Fancy Pizzeria Menu

4.7

(200+ Reviews)

Local Dinner Package / Garrett’s Sweets MONDAY SPECIALS Select 2 Pizzas receive 50%off STARTER Select (2) 1-topping pizzas for $20 Lunch Special (slices)Starters Salads and Sides Pasta Sandwiches Filet and Asparagus Pizza Retail/Merch Signature Drinks The Bakery Catering Pasta Pizza Party Pack Catering Salads

Local Dinner Package / Garrett’s Sweets
We have an amazing offer here for $35 select any starter, followed by any menu pizza. Cruise over to Garrett’s Sweet Shop on main and finish your evening with a delicious treat!
- “Local” Dinner Package
  Select any starter, followed by any menu pizza. Cruise over to Garrett’s Sweet Shop on main and finish your evening with a delicious treat!
  $35.00
MONDAY SPECIALS
Purchase (2) 1-topping pizzas for $20
- $20 (2) 1-topping pizzas
  Start off with our base cheese pizza and build your own pizza
  $20.00
Select 2 Pizzas receive 50%off STARTER
- Cheese Pizza
  12 inch pizza starting with red tomato sauce and shredded mozzarella cheese, make your pizza, your way
  $16.00
- Cadillac Margherita
  The Margherita but with smoked provolone and a Parmesan crust!
  $18.00
- Great Bambino
  pepperoni, hand-made sliced meatball, sausage, shredded mozzarella cheese, red sauce
  $20.00
- Garden pizza
  A fresh take on our veggies with red onion spinach tomatoes tossed in pesto and drizzled with balsamic reduction and Parmesan cheese.
  $19.00
- Margherita
  the traditional Italian pizza made with fresh basil, Real mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce
  $16.00
- Pepperoni Estremo
  A pizza for Pepperoni Lovers
  $21.00
- The Cardinal
  Pepperoni, sausage, onion, bell pepper, black olive, shredded mozzarella cheese and red sauce
  $21.00
- Funghi Pizza
  Savory wood smoked mushrooms enhanced with truffle oil and chives with our Alfredo based sauce. Certainly next level
  $19.00
- Carne Asada Pizza
  We start this pizza with a special roasted poblano cream sauce and incorporate marinated thinly sliced carne asada and wood smoked onions. When that comes out of the oven we then put fresh pico de gallo, queso fresco and cilantro pedals to boot. One of a kind fer sure!
  $21.00
Select (2) 1-topping pizzas for $20
Two pizzas are better than one!
- $20 (2) 1-topping pizzas
  Start off with our base cheese pizza and build your own pizza
  $20.00
Lunch Special (slices)
1 Slice Cheese Pizza
- 1 Cheese Slice
  $5.00
- 2 Cheese Slices
  $10.00
- 1 Pepperoni Slice
  $6.00
- 2 Pepperoni Slices
  2 slices of pepperoni pizza please
  $12.00
- 2 Cheese Slices /24oz drink
  Two slices and a soda
  $12.00
- 1 Cheese slice/ garden salad/24oz drink
  $12.00
Starters
A great way to share is with one of our starters.
- Bruschetta
  This toasted yet soft ciabatta topped with diced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella tossed in pesto and drizzled with balsamic reduction over a bed of arugula. This dish will leave you wanting more!
  $14.00
- Cheese Bread with Pesto
  Our take on breadsticks, with brûlée mozzarella and pesto sauce
  $12.00
- Super Garlic Knots
  Buttery herbed garlic knots dusted in Grated Parmesan cheese, this delight is served with a creamy tomato sauce laden in basil, we call it Rosa Sauce or choice of Classic Marinara
  $14.00
- GiGi Mack & Cheese
  GiGis Mack is penne slathered in a white American Alfredo cheese sauce, then topped with bread crumbs and Parmesan cheese and baked off til golden crispy, garnished with a pinch of parsley
  $12.00
- Meatball Trio
  (3) 4oz Meatballs with Marinara sauce, Basil and grated Parmesan cheese made from scratch with homemade breadcrumbs mama mia!
