Caroline’s Cookies Menu

Our Easter Bunny cake is back! This fun cake comes in our four staple flavors and features a set color scheme and design with our vanilla buttercream. No modifications. It’s about the same size as seven of our regular cookies, making it perfect for sharing at your Easter gatherings. Celebrate Easter with our delicious Easter Bunny cake!

This cookie cake comes in all 4 of our staple flavors and is completely customizable! We offer this sized cake circle and square! It feeds about 10-15 people and is equal to 11 of our regular-sized cookies.

This cookie cake comes in all 4 of our staple flavors and is completely customizable! It feeds about 14-25 people and is equal to 14 of our regular sized cookies.

This cookie cake comes in all 4 of our staple flavors and is completely customizable! It feeds about 22-40 people and is equal to 22 of our regular sized cookies.

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It comes with the set disco theme as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set football theme as shown in the picture! You can customize it with your team colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors always fully iced in our vanilla buttercream frosting. You can choose the background color below as well as customize the writing (number or name) and other design features below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors always fully iced in our vanilla buttercream frosting. You can choose the background color below as well as customize the writing (number or name) and other design features below! The candles will be decorated according to the colors you choose below. Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is a great alternative design to celebrate a birthday! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the number and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is a great alternative design to celebrate a birthday! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the number and colors below! The hearts are optional and we have other mini background design options below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake design is a great option for baptisms, confirmations, and baby showers! You can customize the writing and colors of this cake below! This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors always fully iced in our white vanilla buttercream frosting. The cross is optional, see below.Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below! This design is great for short phrases such as "You're Old," "Get Well," and "Thank You." You can request sprinkles below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border, font, and style as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake design is so elegant and fun! We only offer this theme for our 8x8 heart-shaped cookie cakes. This size feeds 10-15 people. All vintage cakes are fully iced with our vanilla Buttercream frosting. You can customize the writing and colors below! Cherries and edible glitter are optional.

This cookie cake is the perfect addition to all sports-related events and parties! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! Pick your team and team colors below. Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is a classic way to celebrate a birthday! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is the perfect addition to any tailgate or watch party! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! Pick your team and team colors below.Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is a fun way to celebrate a birthday! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake is a fun way to celebrate a birthday! It comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the writing and colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border writing, font, and cap, as shown in the picture! You can customize the colors below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

Cheers! This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the colors below! The hearts are optional and we have other mini background design options below!Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

Cheers! This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors! It will be decorated with the set border design and font as shown in the picture! You can customize the colors below! Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

We are excited to introduce this new and fun cake theme! Our cookie cakes are available in a variety of sizes and flavors. You can customize the colors below and choose to add glitter or sprinkles. Each cookie cake in this theme is fully iced with our delicious vanilla buttercream frosting, complete with the pre-set design and writing!

This cookie cake design is a great option for baptisms, confirmations, and baby showers! You can customize the writing and colors of this cake below! This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors always fully iced in our white vanilla buttercream frosting. The cross is optional, see below.Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

NEW CAKE DESIGN! What's better than disco?? This cookie cake design is so elegant and fun! We only offer this theme for our 8x8 heart-shaped cookie cakes. This size feeds 10-15 people. All vintage cakes are fully iced with our vanilla Buttercream frosting. You can customize the writing and colors below! Bows and discos are optional.

Our take on a classic cookie cake! This cookie cake comes in a variety of sizes, shapes, and flavors. You can customize the colors and writing (number or name) below! Small 8x8: feeds 7-12 people Medium 9x9: feeds 10-15 peopleLarge 12x9: feeds 14-25 peopleExtra Large: feeds 22-40 people

Our Easter Bunny cake is back! This fun cake comes in our four staple flavors and features a set color scheme and design with our vanilla buttercream. No modifications. It’s about the same size as seven of our regular cookies, making it perfect for sharing at your Easter gatherings. Celebrate Easter with our delicious Easter Bunny cake!

This cookie features frosted animal crackers, golden Oreos, rainbow sprinkles, and white chocolate chips. Our staple cookies are sold in increments of 12  cookies. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 12 cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 24  cookies, and so on. Enjoy!

Our classic dough with white chocolate chips, semi-sweet chocolate chips, and Oreos! Our staple cookies are sold in increments of 12 cookies. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 12 cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 24  cookies, and so on. Enjoy!

A sugar cookie with sprinkles mixed throughout! Customize sprinkle colors below. Our staple cookies are sold in increments of 12 cookies. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 12 cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 24  cookies, and so on. Enjoy!

Our classic go-to cookie but bite-sized (1 oz)! All mini cookies are sold in increments of 10 mini cookies per order. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 mini  cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 20 mini cookies, and so on. Please note that we have a $30 minimum for all catering orders.

This cookie contains frosted animal crackers, golden Oreos, rainbow sprinkles, and white chocolate chips! Each mini cookie is 1 oz. All mini cookies are sold in increments of 10 mini cookies per order. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 mini  cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 20 mini cookies, and so on. Please note that we have a $30 minimum for all catering orders.

This cookie features our classic dough with white chocolate chips, semi-sweet chocolate chips, and Oreos. Each mini cookie is 1 oz. All mini cookies are sold in increments of 10 mini cookies per order. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 mini  cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 20 mini cookies, and so on. Please note that we have a $30 minimum for all catering orders.

Our mini cookie bags are the perfect party favors! You can choose up to two flavors for each bag. This item is sold in increments of 10 bags. When you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 bags (20 mini cookies), and ordering 2 quantities will give you 20 bags (40 mini cookies), and so on. Enjoy!

Our mini cookie bags are the perfect party favors! You can choose up to three flavors for each bag. This item is sold in increments of 10 bags. When you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 bags (30 mini cookies), and ordering 2 quantities will give you 20 bags (60 mini cookies), and so on. Enjoy!

Our mini cookie bags are the perfect party favors! You can choose up to four flavors for each bag. This item is sold in increments of 10 bags. When you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 bags (40 mini cookies), and ordering 2 quantities will give you 20 bags (80 mini cookies), and so on. Enjoy!

A sugar cookie with sprinkles mixed throughout, but mini (1 oz)! All mini cookies are sold in increments of 10 mini cookies per order. So, when you order 1 quantity, you’ll receive 10 mini cookies, and 2 quantities will give you 20 mini cookies, and so on. Please note that we have a $30 minimum for all catering orders.