Coney Waffle, Ice Cream and Sweet Shop Menu

4.2

(125+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Ice Cream Toppings Drinks Candy/Fudge Baked Goods Vegan

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- MEDIUM CUP
  UP to 3 scoops Medium Cup
  $7.03
- CONEY WAFFLE
  3 Small Scoops Ice Cream or Cannoli Cream
  $7.50
- SMALL CUP
  2 Small Scoops Small Cup
  $5.86
- Plain Waffle Waffle Cone/Bowl
  Plain Waffle Waffle Cone
  $7.97
- * MILKSHAKE
  Hand-spun milkshakes crafted with creamy ice cream, topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, available in over 50 delightful flavors. Small 20oz, Large 32oz
  $7.74
- LARGE / PINT
  3 Large Scoops Pint Cup
  $8.91
- Giant 1/2lb Cookie
  Assorted GIANT 1/2lb cookie
  $6.10
- Ice Cream Cake Slice
  A slice of one of our delicious ice cream cakes. 2 layers of homemade ice cream, a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with icing and toppings!
  $4.69
- Brownies
  Assorted brownie flavors
  $4.92
- Italian Ice
  Italian Ice
  $3.75
Ice Cream
- Brookie Ice Cream Sandwiches
  4-Pack of our BROOKIE Ice Cream Sandwiches - vanilla or chocolate ice cream sandwiched between a fudgey brownie and a chocolate chip cookie!
  $20.63
- Ice Cream Cake Slice
  A slice of one of our delicious ice cream cakes. 2 layers of homemade ice cream, a layer of chocolate cake crunch, decorated with icing and toppings!
  $4.69
- KIDS CUP
  1 Small Scoop Kids Cup
  $3.75
- SMALL CUP
  2 Small Scoops Small Cup
  $5.86
- MEDIUM CUP
  UP to 3 scoops Medium Cup
  $7.03
- Italian Ice
  Italian Ice
  $3.75
- LARGE / PINT
  3 Large Scoops Pint Cup
  $8.91
- BROWNIE WAFFLE
  3 Small Scoops
  $8.21
- CONEY WAFFLE
  3 Small Scoops Ice Cream or Cannoli Cream
  $7.50
- Rainbow Bowl/Cone
  Rainbow Bowl/Cone
  $8.44
- Cereal Sundae
  Cereal Sunday. Choose up to 2 flavors of ice cream.
  $8.44
- * MILKSHAKE
  Hand-spun milkshakes crafted with creamy ice cream, topped with a generous swirl of whipped cream, available in over 50 delightful flavors. Small 20oz, Large 32oz
  $7.74
- Beach Ball Sandwich
  1 Large Scoop Ice Cream
  $6.10
- CONEY FREEZE
  Made with Soft Serve Ice Cream (Vanilla, Chocolate, or Twist) and up to 3 Toppings
  $8.44
- Float (Soda)
  Float
  $7.74
- Plain Waffle Waffle Cone/Bowl
  Plain Waffle Waffle Cone
  $7.97
- QUART
  4 Large Scoops Quart Cup
  $12.19
- Sprinkle Dipped Bowl/Cone
  Sprinkle Dipped Bowl/Cone
  $8.44
- Ice Cream Filled Cannoli (Two)
  Two Cannoli Filled with Vanilla Soft Serve Ice Cream
  $8.62
- Ice Cream Sandwiches
  6-Pack of Ice Cream Sandwiches with a choice of Vanilla Chocolate Chip or Vanilla Oreo ice cream sandwiches!
  $14.07
Toppings
- Kit Kat on a Stick
  For that little something special, the perfect "Topper" Decorated with Drizzled Chocolate, Sprinkles and Candy Glitter
  $2.50
Drinks
- Hot Chocolate
  Rich and creamy. Available in Large (16oz) or Small sizes.
  $3.28
- Drinks
  Stewarts Fountain Classics
  $2.81
Candy/Fudge
- 12oz Taffy Tub 3/4lb
  Coney Waffle 3/4 Pound of Taffy
  $8.91
- Cotton Candy Large
  Coney Cotton Candy
  $7.03
- Cotton Candy Small
  Coney Cotton Candy
  $5.16
- Ring Pop
  A jewel-shaped hard candy on a plastic ring, offered in a strawberry flavor.
  $1.17
Baked Goods
- Brownies
  Assorted brownie flavors
  $4.92
- Fresh Filled Cannoli (Two)
  Crispy Cannoli Shell filled with Cannoli Cream Made to Order (two)
  $8.62
- Giant 1/2lb Cookie
  Assorted GIANT 1/2lb cookie
  $6.10
Vegan
- Vegan
  A robust selection of plant-based frozen deserts, crafted with non-dairy ingredients, offering a flavorful experience that celebrates the richness of NON-DAIRY treats.
  $4.69