Caragiulo's Italian American Menu

69 S Palm Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236
  • Appetizers

    • CALAMARI FRITTI

      calamari + gardiniera + condimenti
      $18.98
    • ARANCINI ROMANO

      crispy stuffed risotto balls + spinach + artichoke + parmesan + rosemary fonduta + spicy aioli
      $15.50
    • MUSSELS 'NDUJA

      fennel sausage crumbles + scallions + n'duja broth + crostini
      $17.86
    • AVOCADO BRUSCHETTA

      heirloom tomatoes + burrata + herb salad + radish
      $16.74
    • CHICKEN FEGATINI

      liver pate + fig mostarda + balsamic + Tuscan toast
      $18.98
    • CAPRESE BOARD

      House-made mozzarella + local tomato + basil + red onion + balsamico
      $17.86
    • VEGETARIANO BOARD

      seasonal grilled vegetable + goat cheese + aged balsamic
      $17.85
    • SALUMI E FORMAGGI BOARD

      prosciutto di parma + soppresata + pistachio mortadella + giardiniera + parmigiana + gorgonzola dolce + fresh mozzarella + local honeycomb
      $22.34
    • FRIED CALAMARI

      fried calamari only with Sicilian marinara & Sardinian aioli
      $18.94
  • Soups / Salads

    • TUSCAN KALE SALAD

      baby carrots + whipped ricotta + toasted breadcrumbs + lemon-vinaigrette
      $17.64
    • CHOPPED 1989

      grilled chicken + chopped lettuces + soppresata + chickpeas + tomato + pepperoncini + olives + bocconcini + creamy-garlic parmesan vinaigrette
      $18.65
    • ROASTED BEET & AVOCADO SALAD

      goat cheese fondue + orange + shallot vinaigrette + local lettuces + caramelized walnuts
      $18.76
    • SICILIAN CAESAR SALAD

      romaine + radicchio + fried caper crumbs + dried cherries + peppadew peppers + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
      $15.34
    • HOUSE SALAD

      carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + house vinaigrette
      $17.64
    • SIDE HOUSE SALAD

      carrot + tomato + onion + calamata olive + cucumber + house vinaigrette
      $12.60
    • SIDE CLASSIC CAESAR SALAD

      romaine + shaved parmigiana + Caesar dressing
      $7.64
    • WEDDING SOUP

      spinach stracciatella + pastina + small meatballs
      $10.02
  • Dinner Pasta

    • SPAGHETTI + SAUSAGE

      Spaghetti served with Italian sausage and typically includes a tomato-based marinara sauce.
      $22.00
    • PASTA MIA

      pick your pasta: add your favorite sauce
      $14.50
    • RAVIOLI BARESE

      spinach + pomodori + olives + ricotta salata
      $21.22
    • LASAGNA Al FORNO

      bolognese + béchamel
      $22.34
    • ANGEL HAIR ARRABIATA

      shrimp + san marzano fumet + arancia
      $31.30
    • RIGATONI A La VODKA

      crispy pancetta + stracciatella mozzarella + vodka-tomato crema
      $24.00
    • SPAGHETTI & CEDAR KEY CLAMS

      white wine-garlic broth + fresh herbs + fresno chili
      $27.25
    • PACCHERI PASOLINI

      pennoni (large penne) + roasted chicken + crumbled sausage + gorgonzola cream + oven-dried tomatoes
      $25.20
  • Pizza

    • DAVINCI

      fennel sausage + mushroom + pepperoni
      $20.10
    • BIANCA ROSSA

      white pizza with roasted garlic ricotta + arugula
      $20.10
    • FIVE LILY

      sweet & red onions + crispy bacon + garlic + charred scallion + chive + smoked mozzarella
      $18.98
    • MARGHERITA

      san marzano tomatoes + basil + house-made mozzarella
      $20.10
    • WILD MUSHROOM & FONTINA

      with truffle garlic aioli
      $20.10
    • PEAR & GORGONZOLA

      caramelized onions + white balsamic + spicy honey + arugula
      $20.10
    • CHEESE PIZZA

      with sauce + mozzarella
      $16.74
    • CALZONE

      stuffed with ricotta + any 2 toppings
      $20.10
    • PIZZA MIA

      cheese pizza your way with 3 toppings
      $20.10
    • THE GODFATHER SANDWICH

      toasted Bandit Baquette with salumi misto + porvolone + giardiniera + LTO + garlic aioli + vinaigrette
      $18.95
    • JOE Da GREEK

      calamata olives + baby spinach + feta + tomatoes
      $20.10
  • Entrees

    • CHICKEN PARMIGIANA DINNER

      pan fried organic chicken breast with marinara + mozzarella + spaghetti
      $26.82
    • CHICKEN MARSALA

      pan roasted organic chicken breast + roasted cippolini + wild mushroom gravy + roasted potatoes
      $26.82
    • SEARED LOCAL GROUPER

      roasted tomato confit + artichoke + spinach + caper butter + risotto cake
      $41.38
    • CRISPY EGGPLANT PARMESAN Al FORNO

      layered crispy eggplant + plum tomato + ricotta + mozzarella
      $21.22
    • FILETTO Di MANZO

      black angus beef tenderloin + bone marrow butter + port glaze + crispy brussels sprouts + truffle risotto
      $42.50
    • CHICKEN PICATTA

      artichoke + oyster mushroom + caper + lemon-butter + green pea risotto
      $27.95
    • PORK TENDERLOIN MARSALA

      cipollini + wild mushroom gravy crispy leeks + gorgonzola polenta
      $27.95
  • Sides

    • ROASTED CAULIFLOWER

      with calabrian aioli + spicy crumbs
      $11.14
    • TRUFFLE FRIES

      parmigiano + chives
      $11.15
    • CHARRED BROCCOLINI

      with lemon + EVOO
      $11.14
    • RISOTTO MILANESE

      Creamy risotto infused with saffron, topped with fresh greens and an edible flower.
      $11.14
    • SIDE 2 SAUSAGE LINKS

      Two sausage links typically accompanied by a marinara sauce.
      $8.40
    • SIDE PASTA

      Typically served as a smaller portion, this dish consists of pasta with marinara or meat sauce.
      $7.78
    • SIDE ANCHOVIES

      Salt-cured anchovies with a rich, briny flavor and firm texture, ideal for adding a savory depth to your meal.
      $4.48
    • SIDE MIXED VEGETABLES

      A medley of seasonal vegetables, sautéed together, typically includes a vibrant mix of zucchini, carrots, broccoli, and bell peppers.
      $11.14
    • SIDE SAUTEED SPINACH

      Spinach sautéed with garlic and olive oil.
      $11.14
  • Desserts

    • 3 - CANNOLI

      crispy miniature pastries + sweet ricotta + chocolate chips
      $7.78
    • 6 - CANNOLI

      Crispy pastry shells filled with a sweet ricotta and chocolate chip mixture, often garnished with powdered sugar.
      $12.26
    • ZEPPOLI AFFOGATO

      crispy fritters + hazelnut gelato + espresso cascade
      $11.14
    • SPUMONI SUNDAE

      pistachio + vanilla + amarena cherry gelato + dark rum chocolate brownie + cream
      $11.14
    • CHIARA'S TIRAMISU

      lady fingers + espresso + frangelico + mascarpone + cocoa
      $11.14
  • Soft Drinks

    • UNSWEETENED ICED TEA

      Crisp, chilled tea without added sugar for a refreshing, naturally brisk taste.
      $3.30
    • RASPBERRY TEA

      Raspberry-infused Tea: A Refreshing Blend of Sweet and Tart
      $3.90
    • PEPSI

      Classic, refreshing cola soda.
      $3.30
    • DIET PEPSI

      A carbonated soft drink offering the bold taste of Pepsi with no calories, typically in a convenient serving size.
      $3.30
    • LEMONADE

      Refreshing citrus beverage.
      $3.30
    • SIERRA MIST

      Refreshing, crisp lemon-lime soda, perfect for quenching your thirst.
      $3.30
    • GINGERALE

      Refreshing, crisp ginger-flavored carbonated soft drink.
      $3.30
    • DR PEPPER

      $3.30
    • CLUB SODA

      Effervescent Club Soda: Crisp, Refreshing, Perfectly Carbonated
      $3.30
    • HOT TEA

      Steaming, aromatic blend of finely selected tea leaves. Perfectly soothing.
      $3.60
    • COFFEE

      Freshly brewed, aromatic blend to kick-start your day.
      $3.36
    • ESPRESSO

      Rich, flavorful cup of espresso brewed to perfection.
      $3.08
    • DBL ESPRESSO

      Two shots of espresso, prepared to highlight the rich and intense flavors of the coffee.
      $4.20
    • DECAF ESPRESSO

      A single shot of caffeine-free Italian espresso, typically includes a smooth, rich flavor with a velvety crema on top.
      $3.08
    • CAPPUCINO

      Espresso combined with steamed milk, typically topped with a layer of frothy milk foam.
      $4.48
    • DBL CAPPUCINO

      Double shot of espresso harmoniously blended with steamed milk, traditionally crowned with a layer of smooth milk foam.
      $5.60
    • DECAF CAPPUCINO

      Espresso made without caffeine, combined with steamed milk and topped with a layer of milk foam.
      $4.48

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6

Menu Gallery

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
  • Menu 4
  • Menu 5
  • Menu 6
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms