Main Menu
- Shrimp Cocktail^Big beautiful jumbo shrimp served with Bynum's own hot-n-tangy cocktail sauce and lemon$12.00
- Boom Boom ShrimpLightly breaded shrimp tenders tossed in our remoulade sauce$13.00
- Onion FlowerA jumbo onion, cut to flower, hand battered and deep fried, served with our own special sauce$9.00
- Cheese BreadFrench bread baked just right with garlic and three cheeses$7.00
- Potato SkinsSmothered in mozzarella and cheddar cheeses, topped with real bacon and served with sour cream$10.00
- Crab CakesTender chunks of fresh lump crab cakes, skillet seared and topped with Bynum's slightly spicy take on remoulade sauce$12.00
- Stuffed Tater TotsTot-alistic fresh hand-made gold and crispy tots stuffed with bacon and a light, delicate cheesy center, served with Sante Fe Ranch$11.00
- Cajun Chicken SaladGrilled or fried Cajun chicken strips over lettuce with grated parmesan, onions, tomatoes and your choice of dressing$13.00
- Black & Bleu SaladBlackened strips of prime rib encrusted with bleu cheese and served over a bed of crisp greens with bacon and tomatoes$15.00
- Bynum's Chef SaladA crisp salad blend covered by finely chopped smoked hickory ham and oven roasted turkey, topped with crispy bacon bits, shredded cheddar cheese and a hard boiled egg$14.00
- Steak & ShrimpBynum's 14 oz NV strip and four breaded jumbo shrimp, a feast for a king or queen$33.00
- Sirloin For TwoThe flavor filled center cut is a meal for two or more, grilled to your liking$47.00
- SirloinA melt in your mouth 8 oz center cut of sirloin$23.00
- Tender TipsMouth-watering chunks of filet grilled to order$24.00
- Chopped SteakFresh ground filet grilled to order$22.00
- White Marble Farms Pork ChopsTwo bone in cut, thick and charbroiled$27.00
- Bynum's BBQ RibsFull rack, slow roasted to fall-off-the bone perfection$25.00
- Nibblers Can ShareWe invite you to share one of our delicious entrees; well include soup, salad, a side, and bread$12.00
- Prime Rib^Voted Best Prime Rib in Indy - Served daily after 4 pm. A true bone-in prime rib slowly roasted to perfection, served with horseradish sauce and au jus. