Cheaters Creamery Menu

4.5

(225+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Ice Cream Milkshakes Homemade Cookies & Brownies Floats Waffle Cones Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Hand Packed Pint (BEST VALUE)
  Your favorite ice cream flavor hand packed for the party or the couch! The pint is the best and most affordable way to celebrate cheat day at home. Use a metal spoon for the best experience. New Flavors Every Month! (Toppings served on side)
  $12.99
- Regular - 2 Scoops
  2 Scoops of Homemade Ice Cream Worth the Calories New Flavors Every Month!
  $7.99
- Small - 1 Scoop
  1 Scoop of Homemade Ice Cream Worth the Calories New Flavors Every Month!
  $5.49
- Create your own Milkshake
  Create the perfect Milkshake by blending up to 2 flavors and 2 toppings together. WARNING : Milkshakes may not arrive to you in the state that it left our doors. The thick and cold milkshake may melt during transit and factors out of our control may increase delivery time. Visit us in store for the best milkshake experience!
  $9.99
- Root Beer Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of A&W Root Beer (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
- Orange Creamsicle Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of Orange Fanta Soda (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
- Coke Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of Coca Cola (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
- Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  Decadent chocolate brownie with rich fudge
  $3.69
Ice Cream
Classic Ice Cream Worth the Calories
- Hand Packed Pint (BEST VALUE)
  Your favorite ice cream flavor hand packed for the party or the couch! The pint is the best and most affordable way to celebrate cheat day at home. Use a metal spoon for the best experience. New Flavors Every Month! (Toppings served on side)
  $12.99
- Small - 1 Scoop
  1 Scoop of Homemade Ice Cream Worth the Calories New Flavors Every Month!
  $5.49
- Regular - 2 Scoops
  2 Scoops of Homemade Ice Cream Worth the Calories New Flavors Every Month!
  $7.99
Milkshakes
Thick shakes made from your choice of flavors + toppings
- Create your own Milkshake
  Create the perfect Milkshake by blending up to 2 flavors and 2 toppings together. WARNING : Milkshakes may not arrive to you in the state that it left our doors. The thick and cold milkshake may melt during transit and factors out of our control may increase delivery time. Visit us in store for the best milkshake experience!
  $9.99
Homemade Cookies & Brownies
Homemade. Delicious. Sensational.
- Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  Decadent chocolate brownie with rich fudge
  $3.69
Floats
Pick 2 scoops of ice cream and a soda of your choice
- Coke Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of Coca Cola (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
- Root Beer Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of A&W Root Beer (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
- Orange Creamsicle Float
  2 Scoops of Sweet Cream Ice Cream served with 12oz of Orange Fanta Soda (Soda served on side to prevent ice cream from melting)
  $9.59
Waffle Cones
Homemade Waffle Cones made from scratch
- Plain Waffle Cone
  Fresh waffle cones
  $1.99
Beverages
- Coca Cola (12oz Can)
  12oz Can of Coca Cola
  $2.99
- A&W Root Beer (12oz Can)
  12oz Can of A&W Root Beer Soda
  $2.99
- Orange Fanta (12oz Can)
  12oz Can of Orange Fanta
  $2.99