Cinnaholic Menu

33 New St, Metuchen, NJ 08840
  • Seasonal Items

    • Signature Gift Box

      Two customized cinnamon rolls with your choice of one frosting and one topping each, two chocolate covered strawberries, two mini cookies and two brownie bites.
      $34.27
    • Chocolate Covered Strawberries

      Fresh strawberries hand dipped in dark chocolate. Half or full dozen.
    • Chocolate Covered Strawberry Rolls

      Half dozen or full dozen of our classic old skool rolls (vanilla frosting), each topped with a chocolate covered strawberry, chocolate sauce and powdered sugar. Please allow 2 hrs advance notice
    • Cupid's Crush Strawberry Variety

      Fresh strawberries hand-dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in a variety of toppings. Includes chocolate chips, ‘oreos’, homemade pie crumble and sprinkles. please allow 2 hours advance notice.
    • Custom Dipped Strawberries

      Fresh strawberries hand-dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in your choice of topping. please allow 2 hours advance notice.
    • Nuts For You

      Fresh strawberries hand-dipped in dark chocolate and rolled in a variety of nut toppings. Includes almonds, coconut, pecans, and walnuts. Please allow 2 hours advance notice.
    • Cookie Butter Roll

      Cookie Butter frosting topped with cookie butter cookie crumble, sprinkles, and powdered sugar.
      $9.20
    • Coffee Cake Roll

      For our true Cinnaholics, we offer a cinnamon sugar covered roll layered with cinnamon frosting, cinnadoodle bites, streusel topping, homemade cinnamon drizzle, and a dusting of cinnamon sugar.
      $10.47
    • Banana Pancakes Roll

      Pancake frosting topped with banana bread bites, fresh banana slices, blueberries, maple syrup, and a dusting of powdered sugar.
      $10.79
  • Local Rolls

    • Can't Keep My Eyes Off Of You

      Frankie Valli said it best with cake batter frosting, cookie dough, Oreo cookies, and chocolate sauce
      $10.16
    • Burnin’ Up Roll

      As the Jonas Brothers said it, "Cause I'm burnin' up, burnin' up, for you, baby." This cinnamon roll features caramel frosting, marshmallows, popcorn, and sprinkles.
      $9.52
    • Higher Love Roll

      Whitney Houston's cover will have you seeking "Higher Love." Enjoy this cinnamon with strawberry frosting, fresh strawberries, bananas and sprinkles.
      $9.84
    • Glory Days Roll

      Bruce Springsteen's classic anthem starts with "Glory Days." Banana frosting, banana bread bites, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce.
      $9.52
    • Welcome To The Black Parade

      My Chemical Romance topped the charts with this favorite, "Welcome to the Black Parade." Chocolate frosting brownie bites, chocolate chips, and chocolate sauce.
      $10.16
    • New York, New York Roll

      Frank Sinatra said it best on this side of the Hudson. Enjoy this cinnamon roll with cream cheese frosting, blueberries, graham cookies, and powdered sugar.
      $9.20
    • Sunday’s Sundae

      Why pick one? This Sunday's Sundae features it ALL. Base includes a classic cinnamon roll with chocolate frosting and fudge style brownie bites. Now add the full scoop of chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla frosting, chocolate sauce, and rainbow sprinkles.
      $13.97
    • Cinna-Smackdown

      Why have one...classic cinnamon roll with caramel frosting and apples, add a full scoop of cinnadoodle cookie dough, vanilla frosting and caramel drizzle
      $12.70
    • Wanted Dead Or Alive Roll

      Central New Jersey's very own, Bon Jovi hit it big with Wanted: Dead or Alive. Caramel frosting with homemade peanut butter cups, pretzels, and chocolate sauce
      $10.16
  • Signature Rolls

    • Old Skool Roll

      Fresh baked cinnamon roll with vanilla frosting.
      $7.62
    • Build Your Own Cinnamon Roll

      Customize your cinnamon roll with choice of frosting and topping(s).
      $7.62
    • Apple Pecan Pie Roll

      Caramel frosting topped with fresh apples, pecans, and our homemade pie crumble.
      $10.47
    • Cookie Monster Roll

      Cream cheese frosting topped with homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce.
      $9.84
    • Tropical Bliss Roll

      Raspberry frosting topped with fresh bananas, blueberries and coconut.
      $9.84
    • Sparkle Berry Roll

      Chocolate frosting topped with sprinkles and fresh strawberries (sprinkle colors may vary).
      $9.20
    • Blueberry Pie Roll

      Cream cheese frosting topped with homemade pie crumble and fresh blueberries.
      $9.20
    • Raspberry Dream Roll

      Chocolate frosting topped with almonds and fresh raspberries.
      $9.20
    • Plain Roll

      For the purists who want to skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness.
      $6.66
    • Strawberries & Cream Roll

      Cream cheese frosting topped with fresh strawberries and walnuts.
      $9.20
    • Shake, Rattle & Roll

      Peanut butter frosting, topped with homemade peanut butter cups, fresh bananas and pretzels.
      $9.84
    • Very Berry Roll

      Cake batter frosting topped with fresh strawberries, blueberries, raspberry jam and powdered sugar.
      $9.52
    • Campfire S’mores Roll

      Marshmallow frosting topped with marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce.
      $9.84
    • Caramel Apple Pie Roll

      Caramel frosting topped with fresh apples, pecans, homemade pie crumble and caramel sauce.
      $10.47
  • Cookie Dough

    • Cookie Dough Tub

      8 oz or 16 oz container of our homemade chocolate chip cookie dough\n240 Cal - 480 Cal
    • Build Your Own - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with one frosting and one topping of your choice.
      $5.06
    • S'mores - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of marshmallow frosting, marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce.
      $5.06
    • PB&J - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of peanut butter frosting and a drizzle of strawberry jam.
      $5.06
    • Cookies & Cream - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cream cheese frosting and "oreo" cookie morsels.
      $5.06
    • Mocha Madness - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of coffee frosting, chocolate sauce and a sprinkling of coffee dust.
      $5.06
    • Salted Elvis - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of peanut butter frosting, pretzel sticks and a slice of banana.
      $5.06
    • Strawberries & Cream - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cream cheese frosting and fresh strawberries.
      $5.06
    • Confetti - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of cake batter frosting and sprinkles (Sprinkle colors may vary).
      $5.06
    • German Chocolate - Cookie Dough Scoop

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with a dollop of chocolate frosting, a brownie bite morsel, pecans and coconut.
      $5.06
    • Birthday Cake 8oz Cookie Dough

      $8.89
    • Chocolate Peppermint 8oz Cookie Dough

      $8.89
    • Gooey Graham Bliss 8oz Cookie Dough

      $8.89
    • Sweet & Salty Swirl 8oz Cookie Dough

      $8.89
    • Cookie Explosion 8oz Cookie Dough

      $8.89
    • Build Your Own Cookie Dough Scoop (New Flavors)

      Our homemade cookie dough topped with one frosting and one topping of your choice.
      $5.70
  • More to Love

    • Brownies

      Homemade fudge style brownie. customize with frostings and toppings!
      $4.76
    • Baby Buns

      Bite size rolls with your choice of one frosting flavor on the side. Does not include toppings. Serving size is 1 baby bun, 3 servings per package.
      $7.62
    • Side Of Topping

      An extra side of topping.
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies

      Homemade chocolate chip cookie. Customize with frostings and toppings!
      $3.81
    • Cinnadoodle Cookies

      Homemade cinnadoodle cookie (think Snickerdoodle). Customize with frostings and toppings!
      $3.81
    • Chocolate Chip Banana Bread

      Fresh baked chocolate chip banana bread with our homemade brown sugar and cinnamon mix baked in.
      $4.76
    • Build Your Own - Not A Roll

      Our gluten friendly alternative! Your choice of apple or banana topped with your choice of frosting and toppings (* items with an asterisk after them contain gluten).
      $3.17
    • Side Of Frosting

      An extra side of frosting, choose your flavor!
    • Build Your Own Cinnastack

      When 2 become 1! choose a frosting and topping for the cinnamon roll then a frosting and topping of choice for the full-sized cookie dough scoop on top.
      $12.06
  • By the Dozen

    • Baby Buns By The Dozen

      Bite size rolls by the dozen! Price includes your choice of one frosting per dozen, and a pinch of one topping on each roll. Advanced notice may be required.\n\n240 Cal
      $30.48
    • Brownie Bites By The Dozen

      Bite size morsels of our homemade fudge style brownies.
      $20.32
    • Baker’s Box

      Having a hard time deciding? Let us customize a cinnamon roll box for you! Baker's box includes a variety of frostings and toppings. Choose from half or full dozen. Please specify if there are nut allergies.
    • Old Skool Rolls By The Dozen

      Half or full dozen of our classic old skool rolls (vanilla frosting). Does not include toppings.
    • Mini Cookies By The Dozen

      Choose from chocolate chip or cinnadoodle (think snickerdoodle).
      $20.32
    • Plain Rolls By The Dozen (No Frosting)

      Skip the frosting and toppings and simply enjoy the cinnamon roll goodness, plain cinnamon rolls by the dozen. - Serving size one roll.
    • Cookie Monster Roll By The Dozen

      *Customer favorite* Cream cheese frosting topped with homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, chocolate chips and chocolate sauce by the dozen. - Serving size one roll.
    • Very Berry Roll By The Dozen

      Cake batter frosting topped with fresh strawberries, blueberries, raspberry jam and powdered sugar by the dozen.
    • Campfire S’mores Rolls By The Dozen

      Marshmallow frosting topped with marshmallows, graham cookies and chocolate sauce by the dozen. - Serving size one roll.
    • Strawberries & Cream Rolls By The Dozen

      Cream cheese frosting topped with fresh strawberries and walnuts by the dozen. - Serving size one roll.
    • Baby Buns By The Dozen Variety Pack

      Bite size rolls by the dozen! Price includes your choice of one frosting per dozen. Each rolls has one different toppings on each roll. Advanced notice may be required.
      $30.48
    • Signature Rolls Box

      A half dozen (6) box of rolls. Includes Old Skool, Cookie Monster, Caramel Apple Pie, Very Berry, Shake Rattle & Roll, and Campfire S'mores.
      $53.34
  • Beverages

    • Coke

      $5.08
    • Dasani

      $2.54
    • Hot Coffee

      Freshly brewed Gregory's Coffee.
    • Iced Coffee

      Freshly brewed and locally sourced coffee served over ice with an option to add a flavor shot.
      $4.44
    • Hot Chocolate

      Warm up with a cup of rich handcrafted hot chocolate.
      $4.44
    • Hot Tea

      $3.17
    • Mini Milk

      Plant-based, lactose-free and available in vanilla or chocolate flavors.
      $3.17
    • Boylan Creme Soda

      $4.44
    • Boylan Creamy Red Birch Beer

      $4.44
    • Boylan Black Cherry

      $4.44
    • Boylan Ginger Ale

      $4.44
    • Apple Juice

      Apple & Eve Apple Juice
      $3.81
    • Hot Coffee

      Freshly brewed and locally sourced coffee.
      $3.81
  • More to Love

    • Dancing In The Dark

      Fresh baked brownie topped with vanilla frosting, chocolate chips, sprinkles, and chocolate sauce
      $6.66
    • Cinnamon Coffee Cake

      $5.71

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms