City Island Diner Menu

Breaded cutlet, Mozzarella, marinated tomatoes, and onions.

Spicy breaded chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomatoes, and Bleu cheese.

Chicken, roasted peppers, Mozzarella, and pesto.

Pico de gallo and slaw.

White tuna, sliced egg, lettuce, and tomatoes.

Classic with house-made croutons.

Traditional on rye.

Authentic with our special touches.

Turkey, stuffing, and cranberry.

With lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and tartar.

2 pancakes.

2 pancakes.

Bacon, Swiss, tomatoes, and sliced egg.

Roast beef, turkey, ham, cheese, and sliced egg.

Tossed with olives, tomatoes, and red onions.

Traditional with house-made croutons.

Breaded eggplant, salami, ham, Mozzarella, and roast pepper.

Traditional.

Breaded chicken, bacon, tomatoes, shredded Cheddar, and housemade ranch.

Walnuts, red beets, warm Goat cheese, and red onion.

Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.

Roast beef with sauteed onions, Mozzarella, and brown gravy on garlic bread. Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.

Served with French fries or mashed potatoes.

Served with French fries and mashed potatoes.

Your choice of 3 Ingredients. Your choice of 3 Ingredients. Served with coleslaw and fries.

Swiss cheese, sauteed mushrooms, and onions. Served with coleslaw and fries.

American cheese, bacon, and sauteed onions. Served with coleslaw and fries.

Served with choice of coleslaw or macaroni salad.

2 sabrettes dogs with bacon, onions, Cheddar, and fries.

Ham, tomatoes, onions, and Cheddar on Italian rustica.

Please call the restaurant to ask about daily options.

Turkey, red peppers, and Mozzarella. Served with home fries and toast.

Choose up to 3 items from our selection of cheeses, meats, and veggies. Served with home fries and toast.

Spinach, bacon, and Ricotta. Served with home fries and toast.

With salad. Served with home fries and toast.

Spinach, Feta, and tomato. Served with home fries and toast.

Ham, peppers, and onions. Served with home fries and toast.

Bacon, onion, peppers, and cheese. Served with home fries and toast.

Tomato, basil, and Ricotta. Served with home fries and toast.

Sausage, onion, and American cheese. Served with home fries and toast.

Ham, tomato, and Mozzarella. Served with home fries and toast.

Pastrami, onion, and Swiss. Served with home fries and toast.

Mushroom, onion, and tomato. Served with home fries and toast.

Pepper Jack cheese and salsa. Served with home fries and toast.

Homemade chili, Cheddar, and sour cream. Served with home fries and toast.

Everything but the kitchen sink. Served with home fries and toast.

Served with salad.

Served with a choice of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or French fries.

Pint.

Pint.

With homemade apple chutney.

With beer cheese.

With homemade ranch.

Served with your choice of wing sauce.

Choice of beef and Cheddar, chicken chipotle, or black bean and Goat cheese.

With homemade salsa.

With house-made ranch.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with home fries and toast.

Served with soup or salad.

With mashed potato and veggies. Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

With all the trimmings. Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Like grandma made! Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Served with soup or salad.

Toasted. Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.

Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.

Toasted. Subject to availability. Call the restaurant for daily selection.

Toasted.

Served with mashed potatoes.

Stuffing, cranberry, and mashed potatoes.

Served with mashed potatoes.