Elizaville Deli Menu

3.7
(75+ Reviews)
$Deli
  • Deli Pizza

    • Classic Pizza Pie (Large 18")

      The classic NY style: red sauce and our special mozzarella cheese blend
      $16.30
    • White Pie

      Ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic (no tomato))
      $17.85
    • Margherita (Large 18")

      A classico: fresh mozzarella, basil, with tomato sauce!
      $19.60
    • Gravel Pile Pie (Large 18")

      The Elizaville Classic! Named after the old gravel quarry that used to be behind the deli, this pizza has it all: pepperoni, meatball, sausage, peppers, onions, mushrooms, olives!
      $26.10
    • Peppy Peps

      Tomato, mozzarella, pepperoni, pepperoncini, and green peppers
      $23.95
    • Veggie Deluxe

      Tomato, peppers, onions, mushrooms, broccoli, and olives
      $21.75
    • Shroomster

      Tomato, fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, red onion
      $20.00
    • The Popeye

      Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic, spinach, and pickled jalapeno
      $20.90
    • Hawaiian

      Tomato, mozzarella, cappy ham, and pineapple
      $21.75
    • Pizza/Wings Special

      18" pizza with an order of 10 Buffalo chicken wings, plus a 2 liter bottle of soda (a good deal!)
      $32.60
  • Deli Hot Subs And Sandwiches

    • Deli Cheese Quesadilla

      White or Spinach wrap with cheddar cheese and your choice of add-ons, served with sour cream.
      $9.15
    • Deli Chicken Parm

      House-breaded chicken cutlet fried untill golden and crisp, smothered in marinara and topped with melted mozz served on a sub or hard roll
      $10.00
    • Deli Grilled Cheese

      A classic - thick toasted white bread and american cheese, melted to perfection!
      $6.95
    • Deli Hot Pepperoni Parm

      A county fair delicacy, sliced pepperoni, simmered in marinara sauce served in a sub or hard roll
      $8.95
    • Deli Meatball Parm

      Italian style pork meatballs simmered in marinara served on a sub or hardroll
      $10.00
    • Deli Philly Cheesesteak

      Roast beef, griddled with peppers, onions, and mushrooms, with melted provolone cheese served on a sub
      $12.60
    • Deli Reuben

      Corned beef, swiss, sauerkraut and thousand island dressing on toasted rye
      $13.50
    • Deli Burger

      6 oz patty served on a toasted potato bun with lettuce, tomato, onion, a pickle, and deli sauce.
      $8.70
    • Deli Sabrett Hot Dog

      New York's #1 hot dog! All-beef franks served with a toasted bun and your choice of condiments
      $4.35
    • Deli Egg And Cheese

      $4.35
    • Deli Egg, Sausage, American Cheese

      $6.55
    • Deli Egg, Bacon, American Cheese

      $6.75
  • Deli Sandwiches

    • Deli American Mix Sandwich

      turkey, bologna, ham, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, yellow mustard on a hard roll or sub
      $10.25
    • Deli B.L.T. Sandwich

      Classic bacon, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bread
      $9.15
    • Deli Bologna Sandwich

      Boar's Head bologna on your choice of bread
      $7.60
    • Deli Buffalo Chicken Wrap

      Buffalo chicken, lettuce, and house-made blue cheese dressing in a wrap.
      $10.90
    • Deli Cappy Ham Sandwich

      Boar's Head cappy ham on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $8.05
    • Deli Chicken Caesar Wrap

      Classic chicken Ceasar salad wrap with house-made Ceasar dressing.
      $10.90
    • Deli Chicken Cutlet Sandwich

      House-breaded chicken cutlet on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $9.15
    • Deli Chicken Salad Sandwich

      Our homemade chicken salad on your choice of bread with condiments
      $8.95
    • Deli Club Sandwich

      $10.90
    • Deli Corned Beef Sandwich

      Boars Head corned beef on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $10.00
    • Deli Grilled Chicken Sandwich

      Grilled chicken breast served on your choice of bread with condiments
      $9.15
    • Deli Ham Sandwich

      Boar's Head boiled ham on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $9.15
    • Deli Italian Mix Sandwich

      salami, cappy ham, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion, giardiniera with oil and vinegar on a hard roll or sub
      $10.25
    • Deli Liverwurst Sandwich

      Boar's Head Liverwurst on your choice of bread with condiments
      $8.95
    • Deli Pastrami Sandwich

      Pastrami on your choice of bread with condiments
      $10.45
    • Deli Pepperoni Sandwich

      Sliced pepperoni on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $8.95
    • Deli Roast Beef Sandwich

      Beef roasted in house and sliced on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $9.60
    • Deli Tuna Salad Sandwich

      House-made tuna salad on your choice of bread with condiments
      $8.95
    • Deli Turkey Sandwich

      Turkey roasted in house and sliced on your choice of bread with condiments.
      $8.95
    • Deli Vegetarian Sandwich

      Lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese and pickles on your choice of bread with condiments
      $7.85
  • Deli Appetizers

    • Deli Buffalo Wings (5pc.)

      Chicken wings tossed in buffalo sauce served with house-made blue cheese dip and celery/carrots.
      $10.90
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (10pc.)

      $20.65
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (15pc.)

      $27.20
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (20pc.)

      $35.90
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (25pc.)

      $44.60
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (30pc.)

      $53.30
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (35pc.)

      $61.95
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (40pc.)

      $70.65
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (45pc.)

      $79.35
    • Deli Buffalo Wings (50pc.)

      $88.05
    • Deli Chicken Tenders

      Four chicken tenders served with you choice of sauce
      $10.90
    • Deli Chili Cheese Fries

      French fries served with our house made chili and cheddar cheese.
      $7.60
    • Deli Mozzarella Sticks

      $9.80
  • Deli Soups And Sides

    • Deli Onion Rings

      $7.60
    • Deli Fries (Lg.)

      A large portion of fries
      $5.25
    • Deli Fries (Sm.)

      When you want to add a portion of fries to accompany your meal!
      $3.30
    • Deli Chili (Sm.)

      Homemade served with sour cream, cheddar, diced onion, and jalapeno
      $6.55
    • Deli Chili (Lg.)

      Homemade served with sour cream, cheddar, diced onion, and jalapeno
      $9.80
  • Deli Breads, Bagels & Muffins

    • Bagel

      $1.30
    • Danish

      $2.40
    • Doughnut

      $1.30
    • Hard Roll

      $0.00
    • Hard Roll

      $0.90
    • Mighty Doughnut (Weekend Only)

      $3.05
    • Muffin

      $2.40
    • Sub Roll

      $1.75
  • Beverages

    • Arizona Fruit Punch- 20 Oz

      $2.20
    • Arizona Green Tea - 20 Oz

      $2.20
    • Arizona Lemon - 20 Oz

      $1.30
    • Arizona Rx - 20 Oz

      $1.30
    • Barq's Root Beer, 20 Oz. Bottle

      $3.30
    • Canada Dry Ginger Ale, 12 Fl Oz Can

      $1.65
    • Canada Dry Soda Ginger Ale - 2.0 L

      $3.50
    • Coca-Cola Diet Coke Soda Soft Drink, 20 Oz

      $2.20
    • Coca-Cola Diet Soda Soft Drink 2 Liters

      $3.50
    • Coca-Cola Soda - 12.0 Oz

      $2.20
    • Coca-Cola Soda - 16.0 Fl Oz

      $3.05
    • Gatorade Thirst Quencher Lemon-Lime Sport Drink, 20 Fl. Oz

      $2.20
    • Guayaki Organic Yerba Mate, Lemon Elation - 15.5 Fl Oz

      $3.50
    • Hot Coffee Large

      $3.05
    • Hot Coffee Medium

      $2.60
    • Hot Coffee Small

      $2.20
    • Monster Energy Green, Original - 16.0 Oz

      $3.30
    • Mountain Dew Soda - 2.0 L

      $3.50
    • Mug Root Beer 2 Liter

      $4.80
    • Mug Root Beer 20oz Btl

      $3.05
    • Nestle Chocolate Milk Chocolate - 14.0 Fl Oz

      $2.60
    • Pepsi Bottle 2L - 33.8 Oz

      $2.60
    • Pepsi Diet Cola - 20.0 Oz

      $2.20
    • Pepsi Diet, 2 Liter Bottle

      $3.50
    • Poland Spring Sparkling Water 16.9oz

      $2.60
    • Poland Spring Water (Plain) 16.9 Oz

      $1.75
    • Red Bull 8.4oz

      $3.95
    • Schweppes Soda Ginger Ale - 67.6 Oz

      $4.80
    • Snapple Tea, Lemon - 16 Fl Oz

      $2.00
    • Snapple Tea, Raspberry, Diet - 16 Fl Oz

      $3.05
    • Snapple Tea, Lemon - 32 Fl Oz

      $2.85
    • Snapple Tea, Peach - 32 Fl Oz

      $2.85
    • Snapple Tea, Diet, Peach - 32 Fl Oz

      $2.85
    • Sprite Lemon Lime Soda Soft Drink 12 Fl Oz

      $1.65
    • Topochico Mexican Seltzer

      $2.60
    • Water Gallon Jug

      $2.85
    • Yoo-Hoo

      $2.40
  • Deli Coffee Tea

    • Small Hot Coffee

      $1.75
    • Medium Hot Coffee

      $2.20
    • Large Hot Coffee

      $2.60
    • Small Tea

      $1.75
    • Medium Tea

      $2.20
    • Large Hot Tea

      $2.60
    • Cold Brew Coffee

      $3.50
  • Merchandise

    • T Shirt

      $21.75
    • Hats

      $21.75
    • Books

      $17.40
    • Sticker

      $1.75
    • Booknook Book (Deli)

      $6.95

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Elizaville Diner Film Location & Events
Elizaville Diner Film Location & Events
4.2
(244 Reviews)
Diner, American
Kay's Kones
Kay's Kones
4.1
(17 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
ICESCREAMS
ICESCREAMS
4.7
(176 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
Cornucopia Deli
Cornucopia Deli
4.4
(139 Reviews)
Deli
Vosburgh Brewing Company
Vosburgh Brewing Company
5.0
(41 Reviews)
Brewery
Greig Farm
Greig Farm
4.7
(554 Reviews)
Breakfast, Lunch
Lasting Joy Brewery
Lasting Joy Brewery
4.7
(144 Reviews)
Brewery, Bar
Hudson Valley Distillers, LLC
Hudson Valley Distillers, LLC
4.8
(58 Reviews)
Cocktail bar
Tousey Winery
Tousey Winery
4.6
(155 Reviews)
Cafe
Clermont Café
Clermont Café
4.9
(30 Reviews)
Restaurant

+1 845-756-3557

573 E Kerleys Corners Rd, Livingston, NY 12523


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms