Search
Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.- Hot Fudge SundaeClassic vanilla soft serve sundae topped with delicious hot fudge, whipped cream and a cherry.$7.45
- Flying SaucerCreamy fresh soft serve ice cream, served between two flying saucer crackers.$15.99
- Square Ice Cream Celebration CakesLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$25.99
- Hot Caramel SundaeClassic vanilla soft serve sundae topped with rich hot caramel, whipped cream and a cherry.$7.45
- Classic Soft Serve Ice Cream$6.45
- Thick ShakesMilk and Ice cream blended$7.65
- Sundae DasherPremium ice cream layered with toppings, sauces, and whipped cream.$8.45
- Classic Scooped Ice Cream$6.45
- CarvelancheIce cream and topping blended into messy sweetness$8.45
- Deluxe Flying SaucersSix pack. Creamy fresh soft serve ice cream rolled in sprinkles, served between two flying saucer crackers.$16.99
Limited Time Offer
- Peppermint Hot ChocolateScooped peppermint hot chocolate ice cream made with chocolate drops and peppermint pieces$6.00
Ice Cream Celebration Cakes
When ordering please write down what you would like it to say and in pink or blue.- Fudgie the WhaleLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$44.99
- Sheet Ice Cream Celebration CakeLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$48.99
- Round Ice Cream Celebration CakeLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$36.99
- Square Ice Cream Celebration CakesLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$25.99
Sundae Dasher
- Sundae DasherPremium ice cream layered with toppings, sauces, and whipped cream.$8.45
Classic Sundae
- Hot Fudge SundaeClassic vanilla soft serve sundae topped with delicious hot fudge, whipped cream and a cherry.$7.45
- Hot Caramel SundaeClassic vanilla soft serve sundae topped with rich hot caramel, whipped cream and a cherry.$7.45
- Strawberry SundaeStrawberry Shortcake with every spoonful with layers of vanilla, strawberries, pound cake, whipped cream and strawberry drizzle.$7.45
Signature Cakes
- Fudgie the Whale CakeLayers of freshly made premium vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of our famous chocolate crunchies.$44.99
- Cookie Puss CakeThis frozen friend turns any party into a celebration with layers of freshly made vanilla and chocolate ice cream, separated by a layer of chocolate crunchies and topped with a scoop of chocolate ice cream in a sugar cone, two chocolate chip cookies, and milk fudge.$40.99
Carvel Classic Ice Cream
- Classic Scooped Ice Cream$6.45
- Classic Soft Serve Ice Cream$6.45
Novelties
- Deluxe Flying SaucersSix pack. Creamy fresh soft serve ice cream rolled in sprinkles, served between two flying saucer crackers.$16.99
- Flying SaucerCreamy fresh soft serve ice cream, served between two flying saucer crackers.$15.99
- ChipstersSix pack. Creamy fresh soft serve ice cream served between two chocolate chip cookies.$16.99
- Sprinkle CupsSix pack of cups, Your choice of flavor with sprinkles and a maraschino cherry$16.99
- Ice Cream QuartChoice of your favorite flavor of ice cream.$18.00
- Ice Cream Pint$6.50
- BonnetVanilla or Chocolate ice cream Coated in delicious magic shell or rolled in sprinkles$5.00
- Old Fashion SundaeClassic cup of Ice cream and syrup and a cherry$5.00
Shakes, Carvelanches and Beverages
- Thick ShakesMilk and Ice cream blended$7.65
- CarvelancheIce cream and topping blended into messy sweetness$8.45
Side Cup of Toppings (3 Oz)
3 Oz Cup of topping- Chocolate Crunchies$4.49
- Rainbow Sprinkles$3.49
- Mini M&M's$4.49
- Reese's Pieces$4.49
- Numbered CandlesChoose as many as needed between one and nine.$4.00
- 24 Pack Candles$3.00
People Also Viewed
https://locations.carvel.com/ny/sayville/25-montauk-highway?utm_source=google&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=locations_partner
+1 631-563-8103