  $12.00
- Artichoke & Spinach Dip
  A molten crock of bubbling brown cheese and artichokes in a creamed base. Served with our flatbread. Serves 2 or more!
  $15.00
- Artichoke Bruschetta
  We take our rustic homemade foccocia bread and spread with our artichoke cheese medley til brown and bubbling. Garnished with arugula and peppadew peppers!
  $15.00
- Grilled Cheese and Tomato soup
  Creamy tomato soup with fresh Basil. The grilled cheese has bacon and onions.
  $14.00
Salads and Sides
- Caprese Arugula Salad
  Arugula hand tossed in vinaigrette, topped with fresh mozzarella cheese and tomatoes. Drizzled with balsamic reduction and Parmesan cheese.
  $12.00
- Garden Salad
  A wedge of iceberg lettuce, tomato, shredded mozzarella cheese, garnished with Calamata olive
  $6.00
- Italian Chopped Salad
  Thinly sliced iceberg lettuce tossed with ham, salami, pepperoni and provolone cheese, with tangy tomato house dressing garnished with grated Parmesan cheese and finely chopped parsley peppadew peppers and our croutons. Shareable or not;)
  $16.00
- Side of Ranch
  Buttermilk ranch
  $0.50
- Side of House Dressing
  Sweet and tangy tomato vinaigrette
  $0.50
- French onion soup 🎅
  Classic French onion soup with a cheese and chived crouton afloat.
  $6.00
- Tomato Soup 🍅
  $6.00
- SD Rosa Sauce
  $4.00
- SD Pesto
  $2.00
- SD Marinara
  $2.00
Pasta
Cooked to order pasta, come taste fresh ingredients.
- Spaghetti and meatballs
  Three meatballs with a hearty tomato sauce, served on top of spaghetti noodles and garnished with fresh parmesan cheese and basil
  $16.00
- Pasta Carbonara
  Alfredo sauce, bacon, peas, topped with roasted pine nuts over fettuccini noodles
  $16.00
- Carne Asada Pasta
  We feature our poblano cream sauce base. This pasta is loaded with carne asada, wood smoked onions, fire roasted bell peppers. We finish this dish with fresh cut cilantro 🌿
  $16.00
- Pasta Bolognese
  Penne tossed in bolognese sauce topped with ricotta and mozzarella then baked til’ bubbly golden brûléed cheese garnished with Parmesean and basil 🫠
  $16.00
Sandwiches
All of our sandwiches are served on flatbread baked here in our oven to order.
- Italian Beef
  Thinly sliced bottom round beef slowly marinated in beef jus served giardenara peppers and a cup of jus for dunking
  $14.00
- Italian Cold Cut
  Salami, pepperoni, ham, tomato, provolone cheese and our tangy house dressing tossed over iceberg lettuce served on focaccia bread
  $14.00
- Meatball Sandwich
  Hand-made meatballs, shredded mozzarella cheese, red sauce, fresh basil inside fresh flat bread
  $14.00
- Philly Cheesesteak
  Classic Philly meat shaved thin and sautéed along side onions, bell peppers and mushrooms. We then pour our White American cheese sauce over that and it is served on our fresh flat bread!
  $14.00
Filet and Asparagus
- Filet 9oz
  $35.00
- Filet 12oz
  $45.00
Pizza
All pizzas are 12” Neapolitan style, 6 slices to a pizza
- Cheese Pizza
  12 inch pizza starting with red tomato sauce and shredded mozzarella cheese, make your pizza, your way
  $16.00
- Cadillac Margherita
  The Margherita but with smoked provolone and a Parmesan crust!
  $18.00
- Great Bambino
  pepperoni, hand-made sliced meatball, sausage, shredded mozzarella cheese, red sauce
  $20.00
- Garden pizza
  A fresh take on our veggies with red onion spinach tomatoes tossed in pesto and drizzled with balsamic reduction and Parmesan cheese.
  $19.00
- Margherita
  the traditional Italian pizza made with fresh basil, Real mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce
  $16.00
- Pepperoni Estremo
  A pizza for Pepperoni Lovers
  $21.00
- The Cardinal
  Pepperoni, sausage, onion, bell pepper, black olive, shredded mozzarella cheese and red sauce
  $21.00
- Funghi Pizza
  Savory wood smoked mushrooms enhanced with truffle oil and chives with our Alfredo based sauce. Certainly next level
  $19.00
- Carne Asada Pizza
  We start this pizza with a special roasted poblano cream sauce and incorporate marinated thinly sliced carne asada and wood smoked onions. When that comes out of the oven we then put fresh pico de gallo, queso fresco and cilantro pedals to boot. One of a kind fer sure!
  $21.00
- Greek
  Alfredo base, olive tapenade, spinach, artichoke hearts and ricotta cheese
  $20.00
- Roasted Corn Pizza
  Our Smokey green poblano cream sauce with roasted corn, red bell peppers and molten fresh mozzarella garnished with cilantro. 🌿
  $19.00
Retail/Merch
Rep your pizza preference!
- Hat
  Look fly with that side logo all black Fancy cap!
  $20.00
- Shirt
  All black with red print, Fancy!
  $20.00
Signature Drinks
Here we have assembled and crafted some of the most tantalizing drinks combinations. Try an Italian Soda or Homemade Lemonade or a signature Fancy Freeze.
- The Original Italian Soda
  A sweet and sparkling beverage topped with real homemade whip,,, so yumm
  $5.00
- Real Lemonade 24oz
  Homemade Lemonade
  $5.00
- Arnold Palmer 24oz
  1/2 lemonade 1/2 tea
  $5.00
- The “Fancy” Freeze
  A Frozen 🥶 Blend of some of our favorites drinks
  $5.00
- Cherry Limeade 24oz
  Handcrafted with muddled cherries and lime juice, taste what premium cherry limeade is like
  $5.00
- Dreamsicle
  Taste this mandarin orange and French vanilla combo quite the delight
  $5.00
- Prickly Pear Limeade
  Sweet and tangy, certainly refreshing, also a local fan fave. Brilliant pink in color surely to delight.
  $5.00
- Acactus cooler 🍊🍍
  This pineapple orange drink will certainly knock your socks off!! Served with whip and a cherry!
  $5.00
- Raspberry limeade
  Crisp raspberry notes, laced in tart limeade. Certainly a crowd pleaser.
  $5.00
The Bakery
We proudly craft all of our desserts from scratch
- Giant Cookie
  Chocolate chip and toasted walnut with salted caramel
  $5.00
- Lemon Mascarpone cake 🍰
  Lemon mascarpone cake is moist and rich. Try it with a scoop of ice cream!
  $5.00
- Cheese Cake with Chocolate Drizzle
  Creamy Cheese Cake with Chocolate Drizzle
  $4.00
- Pizookie
  House-made cookie crumble with toasted walnuts and chocolate chips, vanilla ice cream and chocolate drizzle, Mexican vanilla whip cream and a cherry.
  $10.00
Catering Pasta
- Full Tray Pasta Carbonara
  A Full tray will feed 20-24people
  $90.00
- Full tray Pasta Veggie Primavera
  A Full tray will feed 20-24people
  $85.00
- Full tray Pasta Bolognese
  A Full tray will feed 20-24people
  $80.00
- 1/2 Tray Pasta Carbonara
  A Half tray will feed 10-12 people
  $45.00
- 1/2 Tray Pasta Veggie Primavera
  A Half tray will feed 10-12 people
  $42.50
- 1/2 Tray Pasta Bolognese
  A Half tray will feed 10-12 people
  $40.00
Pizza Party Pack
- Pizza Party
  Choose 6 Chef inspired Pizzas. Feeds 10-12
  $100.00
Catering Salads
All salads are served with ranch and vinegarette on side
- Half tray Italian Chopped Salad
  $40.00
- Half tray Garden Salad
  $25.00
- Half tray Arugula Salad
  $30.00