Checkle Logo
Checkle
Search
For Businesses

Cary Dairy Ice Cream Cafe Menu

4.7
(375+ Reviews)
$$Ice cream shop, Bakery, Coffee shop
Order Online
Call
(847) 829-4623
Order Online

  • CUSTOM CAKE ORDER

    Order a custom ice cream cake for your event, here! Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom cake orders (Please Note: Any cake orders for Saturday/Sunday pick-up must be placed by 12pm the Thursday before.) If you'd like writing on your cake, type your custom message in Special Instructions Section. All custom cake order sales are final* Stock cakes always available in-store.

    • Custom 8" Cake

      Serves 10-14. Two layers of rich cake, with a thick layer of super-premium ice cream in the middle! Handmade at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom cake orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**
      $46.95
      Custom 8" Cake

    • Custom BabyCake

      Serves 2-3. Layer of rich cake on the bottom, topped with a thick layer of super-premium ice cream. Handmade at Cary Dairy! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom cake orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL REQUESTS section* **All custom cake order sales are final.**
      $13.95
      Custom BabyCake

  • CUSTOM ICE CREAM PIE ORDER

    Serves 7-9. Handmade with a graham cracker crust at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom orders. Please Note: Any pie orders for pick-up Saturday or Sunday must be placed by 12pm the Thursday before.* Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**

    • Ice Cream Pie

      Serves 7-9. Handmade with a graham cracker crust at Cary Dairy with Super-Premium Ice Cream from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company! *Please allow 24-48 hours for all custom orders. Any custom messages, please add in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. If you see/would like a flavor we currently offer on our flavors page, please include in SPECIAL INSTRUCTIONS section. * **All custom cake order sales are final.**
      $25.95

  • SOFT SERVE

    Premium chocolate and vanilla soft serve!

    • Vanilla Soft Serve

      Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
      $4.25
      Vanilla Soft Serve

    • Chocolate Soft Serve

      Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
      $4.25
      Chocolate Soft Serve

    • Vanilla/Chocolate Twist

      Enjoy a cone or dish of our premium, super-creamy soft serve! (Gluten-Free)
      $4.25
      Vanilla/Chocolate Twist

    • Mint Soft Serve

      $4.25

    • Dairy-Free Chocolate Soft Serve

      Oat-Milk based chocolate soft serve! Dairy-free, Vegan, Gluten-Free, Peanut/TreeNut-Free (*Cary Dairy is not a peanut/tree-nut free facility), and Cholesterol-Free!
      $5.00

  • DOLE WHIP

    Refreshingly delicious, enjoy this fruit-flavored soft serve sorbet! (Gluten-Friendly, Vegan & Fat-Free)

    • Dole Whip

      Refreshingly delicious, enjoy this fruit-flavored soft serve sorbet! (Gluten-Friendly, Vegan & Fat-Free)
      $5.50
      Dole Whip

  • FLOATS

    • ROOT BEER FLOAT

      A classic! Vanilla ice cream served float-style with Root Beer.
      $6.50
      ROOT BEER FLOAT

    • DOLE WHIP FLOAT

      Deliciously refreshing Pineapple Dole Whip®, served float-style in pineapple juice! Add Boba Bubbles for extra bursts of flavor!
      $6.50
      DOLE WHIP FLOAT

    • SUNSET FLOAT

      Tropical bliss! Pineapple Dole Whip® served float-style with bursts of Strawberry, Watermelon & Coconut flavors!
      $6.50

    • SODA FLOAT

      Premium vanilla soft serve ice cream, served float-style over your choice of soda!
      $6.50
      SODA FLOAT

    • COFFEE FLOAT

      Two scoops of your favorite ice cream, served float-style in our Cary Dairy Blend Coffee, from Conscious Cup® Coffee Roasters!
      $6.75

    • HOT CHOCOLATE FLOAT

      Two scoops of your favorite ice cream, served float-style in premium hot cocoa, topped with homemade whipped cream!
      $6.50

  • SUNDAES

    Boat Sundaes now available!

    • ICE CREAM SUNDAE

      Classic sundae with your choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, topped with syrup of choice & homemade whipped cream!
      $6.95

    • SOFT SERVE SUNDAE

      $6.95

    • BROWNIE SUNDAE

      Warm gooey brownies, topped with your choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, choice of toppings, homemade whipped cream & a cherry!
      $6.95

    • TURTLE SUNDAE

      Classic turtle sundae with choice of up to (2) flavors of ice cream, hot fudge, pecans, caramel syrup, and topped with homemade whipped cream & a cherry!
      $8.25

    • LUCKY DAY SUNDAE

      PREMIUM mint SOFT SERVE, served with lucky charms® cereal & topped with creamy marshmallow topping & gold star sprinkles!
      $6.75
      LUCKY DAY SUNDAE

  • MILKSHAKES

    • VANILLA SHAKE

      Classic milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream.
      $6.75

    • CHOCOLATE SHAKE

      Classic chocolate milkshake made with premium chocolate ice cream.
      $6.75

    • STRAWBERRY SHAKE

      Classic strawberry milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, blended with sliced strawberry topping.
      $7.75

    • FLAVORED SHAKE

      Classic milkshake made with your choice of premium soft serve ice cream, with added flavor bursts to make any flavor shake you can imagine!
      $6.95

    • HAND-SCOOPED SHAKE

      Classic milkshake made with your choice of up to (3) flavors of premium hand-scooped ice cream.
      $6.75

    • DAIRY-FREE CHOCOLATE SHAKE

      Dairy-free shake made with our oat-based chocolate soft serve, blended with oat milk! (No Whipped Cream)
      $7.75

    • MINT OREO CHIP SHAKE *MARCH SPECIAL*

      Premium Mint Soft Serve blended with Oreo® crumbles, and topped with homemade whipped cream, chocolate syrup, chocolate chips & gold star sprinkles!
      $6.95
      MINT OREO CHIP SHAKE *MARCH SPECIAL*

  • MALTS

    • VANILLA MALT

      Classic malt milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, topped with homemade whipped cream.
      $6.95

    • CHOCOLATE MALT

      Classic malt milkshake made with premium chocolate ice cream, topped with homemade whipped cream.
      $6.95

    • STRAWBERRY MALT

      Classic strawberry malt milkshake made with premium vanilla ice cream, blended with sliced strawberry topping.
      $7.95

    • FLAVORED MALT

      Classic malt milkshake made with your choice of premium soft serve ice cream, with added flavor bursts to make any flavor shake you can imagine!
      $7.25

    • HAND-SCOOPED MALT

      Classic malt milkshake made with your choice of up to (3) flavors of premium hand-scooped ice cream.
      $6.95

    • DAIRY-FREE VANILLA MALT

      Dairy-free malt made with our oat-based chocolate soft serve, blended with oat milk! (No Whipped Cream)
      $7.75

  • SLUSHEE/SNOW-DAYS

    • SLUSHEE

      Enjoy this refreshing treat with 1 or 2 of your favorite flavors!
      $3.95

    • SNOW-DAY

      Your favorite flavor of slushee, blended with premium vanilla soft serve!
      $4.50

  • SCOOPS

    • Double Scoop

      Double scoop of flavor(s) of your choice! Up to 2 flavors. (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
      $5.95
      Double Scoop

    • Single Scoop

      Single scoop of one flavor of your choice! (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
      $4.50
      Single Scoop

    • Triple Scoop

      Triple scoop of flavor(s) of your choice! Up to 3 flavors. (Flavor descriptions available at CaryDairy.com, GF & DF options available)
      $6.75
      Triple Scoop

  • & MORE!

    • Classic Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

      Creamy Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream between two chocolate chip cookies, rolled in colorful sprinkles.
      $6.25
      Classic Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich

    • Pup Cup

      A little something for our four-legged friends! Vanilla soft serve, garnished with a milkbone for the most spoiled canines.
      $1.25

    • Cat Cup

      A treat for our purrfect four-legged friends! Homemade whipped cream with cat treats sprinkled on top.
      $0.95

  • BAKED GOODS

    • Gourmet Brownie

      Delicious gourmet brownies, loaded with extra candies and goodies. Prepared in-house!
      $3.75
      Gourmet Brownie

    • Cake Pop

      Classic cake pop! Rich yellow or chocolate cake dipped in decadent white or milk chocolate. Made specially in-house at Cary Dairy!
      $3.50
      Cake Pop

    • Gluten-Free Oatmeal Creme Pie Sandwich

      Gluten- and Dairy-Free. A delicious oatmeal cookie sandwich filled with cream cheese frosting from Rosie's Gluten Free Sweets.
      $5.25
      Gluten-Free Oatmeal Creme Pie Sandwich

    • Gluten-Free Brownie

      Gluten- and Dairy-Free, this dense, rich chocolate brownie is sure to satisfy any craving! Add a pint of Old Fashioned Vanilla ice cream (GF) to create your own gluten-free sundae! (Rosie's Gluten Free Sweets) *Contains Coconut Milk*
      $10.25
      Gluten-Free Brownie

    • Gluten-Free Brookie Bar

      Brownie on bottom, chocolate chip cookie on top! This treat is dairy-free, gluten-free, and vegan. Baked fresh from Rosie's Gluten-Free Sweets.
      $10.25
      Gluten-Free Brookie Bar

  • PINTS TO GO

    To be shared with a few friends, or enjoyed by yourself! Super-premium ice cream flavors from Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Co.

    • Pint To-Go

      Super-premium ice cream to be shared with a few friends, or enjoyed by yourself!
      $7.25
      Pint To-Go

  • QUARTS TO GO

    Super-premium ice cream to be shared with a few friends, or enjoyed by yourself!

    • Quart To Go

      Super-premium ice cream to be shared with a few friends, or enjoyed by yourself!
      $14.50

  • HOT DRINKS

    • COFFEE

      Enjoy a cup of Conscious Cup's special Cary Dairy Blend regular coffee served in a compostable cup!
      $2.95
      COFFEE

    • HOT CHOCOLATE

      Enjoy a cup of delicious, premium hot cocoa, served in a compostable cup! Try it topped with our homemade whipped cream. 12oz and 16oz available.
      $2.95

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Buena Vista Restaurant Mar Y Tierra
Buena Vista Restaurant Mar Y Tierra
4.3
(157 Reviews)
Mexican, Restaurant, Seafood
The Texan Barbecue
The Texan Barbecue
4.4
(1,043 Reviews)
Barbecue, Restaurant
Sushi King
Sushi King
4.0
(148 Reviews)
Japanese, Sushi
Odeo Café
Odeo Café
4.9
(228 Reviews)
Patisserie, Coffee shop
Jimmy John's
Jimmy John's
2.9
(135 Reviews)
Sandwich shop
EGM
EGM
5.0
(1 Reviews)
Cafe
Restaurante
Restaurante
3.1
(519 Reviews)
Bar
Port Edward Restaurant
Port Edward Restaurant
4.2
(2,047 Reviews)
Seafood
McDonald's
McDonald's
3.5
(1,126 Reviews)
Breakfast, Coffee shop, Hamburger
Thai Pot
Thai Pot
4.7
(43 Reviews)
Thai
https://www.carydairy.com/
(847) 829-4623

395 Cary Algonquin Rd Unit E, Cary, IL 60013

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms