Search
Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream Menu
4.6
(500+ Reviews)
Hard Cones
- Hard Cone SMALL$6.25
- Hard Cone LARGE$7.29
- Empty Cone$0.78
Hard Sundaes
- Hard Sundae SMALL (6 oz.)$7.81
- Hard Sundae MEDIUM (8oz.)$8.59
- Hard Sundae LARGE (12oz.)$9.37
- Hard Sundae XL (16 oz.)$10.42
- Hard Sundae SUPER (32 oz.)$16.40
Sandwiches
- Ice Cream Sandwiches (six pack)$12.50
- Ice Cream Sandwiches (2 six Packs)$20.83
- Chipwiches ( Pack of Six)$12.50
- Chipwiches (2 six packs)$20.83
Banana Boat
- Banana Boat HARD$10.16
- Banana Boat SOFT$9.38
Egg Cream
- Egg Cream SMALL$3.13
- Egg Cream LARGE$4.17
Ice Cream Soda
- Ice Cream Soda SMALL$6.25
- Ice Cream Soda LARGE$7.81
Italian Ice
- Italian Ices KIDS$2.60
- Italian Ices SMALL$3.13
- Italian Ices MEDIUM$4.17
- Italian Ices LARGE$5.21
- Italian Ices PINT$6.25
- Italian Ices QUART$8.33
Novelties
- Any Novelty$4.16
- Coke Bottle
- Coke 6 Pack$8.75
- Water Bottle$1.56
- Cannoli (Box of 5)$15.57
- Coated Cone (1)$4.69
- Coated Cones (3)$12.50
- Mini Sundaes (box of 5)$11.40
- S'Mores Treats (box of 4)$14.53
- S'Mores Treat (1)$3.90
- Tartufos (box of 4)$23.91
- Santa/Snowman (box of 4)$14.53
- Cooler Bag$8.33
- St. Pat's day Leprechaun Sundae/ Shamrock Shake$8.59
- Hearts (Box of 4)$13.52
- Turkey Gobblers (box of 4)$16.61
- Coated Cones (3)$12.50
- Karamel Krisp$4.17
- Open charge
- Valentine Hearts$13.95
- Valentine Hearts$14.55
- Snapple Iced Tea$2.25
- Holiday Novelty (4 Pack)$16.95
Soft Cups
- Soft Cup KIDS$3.90
- Soft Cup SMALL$4.95
- Soft Cup MEDIUM$5.99
- Soft Cup LARGE$7.03
Soft Cones
- Soft Cone SMALL$5.21
- Soft Cone Large$6.25
- Empty Cone$0.78
Soft Sundaes
- Soft Sundae SMALL (6 oz)$6.77
- Soft Sundae MEDIUM (8 oz)$7.55
- Soft Sundae LARGE (12 oz.)$8.85
- Soft Sundae XL (16 oz)$9.90
- Soft Sundae SUPERSIZE (32 oz.)$13.80
Specialty Sundaes
- Specialty Sundae REGULAR. (12oz)$9.63
- Specialty Double (24 oz.)$15.01
Waffle Bowls
- Waffle Bowl Sundae$9.64
- Waffle Bowl EMPTY$2.60
Waffle Cones
- Waffle Cone Sundae$8.59
- Waffle Cone EMPTY$2.60
Hard Sunades
- Hard Sundae XL (16 oz)$10.94
Toppings To Go
- Sprinkles KIDS (4OZ)$1.04
- Sprinkles SMALL (6 OZ,)$1.56
- Sprinkles MEDIUM (8 oz.)$2.08
- Sprinkles LARGE (12 oz.)$3.13
- Sprinkles PINT (16 oz.)$4.17
- Sprinkles QUART (32 oz.)$8.33
- Toppings KIDS (4oz.)$2.08
- Toppings SMALL (6 OZ.)$3.12
- Toppings MEDIUM (8 OZ.)$4.17
- Toppings LARGE (12 oz.)$6.25
- Toppings PINT (16 oz.)$8.33
- Toppings QUART (32 oz.)$16.66
All Items
- Gift card
Extra Toppings
- 1 Extra Topping$1.04
- 2 extra toppings$2.04
- 3 extra toppings$3.12
- Pick Your Topping
- brownies$1.82
- Cookie Dough$1.82
Any Item
- Doggy Delights$2.08
- Delivery Fee
Candys & Cookies
- Blow Pops$0.26
- Candy Bars$1.56
- Cotton Candy$3.65
- Ring Pops$1.04
- Skittles$1.56
- Cookie (1)$1.04
- Cookies (3)$2.60
Cakes
- Custom Cakes$21.82
- Banana Split Cake$37.45
- Blend of the Best$37.45
- Chocolate Overload$37.45
- Chocolate Raspberry Chip$37.45
- Mississippi Mud$37.45
- Oreo$37.45
- Regular Cake$19.74
- Sticky Finger$37.45
- Strawberry Shortcake$37.45
- Bunny Cake$36.40
- Christmas Tree/Santa Cake$46.88
- Heart Cake$25.99
- Pie 9"$24.95
- Valentine Cake$27.95
Pint
- PINT Hard$8.59
- PINT Soft$8.07
- PINT Ices$6.25
Quart
- QUART Hard$14.58
- QUART Soft$11.98
- QUART Ices$8.33
Shakes
- Shake LARGE$9.64
- Shake Small$7.03
- Malted Large$10.67
- Malted Small$8.07
- Long Island Shake Large$9.90
- Long Island Shake Small$7.29
Hard Cups
- Small Hard Cup$5.99
- Medium Hard Cup$6.77
- Large Hard Cup$7.55
Hard Cones
- Small Hard Cone$6.25
- Large Hard Cone$7.29
Waffle
- Waffle Bowl Sundae$9.64
- Waffle Cone Sundae$8.59
Shakes
- Small Shake$7.03
- Large Shake$9.64
To Go
- Pint Hard$8.59
- Quart Hard$14.58
Hard Ice Cream
- Hard Cups$7.55
- Hard Cones$7.29
- Hard Sundae$7.81
Soft Ice Cream
- Soft Cups$7.03
- Soft Cones$6.25
- Soft Sundae$6.77
Novelties
- Chipwiches$12.50
- Coated Cone$4.69
- Karamel Krisp$4.17
- Mini Sundaes$11.40
- S'mores Treats$14.53
- Sandwiches$12.50
- Tartufos$23.91
- Holiday Sundaes$16.61
- Doggie Delights$2.08
Special Sundaes
- Banana Boat$10.16
- Specialty Sundae$9.63
- Waffle Bowl Sundae$9.64
- Waffle Cone Sundae$8.59
Shakes & Malts
- Long Island Shake$9.90
- Shake$9.64
- Egg Cream$3.13
- Ice Cream Soda/Float$6.25
Cakes
- Banana Split Cake$37.45
- Custom Cakes$21.82
- Regular Cake$19.74
- Blend of the Best$37.45
- Chocolate Raspberry Chip$37.45
- Oreo$37.45
- Mississippi Mud$37.45
- Sticky Finger$37.45
- Strawberry Shortcake$37.45
- Holiday Cakes$36.40
To Go
- Quart$14.58
- Pint$8.59
- Topping To Go$1.04
- Sprinkles To Go$1.04
Menu Photos
Menu Photos
Loading...
