Cookies & Cream On Elmwood Menu

4.1

(125+ Reviews)

$$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Cookies Cookies & Cream Hard Ice Cream Flavors Soft Serve Custard 77's Traditional Sundaes Novelties

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Triple Chocolate Chip
  $4.00
- M&M
  $4.00
- Salted Caramel
  $4.00
- Sugar
  $4.00
- Reese’s PB Cup Cookie Sundae
  Vanilla ice-cream, with a Reese's Peanut Butter cookie, topped with peanut butter sauce, Reese’s cups, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- M&M Cookie Sundae
  Cookie Dough ice-cream, with a M&M cookie, topped with hot fudge, rainbow sprinkles, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae
  Vanilla ice-cream, with a chocolate chip cookie, topped with hot fudge, rainbow sprinkles, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- Hot Fudge
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with hot fudge, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $6.75
- Cookie Sandwich
  Your choice of two cookies and ice-cream in-between sandwich style, rolled in sprinkles! [Please include in special instructions if you would like two different flavor cookies]
  $13.50
- Reese's
  Peanut butter cookie with chunks of Reese's cups. Available in 1, 6, or 12 sizes.
  $4.00
Cookies
- Triple Chocolate Chip
  $4.00
- Reese's
  Peanut butter cookie with chunks of Reese's cups. Available in 1, 6, or 12 sizes.
  $4.00
- M&M
  $4.00
- Sugar
  $4.00
- Salted Caramel
  $4.00
- Oreo
  Oreo White Chocolate Chip
  $4.00
- Snickers
  $4.00
- Butterfinger PB Cup
  $4.00
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip
  3-Gluten Free Cookies Included!
  $4.00
Cookies & Cream
Signature Sundae Creations.
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae
  Vanilla ice-cream, with a chocolate chip cookie, topped with hot fudge, rainbow sprinkles, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- Reese’s PB Cup Cookie Sundae
  Vanilla ice-cream, with a Reese's Peanut Butter cookie, topped with peanut butter sauce, Reese’s cups, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- M&M Cookie Sundae
  Cookie Dough ice-cream, with a M&M cookie, topped with hot fudge, rainbow sprinkles, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $10.75
- Warm Brownie Sundae
  Warm brownie, vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, whipped cream, cherry and brownie pieces crumbled on top!
  $10.75
- Create Your Own Cookie Sundae
  Your choice of any cookie, 2 scoops of ice cream, and 2 toppings. Comes with whipped cream and cherry on top!
  $10.75
Hard Ice Cream Flavors
- Black Cherry
  $5.25
- Butter Pecan
  Butter pecan ice cream, available in 1, 2, or 3 scoops.
  $5.25
- Chocolate
  $5.25
- Chocolate Peanut Butter
  $5.25
- Coffee
  $5.25
- Cotton Candy
  $5.25
- Cookies & Cream
  $5.25
- Cookie Dough
  $5.25
- Cupcake
  $5.25
- Mango Sorbet
  *Dairy Free*
  $5.25
- Mint Chocolate Chip
  $5.25
- Moose Tracks
  $5.25
- Nuts About Buckeyes
  $5.25
- Rainbow Sherbet
  $5.25
- Red Raspberry Sorbet
  *Dairy-Free*
  $5.25
- Sea Salt Caramel
  $5.25
- Strawberry
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with strawberry topping, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top
  $5.25
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  $5.25
- Superman
  $5.25
- Vanilla
  $5.25
- Vanilla Frozen Yogurt
  $5.25
- Wild Mountain Blackberry
  $5.25
Soft Serve Custard
- Vanilla
  $4.00
- Chocolate
  $4.00
- Twist
  $4.00
77's
Try one of our 19… 77’s (Blizzards).
- Andes Mint
  Chocolate soft serve blended with hot fudge, and Andes mints!
  $7.00
- Brownie
  Chocolate soft serve blended with hot fudge, and brownie bites!
  $7.00
- Butterfinger
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge, and butterfinger!
  $7.00
- Chocolate Turtle
  Chocolate soft serve blended with caramel and pecans!
  $7.00
- Cookies & Cream
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge, and chocolate chip cookie bites!
  $7.00
- Cookie Dough
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge, cookie dough bites, and rainbow sprinkles!
  $7.00
- Heath Bar
  Vanilla soft serve blended with caramel, and heath bar!
  $7.00
- M&M
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge, and M&Ms!
  $7.00
- Oreo
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge and oreos!
  $7.00
- Reese’s Cups
  Vanilla soft serve mixed with peanut butter sauce, and Reese's cups!
  $7.00
- Reese’s Pieces
  Vanilla soft serve blended with peanut butter sauce, and Reese's pieces!
  $7.00
- S’mores
  Chocolate soft serve blended with hot fudge, graham cracker, and marshmallows!
  $7.00
- Strawberry Cheesecake
  Vanilla soft serve blended with strawberry topping, and cheesecake bites!
  $7.00
- Sugar Cookie
  Vanilla soft serve blended with hot fudge, sugar cookie bites, and rainbow sprinkles!
  $7.00
Traditional Sundaes
- Caramel
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with caramel, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $6.75
- Hot Fudge
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with hot fudge, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $6.75
- Peanut Butter
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with peanut butter sauce, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $6.75
- Strawberry
  Vanilla soft serve, topped with strawberry topping, chopped peanuts, whip cream, and a cherry on top!
  $6.75
Novelties
- Cookie Sandwich
  Your choice of two cookies and ice-cream in-between sandwich style, rolled in sprinkles! [Please include in special instructions if you would like two different flavor cookies]
  $13.50
- Root Beer
  $3.75
- Root Beer Float
  Root Beer and 2 scoops of ice cream topped with whipped cream and cherry!
  $7.85