Carmen's Italian Ice Menu

4.8

(950+ Reviews)

Customer Favorites Popular Italian Ice Gelati Frozen Custard Carmen's Creations Cookie Dough Grab-n-Go Oven Baked Snacks

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Gelati
  Italian ice and frozen custard, together in layers.
  $4.25
- Italian Ice
  Traditional home made Italian ice. Our specialty!
  $3.50
- Custard
  Fresh frozen custard, Jersey Shore style!
  $5.25
- Milkshake
  Thick and creamy Milkshakes made with our Jersey Shore Frozen Custard
  $7.00
- Pretzel Bites
  Pint of piping hot pretzel bites! Choice of salt or cinnamon sugar.
  $6.00
- Churros
  Cinnamon sugar covered churros.
  $3.00
- Cookie Dough Gelati
  Chocolate chip cookie dough in between layers of frozen custard
  $7.50
- Freeze
  For those days when you want a creamy frozen drink that's lighter than our shakes. It's half Italian Ice, half Frozen Custard blended together with a liquid base.
  $7.00
- Custard Quarts
  Pre-packaged quarts of frozen custard. Always available in our most popular flavors!
  $12.50
- Custard Pints
  Pre-packaged pints of frozen custard. Always available in our most popular flavors!
  $8.50
- Island Refresher
  Ting grapefruit soda and a scoop Italian ice.
  $5.50
- Online Mystery Bag
  $10 worth of random Items from our menu
  $5.00
Popular
Our Most Popular items
- Italian Ice
  Traditional home made Italian ice. Our specialty!
  $3.50
- Gelati
  Italian ice and frozen custard, together in layers.
  $4.25
- Milkshake
  Thick and creamy Milkshakes made with our Jersey Shore Frozen Custard
  $7.00
- Jersey Shore Mocha
  Carmen's original! Combination of Chocolate Italian Ice and Vanilla Frozen Custard blended together with real shots of espresso for an addictive frozen drink
  $7.50
- Pretzel Bites
  Pint of piping hot pretzel bites! Choice of salt or cinnamon sugar.
  $6.00
- Funnel Cake Fries
  Crispy funnel cake 'fries' topped with powdered sugar.
  $5.25
- Churros
  Cinnamon sugar covered churros.
  $3.00
- Cookie Dough Gelati
  Chocolate chip cookie dough in between layers of frozen custard
  $7.50
- Custard
  Fresh frozen custard, Jersey Shore style!
  $5.25
- Cookie Dough Cup
  Just Cookie Dough.... in a cup
  $7.00
Italian Ice
It's in our name, so you know it's good
- Italian Ice
  Traditional home made Italian ice. Our specialty!
  $3.50
Gelati
The most popular thing on the menu
- Gelati
  Italian ice and frozen custard, together in layers.
  $4.25
Frozen Custard
A Jersey Shore classic
- Custard
  Fresh frozen custard, Jersey Shore style!
  $5.25
Carmen's Creations
Cool down with these specialty beverages and tasty creations!
- Jersey Shore Mocha
  Carmen's original! Combination of Chocolate Italian Ice and Vanilla Frozen Custard blended together with real shots of espresso for an addictive frozen drink
  $7.50
- Milkshake
  Thick and creamy Milkshakes made with our Jersey Shore Frozen Custard
  $7.00
- Island Refresher
  Ting grapefruit soda and a scoop Italian ice.
  $5.50
- Pick-Me-Up Refresher
  Bawls energy drink over a scoop of Italian ice.
  $5.50
- Freeze
  For those days when you want a creamy frozen drink that's lighter than our shakes. It's half Italian Ice, half Frozen Custard blended together with a liquid base.
  $7.00
- Root Beer Float
  Our jersey spin on the ice cream shop classic.
  $5.50
- Carmen's Cherry Coke
  Coca-Cola over a scoop of cherry Italian ice.
  $5.50
Cookie Dough
Edible raw cookie dough! Served as a 'Gelati' with frozen custard or just grab a cup of cookie dough.
- Cookie Dough Gelati
  Chocolate chip cookie dough in between layers of frozen custard
  $7.50
- Cookie Dough Cup
  Just Cookie Dough.... in a cup
  $7.00
Grab-n-Go
Pre-packaged sweet treats for you to share with friends and family!
- Online Mystery Bag
  $10 worth of random Items from our menu
  $5.00
- Custard Quarts
  Pre-packaged quarts of frozen custard. Always available in our most popular flavors!
  $12.50
- Custard Pints
  Pre-packaged pints of frozen custard. Always available in our most popular flavors!
  $8.50
- Italian Ice Quarts
  Pre-packaged quarts of our most popular Italian ice flavors!
  $10.00
- Oreo Custard Pie
  A whole custard pie, homemade in our store. Oreo crust, vanilla and chocolate swirl custard, chocolate cookie pieces and homemade whipped cream. (Feeds 8 people)
  $27.00
- Assorted Ice Cream Sandwiches
  Handmade vanilla and chocolate frozen custard 'ice cream' sandwiches! Made on chocolate wafers and topped with rainbow sprinkles, chocolate sprinkles and M&M's
  $28.00
Oven Baked Snacks
Hot and fresh sweet treats!
- Funnel Cake Fries
  Crispy funnel cake 'fries' topped with powdered sugar.
  $5.25
- Pretzel Bites
  Pint of piping hot pretzel bites! Choice of salt or cinnamon sugar.
  $6.00
- Churros
  Cinnamon sugar covered churros.
  $3.00