Casey's Ice Cream & Candies Menu

4.7

(475+ Reviews)

$Ice cream shop

Customer Favorites Chocolate Ice Cream

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Meadville Mud
  Double Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of our Homemade Chocolate Fudge and Fudge Sauce
- Dizzy Lizzy
  Yellow Cake Batter Ice Cream with Rainbow
- Cookie Monster
  Blue Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Sugar Cookies, Oreos, & Cookie Dough
- Cookie Dough
  Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of Our Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
- Mint Chip
  Creme de Menthe Ice Cream Loaded with Chocolate Pieces
- Nerd Heaven
  Blue Moon Ice Cream with Sour Candy Nerds
- Oreo
  Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Oreo Pieces
- White Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  White Chocolate Ice Cream with a Homemade Brownie Pieces & Fudge Topping
- Frog
  Chocolate Ice Cream Packed with Fresh Roasted Pecans Halves & Caramel
- Cinnamon Bun
  Caramel Ice Cream with Chunks of Cinnamon Rolls, and Cinnamon Topping
Chocolate
- 8 oz. Peanut Butter Meltaway Box
  Melt in your mouth peanut butter enrobed in milk chocolate
  $15.75
- 8 oz. Frog Bag
  Casey’s caramel, fresh pecans, and our special blend of creamy milk chocolate
  $14.50
- 8 oz. Mini Pretzel Bag
  Salty Pretzel twists coasted in Casey's milk chocolate blend
  $14.50
- 8 oz. Awful Waffle Bag
  Casey's homemade waffle cones dipped into our signature milk chocolate
  $14.50
Ice Cream
- Strawberry
  Strawberry Ice Cream with Strawberry Puree
- Cookie Dough
  Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of Our Homemade Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
- Really, Really, Raspberry
  Raspberry Ice Cream Made with Raspberry Puree
- Chocolate
  Chocolate Ice Cream Made with Our Homemade Chocolate Syrup
- Meadville Mud
  Double Dutch Chocolate Ice Cream Loaded with Chunks of our Homemade Chocolate Fudge and Fudge Sauce
- Vanilla
  Vanilla Ice Cream
- Squirrel Treats
  Vanilla Ice Cream Packed with Fresh Roasted Deluxe Mixed Nuts
- Butter Pecan
  Butter Pecan Ice Cream loaded with freshly roasted pecan halves.
- Chocolate Almond
  Chocolate Ice Cream with Almonds
- Coconut
  Coconut Ice Cream with Angel Flake Coconut & Chocolate Pieces
- Cotton Candy
  Sweet and nostalgic Cotton Candy Ice Cream
- Nerd Heaven
  Blue Moon Ice Cream with Sour Candy Nerds
- Elephant Tracks
  Malted Vanilla Ice Cream with Chunks of Casey's Homemade Peanut Butter Fudge
- Raspberry Cheesecake
  Made with Generous Amounts of Pure Cream Cheese & Swirled with Raspberry Puree
- Vanilla Peanut Butter
  Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Fresh Creamy Jiff Peanut Butter
- White House
  Vanilla Ice Cream with Maraschino Cherry Halves
- Dizzy Lizzy
  Yellow Cake Batter Ice Cream with Rainbow
- Frog
  Chocolate Ice Cream Packed with Fresh Roasted Pecans Halves & Caramel
- Chocolate Peanut Butter
  Chocolate Ice Cream Swirled with Fresh Creamy Jiff Peanut Butter
- Mint Chip
  Creme de Menthe Ice Cream Loaded with Chocolate Pieces
- Cinnamon Bun
  Caramel Ice Cream with Chunks of Cinnamon Rolls, and Cinnamon Topping
- Blueberry
  Blueberry Flavored Ice Cream Loaded with Real Blueberries
- Conneaut Lake Crunch
  Vanilla Ice Cream Packed with Fresh Roasted Cashews & Caramel
- Fluff N Stuff
  Peanut Butter Ice Cream with Marshmallow Fluff and Chunks of Peanut Butter Cookies
- Snickers
  Vanilla Ice C ream with Snicker's Candy Bars Pieces
- Maple Walnut
  Maple Walnut Flavored Ice Cream Loaded with English Walnuts
- Awful Waffle
  Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Our Homemade Chocolate Covered Waffle Cones and Caramel
- French Vanilla
  Vanilla Ice Cream made with Egg Custard
- Oreo
  Creamy Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Oreo Pieces
- Toffee
  Toffee Flavored Ice Cream with Toffee Pieces
- White Chocolate Fudge Brownie
  White Chocolate Ice Cream with a Homemade Brownie Pieces & Fudge Topping
- Pistachio
  Pistachio Ice Cream Loaded with Whole Roasted Pistachios
- Rocky Road
  Chocolate Ice Cream with English Walnuts and Marshmallows
- Cookie Monster
  Blue Vanilla Ice Cream Loaded with Sugar Cookies, Oreos, & Cookie Dough
- Coffee & Cream
  Coffee Ice Cream swirled with Sweet Cream Ice Cream