Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu

3.9

(250+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Fun Foods Hot Pocket Wedges Traditional Pizzas Specialty Pizzas Calzones and Strombolis Pasta Dinners Sicilian Pizza Focaccia Sandwiches Oven Baked Hoagies Gyros and Wraps Fresh Salads Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- X-large - 12 Cut
  X-Large 12-cut pizza with choice of red or white sauce.
  $14.99
- Large - 10 Cut
  Large 10-cut pizza. Choice of red or white sauce.
  $12.99
- Medium - 8 Cut
  $11.25
- Philly Steak
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Provolone Wedges
  Golden, crispy breaded wedges filled with melted provolone cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce.
  $7.99
- Steak
  Steak filled stromboli or calzone, option for either style.
  $11.99
- Italian
  all hoagies come with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and dressing.
  $14.99
- Meaty Wings
  Chicken wings, available in half or whole dozen. Choices of Buffalo, garlic butter, BBQ, season salt, or garlic parm sauce.
  $8.99
- Small - 4 Cut
  4-cut traditional pizza. Choice of red or white sauce.
  $7.99
- 2-Liter
  $3.99
Fun Foods
- Meaty Wings
  Chicken wings, available in half or whole dozen. Choices of Buffalo, garlic butter, BBQ, season salt, or garlic parm sauce.
  $8.99
- Breadsticks
  Breadsticks brushed with garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, typically served with marinara sauce for dipping.
  $4.99
- Cheezy Garlic Toast
  Garlic toast generously topped with a blend of melted cheeses, typically accompanied by hints of garlic and herbs.
  $1.99
- Garlic Toast
  Garlic-infused bread, toasted to perfection.
  $1.49
- 12-Inch Pepperoni or Jalapeño Rolls
  $10.99
- Provolone Wedges
  Golden, crispy breaded wedges filled with melted provolone cheese, served with a side of marinara sauce.
  $7.99
- Fried Mushrooms
  Crispy Golden-Battered Mushrooms
  $7.99
- Single Cuts Pizza
  Individually sliced pizza, typically featuring a classic blend of cheese and tomato sauce, with options for additional toppings.
  $2.25
- Jalapeño Poppers
  Spicy peppers stuffed with cream cheese, breaded and fried
  $7.99
- Chicken Tenders and Fries
  Crispy Chicken Strips & Golden Fries Combo
  $11.99
- Loaf Garlic Bread
  A loaf of bread generously coated with a blend of minced garlic and butter, then toasted until golden.
  $3.99
Hot Pocket Wedges
All pocket sandwiches made with homemade dough. Served with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo, homemade Italian dressing. Add the works which is sautéed onions, mushrooms, hot peppers, and green onions for an additional charge.
- Pepperoni
  $14.99
- Steak
  Filled with tender steak slices, melted cheese, and savory seasonings, enveloped in a golden-brown, crispy crust.
  $14.99
- Turkey
  Slices of turkey paired with American cheese, complemented by crisp lettuce, fresh tomato, and a spread of mayo, all encased in a warm pocket wedge.
  $14.99
- Ham
  Slices of ham paired with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, typically includes a blend of cheeses.
  $14.99
- Tuna
  Tuna encased in a warm pocket wedge, typically includes a blend of cheese and a mix of vegetables like lettuce and tomato.
  $14.99
- Italian
  Ham, salami, provolone, capicola, and pepperoni, typically includes lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, and vinegar.
  $14.99
- Veggie
  Stuffed with a medley of vegetables including broccoli, mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions, complemented by a blend of American and Provolone cheese, encased in a crispy pocket wedge.
  $14.99
- Grilled Chicken
  12'' hoagie
  $14.99
- Philly Steak
  Tender steak slices with melted cheese, topped with fresh lettuce, tomato, and onion slices.
  $14.99
- Club
  Ham, turkey, bacon, and cheese, typically accompanied by lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, enclosed in a hot pocket wedge.
  $14.99
Traditional Pizzas
Red or white original homemade pizza sauce 100% fat-free. Toppings: pepperoni, sausage, ham, mush, onions, bacon bits, black olives, anchovies, jalapeño peppers, green & hot peppers, tomato. Extra cheese is double topping.
- Small - 4 Cut
  4-cut traditional pizza. Choice of red or white sauce.
  $7.99
- Medium - 8 Cut
  $11.25
- Large - 10 Cut
  Large 10-cut pizza. Choice of red or white sauce.
  $12.99
- X-large - 12 Cut
  X-Large 12-cut pizza with choice of red or white sauce.
  $14.99
Specialty Pizzas
Original or white.
- Spinach & Tomato
  Spinach & tomato pizza with options for original or white sauce. Size choices range from small (4-cut) to x-large (12-cut).
  $9.99
- Steak & Mushroom
  Steak & Mushroom Pizza: Topped with succulent steak pieces, fresh mushrooms. Sizes range from small to x-large. Choose between original or white base.
  $9.99
- Ricotta & Tomato
  Ricotta & Tomato Pizza: Creamy ricotta, ripe tomatoes. Options: 4, 8, 10, 12 cuts; Original or White base.
  $9.99
- Hawaiian
  Hawaiian pizza: Ham, pineapple, mozzarella. Sizes range from small to x-large. Choose original or white sauce base.
  $9.99
- Veggie
  Veggie Pizza: Mix of seasonal vegetables, available in sizes from small (4 cut) to x-large (12 cut), original or white base.
  $9.99
- Cheeseburger & Bacon
  Specialty Pizza: Cheeseburger & bacon toppings. Sizes: small (4 cut), medium (8 cut), large (10 cut), x-large (12 cut). Prep: original or white base.
  $9.99
- Philly Steak
  Philly Steak Pizza: Thinly sliced steak, mozzarella, with options for original or white base. Sizes range from small (4 cut) to x-large (12 cut).
  $9.99
- Spinach & Ricotta
  Spinach & Ricotta Pizza: Creamy ricotta, fresh spinach. Options: 4, 8, 10, or 12 slices; Original or White base.
  $9.99
- Barbecue Chicken & Bacon
  Barbecue chicken & bacon on dough, sizes from small (4 cut) to x-large (12 cut). Option for original or white base.
  $9.99
- Buffalo Chicken Ranch
  Buffalo chicken, drizzled ranch over choice of original or white base. Sizes: small to x-large.
  $9.99
- Greek
  Greek pizza available in small (4 cut), medium (8 cut), large (10 cut), x-large (12 cut) sizes. Choose from original or white preparation.
  $9.99
- All Meat Deluxe
  Heaped with various meats on a choice of original or white base. Sizes from small (4) to X-large (12 cuts).
