Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Cookie Plug Menu

646 Massachusetts Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Order Online
Cookies - PhattiesCookie SacksDessert Catering - Bakery CateringCookie CakesCookie and Ice Cream SandwichDranks

  • Cookies - Phatties

    • The Fruity Pebbles Cookie - Bam Bam Cookie

      Fruity Pebbles cookies aren’t just for kids but for all ages. Try our fat stacked Bam Bam cookie cereal recipe. Our cookies are truly unique. They’re part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie. Why have cereal in a bowl if you can have it in a yummy cookie? Our Fruity Pebbles cookies are available at the Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Triple Chunk Chocolate Cookie - Chocolate XTC Cookie

      Our chocolate chunk cookies are perfect for when you want chocolate on top of chocolate. This Triple Chunk Chocolate Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN. Our cookie contains semi-sweet & bittersweet chocolate chips, white chocolate chips & cocoa powder and is part cake, part brownie, and of course part cookie all rolled into one delicious fat stack.
      $5.00

    • The Cookies And Cream Cookie - Cookie Cookie Cream Cookie

      Cookies n cream? Yes, please! Our infamous cookies and cream cookie stacks are thick, fat, and have a unique twist. They’re part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie with white chocolate chips and crushed Oreos! As you can see, Cookie Plug’s cookies and cream recipe is not the norm, but you can find them at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, or any other bakery we have nationwide.
      $5.00

    • The Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie - Crunch Nugget Cookie

      This Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie has crunchy peanut butter, chocolate, and chocolate peanut butter cups. What more could you really want? Two of your favorite desserts together with peanut butter in one thick cookie which is part brownie and part cake! Our chocolate peanut butter cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Smores Cookie - Firecracker Cookie

      Get lit without the campfire with our Firecracker Smores cookie recipe. Ooey gooey marshmallow paired with a graham cracker crunch and rich chocolate chips all packed together in a warm cookie fat stack. Our smores cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie - Nutty OG Cookie

      Think thick, rich chunks of ooey gooey chocolate but with a nutty crunch. The nutty O.G. is another Cookie Plug classic. Perfect for milk and cookies. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick fat warm cookie stack. Our Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Chocolate Chip Cookie - O.G. Cookie

      If you’re wanting a straight classic then the O.G. Chocolate Chip Cookie is for you. Think thick, rich chunks of ooey gooey chocolate. Perfect for milk and cookies. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick, fat warm cookie stack. Our O.G. Chocolate Chip Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie - Pink Elephant Cookie

      Think strawberry cheesecake but in a cookie. You can’t go wrong with our strawberry cheesecake cookies recipe because we offer something new and very yummy that the streets have never seen before. They are part cake, part brownie, and part cookie, all formed into a thick, fat delicious stack. Our Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN. It contains white chocolate chips, strawberry, & cheesecake flavors.
      $5.00

    • The Sugar Cookie - Pixie Junkie Cookies

      Butter, sugar, and loads of sprinkles make for the perfect warm cookie. This is not your grandma’s sugar cookie recipe. Meet Pixie Junkie, a highly addictive sugar cookie that’s available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN. Our cookies are part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie all rolled into one thick fat warm cookie stack.
      $5.00

    • The Purple Velvet Cookie - Purple Haze Cookie

      Feast your eyes on the Purple Haze Cookie – the baddest cookie in town straight outta Cookie Plug's stash. Picture this: a criminal combo of white chocolate chips smuggled into a top-secret white chocolate chip cookie recipe.We're talking about a symphony of luxury, with premium ingredients handpicked for their street cred in the cookie game. Each Purple Haze cookie is a deep and rich ticket to chewy perfection – a soft, melt-in-your-mouth experience that'll have you double-crossing your diet without remorse. Part cake, part brownie, and part cookie. Purple Velvet Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Snickerdoodle Cookie - Snooperdoodle Cookie

      Picture this: a perfectly thick and fat golden-brown canvas, crackling with the dopest cinnamon charm. Each bite, a journey through the mean streets of flavor town, where the snickerdoodle meets its streetwise cousin, the Snooperdoodle. It's a cookie with moxie, pal, and it ain't afraid to show it. Made to be part cake, part brownie, and part cookie. Our snickerdoodle cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Red Velvet Cake Cookie - Good Luv Cookie

      At Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, we're dishing out a red velvet cake cookie that'll make your taste buds sing. Picture this: a cookie so smooth, it's like walking on velvet streets. Good Luv ain't just a cookie; it's a flavor heist, a thick, red velvet stack that’s part cake, part brownie, and of course, part cookie, that'll have you hooked from the first bite. We're talkin' cocoa dreams, buttery schemes – a symphony of indulgence that'll leave you wonderin' if you stumbled into dessert paradise. Good Luv rules the streets at Cookie Plug cookie bakery – where the game's sweet and the cookies are even sweeter.
      $5.00

