Please order at least 48 hours ahead(no same-day or next day). Tart and tangy key lime pie in our graham cracker crust and topped with fresh whipped cream! (gluten-free)
$37.70
10" French Silk Pie
Please Order At Least 48 hours in Advance. (No Same-day or Next Day). Chocolate mousse pie with a gluten-free Oreo butter crust.
$37.70
10" Tart Cherry
Tart Montmorency cherries in our signature all-butter crust.
$32.50
10" Apple Bourbon Caramel
Brown sugar apples topped with bourbon caramel oat topping.
$32.50
10" Classic Apple
Granny Smith Apples, cinnamon, and nutmeg in our signature all-butter crust.
$32.50
10" Mixed Berry
Strawberry, Blackberry, Blueberry, and Raspberry all packed together in our classic all-butter crust.
$32.50
Gluten-Free 10" Tart Cherry
Our same Montomercy tart cherry filling in a homemade gluten-free crust! Note: all pies are baked in the same facility as items with regular flour. Not recommended for those with severe allergies.
$35.10
Take & Bake 10" Apple Bourbon Caramel
Frozen take-n-bake. Brown sugar apples topped with bourbon caramel oat topping. Takes about an hour and a half to bake from frozen.
$32.50
Take & Bake 10" Classic Apple
Frozen take-n-bake. Granny Smith Apples, cinnamon, and nutmeg in our signature all-butter crust. Takes about an hour and a half to bake from frozen.
$32.50
Take & Bake 10" Gluten-Free Tart Cherry
Frozen take-n-bake. Our same Montomercy tart cherry filling in a homemade gluten-free crust! Takes about one and a half hours to bake from frozen.\r\nNote: all pies are baked in the same facility as items with regular flour. Not recommended for those with severe allergies.
$35.10
Take & Bake 10" Mixed Berry
Frozen take-n-bake. Strawberry, Blackberry, Blueberry, and Raspberry all packed together in our classic all-butter crust. Takes about an hour and a half to bake from frozen.
$32.50
Take & Bake 10" Tart Cherry
Frozen take-n-bake. Tart Montmorency cherries in our signature all-butter crust. Takes about an hour to bake from frozen.
$32.50
Take & Bake 10" Wild Blueberry
Frozen take-n-bake. Wild Maine blueberries in our classic all-butter crust. Takes about an hour to bake from frozen.
$32.50
Mini Sweet Pies
Mini Key Lime
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings. Tart and tangy key lime pie in our graham cracker crust and topped with fresh whipped cream! (gluten-free)
$16.90
Mini Tart Cherry
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings. Tart Montomercy cherry filling in our signature all-butter crust.
$14.30
Mini Apple Bourbon Caramel
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings of brown sugar apples topped with bourbon caramel oat topping.
$14.30
Mini Classic Apple
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 Servings. Granny Smith Apples, cinnamon, and nutmeg in our signature all-butter crust.
$14.30
Mini Mixed Berry
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 Servings. Strawberry, Blackberry, Blueberry, and Raspberry all packed together in our classic all-butter crust.
$14.30
Mini French Silk
Perfect for sharing! 2-3 Servings. Chocolate mousse pie in a homemade oreo cookie crumble crust and topped with fresh whipped cream. (gluten-free)
$16.90
Take & Bake Mini Apple Bourbon Caramel
Frozen take-n-bake. Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings of brown sugar apples topped with bourbon caramel oat topping. Takes about one hour to bake from frozen.
$14.30
Take & Bake Mini Classic Apple
Frozen take-n-bake. Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings. Granny smith apples with cinnamon and nutmeg in our signature all-butter crust.
$14.30
Take & Bake Mini Mixed Berry
Frozen take-n-bake. Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings. Strawberry, raspberry, blackberry, and blueberry all packed into our signature all-butter crust.
$14.30
Take & Bake Mini Tart Cherry
Frozen take-n-bake. Perfect for sharing! 2-3 servings. Tart Montomercy cherry filling in our signature all-butter crust. Takes about one hour to bake from frozen.
$14.30
Sweet Hand Pies
Cherry Hand Pie
Tart Montomercy cherry filling wrapped in our signature all-butter crust. Perfect for pie on the go!
$6.83
Mixed Berry Hand Pie
Strawberry, raspberry, blackberry, and blueberry filling all wrapped in our signature all-butter crust with an icing drizzle. Perfect for pie on the go!
$6.83
Classic Apple Hand Pie
Classic Granny Smith cinnamon apple filling wrapped in our signature all-butter crust. Perfect for pie on the go!
$6.83
Mini Pot Pies
Mini Chicken Hot And Ready
Classic, old-fashioned chicken pot pie. Shredded chicken, peas, carrots, and onions in a cream sauce.
$15.60
Take & Bake Mini Chicken
Frozen take-n-bake chicken pot pie. Shredded chicken, peas, carrots, and onions in a homemade cream sauce. Takes about one hour to bake from frozen.
$15.60
Mini Bison Hot And Ready
Ground bison with potatoes, mushrooms, and onions, all in a stout gravy.
$15.60
Take & Bake Mini Bison
Frozen take-n-bake. Ground bison with potatoes, mushrooms, and onions, all in a stout gravy. Takes about one hour to bake from frozen.
$15.60
Mini Mushroom Veggie Hot And Ready
Loaded with mushrooms, potatoes, peas, carrots, and onions in a cream sauce.
$15.60
Take & Bake Mini Mushroom Veggie
Frozen take-n-bake. Loaded with mushrooms, potatoes, peas, carrots, and onions in a cream sauce. Takes about one hour to bake from frozen.
$15.60
Lunch Hand Pies
Pork Green Chile Hand Pie
Hot and Ready Only. Post Oak shredded Pork in a homemade green chile and white cheddar sauce.
$9.75
Veggie Curry Hand Pie
Hot and Ready Only. Chickpeas, potatoes, carrots, peas, and onions in a coconut curry sauce. (vegetarian)
$9.75
Buffalo Chicken Hand Pie
Hot and Ready Only. Shredded chicken with buffalo hot sauce, cream cheese, and green onions. Like a hot wing in a pie crust!
$9.75
Customize Your Pie!
Pie Phrases
10" Pies Only, Must Have 24 Hours Notice. Please Call the Store to Personalize.
$28.00
Handwritten Note
Have the team attach a short handwritten letter to your loved one! Max three sentences.
$1.50
Wrap The Box In Ribbon
Have ribbon or twine tied around the box as a gift!
$3.00
Eiskaffee Vanilla Ice Cream Pint
Pint of vanilla ice cream from Eiskaffee! Perfect pairing for pie!