East of Chicago Pizza Menu

4.2
(475+ Reviews)
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Cheese Pizza

      Different size options from Small (9") to Extra Large (16"), serving 6 to 12 slices.
      $9.50
      Cheese Pizza
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      140 cal/pc.
      $4.99
      Garlic Cheese Bread
    • The Tower

      170-360 cal. 10 toppings - pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers, onions, ham, bacon, mild banana peppers, green & black olives. Additional price for topping addition.
      $15.49
      The Tower
    • All Meat

      160-360 cal. Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon & beef.
      $13.49
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      170-400 cal. Ranch dressing, grilled fajita chicken, bacon, and tomatoes. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE RANCH SAUCE UNDER CHEESE
      $13.49
    • Boneless Wings

      Choice of 10, 20, 30, or 50 pieces. Seven great tasting sauces.
      $11.99
    • Breadsticks

      150 cal/pc. Sticks with pizza or marinara sauce.
      $4.99
    • Deluxe

      160-330 cal. Pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, green peppers, green olives & mild banana peppers.
      $13.49
    • CinnaPOPs™

      120 cal/2 pieces. With icing.
      $5.99
    • Chicago Melt

      160-340 cal. Pepperoni, sausage, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese.
      $13.49
  • Pizza

    Serving size: 1 slice. Pan (130-230 cal) (Our signature crust. Light and airy with a crunch! "Best pan pizza east of Chicago. 6", 9", 12", and 14"). Thin (130-260 cal) (Hand tossed with a golden brown crust. 9", 12", 14", and 16"). Authentic Chicago style™ (290 cal) (Seasoned crust filled with your favorite toppings, covered in marinara sauce and topped with parmesan cheese. 12" only.) Crispy (130 cal) (A very thin crust with a distinctive crunch. 12" and 14" only.) Square (240 cal) Thin crust - 16" only.) Loaded crust™ (280/300 cal) (Thin center with cheese & pepperoni baked inside a folded edge. 12" and 14" only.)
    • Cheese Pizza

      Different size options from Small (9") to Extra Large (16"), serving 6 to 12 slices.
      $9.50
      Cheese Pizza
  • Specialty Pizza

    • All Meat

      160-360 cal. Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon & beef.
      $13.49
    • Chicago Melt

      160-340 cal. Pepperoni, sausage, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese.
      $13.49
    • Deluxe

      160-330 cal. Pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, green peppers, green olives & mild banana peppers.
      $13.49
    • Taco with Meat or Chicken

      Taco with meat (170-310 cal) or chicken (170-330 cal). Salsa & taco - style meat or grilled fajita chicken topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, black olives, sour cream, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheeses. Additional price for grilled fajita chicken. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE SALSA UNDER CHEESE
      $13.49
    • BBQ Chicken

      150-300 cal. BBQ sauce, grilled fajita chicken, and pineapple. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE BBQ SAUCE UNDER CHEESE
      $13.49
      BBQ Chicken
    • Chicken Bacon BBQ

      130-330 cal. BBQ sauce, grilled fajita chicken and bacon. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE BBQ SAUCE UNDER CHEESE
      $14.49
    • Double Stack Pepperoni

      180-380 cal. Pepperoni double stacked between a layers of our signature cheese blend and topped with parmesan.
      $13.49
    • 7 Layer Veggie

      170-360 cal. Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mild banana peppers, tomatoes, green olives & black olives.
      $13.49
    • Buffalo Chicken

      180-340 cal. Mild or hot (140-310 cal) sauce topped with boneless breaded chicken. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE MILD SAUCE UNDER CHEESE
      $13.49
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      170-400 cal. Ranch dressing, grilled fajita chicken, bacon, and tomatoes. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE- DOES NOT INCLUDE RED SAUCE ON TOP- BUT WILL HAVE RANCH SAUCE UNDER CHEESE
      $13.49
    • Hawaiian

      180-350 cal. Ham, pineapple, and bacon.
      $13.49
    • The Tower

      170-360 cal. 10 toppings - pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, green peppers, onions, ham, bacon, mild banana peppers, green & black olives. Additional price for topping addition.
      $15.49
      The Tower
  • Oven Baked Subs

    • American

      700 cal. Ham, salami, bologna, signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & special sauce.
      $7.50
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled fajita chicken, bacon, tomatoes, signature cheese blend & ranch dressing.
      $7.50
    • Italian

      Ham, salami, pepperoni, signature cheese blend, lettuce, tomatoes, onions & Italian dressing.
      $7.50
    • Steak

      Strips of steak blended with green peppers and onions, lettuce, tomatoes & miracle whip.
      $7.50
    • BLT

      Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes & miracle whip™.
      $7.50
    • Deluxe

      Pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, green peppers, green olives, mild banana peppers with pizza sauce & signature cheese blend.
      $7.50
    • Meatball

      Meatballs, pizza sauce & signature cheese blend.
      $7.50
    • 7 Layers Veggie

      Mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, green peppers, green olives & black olives, mild banana peppers with pizza sauce & signature cheese blend.
      $7.50
    • Buffalo Chicken

      Grilled fajita chicken tossed in mild or hot 700/1400 cal. Sauce, topped with lettuce, tomatoes, signature cheese blend, cheddar cheese & ranch dressing.
      $7.50
    • Ham & Cheese

      Ham, signature cheese blend, lettuce, and tomatoes & miracle whip™.
      $7.50
    • Pizza

      Any 2 pizza toppings, pizza sauce & signature cheese blend.
      $7.50
  • Salads

    • Buffalo Chicken Salad

      410 cal. Grilled fajita chicken tossed in mild or hot (300 cal) sauce, lettuce, green peppers, tomatoes, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese
      $10.95
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      280 cal. Grilled fajita chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese
      $10.95
    • Side Salad

      110 cal. Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese
      $5.99
    • Chef Salad

      290 cal. Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, pepperoni, ham, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese
      $10.95
    • Taco Salad

      880 cal. Layers of tortilla chips, shredded lettuce, sour cream, salsa & taco style meat. Topped with cheddar cheese, tomatoes, black olives, and more tortilla chips sprinkled on top
      $10.95
  • Wings-Seven Great Tasting Sauces

    Order the sauce on your wings or on the side.
    • Regular Wings

      Choice of 8, 16, 24, or 40 pieces. Seven great tasting sauces available.
      $14.49
    • Boneless Wings

      Choice of 10, 20, 30, or 50 pieces. Seven great tasting sauces.
      $11.99
  • Great Additions

    • ParmPOPs

      120 cal/ 2 pc. Hot & tasty "pops," made from our signature dough. Baked to a golden brown in sizzling garlic butter. Sprinkled with toasted parmesan and served with marinara sauce or pizza sauce.
      $5.99
    • Pizza Foldover - Two Topper

      1420-1800 cal. Our signature dough packed with tasty toppings & signature cheese blend, topped with garlic butter & parmesan, served with pizza sauce.
      $10.95
    • Breadsticks

      150 cal/pc. Sticks with pizza or marinara sauce.
      $4.99
    • Garlic Cheese Bread

      140 cal/pc.
      $4.99
      Garlic Cheese Bread
    • Cheezy Pan

      140 cal/pc.
      $7.50
    • Garlic Pizza Bread

      150-20 cal/pc. An open sub bun with garlic butter, pizza sauce, signature cheese blend, and one topping.
      $10.95
    • Loaded Nachos - Fiesta for Two

      Layers of tortilla chips, taco style meat or grilled fajita chicken, sour cream, nacho cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, onions, and jalapeño peppers. Served with a side of salsa. (2 servings) for grilled fajita chicken add additional price.
      $9.99
    • Loaded Nachos - Fiesta for Four

      Layers of tortilla chips, taco style meat or grilled fajita chicken, sour cream, nacho cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, onions, and jalapeño peppers. Served with a side of salsa. (4 servings) for grilled fajita chicken add additional price.
      $15.99
    • Dipping Sauces

      Blue cheese, BBQ, hot sauce, mild sauce, zesty BBQ, zesty garlic, ranch, marinara, pizza, salsa, and cheddar cheese.
      $1.15
  • No Crust Pizza Bowl

    • Up to 4 Items

      640-1080 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.
      $9.95
    • Specialty - Deluxe

      800 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.
      $10.95
    • Specialty - All Meat

      880 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.
      $10.95
    • Specialty - 7 Layer Veggie

      690 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.
      $10.95
    • Specialty - Taco with Meat

      890 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.
      $10.95
  • Desserts

    • Peanut Butter & Jelly Pizza

      190-290 cal.
      $14.49
    • Dutch Crunch

      100-200 cal.
      $14.49
    • CinnaPOPs™

      120 cal/2 pieces. With icing.
      $5.99
    • Chewy Chocolate Chip and Chunk Cookie

      120 cal/slice.
      $8.49
  • Beverages

    • 2 Liters

      Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mug Root Beer, Starry, Mountain Dew.
      $3.99
    • 20 oz Bottles

      Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mug Root Beer, Starry, Mountain Dew.
      $2.75
    • Aquafina (20 oz)

      Pure water for a perfect taste.
      $2.75
      Aquafina (20 oz)

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Wana-Cup Restaurant
Wana-Cup Restaurant
4.2
(881 Reviews)
American
Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
Shipshewana Auction Restaurant
3.9
(160 Reviews)
Restaurant
Blue Gate Hospitality
Blue Gate Hospitality
4.6
(194 Reviews)
American
Yoder's Hand-Rolled Pretzels
Yoder's Hand-Rolled Pretzels
4.8
(37 Reviews)
Restaurant
Subway
Subway
3.7
(96 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
4.5
(5,731 Reviews)
Restaurant, American, Bakery
Kukuis Hawaiian Shave Ice
Kukuis Hawaiian Shave Ice
4.7
(3 Reviews)
Dessert
Shawna Rae's Bakery & Cafe
Shawna Rae's Bakery & Cafe
4.9
(34 Reviews)
Bakery, Ice cream shop, Restaurant
Kitchen Cupboard Coffee House
Kitchen Cupboard Coffee House
4.8
(55 Reviews)
Coffee shop
Millie's Market Cafe
Millie's Market Cafe
4.5
(62 Reviews)
Restaurant

+1 260-768-7272

350 S Van Buren St # C, Shipshewana, IN 46635


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms