• Antipasti

    • Carfagna Bruschetta

      Ciabatta, fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, garlic, basil and grated parmigiano
      $10.95
      Carfagna Bruschetta
    • Fried Calamari

      Broccoli, red peppers, marinara and sweet chili dipping sauce
      $14.95
    • Arancini

      Fried risotto and cheese with marinara
      $12.95
      Arancini
    • Pasta Fritta

      Italian breaded and deep fried logs of fettuccine alfredo. Comes topped with your choice of marinara or alfredo sauce.
      $13.95
    • Spinach Alfredo Dip

      Spicy and served with crostini for dipping
      $10.95
      Spinach Alfredo Dip
    • Meatball Trio

      (3) Homemade meatballs topped with marinara and romano cheese.
      $9.95
      Meatball Trio
    • Provolone Wedges

      Fried mezzaluna shape with marinara dipping sauce
      $10.95
    • Burrata Caprese

      Fresh mozzarella with stracciatella & cream, served with crostini, pesto, & bruschetta mix
      $13.95
    • Italian Grilled Wings

      Marinated chicken wings, fire grilled and tossed with garlic butter and parmesan.
      $13.95
  • Zuppa

    • Cup

      $3.95
    • Bowl

      $5.95
    • Quart

      $8.95
  • Insalata

    • Side House

      $4.95
      Side House
    • Side Caesar

      $4.95
      Side Caesar
    • Lrg House Salad

      Tomato, cucumber, red onion, shredded provolone, croutons
      $9.95
      Lrg House Salad
    • Lrg Caesar Salad

      Bacon, red onion, parmigiano, croutons
      $9.95
      Lrg Caesar Salad
    • Big D Cobb

      Mixed greens, hardboiled egg, bacon, tomato, red onion, gorgonzola, provolone, croutons
      $12.95
      Big D Cobb
    • Chef Salad

      Mixed greens, salami, capicollo, pepperoni, tomato, provolone, banana peppers, red onion, croutons
      $12.95
    • Apple Walnut Salad

      Spinach, apples, walnut, tomato, cucumber, red onion, and house made strawberry vinaigrette
      $12.95
  • Sandwiches

    • Meatball Sub

      Baked sub with our homemade meatballs, Carfagna's marinara, and provolone
      $12.95
      Meatball Sub
    • Italian Festival Sausage

      Homemade sausage topped with grilled green & red bell peppers and onions
      $10.95
    • Chicken Parm Sandwich

      Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and provolone, and baked on ciabatta
      $14.95
    • Prime Rib Sandwich

      Roasted thin sliced prime rib topped with provolone, bell peppers & onions, & served with au jus
      $13.95
    • Italian Sub

      Salami, capocollo, pepperoni, and provolone, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, banana peppers, and house dressing
      $10.95
      Italian Sub
  • Pastas

    • Baked Lasagna

      House favorite with layers of pasta, meat sauce, ricotta, & topped with provolone
      $18.95
      Baked Lasagna
    • Spaghetti + Meatballs

      Homemade spaghetti and our famous meatballs
      $17.95
      Spaghetti + Meatballs
    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      Fresh cream and parmigiano.
      $15.95
    • Pasta Al Vodka

      Fresh fettuccine noodles tossed in vodka infused creamy pomodoro sauce
      $17.95
      Pasta Al Vodka
    • Spaghetti Carbonara

      Bacon, onion, garlic, and whipped eggs infused with cream and romano cheese
      $18.95
      Spaghetti Carbonara
    • Spicy Creamy Chicken

      Fire grilled chicken breast atop rigatelli noodles in a spicy pomodoro sauce
      $20.95
    • Shrimp Scampi

      Sautéed shrimp, basil, and diced onion & tomato in a garlic white wine sauce
      $19.95
    • Chicken Creamy Pesto

      Fire grilled chicken breast over fettuccine noodles tossed with basil pesto & cream
      $20.95
      Chicken Creamy Pesto
    • Spaghetti Bolognese

      Seasoned ground beef & pork mix, garlic, onion, tomato, and basil sautéed in marinara
      $18.95
    • White Clam Pasta

      Tender clams, blistered cherry tomatoes, and sautéed onion & garlic over spaghetti, served with a grilled lemon half and crostini.
      $19.95
    • Sausage + Peppers Pasta

      Garlic oil, sliced sausage, roasted peppers, onion, and mushrooms tossed with rigatelli
      $18.95
      Sausage + Peppers Pasta
    • Gnocchi Carfagna

      Classic potato dumplings served with your choice of alfredo or marinara
      $16.95
      Gnocchi Carfagna
    • Baked Ziti

      Rigatelli in our bolognese sauce, baked with provolone, & topped with ricotta cheese
      $18.95
    • Cheese Ravioli

      Choose either MEAT or CHEESE filled. Served with your choice of alfredo or marinara, and topped with provolone.
      $17.95
    • Meat Ravioli

      $17.95
    • Cheese Manicotti

      Homemade crepes filled with ricotta, then topped with marinara & provolone
      $18.95
    • Pasta Combo Platter

      Lasagna, cheese ravioli, cheese manicotti, and gnocchi topped with provolone
      $22.95
    • Meat Combo Platter

      Chicken parm, lasagna, meat ravioli, and meatballs topped with provolone
      $24.95
    • BYO Pasta

      $15.95
  • Piatti

    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      With provolone and homemade marinara.
      $18.95
    • Chicken Parmigiana

      With provolone and homemade marinara.
      $21.95
      Chicken Parmigiana
    • Veal Parmigiana

      $25.95
    • Chicken Marsala

      Marsala wine, butter, mushrooms.
      $21.95
      Chicken Marsala
    • Veal Marsala

      $25.95
      Veal Marsala
    • Chicken Piccata

      Lemon wine sauce with capers.
      $21.95
    • Veal Piccata

      $25.95
    • Salmon Entree

      $24.95
  • Thin Crust Pizza

    • 8" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $10.95
      8" Margherita Pizza
    • 11" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $15.95
      11" Margherita Pizza
    • 14" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $20.95
      14" Margherita Pizza
    • 8" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $11.95
    • 11" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $16.95
    • 14" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $22.95
    • 8" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $8.95
    • 11" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $13.95
    • 14" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $16.95
    • 8" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $10.95
    • 11" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $16.95
    • 14" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $21.45
    • 8" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $11.95
    • 11" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $17.95
    • 14" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $22.95
    • 8" Build Your Own Pizza

      $7.45
      8" Build Your Own Pizza
    • 11" Build Your Own Pizza

      $11.95
      11" Build Your Own Pizza
    • 14" Build Your Own Pizza

      $14.95
  • Pan Pizza

    • 1/2 Pan Margherita

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $20.95
    • Full Pan Margherita

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $28.95
    • 1/2 Pan Siciliano

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $22.95
    • Full Pan Siciliano

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $30.95
    • 1/2 Pan Bruschetta

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $16.95
    • Full Pan Bruschetta

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $25.95
    • 1/2 Pan Veggie

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $21.45
    • Full Pan Veggie

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $29.45
    • 1/2 Pan House

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $22.95
    • Full Pan House

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $30.95
    • 1/2 Pan BYO

      $14.95
    • Full Pan BYO

      $23.95
  • Stromboli

    • Carfagna Stromboli (Regular)

      Salami, capicollo, tomato, banana peppers
      $16.95
      Carfagna Stromboli (Regular)
    • Carfagna Stromboli (LARGE)

      Salami, capicollo, tomato, banana peppers
      $23.95
      Carfagna Stromboli (LARGE)
    • Build Your Own Stromboli (Regular)

      $12.95
      Build Your Own Stromboli (Regular)
    • Build Your Own Stromboli (LARGE)

      $16.95
      Build Your Own Stromboli (LARGE)
  • Desserts

    • Tiramisu

      $6.00
      Tiramisu
    • Cannoli

      $6.00
      Cannoli
    • Chocolate Bomba

      $8.00
      Chocolate Bomba
    • Raspberry Almond

      $7.00
      Raspberry Almond
    • Rainbow Cake

      $8.00
      Rainbow Cake
  • Sides

    • Fresh Cut Fries

      $4.95
      Fresh Cut Fries
    • Garlic Smashed Potatoes

      $4.95
    • Mixed Vegetable

      $4.95
      Mixed Vegetable
    • Sautéed Spinach

      $4.95
    • Grilled Asparagus

      $4.95
    • Brussel Sprouts

      $6.95
    • Add Protein

  • Sauce Side Upgrades

    • Side Marinara

      $1.50
    • Side Alfredo

      $1.50
    • Side Bolognese

      $3.00
    • Side Carbonara

      $3.00
    • Side Creamy Pomodoro

      $2.00
    • Side Spicy Pomodoro

      $2.00
    • Side Pesto

      $2.00
    • Side Creamy Pesto

      $2.00
    • Side Vodka Sauce

      $2.00
    • Side Arrabbiato

      $2.00
    • Side Piccata

      $2.00
    • Side Marsala

      $2.00
  • Antipasti

    • Carfagna Bruschetta

      Ciabatta, fresh mozzarella, tomato, onion, garlic, basil and grated parmigiano
      $10.95
      Carfagna Bruschetta
    • Fried Calamari

      Broccoli, red peppers, marinara and sweet chili dipping sauce
      $14.95
    • Arancini

      Fried risotto and cheese with marinara
      $12.95
      Arancini
    • Pasta Fritta

      Italian breaded and deep fried logs of fettuccine alfredo. Comes topped with your choice of marinara or alfredo sauce.
      $13.95
    • Spinach Alfredo Dip

      Spicy and served with crostini for dipping
      $10.95
      Spinach Alfredo Dip
    • Meatball Trio

      (3) Homemade meatballs topped with marinara and romano cheese.
      $9.95
      Meatball Trio
    • Provolone Wedges

      Fried mezzaluna shape with marinara dipping sauce
      $10.95
    • Burrata Caprese

      Fresh mozzarella with stracciatella & cream, served with crostini, pesto, & bruschetta mix
      $13.95
    • Italian Grilled Wings

      Marinated chicken wings, fire grilled and tossed with garlic butter and parmesan.
      $13.95
  • Zuppa

    • Cup

      $3.95
    • Bowl

      $5.95
    • Quart

      $8.95
  • Insalata

    • Side House

      $4.95
      Side House
    • Side Caesar

      $4.95
      Side Caesar
    • Lrg House Salad

      Tomato, cucumber, red onion, shredded provolone, croutons
      $9.95
      Lrg House Salad
    • Lrg Caesar Salad

      Bacon, red onion, parmigiano, croutons
      $9.95
      Lrg Caesar Salad
    • Big D Cobb

      Mixed greens, hardboiled egg, bacon, tomato, red onion, gorgonzola, provolone, croutons
      $12.95
      Big D Cobb
    • Chef Salad

      Mixed greens, salami, capicollo, pepperoni, tomato, provolone, banana peppers, red onion, croutons
      $12.95
    • Apple Walnut Salad

      Spinach, apples, walnut, tomato, cucumber, red onion, and house made strawberry vinaigrette
      $12.95
  • Sandwiches

    • Meatball Sub

      Baked sub with our homemade meatballs, Carfagna's marinara, and provolone
      $12.95
      Meatball Sub
    • Italian Festival Sausage

      Homemade sausage topped with grilled green & red bell peppers and onions
      $10.95
    • Chicken Parm Sandwich

      Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and provolone, and baked on ciabatta
      $14.95
    • Prime Rib Sandwich

      Roasted thin sliced prime rib topped with provolone, bell peppers & onions, & served with au jus
      $13.95
    • Italian Sub

      Salami, capocollo, pepperoni, and provolone, topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, banana peppers, and house dressing
      $10.95
      Italian Sub
  • Pick 2

    • Side House Salad

      $6.50
    • Side Caesar Salad

      $6.50
    • Bowl Soup

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Spaghetti

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Fettuccine

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Rigatelli

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Sausage Sandwich

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Meatball Sub

      $6.50
    • 1/2 Italian Sub

      $6.50
    • 8" Cheese

      $6.50
    • 8" Pepperoni

      $6.50
    • 8" Bruschetta

      $6.50
  • Pastas (Lunch)

    • Lasagna (Lunch)

      $15.95
    • Spaghetti+Meatballs (Lunch)

      $14.95
    • Fettuccine Alfredo (Lunch)

      $12.95
    • Pasta Al Vodka (Lunch)

      $14.95
    • Spaghetti Carbonara (Lunch)

      $15.95
    • Spicy Creamy Chicken (Lunch)

      $17.95
    • Shrimp Scampi (Lunch)

      $16.95
    • Chicken Creamy Pesto (Lunch)

      $17.95
    • Spaghetti Bolognese (Lunch)

      $15.95
    • Sausage+Pepper Pasta (Lunch)

      $15.95
    • Gnocchi Carfagna (Lunch)

      $13.95
  • Piatti (Lunch)

    • 1/2 Chicken Parmigiana

      $16.95
    • 1/2 Chicken Piccata

      $16.95
    • 1/2 Chicken Marsala

      $16.95
  • Stromboli

    • Carfagna Stromboli (Regular)

      Salami, capicollo, tomato, banana peppers
      $16.95
      Carfagna Stromboli (Regular)
    • Carfagna Stromboli (LARGE)

      Salami, capicollo, tomato, banana peppers
      $23.95
      Carfagna Stromboli (LARGE)
    • Build Your Own Stromboli (Regular)

      $12.95
      Build Your Own Stromboli (Regular)
    • Build Your Own Stromboli (LARGE)

      $16.95
      Build Your Own Stromboli (LARGE)
  • Thin Crust Pizza

    • 8" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $10.95
      8" Margherita Pizza
    • 11" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $15.95
      11" Margherita Pizza
    • 14" Margherita Pizza

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $20.95
      14" Margherita Pizza
    • 8" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $11.95
    • 11" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $16.95
    • 14" Siciliano Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $22.95
    • 8" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $8.95
    • 11" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $13.95
    • 14" Bruschetta Pizza

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $16.95
    • 8" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $10.95
    • 11" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $16.95
    • 14" Veggie Pizza

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $21.45
    • 8" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $11.95
    • 11" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $17.95
    • 14" House Pizza

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $22.95
    • 8" Build Your Own Pizza

      $7.45
      8" Build Your Own Pizza
    • 11" Build Your Own Pizza

      $11.95
      11" Build Your Own Pizza
    • 14" Build Your Own Pizza

      $14.95
  • Pan Pizza

    • 1/2 Pan Margherita

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $20.95
    • Full Pan Margherita

      Tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella
      $28.95
    • 1/2 Pan Siciliano

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $22.95
    • Full Pan Siciliano

      Roasted red peppers, capocollo, pepperoni, and fresh mozzarella
      $30.95
    • 1/2 Pan Bruschetta

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $16.95
    • Full Pan Bruschetta

      Garlic & oil, provolone, bruschetta topping
      $25.95
    • 1/2 Pan Veggie

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $21.45
    • Full Pan Veggie

      Roasted red peppers, onion, tomato, mushroom
      $29.45
    • 1/2 Pan House

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $22.95
    • Full Pan House

      Pepperoni, sausage, mushroom, onion, banana pepper
      $30.95
    • 1/2 Pan BYO

      $14.95
    • Full Pan BYO

      $23.95
  • Sides

    • Fresh Cut Fries

      $4.95
      Fresh Cut Fries
    • Garlic Smashed Potatoes

      $4.95
    • Mixed Vegetable

      $4.95
      Mixed Vegetable
    • Sautéed Spinach

      $4.95
    • Grilled Asparagus

      $4.95
    • Brussel Sprouts

      $6.95
    • Side House Salad

      $4.95
    • Side Caesar Salad

      $4.95
    • Add Protein

  • Desserts

    • Tiramisu

      $6.00
      Tiramisu
    • Cannoli

      $6.00
      Cannoli
    • Chocolate Bomba

      $8.00
      Chocolate Bomba
    • Raspberry Almond

      $7.00
      Raspberry Almond
    • Rainbow Cake

      $8.00
      Rainbow Cake
  • Sauce Side Upgrades

    • Side Marinara

      $1.50
    • Side Alfredo

      $1.50
    • Side Bolognese

      $3.00
    • Side Carbonara

      $3.00
    • Side Creamy Pomodoro

      $2.00
    • Side Spicy Pomodoro

      $2.00
    • Side Pesto

      $2.00
    • Side Creamy Pesto

      $2.00
    • Side Vodka Sauce

      $2.00
    • Side Arrabbiato

      $2.00
    • Side Piccata

      $2.00
    • Side Marsala

      $2.00
  • Kids Menu

    • Kids Spaghetti + Meatballs

      $8.95
    • Kids Mac + Cheese

      $8.95
    • Kids Meat Ravioli

      $9.95
    • Kids Cheese Ravioli

      $9.95
    • Kids Spaghetti

      $6.95
    • Kids Rigatelli

      $6.95
    • Kids Fettuccine

      $6.95
    • Kids Chicken Fingers+Fries

      $9.95
    • Kids Cheese Pizza

      $7.45
    • Kids Pepperoni Pizza

      $8.95
    • Kids Gluten Free

      $7.95
    • Kids Gnocchi

      $7.95

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

China Wok
China Wok
4.1
(263 Reviews)
Chinese
Fitzwillys Pub
Fitzwillys Pub
4.4
(191 Reviews)
Bar
Calero's Bar & Grill
Calero's Bar & Grill
4.7
(62 Reviews)
Bar & grill
Tasty Hands Restaurant
Tasty Hands Restaurant
4.2
(266 Reviews)
African, American, Restaurant
Super Seafood Buffet
Super Seafood Buffet
3.3
(813 Reviews)
Buffet, Chinese, Seafood
Tasty Tacos
Tasty Tacos
4.7
(440 Reviews)
Mexican, Restaurant
Springers pub and billiards
Springers pub and billiards
4.8
(30 Reviews)
Bar
Red Sea Cafe & Deli - Somali Restaurant
Red Sea Cafe & Deli - Somali Restaurant
4.8
(88 Reviews)
East African
Subway
Subway
3.8
(284 Reviews)
Sandwich shop, Restaurant
Waffle House
Waffle House
3.8
(1,676 Reviews)
Breakfast, American, Diner

+1 614-848-4488

1440 Gemini Pl, Columbus, OH 43240


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms