Cristy's Pizza Menu

$$Pizza
914 Pierce Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130
  • Garden Fresh Salads

    • Small House Salad

      Fresh mixed greens with tomato, bacon & provolone.
      $5.60
    • Large House Salad

      A side for 2 or a meal for 1 - Fresh mixed greens with tomato, bacon & provolone.
      $8.73
    • Salad Your Way

      Layer a bed of fresh chopped mixed greens with your choice of meats, cheeses & veggies.
      $4.99
    • Chef Salad

      Loaded with pepperoni, ham, provolone, mushroom, tomato, green pepper, onion, green olive, hot pepper & croutons.
      $9.99
    • Grilled Chicken Salad

      Grilled chicken, tomato, cucumber, Parmesan & croutons.
      $12.50
    • Big House Salad

      Feeds 8-10 -- Lettuce, Tomato ,Provolone and Bacon.
      $50.00
  • Appetizers

    • Pepperoni Nibblerz (10 Pieces)

      Single bites of pepperoni pizza all rolled up, slathered with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce. Served with sweet & tangy tomato or creamy Parmesan garlic butter.
      $9.99
    • Four Cheese Garlic Bread

      An Italian loaf with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce then topped with provolone, cheddar, Parmesan & mozzarella with a side of sweet & tangy tomato sauce.
      $7.50
    • Cristy's Famous Cheesy Breadstix

      Is it the provolone? Our creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce? Or could it be the sweet & tangy tomato dipping sauce? We're not sure what folks love the most, we just know they love 'em.
      $12.50
    • Cheese Nibblerz (10 Pieces)

      Single bites of cheese pizza all rolled up, slathered with creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce. Served with sweet & tangy tomato or creamy Parmesan garlic butter.
      $9.99
  • Build-Your-Own Pizza

    • Build -Your-Own Small Pizza

      Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
      $14.05
    • Build -Your -Own Small Cauliflower Crust Pizza

      Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
      $17.64
    • Build -Your -Own Medium Pizza

      Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
      $18.05
    • Build -Your- Own Large Pizza

      Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
      $23.05
    • Build -Your -Own XLarge Pizza

      Cristy's is Not an entirely Gluten Free Facility. Please specify if an allergy exists and we will do our best to prepare your meal without exposing it to potential allergens.
      $27.54
  • Cauliflower Crust Pizzas

    • Small Cauliflower New York Pepperoni

      Triangle cut slices with pepperoni over provolone & creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce brushed cauliflower dough. “Fuggetaboutit” nobody does it better.
      $22.99
    • Small Cauliflower Islander

      ALOHA! Hickory-smoked ham, pineapple, cinnamon & provolone on cauliflower dough.
      $22.99
    • Small Cauliflower Goliath

      DOUBLE PEPPERONI & EXTRA CHEESE. Two thick layers of provolone layered completely with pepperoni on cauliflower dough.
      $22.99
    • Small Cauliflower Four Cheese

      A gooey combination of four of our favorite cheeses. We've layered the highest quality provolone, mozzarella, cheddar and Parmesan and baked it atop our cauliflower dough to create a cheesy, mouthwatering masterpiece.
      $22.99
  • Original Pizzas

    • New York Pepperoni

      Triangle cut slices with pepperoni over provolone & creamy Parmesan garlic butter sauce brushed dough. “Fuggetaboutit” nobody does it better.
      $12.50
    • The Islander

      ALOHA! Hickory-smoked ham, pineapple, cinnamon & provolone.
      $14.40
    • The Goliath

      DOUBLE PEPPERONI & EXTRA CHEESE. Two thick layers of provolone layered completely with pepperoni.
      $16.90
    • Four Cheese

      A gooey combination of four of our favorite cheeses. We've layered the highest quality provolone, mozzarella, cheddar and Parmesan and baked it atop our fresh dough to create a cheesy, mouthwatering masterpiece.
      $16.90
  • Loaded Pizzas

    • The Italian Pizza

      Sweet & tangy tomato sauce, pepperoni, salami, ham, hot pepper, onion & provolone topped with our Cristy's Italian spice blend.
      $18.40
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Creamy ranch dressing, grilled chicken, bacon, tomato, provolone & cheddar.
      $18.40
    • Veggie

      Tomato, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, green olive, black olive & provolone.
      $18.40
    • Bigg Meat

      The name speaks for itself when you load up with salami, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham, & provolone to keep it all together. Better grab a friend (or five) for this one.
      $18.40
    • Cristy's Classic

      A customer favorite with ham, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, hot pepper & provolone.
      $18.40
  • Oversized Oven-Baked Subs

    • The Italian Sub

      Provolone, salami, ham, pepperoni, hot pepper, onion, lettuce, tomato & side of Italian dressing.
      $12.50
    • Pizza Sub

      Our delicious pepperoni pizza in sandwich form.
      $11.50
    • Ham & Cheese Sub

      An American classic with ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato & side of Italian dressing.
      $11.50
    • Veggie Sub

      Provolone, lettuce, tomato, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, green olive, black olive & side of Italian dressing.
      $11.50
    • Chicken Sub

      Grilled chicken, provolone, lettuce, tomato & choice of Miracle Whip or honey mustard on the side.
      $12.50
    • Meatball Sub

      100% beef meatballs in sweet & tangy tomato sauce covered with provolone.
      $11.50
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch Sub

      Creamy ranch dressing, grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, provolone & cheddar.
      $12.50
  • Housemade Calzones

    • Cristy's Classic

      Provolone, ham, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom & hot pepper. Better use a knife & fork, it gets messy.
      $11.25
    • Veggie

      Tomato, mushroom, onion, green pepper, hot pepper, green olives, black olives, and provolone
      $11.25
    • Bigg Meat

      Believe it or not, we found a way to load it with salami, pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham & provolone.
      $11.25
    • Chicken Bacon Ranch

      Grilled chicken, bacon, tomato, provolone & cheddar with creamy ranch dressing.
      $11.25
    • Create-Your-Own Calzone

      A custom made calzone just for you. Additional Fillings for an additional charge.
      $8.75
    • The Islander

      Provolone, ham and pineapple.
      $9.69
    • Cheese

      A custom made calzone just for you. Start with cheese and all your favorite pizza toppings. Click on the price to get started.
      $8.50
  • Desserts

    • Double Fudge Brownie

      A decadent fudgy brownie loaded with heavenly chocolate chips.
      $2.50
    • Big Brookie

      Our Big 9 Inch Brookie, Baked and Served warm. A perfect blend of Decadent Fudgy Brownie and Chocolate Chip Cookie.
      $12.99
  • Drinks

    • Coca-Cola

      20oz
      $2.90
    • Diet Coke

      20oz
      $2.90
    • Sprite

      20oz
      $2.90
    • Dasani Water

      $2.90
  • Extras

    • Side Yellow Banana Peppers

      Mild banana pepper rings.
      $0.95
    • Parmesan Cheese Pack

      $0.10
    • Red Pepper Seed Pack

      $0.10
    • Side Jalapeño Peppers

      $0.90
  • Sauce

    • Ranch Dressing

      $0.75
    • French Dressing

      $0.75
    • Italian Dressing

      $0.75
    • Lite Italian Dressing

      $0.75
    • Blue Cheese

      $0.75
    • Fat Free Ranch Dressing

      $0.75
    • Honey Mustard

      $0.75
    • Miracle Whip

      $0.50
    • Sweet & Tangy Tomato

      $1.06
    • Hot Sauce

      $0.75
    • BBQ Sauce

      $0.75
    • Creamy Parmesan Garlic Butter

      $1.06

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms