Appetizers
- Meatballs
- Pizza Stix
- Cheesy Garlic Bread
Others
- Traditional
- Boneless
- 10" 1 Topping Pizza & A 12 Oz Soda
Fresh Salads
- Old School
- Caesar
- Fancy Pants
- Cardinal House
Pasta
- Spaghetti & Meatballs
New York Specialty Pies
- Taylor's Favorite
- A Pizza My Heart
- Five Boroughs
- Margherita
- The White
- The Basil Birdy
Columbus Specialty Pies
- Flexitarian
- The Tower
- A Pizza Meat
- The Roasty
Specials
- 14" 1 Topping Pizza, 6 Wings & A 2 Liter
Drink Specials
- All Domestic Cans
- All Craft Cans
- Bud Licht Draft
Subs & Wraps
- The Stallion Sub
- Club Sub
- Meatball Sub
- Italian Chicken Sub
- The Free Bird
- Pizza Sub
- A Pizza My Heart Sub
- House Wrap
- Tomato Pesto Wrap
Extras
- Housmade Pizza Sauce
- Spicy Pizza Sauce
- Housemade Dressing
- Housemade Roasted Garlic Sauce
- Marinara
