Cafe Bella Mia Menu

635 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
  • Pizza

    • Cheese Pizza

      Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
      $14.95
    • Cheese Pizza Supreme

      $31.00
    • Margherita Pizza

      zesty plum tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & basil.
      $14.00
    • Sicilian Cheese Pizza

      $23.00
    • Sicilian Supreme Pizza

      $33.00
    • Grandma Pizza

      $23.00
    • Polynesian Pizza

      Glazed teriyaki chicken, pineapple & ham, topped with scallions & sesame seeds.
      $16.00
    • Shrimp Pesto Pizza

      Lightly fried shrimp in a pink pesto cream sauce.
      $21.00
    • White Pizza

      Ricotta, mozzarella & parmesan cheese.
      $15.95
    • Broccoli White Pizza

      Broccoli, ricotta & mozzarella cheese.
      $15.95
    • Creamy Spinach Pizza

      Sauteed onions, topped with mozzarella.
      $16.00
    • Eggplant Pizza

      Lightly fried eggplant, topped with mozzarella & zesty tomato sauce.
      $17.00
    • Bacon Chicken Ranch Pizza

      Maple glazed bacon topped with cheddar & ranch dressing.
      $18.00
    • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

      Topped with signature hot sauce & blue cheese.
      $18.00
    • BBQ Chicken Ranch Pizza

      Topped with bermada onions, cheddar, zesty bbq sauce & creamy ranch.
      $18.00
    • Chicken Ala Vodka Pizza

      Chicken cutlet in our signature vodka sauce.
      $18.00
    • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza

      Chicken cutlet with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
      $18.00
    • Sweet Chili Chicken Pizza

      Chicken cutlet with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
      $17.95
    • Chicken Florentine Pizza

      Chicken, broccoli, fresh plum tomatoes, mozzarella & parmesan cheese, drizzled with garlic & oil.
      $17.95
    • Garlic Knot Pizza

      $17.00
    • Eggplant Rollantine Pizza

      Eggplant rolled with ricotta & topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $17.00
    • Salad Pizza

      Mixed green salad topped with cold mozzarella.
      $17.00
  • Specials

    • 4 Heros Special

      Buy 3 heroes and get the 4th for free.
      $36.00
    • Regular Pizza First Responder Special

      $14.95
  • Tuesday Special

    • Baked Pasta Dishes Tuesday Special

      Includes a side salad, 2 garlic knots, dessert & a 12 oz. soda.
      $16.50
  • Wednesday Daily Special

    • All Day Regular Pizza Wednesday Special

      $14.95
  • Thursday Special

    • Chef Special's Thursday Daily Special

      Includes small salad, 2 garlic knots, dessert & a 12 oz. soda.
      $20.95
  • Sunday Special

    • 10 Wings, 12 Garlic Knots & A Regular Pizza & 2 Liter Bottled Of Soda Sunday Daily Special

      $37.95
  • Appetizers

    • Mozzarella Sticks

      Served with a marinara sauce.
      $8.95
    • Fritte Misti

      Fried zucchini, fried ravioli, fried calamari, mozzarella sticks.
      $17.95
    • Mussels

      Your choice of marinara sauce or garlic & oil.
      $16.95
    • Fried Calamari

      Served in a marinara sauce.
      $13.95
    • Calamari Picante

      Tossed with sliced cherry peppers, gaeta olives, artichoke hearts, roasted peppers & bermuda onions in a light marinara sauce.
      $14.95
    • Sweet Chili Calamari

      Topped with toasted sesames, served in a sweet chili glaze.
      $14.95
    • Buffalo Wings

      $17.95
    • Asian Wings

      Sweet chili unami & scallions.
      $17.95
    • Gorgonzola Wings

      Creamy gorgonzola with roasted garlic parmesan & parsley.
      $18.95
    • Rice Ball

      Stuffed with bolognese meat sauce.
      $4.95
    • Fried Ravioli

      $8.95
    • Baked Clams

      Stuffed with bread crumbs garlic celery & onions.
      $14.00
    • Mussels Gorgonzola

      Mussels sauteed in a creamy gorgonzola sauce.
      $21.00
    • Buffalo Calamari

      Tossed in buffalo sauce, served with bleu cheese dipping sauce.
      $18.00
    • Bruschetta

      Chopped plum tomato, fresh mozzarella & bermuda onion drizzled with olive oil balsamic glaze, garnished with fresh basil.
      $14.00
    • Fried Clam Strips

      $14.00
    • Fried Seafood Platter

      Calamari, clams, shrimp.
      $21.00
  • Soups

    • Tortellini Stracciatella Soup

      Italian style, spinach & egg drop.
      $6.95
    • Pasta Fagioli Soup

      $6.95
    • Lentil Soup

      $6.95
    • Italian Style Chicken Noodle Soup

      Chicken broth, sauteed onions, carrots, celery & fettuccine pasta.
      $6.95
  • Salads

    • Antipasto Salad

      Ham, salami, provolone, pepperoncini, olives, roasted red peppers & tomatoes over a bed of lettuce.
      $12.95
    • Caesar Salad

      $7.95
    • Garden Salad

      Romaine lettuce, cucumber, tomato, onions & olives, served with our house dressing.
      $8.95
    • Greek Salad

      Romaine lettuce, cucumber, plum tomato, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, red onions & feta cheese served with our house dressing.
      $10.95
    • Venetian Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tossed with walnuts, gorgonzola cheese, cranberries, apples & grilled shrimp in a raspberry balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
      $13.95
    • Avocado Chicken Salad

      Romaine lettuce, tossed with fresh avocado, grilled chicken, walnuts, dried cranberries & mandarin oranges with our signature sesame dressing.
      $13.95
    • Tomato Caprese Salad

      Beef steak tomatoes, thin sliced, prosciutto di parma & fresh mozzarella with fire-roasted peppers with olive oil, fresh basil & balsamic vinegar.
      $16.95
  • Side Orders

    • Meatballs

      $8.95
    • Sausage

      $7.95
    • Grilled Chicken

      $7.95
    • Sauteed Broccoli

      $7.95
    • Sauteed Spinach

      $7.95
    • French Fries

      $6.95
  • Pizza Sides

    • Spinach Wheels

      $4.95
    • Pepeproni Wheels

      $4.95
    • Garlic Knots

      $3.00
    • Pepperoni Bites

      $0.75
    • Buffalo Chicken Bites

      $1.25
  • Calzone & Rolls

    • Calzone

      Ricotta & mozzarella.
      $8.95
    • Ham Calzone

      $9.95
    • Italian Feast Roll

      Sausage, pepeprs, onions & mozzarella.
      $8.95
    • Roni Roll

      Pepperoni, ham, ricotta & mozzarella.
      $8.95
    • Chicken Roll

      Chicken parmigiana
      $8.95
    • Buffalo Chicken Roll

      $8.95
  • Heros

    • Chicken Caprese Hero

      Grilled chicken breast with fresh mozzarella, thick slice beefsteak tomato, topped with baby greens, five roasted peppers & atomic balsamic vinaigrette dressing.
      $13.95
    • Cold Italian Sub

      Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato & onion with house dressing.
      $13.95
    • Philly Cheese Hero

      Thin cut sirloin steak with caramalzed onions & cheese.
      $13.95
    • Chicken Polletti Hero

      Grilled chicken topped with sauteed broccoli rabe on a roasted hero.
      $14.95
    • Pepper & Eggs Hero

      $11.95
    • Potato & Eggs Hero

      $11.95
    • Sausage & Pepper Hero

      $11.95
    • The Sicilian Hero

      Grilled sausage with broccoli rabe & fersh five roasted peppers.
      $14.00
    • Grilled Chicken Hero

      With lettuce, tomato & onions.
      $15.00
    • Fried Chicken Hero

      With lettuce, tomato & onions.
      $15.00
  • Heros ala Parmigiana

    • Meatball Hero

      $11.95
    • Chicken Hero

      $13.95
    • Sausage Hero

      $11.95
    • Eggplant Hero

      $11.95
    • Coteletta Hero

      $13.95
    • Shrimp Hero

      $16.95
  • Wraps

    • Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap

      $11.95
    • Chicken Wrap

      Grilled or fried with lettuce & tomato.
      $11.95
    • Fried Eggplant Wrap

      With roasted peppers & mozzarella.
      $11.95
  • Italian Classics

    • Baked Ziti

      $14.95
    • Lasagna

      $14.95
    • Spaghetti With Meatballs

      Served with our delicious tomato sauce.
      $14.95
    • Baked Ravioli

      $14.95
    • Manicotti

      $14.95
    • Stuffed Shells

      $14.95
    • Trezzi's Trio

      Lasagna, ravioli & meatballs.
      $16.95
    • Ravioli With Meatballs

      $16.95
    • Grimaldi Delight

      Lasagna, chicken cutlet & meatballs.
      $21.95
  • Pasta Dishes

    • Tortellini Amelia

      Imported ham, mushrooms & caramelized onions in a creamy alfredo sauce. Signature dish.
      $20.95
    • Spaghetti With Red Clam Sauce

      $19.95
    • Spaghetti With White Clam Sauce

      $19.95
    • Penne Ala Vodka

      Rigatoni flambeed with vodka, tomato, bolognese, onions & scallions in a creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $19.95
    • Spaghetti Frutti Di Mare

      Clams, mussels, calamari, shrimp & lump crab meat tossed in a spicy plum marinara sauce over linguine.
      $26.95
    • Penne Bolognese

      Sauteed onions & ground beef in a creamy red tomato sauce.
      $19.95
    • Mussels Marinara

      Served over linguine.
      $19.95
    • Fettuccine Alfredo

      White creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $18.95
    • Fettuccine Carbonara

      Crispy bacon & sauteed onions in a white creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $19.95
    • Luca Pasta

      Topped with grilled chicken & fresh broccoli, sauteed with fresh basil & spices. Signature dish.
      $20.95
    • Gluten Free Penne

      Chopped broccoli & tomato with garlic & oil.
      $19.95
    • Pasta Fanatico

      Sauted mushrooms, asparagus & chicken in a creamy pink pesto sauce.
      $20.95
    • Shrimp Marinara

      Shrimp sauteed with garlic & olive oil in a san marzano marinara sauce over linguine.
      $24.95
    • Calamari Marinara

      Calamari sauteed with garlic & olive oil in a san marzano marinara sauce over linguine.
      $24.95
    • Stuffed Rigatoni Grimaldi

      Crispy chicken cutlets in a pink cream sauce topped with fresh mozzarella.
      $21.95
  • Chicken Entrees

    • Chicken Parmigiana

      Topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $20.95
    • Chicken Marsala

      Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
      $22.95
    • Chicken Francese

      Sauteed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
      $22.95
    • Chicken Bruschetta

      Sauteed in egg butter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Danielle

      Sauteed in egg batter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Gorgonzola

      Topped with gorgonzola sauce nestled over mashed potatoes.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Roma

      In a light pink brandy sauce with spinach & melted mozzarella.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Sorrentino

      Topped with prosciutto di Parma, breaded eggplant & topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Saltimboca

      Topped with prosciutto de Parma & fresh spinach, topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce
      $23.95
    • Chicken Napoli

      Sauteed with fresh funnel sausage, garden spinach & roasted peppers in a garlic white wine sauce.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Picanti

      Sliced cherry peppers, capers, artichoke harts& gaeta olives in a san Marzano plum tomato sauce.
      $23.95
    • Chicken Ala Vodka

      Flambeed with vodka, tomato, Bolognese, onions & chives in a creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $24.95
  • Cotoletta Entrees

    • Cotoletta Parmigiana

      Topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $20.95
    • Cotoletta Marsala

      Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
      $22.95
    • Cotoletta Francese

      Sauteed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
      $22.95
    • Cotoletta Bruschetta

      Sauteed in egg butter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Danielle

      Sauteed in egg batter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Gorgonzola

      Topped with gorgonzola sauce nestled over mashed potatoes.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Roma

      In a light pink brandy sauce with spinach & melted mozzarella.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Sorrentino

      Topped with prosciutto di Parma, breaded eggplant & topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Saltimboca

      Topped with prosciutto de Parma & fresh spinach, topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Napoli

      Sauteed with fresh funnel sausage, garden spinach & roasted peppers in a garlic white wine sauce.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Picanti

      Sliced cherry peppers, capers, artichoke harts& gaeta olives in a san Marzano plum tomato sauce.
      $23.95
    • Cotoletta Ala Vodka

      Flambeed with vodka, tomato, Bolognese, onions & chives in a creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $24.95
  • Shrimp Entrees

    • Shrimp Parmigiana

      Topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Marsala

      Sauteed in a marsala wine sauce with mushrooms.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Francese

      Sauteed in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Bruschetta

      Sauteed in egg butter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Danielle

      Sauteed in egg batter topped with broccoli & melted over mashed potatoes in a garlic cream sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Gorgonzola

      Topped with gorgonzola sauce nestled over mashed potatoes.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Roma

      In a light pink brandy sauce with spinach & melted mozzarella.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Rorrentino

      Topped with prosciutto di Parma, breaded eggplant & topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Saltimboca

      Topped with prosciutto de Parma & fresh spinach, topped with melted mozzarella in a madeira wine sauce
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Napoli

      Sauteed with fresh funnel sausage, garden spinach & roasted peppers in a garlic white wine sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Picanti

      Sliced cherry peppers, capers, artichoke harts& gaeta olives in a san Marzano plum tomato sauce.
      $29.00
    • Shrimp Ala Vodka

      Flambeed with vodka, tomato, Bolognese, onions & chives in a creamy parmigiana sauce.
      $29.00
  • Classic

    • Cafe Bella Mia Special

      Tender chicken cutlet & eggplant parmigiana.
      $20.95
    • Eggplant Rollatini

      Rolled eggplant filled with ricotta and topped with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $20.95
    • Eggplant Parmigiana

      Delicious eggplant baked with tomato sauce & mozzarella cheese.
      $20.95
    • Cotoletta

      Thin cut pork cutlets & golden fried shrimp with mozzarella & tomato sauce.
      $24.95
    • Grilled Chicken With Broccoli Rabe

      Grilled chicken topped with saluted broccoli rabe.
      $24.95
  • Desserts

    • Cannoli

      $4.95
    • Zeppole

      $1.00
    • San Giuseppe Canoli Stuffed Zeppole

      $4.95
    • Cinnamon Twists

      $1.25
  • Drinks

    • Soda

      $2.25
    • Snapple

      $3.25
    • Iced Tea

      $3.25
    • Vitamin Water

      $3.25

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

Nicky's Clam Bar
Nicky's Clam Bar
4.1
(387 Reviews)
Seafood, American, Bar
Chowder Bar
Chowder Bar
4.5
(421 Reviews)
Seafood
Lakehouse
Lakehouse
4.5
(1,367 Reviews)
New American, Restaurant
Whalers
Whalers
4.3
(746 Reviews)
New American
Nicky's on the Bay
Nicky's on the Bay
Seafood, Restaurant
Toast Coffeehouse
Toast Coffeehouse
4.4
(1,112 Reviews)
Breakfast, Brunch, Cafe
Salt & Barrel
Salt & Barrel
4.4
(950 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar, Oyster bar
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering
4.4
(1,959 Reviews)
Seafood, Bar, Restaurant
The Penny Pub
The Penny Pub
4.3
(364 Reviews)
Restaurant
Lala's Lounge
Lala's Lounge
4.3
(366 Reviews)
Bar & grill, Bar, Live music bar

© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms