City Cakes Menu

$$Bakery
155 W 18th St, New York, NY 10011
  • 7" TAKEAWAY CAKES

    • 7" Whiskey Pecan Takeaway Cake

      Our top selling caramel pound cake with whiskey pecan pie filling, covered in cream cheese buttercream.
      $65.00
    • 7" Nutella Cookies And Dream Takeaway Cake

      Oreo cookie-packed Vanilla Bean Cake with a hidden layer of Oreo-filled Nutella filling, covered in Vanilla Bean Buttercream with a swirl of Nutella on top and crushed Oreo crumb details. Available only for our summer months and meant to stay chilled until consumption. 7" Takeaway Cake serves 12-15 people, and you can order a printed sugar disc message on top for an additional charge.
      $65.00
    • 7" Exquisite Carrot Takeaway Cake

      Our gluten free carrot cake features a naked design with a delicate layer of sweetened cream cheese between spiced carrot pecan layers. Covered with cream cheese buttercream, and a butterscotch drizzle topped with crushed pecans. 7" Takeaway Cake serves 12-15 people, and you can order a printed sugar disc message on top for an additional charge.
      $65.00
    • 7" Chocolate Decadence Takeaway Cake

      Our stunning gluten free chocolate decadence cake is filled with delicious chocolate buttercream and covered in vanilla buttercream. It features an elegant chocolate drip design and topped with dark chocolate curls. 7" Takeaway Cake serves 12-15 people, and you can order a printed sugar disc message on top for an additional charge.
      $65.00
    • 7" Vanilla Funfetti Takeaway Cake

      This sprinkle-filled vanilla bean cake is covered in sprinkle-filled vanilla bean buttercream and topped with rainbow sprinkles. 7" Takeaway Cake serves 12-15 people, and you can order a printed sugar disc message on top for an additional charge.
      $65.00
    • 7" Sultry Red Velvet Takeaway Cake

      Our sultry red velvet cake is filled with sweetened cream cheese and features our unique striped design, topped with our red velvet cookie crumbs. 7" Takeaway Cake serves 12-15 people, and you can order a printed sugar disc message on top for an additional charge.
      $65.00
  • CAKES BY THE SLICE

    • Whiskey Pecan Cake Nice Slice

      Our top selling caramel pound cake with whiskey pecan pie filling, covered in cream cheese buttercream and caramel buttercream decorations
      $9.00
    • Nutella Cookies And Dream Slice

      A slice of our Oreo cookie packed Vanilla Bean Cake with a hidden layer of Oreo-filled Nutella filling, covered in Vanilla Bean Buttercream with a swirl of Nutella on top and crushed Oreo crumb details.
      $9.00
    • Exquisite Carrot Cake Nice Slice

      Our gluten free carrot cake features a naked design with a delicate layer of sweetened cream cheese between spiced carrot pecan layers. Covered with cream cheese buttercream, and a butterscotch drizzle topped with crushed pecans. (Pecan glass currently unavailable)
      $9.00
    • Chocolate Decadence Cake Nice Slice

      Our stunning gluten free chocolate decadence cake is filled with delicious chocolate buttercream and covered in vanilla buttercream. It features an elegant chocolate drip design and topped with dark chocolate curls.
      $9.00
    • Vanilla Bean Funfetti Cake Nice Slice

      This sprinkle-filled vanilla bean cake is covered in sprinkle-filled vanilla bean buttercream and topped with rainbow sprinkles.
      $9.00
    • Sultry Red Velvet Cake Nice Slice

      Our sultry red velvet cake is filled with sweetened cream cheese and features our unique striped design, topped with our red velvet cookie crumbs.
      $9.00
  • CUPCAKE MULTI PACKS

    • Choose-Your-Own Assorted Cupcakes, 2pk

      Choose up to 2 delicious flavors
    • Choose-Your-Own Assorted Cupcakes, 6pk

      Choose up to 6 delicious flavors
  • COOKIE MULTI PACKS

    • Choose-Your-Own Assorted Half Pound Cookies, 4pk

      Choose up to 4 delicious flavors
    • Choose-Your-Own Assorted Half Pound Cookies, 8pk

      Choose up to 8 delicious flavors
  • INDIVIDUAL & FROSTED COOKIES

    • Frost & Sprink Half Pound Cookie

      A City Cakes' original! Choose your cookie, then your frosting and sprinkles.
    • Stuffed Pink Velvet Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked gluten free sweet white cocoa cookie filled with sweetened cream cheese. (*GFI - gluten free ingredients)
      $6.50
    • Milk Chocolate Macamochip Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked gluten free milk chocolate chip cookie macadamia nut cookie with brown rice crispies and filled with a layer of Nutella. (*GFI - gluten free ingredients)
      $6.50
    • Rich Chocolate Chip Half Pound Cookie

      Our soft baked chocolate chip cookie features a buttery savory dough sprinkled with bittersweet dark chocolate chips.
      $6.00
    • Reeses Peanut Butter Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked peanut butter cookie loaded with reese's pieces.
      $6.00
    • Dark Horse Salted Double Chocolate Chip Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked onyx cocoa cookie filled with semi sweet chocolate chunks!
      $6.00
    • Signature Sugardoodle Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked buttery sugar cookie, rolled in coarse sugar and cinnamon!
      $6.00
    • Sultry Red Velvet Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked Valrhona cocoa cookie filled with sweetened cream cheese, rolled in coarse red sugar.
      $6.00
    • Hearty Oatmeal Raisin Half Pound Cookie

      A soft baked old fashioned oatmeal cookie with dark and golden raisins and subtle hints of spices
      $6.00
    • Ginger Spice Half Pound Cookie

      $6.00
  • TRIPLE STACKED COOKIE CAKE

    • Triple-Layer Stacked Cookie Cake

      Choose 3 of our famous Half Pound Cookies, and pick a frosting and sprinkle selection. We stack them and put frosting in between each layer, also on top and add your sprinkle choice, too! No custom messaging on the cake is possible. Perfect for 4-8 people!
  • BARS

    • Yogurt Berry Oat Bar

      Vegan oat bar with a mixed berry center and coconut topped with a oat milk yogurt drizzle.
      $5.50
    • Brownie Nouveau

      Rich brownie made with bittersweet chocolate, covered in semi-sweet chocolate chips.
      $5.50
  • WHOLE PIES

    • Salted Caramel Apple Nice Slice Pie - Whole

      Savory green apple Nice Slice with layers of salted caramel under a delicious flaky crust. Inspired by our fall special Caramel Apple Pie cupcake, but meant for sharing.
      $40.00
  • PIES BY THE SLICE

    • PIE Dark Horse Salted Double Chocolate Nice Slice Pie

      The silent winner, this Nice Slice pie is one of the most remarkable of them all. Inspired by our Dark Horse bestselling cookie, this features a custard-like black chocolate center, topped with chocolate ganache, in our house Oreo Graham crust and dusted with black Mediterranean salt. Store chilled, but insane chilled or room temp.
      $6.50
    • PIE Salted Caramel Apple Pie Nice Slice

      Savory green apple Nice Slice with layers of salted caramel under a delicious flaky crust. Inspired by our fall special Caramel Apple Pie cupcake, but meant for sharing.
      $6.50

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2024 Checkle, Inc