Captain Cookie & the Milk Man Menu

3.9

(50+ Reviews)

$Dessert shop

Customer Favorites The Captain's Cookies Local Ice Cream Tasty Drinks

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Assorted Half Dozen
  6 cookies for you and your friends. Or just you. Almost too good to share!
  $12.00
- Assorted Bakers Dozen
  The only thing better than cookies is more cookies. Sharing is even better.
  $25.00
- Ice Cream Sandwich
  Our famous sandwich - choose any two cookies and ice cream!
  $8.50
- 2 Cookies & Milk
  Reheat Instructions: Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
  $7.00
- Chocolate Chip
  This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years.
  $2.50
- Local Milk
  Local Milk - Choice of chocolate or whole milk.
  $3.00
- Milkshake
  Milkshake available in chocolate, strawberry, or vanilla flavors.
  $8.00
- Ice Cream Single Scoop
  Double scoop.
  $5.00
- The Duo
  Single Scoop of Ice Cream+ Cookie
  $6.50
- Snickerdoodle
  Guaranteed to take you back to childhood with one bite. Our snickerdoodles are buttery, tender, and rolled in cinnamon sugar, just like Mom did.
  $2.50
The Captain's Cookies
- Assorted Bakers Dozen
  The only thing better than cookies is more cookies. Sharing is even better.
  $25.00
- Assorted Half Dozen
  6 cookies for you and your friends. Or just you. Almost too good to share!
  $12.00
- Chocolate Chip
  This is how it all started. The Captain has been perfecting the recipe for these rich, chewy cookies studded with dark chocolate chips for over 20 years.
  $2.50
- Oatmeal Raisin
  The classic. Chewy oats with just the right level of spice and a generous helping of plump raisins.
  $2.50
- Peanut Butter
  Our special twist on the classic peanut butter - it's gooey, with honey vanilla notes, and chock full of peanut butter.
  $2.50
- Ginger Molasses
  Chewy, puffy cookies with dark molasses flavor, spiced with cloves, cinnamon, and lots of ginger. Crowned with sugar for a crispy crust!
  $2.50
- Snickerdoodle
  Guaranteed to take you back to childhood with one bite. Our snickerdoodles are buttery, tender, and rolled in cinnamon sugar, just like Mom did.
  $2.50
- Double Chocolate
  Our version of the chocolate lover's classic is rich, fudgy, and loaded with dark chocolate.
  $2.50
- Vegan Chocolate chip
  The Captain churns our vegan butter from scratch- these cookie are a three-day process, and their amazing taste is the result of years of recipe- tweaking.
  $2.50
- Confetti
  Our sugar cookie, made 80% more fun with sprinkles! Tastes like a birthday party.
  $2.50
Local Ice Cream
- Ice Cream Single Scoop
  Double scoop.
  $5.00
- Double Scoop
  Double scoop
  $8.00
- Ice Cream Sandwich
  Our famous sandwich - choose any two cookies and ice cream!
  $8.50
- The Duo
  Single Scoop of Ice Cream+ Cookie
  $6.50
Tasty Drinks
Local milk.
- Local Milk
  Local Milk - Choice of chocolate or whole milk.
  $3.00
- 2 Cookies & Milk
  Reheat Instructions: Air fryer - 1 minute at 300 degrees Microwave - 5-7 seconds under a damp paper towel
  $7.00
- Milkshake
  Milkshake available in chocolate, strawberry, or vanilla flavors.
  $8.00