Extraordinary Cupcakes Menu

$Bakery

435 W Duke of Gloucester St, Williamsburg, VA 23185

Order Online

Valentine's Day Cakes
- 6 Inch Heart Cake With Vanilla Icing - 1 Day Advance Notice Required
  Your choice of vanilla, chocolate, or lemon cake iced with your choice of colors for the vanilla icing and message. 1 day advance order required. 2 day advance notice preferred.
  $45.00
Unfilled Cupcakes
- Fantastic Chocolate Flip
  Wicked chocolate cake, topped with our famous Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing.
  $3.95
- Fantastic Vanilla Flip
  Moist vanilla cake, topped off with rich wicked chocolate buttercream icing.
  $3.95
- Marvelous Madagascar - Requires Additional Prep Time
  Baking begins in a cold oven so this creation takes a little more time but it is our most popular cupcake. Not your grocery store vanilla cupcake. This is a dense, traditional pound cake that my mom used to make, We added some Madagascar vanilla bean to it and topped it with our Madagascar buttercream icing.
  $4.45
- Wicked Chocolate
  The only good bomb is a chocolate one and this is it. Wicked chocolate cake and a rich Wicked chocolate buttercream icing. Mic drop here.
  $3.95
- Uncommon Carrot
  Fresh grated carrot, crushed pineapple, walnuts, and Vietnamese Cinnamon make this cake uncommon and moist. Combine that with our amazing cream cheese icing and you are sure to be hooked.
  $3.95
- Remarkable Red Velvet
  Classic red velvet cake with a remarkable cream cheese icing make this cupcake a fan favorite.
  $3.95
- Monumental Marble
  Chocolate and vanilla marble cake with Wicked Chocolate icing.
  $3.95
- Wondrous Gingerbread
  Available in December only - Gingerbread cake topped with sweet cinnamon buttercream icing.
  $3.95
Filled Cupcakes
- Luscious Lemon Raspberry
  Moist vanilla cake, filled with a rich raspberry compound, topped with raspberry buttercream icing.
  $4.45
- Phenonmenal Peanut Butter
  Moist chocolate cake, filled with creamy peanut butter, and topped with peanut butter buttercream icing. Feel the stress melt away.
  $4.45
- The Great Pumpkin
  Available in November - Vanilla cake filled with pumpkin pie filling and a cinnamon cream cheese icing. Hello Thanksgiving!
  $4.45
- Sensational S'mores
  Available September 21 - December 21 Vanilla cake with a dash of Vietnamese Cinnamon, filled with graham cracker, marshmallow, and chocolate then covered in melted chocolate and topped with a extraordinarily large toasted marshmallow. Best eaten warm. Put in microwave for 10 seconds on low or in the oven on 350 for 6 minutes.
  $4.45
- Gregarious German Chocolate
  Available December 21 - March 19 Super-light chocolate cake with a pecan & coconut caramel frosting and a rich coconut & pecan filling.
  $4.45
- Miraculous Mint Cocoa
  Available in January - Our Wicked Chocolate cake, filled with a fluffy mint cream and topped with a Vanilla/Mint Buttercream icing.
  $4.45
- Ravishing Raspberry Chocolate
  $4.45
Mini Cupcakes Dozen
- 12 Mini Cupcakes
  $29.40
Special Occasion Cakes - Minimum 3 Day Advance Order Required
- 6" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  3- Day minimum advance order required.
  $45.00
- 8" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $55.00
- 10" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $65.00
- 12" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $85.00
- 1/2 Sheet Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $90.00
- Full Sheet Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $180.00
- Gluten Free Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required
  $55.00
Other Extraordinary Items
- Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding - Requires 3 Day Advance Ordering
  My mom's recipe. Nothing fancy, just Mmm Mmm good.
  $6.95
- OMG NY Cheesecake
  Made from the famous recipe from Carnegie Deli in NY.
  $6.95
- Walnut Mousse Bar
  $6.95
- Makin' Whoopie Pie - Requires 2 Day Advance Ordering
  Our moist red velvet cake filled with our simply amazing cream cheese icing.
  $6.95
- Cake Push-Up Pops - Minimum 3 Day Advance Ordering Required
  Our classic flavors presented in fun push-up pop containers. Give your events a dash of nostalgia and fun. ***Stand in picture is not included.
  $4.45
- Run Run As Fast As You Can Gingerbread
  An Extraordinary customer favorite - fresh made gingerbread cookies decorated to make you smile.
  $5.50
Gluten-Free Cupcakes
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcake Filled
  $5.45
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcake Unfilled
  $4.95
- Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcake Filled
  $5.45
- Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcake Unfilled
  $4.95
Gluten-Free Monumental Marble Unfilled Cupcake
- Gluten-Free Monumental Marble Cupcake
  $4.95
Mini Gluten-Free Cupcake Dozen
- 12 Mini Size Gluten-Free Cupcakes
  $32.50

Menu Gallery

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Privacy

Terms

Extraordinary Cupcakes Menu

Valentine's Day Cakes

6 Inch Heart Cake With Vanilla Icing - 1 Day Advance Notice Required

Unfilled Cupcakes

Fantastic Chocolate Flip

Fantastic Vanilla Flip

Marvelous Madagascar - Requires Additional Prep Time

Wicked Chocolate

Uncommon Carrot

Remarkable Red Velvet

Monumental Marble

Wondrous Gingerbread

Filled Cupcakes

Luscious Lemon Raspberry

Phenonmenal Peanut Butter

The Great Pumpkin

Sensational S'mores

Gregarious German Chocolate

Miraculous Mint Cocoa

Ravishing Raspberry Chocolate

Mini Cupcakes Dozen

12 Mini Cupcakes

Special Occasion Cakes - Minimum 3 Day Advance Order Required

6" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

8" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

10" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

12" Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

1/2 Sheet Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

Full Sheet Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

Gluten Free Cake 3- Day Minimum Advance Order Required

Other Extraordinary Items

Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding - Requires 3 Day Advance Ordering

OMG NY Cheesecake

Walnut Mousse Bar

Makin' Whoopie Pie - Requires 2 Day Advance Ordering

Cake Push-Up Pops - Minimum 3 Day Advance Ordering Required

Run Run As Fast As You Can Gingerbread

Gluten-Free Cupcakes

Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcake Filled

Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcake Unfilled

Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcake Filled

Gluten-Free Vanilla Cupcake Unfilled

Gluten-Free Monumental Marble Unfilled Cupcake

Gluten-Free Monumental Marble Cupcake

Mini Gluten-Free Cupcake Dozen

12 Mini Size Gluten-Free Cupcakes

Menu Gallery

Menu Gallery