Baked Goods
- Traditional: Chocolate ChipDelicious, the all-time cookie classic. Semi-sweet chocolate chips meticulously folded into rich cookie batter. Contains: wheat, eggs, soybeans and milk.$2.35
- Traditional: CarnivalA fun and colorful cookie comprised of multi-colored candied gems made from semi-sweet chocolate coated in a confectioner's glaze. Contains: wheat, eggs, soybeans and milk.$2.35
- Traditional: Oatmeal RaisinRolled oats with real California raisins and cinnamon spice create the ultimate comfort snack! Just like grandma used to make!$2.35
- Traditional: Peanut ButterRich creamy peanut butter make for "Stick-to-the-roof-of-your-mouth" goodness that leaves you wanting more. Contains: wheat, eggs, milk and peanuts.$2.35
- Traditional: Reese's PiecesA chocolate cookie dough base loaded with Reese's pieces® candies for a peanut butter and chocolate delight.$2.35
- Traditional: S'moresMade with a dark chocolate base, then loaded with chocolate chunks and blended with Hershey's s'mores bars, mini marshmallows, caramel, and graham bits.$2.35
- Traditional: SnickerdoodleSugar and cinnamon.$2.35
- Traditional: Strawberry ShortcakeAll of the taste of the favorite summertime dessert with strawberries, cranberries and white chips. Contains: wheat, eggs, soybeans and milk.$2.35
- Sugar With Spooky SprinklesSugar with spooky sprinkles.$2.35
- Traditional: SugarSimple flavors are perfectly balanced in this classic cookie, with our signature vanilla blend and just the right sweetness. Contains: milk, eggs and wheat.$2.35
- Traditional: Chocolate Dark ChocolateA rich and smooth chocolate dough with dark chocolate chips mixed in! 1.5 oz.$2.35
- Traditional: Heath Bar CrunchChopped, crispy, crunchy heath bar candy hand-blended into our all-natural ingredient dough.$2.35
- Traditional: Macadamia NutA scrumptious selection of macadamia nuts, white chocolate chips and a touch of sweetness from brown sugar. Contains: wheat, eggs, soybeans, milk and macadamia nuts, coconut.$2.35
- Traditional: Mint Chocolate ChipDark chocolate dough mixed with mints!$2.35
- Traditional: Red VelvetRich red velvet cookies loaded with dark and white chocolate chips. Velvety delicious!$2.35
- Traditional: S'mores ReserveYou can all but hear the crackle of the campfire with this delicious cookie made with graham cracker pieces, gooey marshmallows and of course, real Hershey's chocolate!$2.35
- Traditional: Salted Caramel Chocolate ChunkSalted caramel chocolate chunk.$2.35
- Premium: Chaos CookieOur large 4.5 oz cookies loaded with Oreo crumbles, pretzels, peanut butter chips, pecans, potato chips, and of course chocolate chips!$4.35
- Premium: Lemon BlueberryNatural lemon flavor makes this cookie both tart and refreshing while dried wild blueberries contribute a sweet note to this light, tender and chewy cookie 4.5 oz.$4.35
- Premium: Oatmeal Walnut Chocolate Chunk (Cowboy)Oatmeal, walnuts and two types of chocolate - dark chunks and milk chips - plus a hint of cinnamon combine to make this our delicious take on a cowboy cookie. Rich, chewy and oh so satisfying! Whether you consider it an oatmeal cookie or a chocolate chip cookie - this one has all the bases covered! Yum!$4.35
- Premium: Reese's Peanut Butter CupA very large, super-premium cookie covered and infused with real Reese's peanut butter cups.$4.35
- Premium: Salted Caramel ToffeeWe start with a brown-sugar based dough accented with flakes of pure sea salt and add generous amounts of creamy caramel and buttery heath toffee bits covered in milk chocolate. This salty-sweet combo is offset with natural vanilla flavor to make this a chewy, scrumptious and crave-able cookie! 4.5 oz.$4.35
- Premium: SnickersBrown sugar based dough with milk chocolate chunks, bits of caramel, roasted salted peanuts and a generous amount of snickers bites candy. 4.5 oz.$4.35
- Premium: Triple ChocolateChocolate chunk cookie dough generously topped with Hershey's kisses, semi sweet chunks and milk chocolate chunks.$4.35
- Premium: TurtleDark chocolate cookie with chocolate chips, caramel bits, studded with pecans.$4.35
- Gluten Free SnickerdoodleGluten free snickerdoodle.$2.35
- Vegan: Chocolate Chip1.5 oz Ade with only premium ingredients, these are the best vegan chocolate chip cookies!$2.35
- Vegan: Oatmeal Raisin1.5 oz vegan: oatmeal raisin.$2.35
- Vegan: Peanut Butter1.5 oz vegan peanut butter.$2.35
- Vegan: Ranger1.5 oz vegan ranger.$2.35
- Dark Chocolate BrownieLarge rectangles 3"x4": the deep flavor and smooth texture of our brownies will make you wanting more. Filled with 3 kinds of chocolate chips.$2.35
- Stuffed Soft Pretzels Filled With JalapeñO And Jack CheeseBaked to order 6.25 oz hand twisted pretzel with your choice of brewpub mustard dipping sauce.$6.65
Cookie Cake
- Cookie Cake - PlainCustom created, select your colors and fill in your text! We are unable to deliver decorated cookie cakes warm because the icing will melt! If the decorating layer is not centered on the cake, make sure your browser is zoomed in to 100%. Please note decorated cookie cakes usually take at least an hour for delivery. **Gluten warning** the butter creme we use around the edges is gluten free, however the text icing is not. If you order a decorated gluten free cookie cake you can't have any text on the cake.$19.85
- Cookie Cake - Custom CakeCustom created, select your colors and fill in your text! We are unable to deliver decorated cookie cakes warm because the icing will melt! If the decorating layer is not centered on the cake, make sure your browser is zoomed in to 100%. Please note decorated cookie cakes usually take at least an hour for delivery. **Gluten warning** the butter creme we use around the edges is gluten free, however the text icing is not. If you order a decorated gluten free cookie cake you can't have any text on the cake.$22.85
Milk & Beverages
- Local Mt. Crawford Whole Milk8 oz.$2.35
- Local Mt. Crawford Chocolate Milk8 oz.$2.35
- Silk's Very Vanilla SoymilkSilk's very vanilla soymilk, with straw.$2.49
- Starbucks Mocha FrappuccinoStarbucks mocha frappuccino 9.5 fl oz.$3.99
- Swiss Miss Hot ChocolateA packet of SwissMiss hot chocolate.$0.55
Ice Cream
- Local Homestead Creamery Vanilla8 oz.$4.85
- Local Homestead Creamery ChocolateChocolate ice cream cup 8 oz.$4.85
- Local Homestead Creamery Coffee Espresso8 oz.$4.85
- Local Homestead Creamery Mint Chocolate8 oz.$4.85
- Local Homestead Creamery Cookies And Cream8 oz.$4.85
- Blue Bunny Caramel Pecan PralineButter pecan with other natural flavors frozen dairy dessert, caramel swirls, praline pecans. 8 oz.$4.85
- Blue Bunny Cotton Candy8 oz cotton candy.$4.85
- Blue Bunny Rocky RoadChocolate frozen dairy dessert, marshmallow and fudge swirls, chocolaty dipped almonds. 8 oz.$4.85
Care Packages
- Fraternity PackageYour choice of 12 cookies, milk, 2 themed cups, 1 decal, 1 pen.$34.99
- Sorority PackageYour choice of 12 cookies, a milk, 2 themed cups, 1 decal and 1 ornament.$34.99
- Milk And Dark Chocolate Gobblers3 Milk and 3 Dark Chocolate Gobblers from a local chocolatier, The Chocolate Spike.$36.99
- I Love You PackageFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. Our exclusive love plush cookie character.$34.99
- Chocolate Lovers Package4 chocolate chip cookies. 2 double chocolate cookies. 2 triple chocolate cookies. 2 brownies. 1 milk.$30.99
- Stay Healthy12 cookies of your choice. 1 milk. 2 packets of Emergen - c. 1 hand sanitizer.$34.99
- Stay Warm PackageFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. 4 hand warmers (each lasting 7 hours), and 4 SwissMiss hot chocolate packets.$36.99
- VT Puzzle PackageFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. A 8" by 10" 30 piece puzzle from our 'i spy the cookie guy' game of either the Bridgeforth stadium or the quad.$30.99
