De Pietro's NY Pizzeria

Ordered a large pepperoni pizza. It was delicious!

The very best pizza I’ve ever eaten on Delmarva! The crust, toppings and cheese are just great! One pizza 2 years ago and never order it anywhere else!

Second and last over cooked pizza I got from NY Pizzaria. The first was a regular pizza that felt light. When I got home the crust was dried out and tasteless like a cracker. I was hungry and tolerated it. The second was their Rustico pizza which was apparently supposed to be burnt per the employee/owner when I took it back a couple days later. He insisted a totally burnt dried out pizza was to be expected. You eat burnt pizza crust and you tell me. I only brought the pizza back to him to show him what he was putting in pizza boxes to give him the opportunity to fix it. He claims he's been doing this for a long time and it wasn't overcooked. And to think I waited in the shop for 5-7 minutes while he finished burning it his way.

I like their Pizza. I would probably rate it as one of the best pizzas in the area. What I don't like about this place is that if they are busy they just don't answer the phone.not even a message to say we are not taking orders at this time. Just a phone that rings and rings.

Best pizza in Salisbury and this is coming from a picky NJ pizza enthusiast. Haha

Had an issue with my order one time since I’ve been going to this place. And they fixed it immediately. Great food, great people and great customer service! Highly recommend!