Being from New England. I have visited Newhaven and enjoyed their delicious Pizza, with that being said ,Fantini's nailed it.Perfect crust, simple light sauce with fresh toppings. It absolutely worked . A must try
I have never complained, nor have I ever sent a meal back at any restaurant in my lifetime. I ordered two pizzas. A large pepperoni and sausage and I waited 40 minites for a white clam pizza no cheese. As my wife is highlighted allergic. The waiter repeated the order back to me "no mutz, no mutz". The waiter said they had to remake it a 2nd time. It came back with mutz. They refuse to make a pizza without mutz. I said something to the manager, who had no empathy and stated "we don't make a pizza without cheese". Overrated!
Probably the best pizza i have had here in florida! Definitely my new go to place. It's a little expensive but it's worth every penny. I can not wait to get pizza from Fantini's again. 5
Won’t be back. Ordered two pizzas. One was to be clams casino - no “mutz”. Waiter repeated back to me and I repeated back to him. No cheese is not a preference to me. I am very allergic. My husband and son got their large in about 15-20 minutes. I waited nearly 35 to get mine. It came out covered in cheese. I said I asked for no cheese. He said “sorry. We don’t customize”.. We paid the bill and hopefully my husband son like the clams casino pizza bec I had wine for dinner. We will absolutely not be back. I’m also Italian - so I get the love of cheese.the New Haven pizzeria they are trying to mirror makes this pizza for me without hesitation. Dietary restrictions: They don’t care if you have a restriction. Just watch your party eat if you have one.
There may be no better pizza I florida. I could of used a slight bit more char. Excellent either way. When I'm on the east coast I'll make sure to swing by. The only thing I didn't understand is how they had no highchairs. Makes it tough with a little one
My husband and I eat here often and the food is incredible! We first went to try the pizza, it is the best pizza around the area and in general. We decided to try their bucatini and meatballs my gosh their meatballs are the best. The sauce is also amazing, the pasta was perfectly cooked.
Best pizza outside New Haven !!
Good pizza, the middle was soggy. I'm not a new york style pizza kind of person. The ingredients were fantastic. Pretty pricey, though, for pizza. Took 1 1/2 hours together our order & they said 40 minutes & it was take-out. Don't go on Saturday.
Hands down, Best pizza I have ever had. The crust is perfect. The sauce is so good. And the cannoli… oh man.