- Happy Birthday Gift For An IndividualA dozen assorted traditional cookies. 2 brownies. 1 2% milk. 1 happy birthday balloon. 1 exclusive plush campus cookie . Birthday character. Whole milk, happy birthday balloon and plush campus cookie bday character.$36.99
- Happy Birthday Gift For A Group Package2 dozen assorted traditional cookies. 4 2% milks. 6 brownies. 1 happy birthday balloon. 1 exclusive plush campus cookie . Birthday character. 4 2% milks, happy birthday balloon and plush campus cookie bday character.$60.99
- Individual Study Package12 assorted traditional cookies. 1 campus cookie pen. 1 campus cookies notebook. 1 campus cookies stress ball cookie. Choice of your milk.$34.99
- Group Study Package4 dozen traditional cookies of your choice, 4 2% milks, 4 campus cookies pens, 4 campus cookies note pads, 4 campus cookies stress cookies.$96.99
- 6" Happy Birthday Bear With StarFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. A 6" plush happy birthday bear with star.$32.99
- 6 Smarty Bear PackageFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. 6" plush bear character.$32.99
- St. Patty's PackageFeaturing a dozen traditional cookies of your choice. A milk of your choice. A mini sequin plush shamrock, 4 shamrock plastic cups, 3 green and 3 gold coins, a shamrock necklace. 1st Half is sugar cookies with shamrock sprinkles.$30.99
Balloons
- 18" School Is Cool$4.99
- 21" VT Football$9.99
- 32" Foil Shape Back 2 School Pencil$9.99
- 18" Happy Birthday Sports$4.99
- 18" Birthday Colors Balloon$4.99
- 18" Brewster Bear Happy Birthday$4.99
- 18" Happy Bday Gift Box Shape$4.99
- 18" Happy Birthday Candles$4.99
- 18" Happy Birthday Party Hat$5.99
- 18" Happy Birthday Purple Heart With Flowers$4.99
- 18" Happy Birthday With Love$4.99
- 18" Monkey Around Birthday Balloon$4.99
- Mylar 18" Happy Birthday Twinkle Stars$4.99
- Mylar 18" Happy Birthday Glitters$4.99
- 14" (Smaller) Sunshine$3.99
- 18" Congratulations$4.99
- 18" Holographic Snowflake Sparkle Balloon Blue$5.99
- 18" Holographic Snowflake Sparkle Balloon White$5.99
- 18" Thinking Of You$4.99
- 18" You're The Best Bear Purple$4.99
- 23" Jumbo See Through Glass Beer Balloon$10.99
- 31" You're So Special Turtle$7.99
- Campus Cookies 18" Red Heart Shaped Mylar Balloon$4.99
- Mylar 18" Thank You Stars$4.99
- Mylar - 21" Chocolate Chip Cookie Balloon$5.99
- Mylar - 31" Sesame Street Cookie Monster$9.99
- 40 Inch Foil Eight Balloon$8.99
- 40 Inch Foil Nine Balloon$8.99
- 40 Inch Foil One Balloon$8.99
- 40 Inch Foil Two Balloon$8.99
- 40 Inch Foil Zero Balloon$8.99
- 12" Campus Cookies Latex Maroon With Orange Imprint$3.00
- 12" Campus Cookies Latex Orange With Maroon Imprint$3.00
- Black Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Green Latex Balloon$3.00
- Maroon Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Orange Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Purple Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Pink Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Red Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- White Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- Yellow Helium Filled Balloon$3.00
- 17" Happy Valentine's Pattern Hearts$4.99
- 18" Holographic Balloon Main Squeeze$4.99
JMU Accessories
- James Madison Bottle Opener Keychain Silver$6.00
- Purple Rhinestone Heart$7.00
- James Madison Bottle Opener Keychain Purple$6.00
- James Madison Spinner Keychain$8.00
- Medium Die Cut Decal$8.00
- James Madison 8-PC Tattoo Set$6.00
- James Madison The Quad Decal$8.00
- James Madison Medium Weight Adult Rain Poncho$14.00
- Campus Cookies Dipping MugA Ceramic Cookie Dipping Mug!$7.00
- Campus Cookies Stress CookieA cookie shaped stress ball with our logo on the front.$5.00
- Cookie Cake CutterPerfect to cut and scoop your cookie cake. Made of durable plastic, so you'll certainty be able to keep it for the future. Dishwasher safe!$5.00
- Campus Cookie AYour new best friend and travel buddy, exclusive plushy.$8.00
- Campus Cookie BChoc Fro.$8.00
- Campus Cookie CWCMN with Backpack.$8.00