Cockeye Creamery Menu

Caramel Hot Chocolate: freshly steamed milk meets premium Ghiradelli chocolate and caramel for a fusion of rich and sweet delight.

Vanilla Hot Chocolate: freshly steamed milk, rich Ghiradelli premium chocolate syrup, and a splash of vanilla for an aromatic twist on traditional hot chocolate.

Oat milk, real rolled oats, raisins

Oat milk, strawberry purée, bananas

Chocolate ice cream, brownies, candy-coated mini chocolate chips.

Black cherry ice cream with real halved Bing cherries

Real blackberries, chocolate chunks. Your wife will love this one.

Real blueberries in a cheesecake ice cream.

Hillson buttered pecans in smooth nutty base.

Cockeye Creamery’s signature chef-inspired flavor; made with fresh-baked buttermilk pies from Cockeye BBQ’s kitchen.

Chocolate super-premium ice cream with salted pecan halves

Cookie dough ice cream with Oreos and chocolate chip cookie dough.

Cranberry super-premium ice cream w/ real cranberries

Cockeye Creamery's take on traditional, American chocolate ice cream.

Egg, premium vanilla bean.

Strawberry puree and hunks of fresh strawberry.

Green apple ice cream w/ real apples and a caramel swirl

Real Ohio wildflower honey (Kline Honey, Rootstown, OH), vanilla, and lavender

Bright, house-made lemon bar filling, luscious black raspberry pureé, and a crunchy cinnamon streusel baked in-house to golden perfection. Cockeye Cares Pint Program: 100% of pint sales proceeds to benefit Trumbull County Historical Society

Banana ice cream with graham crackers and mini buckeyes.

Creme de menthe, chocolate chunks.

Velvety cheesecake ice cream with halved maraschino cherries, graham crumb, and real cheesecake pieces

milk, cream, sugar, brown sugar, molasses, real rolled oats and raisins

Creamy Reese’s peanut butter, marshmallow, graham cracker, chocolate chunks.

Beautifully green pistachio ice cream with salty Hillson pistachios.

Chocolate, pistachio, and black cherry super-premium ice cream

Our take on the Russian classic: sweet cream vanilla ice cream w/ real strawberries

White chocolate ice cream w/ red raspberry swirls + dark chocolate raspberry truffles

Our French vanilla bean ice cream with maraschino cherries throughout.

Coffee ice cream made with fresh ground Youngstown Coffee Co. espresso beans, chocolate chunks, and brownies.

Our made-to-order ice cream sandwich with fresh-baked (and then frozen) chocolate chip cookies. Just choose your flavor!

Our Buttermilk Pie ice cream inside a graham cracker pie crust!

A cute little koozie that fits Cockeye Creamery pints. You'll wish you had this when you're eating a pint on your couch!

Rep your favorite ice cream brand. Sticks to anything!

Rep your favorite ice cream brand. Sticks to anything!

Rep your favorite ice cream brand. Sticks to anything!

A cute cooler bag sized to fit up to two pints or four bowls! Perfect for getting our super-premium ice cream back home after a long drive!

Just tell us what size and color at the register