
  $5.00
- Guajillo Chile
  4 ounces
  $4.00
- Ancho Chile
  4 ounces
  $5.00
- La Fede Balsamic Vinegar
  16.9 fl oz
  $4.25
- Elsa Aged Balsamic Vinegar
  Balsamic vinegar of Modena, aged 6 years. Product of Italy, 8.5 ounces.
  $17.00
- La Fede Giardiniera
  A mix of pickled vegetables including peppers, carrots, and cauliflower, offering a tangy and crunchy addition to your breakfast.
  $2.75
- La Fede Marinated Eggplant Strips
  12 oz
  $3.65
- La Fede Pepperoncini
  Crisp, tangy pepperoncini peppers, perfect for adding a zesty kick to salads, sandwiches, or antipasto platters.
  $5.00
- La Fede Red Wine Vinegar
  Imported from Italy
  $2.75
- La Fede Roasted Red Peppers
  Fire-roasted red peppers preserved to enhance their natural sweetness, typically used to add depth and flavor to various dishes.
  $3.25
- Three Little Pigs Whole Grain Mustard
  Moutarde a lancienne made in Brooklyn, NY. 7 oz.
  $6.50
- Mutti Tomato Paste
  4.5 oz
  $3.85
- Not Your Moma’s Flour
  Gluten free AP flour
  $8.00
- Pastificio Di Martino Penne Pasta
  IGP Protected, made in Gragnano Italy, bronze die cut, 100% Italian wheat (no Gliophosate)
  $3.85
- Pastificio G. DiMartino Bucatini
  IGP Protected, made in Gragnano Italy, bronze die cut, 100% Italian wheat (no Gliophosate)
  $3.00
- Pastificio Di Martino Spaghetti
  IGP Protected, made in Gragnano Italy, bronze die cut, 100% Italian wheat (no Gliophosate)
  $2.65
- Pastificio Di Martino Tagliatelle
  IGP Protected, made in Gragnano Italy, bronze die cut, 100% Italian wheat (no Gliophosate)
  $3.50
- Pearled Farro
  Roland imported pearled Italian farro 1lb, 1.6oz
  $6.25
- Riscossa Lasagna
  Dried lasagna noodle imported from Puglia, Italy
  $5.00
- Mafaldine
  Imported Riscossa brand noodle
  $2.50
- Delverde No Boil Lasagna
  Imported instant lasagna noodles
  $6.75
- Rummo Gluten Free Penne
  Rummo imported Italian gluten free penne no. 66 (12 oz)
  $5.00
- Pasta D Oro Gluton Free Spaghetti
  100 percent corn pasta
  $3.75
- San Marzano Tomatoes-La Fede
  The iconic D.O.P. Italian whole canned tomatoes
  $6.00
- Mutti Cherry Tomatoes
  Mutti Cherry Tomatoes - 100% Italian cherry tomatoes in tomato juice.
  $3.25
- Scotti Carnaroli Rice for Risotto
  Risotto 2.2 lb
  $5.50
- Sicilian Sea Salt
  Coarse sea salt imported from Sicily
  $2.75
- Purell Hand Sanitizer
  8 oz hand sanitizer
  $7.00
- Toilet Paper 2-ply Individual Roll
  Standard roll, 500 sheets per roll
  $1.00
- FP Retro Trucker Hat
  Structured cap featuring a low crown, mesh back, and velcro closure, typically adorned with the FP logo embroidered on the front.
  $30.00
- Half and Half Quart
  A quart of half and half, typically used as a creamy addition to coffee or desserts.
  $5.00