  $9.99
- Pierogi
  Pierogi pizza with options of original or white base. Sizes: small to x-large.
  $9.99
- Chicken Parmesan
  Breaded chicken, marinara, melted mozzarella on a hand-tossed crust. Sizes: 4, 8, 10, 12 cut. Original or white base option.
  $9.99
Calzones and Strombolis
Calzones include ricotta cheese. Add works for an additional charge.
- House (Pepperoni and Sausage)
  Stuffed with pepperoni and sausage, choice of stromboli or calzone.
  $11.99
- Mushroom and Cheese
  Mushroom and cheese blend, choice of calzone or stromboli.
  $11.99
- Veggie Combination
  Stuffed with mushrooms, spinach, bell peppers, onions, mozzarella, and marinara. Choose between stromboli or calzone style.
  $11.99
- Cheese
  12'' hoagie
  $11.99
- Steak
  Steak filled stromboli or calzone, option for either style.
  $11.99
- Meatball
  12'' hoagie
  $11.99
- Italian
  Calzone filled with traditional Italian cheeses and meats. Option for stromboli rendition.
  $11.99
- Pepperoni
  $11.99
- Spinach
  Spinach filled, choice between stromboli or calzone.
  $11.99
Pasta Dinners
All dinners served with garlic toast.
- Penne & Marinara Sauce
  Penne pasta tossed with a traditional marinara sauce, often garnished with parmesan.
  $7.99
- Meatball Casserole and Pasta
  House-made meatballs nestled in a casserole with pasta, typically includes a rich marinara sauce, baked and finished with a layer of melted cheese.
  $9.99
- Eggplant Parmesan
  Elegant and savory dish made with breaded eggplant, tomato sauce, and melted cheese.
  $10.99
- Chicken Parmesan
  Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara sauce and parmesan cheese, typically served over spaghetti.
  $13.99
Sicilian Pizza
Square cut pizza.
- Whole - Sicilian 16 Cut
  Square Sicilian-style pizza, cut into 16 pieces, featuring a thick crust traditionally topped with tomato sauce and cheese.
  $19.99
- Half - Sicilian 8 Cut
  Traditional Sicilian pizza cut into 8 square slices, featuring a thick, airy crust, typically includes tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses.
  $12.99
Focaccia Sandwiches
All sandwiches served on our homemade square sliced focaccia bread with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & dressing. Add the works: sautéed onions, mushrooms, hot & green peppers for an additional charge.
- Italian
  all sandwiches served on our homemade seasoned square sliced focaccia bread with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo or dressing, add the works 1.25
  $7.99
- Grilled Chicken
  12'' hoagie
  $8.50
- Steak
  Grilled steak wrapped in freshly baked focaccia bread with melted cheese.
  $8.50
- Turkey
  Sliced turkey and provolone on homemade focaccia, typically includes lettuce, tomato, and a spread of pesto.
  $8.50
- Ham
  Served on homemade focaccia bread, this sandwich combines ham with a selection of cheeses and is typically garnished with fresh lettuce and tomato.
  $8.50
- Grilled Chicken & Roasted Red Peppers
  Grilled chicken and roasted red peppers served on focaccia, typically includes a light spread of olive oil.
  $8.99
Oven Baked Hoagies
All hoagies served with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo & hoagie dressing. Add the works: sautéed onions, mushrooms, hot & green peppers for an additional charge. Extra meat for an additional charge. EXCEPT: Meatball, Hot Sausage, Buffalo Chicken, Eggplant & Sausage
- Italian
  all hoagies come with lettuce, tomato, onion, mayo, and dressing.
  $14.99
- Steak
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Meatball
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Veggie
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Eggplant Parm
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Ham & Cheese
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Egg & Pepperoni
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Egg & Sweet Pepper
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Cheese
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Philly Steak
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Club (Turkey, Ham & Bacon)
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Buffalo Chicken
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Chicken Parm
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Cheeseburger
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Hot Sausage
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
- Fish
  12'' Hoagie
  $14.99
Gyros and Wraps
- Gyros - Lamb and Beef
  Thinly sliced lamb and beef, wrapped in warm pita bread with lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, and tzatziki sauce.
  $7.99
- Wraps
  Wraps available with a selection of turkey, Italian deli meats, assorted veggies, grilled steak, chicken, or chicken Caesar. Served in Italian style.
  $7.99
Fresh Salads
Dressings: Italian, ranch, honey mustard, Caesar, blue cheese, Greek, light Italian. Extra dressing for an additional charge.
- Small Salad
  Mixed greens, tomatoes, and cucumbers, typically includes a variety of fresh vegetables and Italian dressing.
  $4.99
- Large Garden Salad
  A mix of fresh greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and olives, typically dressed with olive oil and balsamic vinegar.
  $7.99
- Super Salad
  A blend of mixed greens, artichokes, eggs, walnuts, and strawberries, complemented by dried cranberries and typically dressed with balsamic vinaigrette.
  $10.99
- Greek Salad
  Fresh mixed greens, olives, feta, cucumber, and tomato in homemade dressing.
  $10.99
- Club Salad
  Romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, and hard-boiled eggs, typically includes a blend of cheeses.
  $10.99
- Antipasto Salad
  Antipasto salad combines a mix of cured meats like ham, salami, and provolone cheese, typically served over a bed of lettuce with tomatoes, olives, and Italian dressing.
  $10.99
- Grilled Chicken Salad
  Comes with fries.
  $11.99
- Chicken Caesar Salad
  Comes with fries.
  $11.99
- Buffalo Chicken Salad
  Comes with fries.
  $11.99
Beverages
- 2-Liter
  $3.99
- 20 Ounce
  A 20-ounce serving of a variety of beverages, which may include sodas, juices, and water, catering to different tastes and preferences.
  $2.50
- Can
  Choose from our selection of canned beverages, offering a range of popular soda flavors.
  $1.50

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

Carol of Caseys Pizza Shop Menu

Customer Favorites

X-large - 12 Cut

Large - 10 Cut

Medium - 8 Cut

Philly Steak

Provolone Wedges

Steak

Italian

Meaty Wings

Small - 4 Cut

2-Liter

Fun Foods

Meaty Wings

Breadsticks

Cheezy Garlic Toast

Garlic Toast

12-Inch Pepperoni or Jalapeño Rolls

Provolone Wedges

Fried Mushrooms

Single Cuts Pizza

Jalapeño Poppers

Chicken Tenders and Fries

Loaf Garlic Bread

Hot Pocket Wedges

Pepperoni

Steak

Turkey

Ham

Tuna

Italian

Veggie

Grilled Chicken

Philly Steak

Club

Traditional Pizzas

Small - 4 Cut

Medium - 8 Cut

Large - 10 Cut

X-large - 12 Cut

Specialty Pizzas

Spinach & Tomato

Steak & Mushroom

Ricotta & Tomato

Hawaiian

Veggie

Cheeseburger & Bacon

Philly Steak

Spinach & Ricotta

Barbecue Chicken & Bacon

Buffalo Chicken Ranch

Greek

All Meat Deluxe

Pierogi

Chicken Parmesan

Calzones and Strombolis

House (Pepperoni and Sausage)

Mushroom and Cheese

Veggie Combination

Cheese

Steak

Meatball

Italian

Pepperoni

Spinach

Pasta Dinners

Penne & Marinara Sauce

Meatball Casserole and Pasta

Eggplant Parmesan

Chicken Parmesan

Sicilian Pizza

Whole - Sicilian 16 Cut

Half - Sicilian 8 Cut

Focaccia Sandwiches

Italian

Grilled Chicken

Steak

Turkey

Ham

Grilled Chicken & Roasted Red Peppers