    • The Secret Stash Cookie - Rotating Secret Cookie Flavor

      Try our hush-hush flavor of the month cookie. Every month, we're cookin' up somethin' that'll blow your taste buds away. From the shadows emerges a cookie so mysterious, even the dough dons a disguise. One month it might be a sultry salted caramel surprise, and the next, a zesty citrus chocolate sensation that'll leave you beggin' for the recipe. Our Secret Stash Cookie is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Keto Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie - Bart Keto Cookie

      Cravin’ Keto Peanut Butter Cookies? Skip the hustle and grab ‘em!” You’re in luck! We took our best chocolate chip cookies mixed in peanut butter, and then made them keto with almond flour. The result was a bomb keto cookie recipe. Find our Keto Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Keto Chocolate Cookie - Black Magic Keto Cookie

      Tired of looking for the perfect chocolate Almond Flour Cookies? You’re in luck! We’ve perfected ours so you don’t have to. We modified our best seller Triple Chocolate XTC Cookie and made it keto. It’s still fat and thick like our original, but it’s made with almond flour. The result was a bomb keto almond flour cookie that we know you’ll enjoy! Our Keto Chocolate Cookie can be found at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie - Calvin Keto Cookie

      Cinnamon-spiced perfection, wrapped in a guilt-free cookie package. It’s like a flavor heist in your mouth, and the only thing missin’ is the guilt. So, slide through, grab a batch, and let your taste buds join the keto revolution. We’re here to keep it real, keep it gangsta, and keep it keto, baby! Our Keto Snickerdoodle Cookie is sold at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

    • The Keto Chocolate Chip Cookie - Kitt Keto Cookie

      Word on the street is we have the best keto chocolate chip cookie recipe. Kitt is not like any other keto cookie recipe that you have had before. It’s thick and fat. Pair our best chocolate chip cookie recipe with some of our other bomb AF keto items that’s available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $5.00

  • Cookie Sacks

    • Plug Poppers Mini Cookies

      Mini Cookies: Don’t let the size fool ya. These little monsters pack a punch of flavor that’ll leave ya beggin’ for more. We’re talkin’ max taste in a mini package. The smallest cookie, the biggest whammy: Poppers prove that dynamite comes in small packages. When you need just a taste of heaven, these small chocolate chips and more cookies are your go-to hit. Find our Plug Poppers Mini Cookies at the Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $12.00

    • Cookie Bump Sack

      Get any 4 cookies at Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, for $20. Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
      $20.00

  • Dessert Catering - Bakery Catering

    • Cookie Half Sack

      Get any 7 cookies at Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, for $30. Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
      $30.00

    • Cookie Fat Sack

      Get any 12 cookies at Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, for $40. Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
      $40.00

    • Cookie Dub Sack

      Get any 20 cookies at Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, for $55.00. Choose any of our 20 cookie types, Fruity Pebbles Cookie (Bam Bam), Cookies and Cream Cookie (Cookie Cookie Cream), Sugar Cookie (Pixie Junkie), Smores Cookie (Firecracker), Strawberry Cheesecake Cookie (Pink Elephant), or any other flavor we’re slangin’!
      $55.00

  • Cookie Cakes

    • Custom Cookie Cakes

      At Cookie Plug, we're slangin' massive cookie cakes that'll make even the toughest of cookies weak at the knees. Available in custom colors and comes with a personalized message for any occasion: Birthday, Graduation, Celebration, Work event and more. Call our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN, to place your order for a custom cookie cake!

  • Cookie and Ice Cream Sandwich

    • Cookie And Ice Cream Sandwich - Iced Up Cookies

      We’re bringin’ you the baddest duo in dessert history – our Cookie and Ice Cream Sandwich! Two slabs of chewy, melt-in-your-mouth cookies, holdin’ together a scoop of creamy, cold-as-ice heaven. It’s a match made in dessert paradise, a symphony of flavor that’ll make your taste buds breakdance. We’re talkin’ cookies that are so fresh, they practically got an alibi. And that ice cream? Creamy, dreamy, and colder than a gangster’s stare. We’ll put ’em together like a criminal mastermind. Our Cookie and Ice Cream Sandwich is available at our Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.

  • Dranks

    • Purple Lemonade - Purple Drank

      Sippin’ Royalty in a Baby Bottle or Double Cup! Cookie Plug is droppin’ the illest concoction on the block: Purple Drank. This ain’t your grandma’s lemonade stand, nah, this is the real deal, the boss of all thirst-quenchers. Picture this: a smooth blend of zesty lemons, with a hit of that royal purple vibe, giving you a taste that’s straight outta the hood. It’s got that sweet kick that’ll make your taste buds do a happy dance, and that swagger that’ll have you sippin’ like a true player. So step up and get your sip on, ’cause Purple Drank ain’t just a drink, it’s a statement. When you roll with our purple lemonade, you roll with the best. Find Purple Drank at Chatham-Arch Indianapolis Cookie Plug - cookie bakery in Indianapolis, IN.
      $4.00

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
Menus may not be up to date.

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2024 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms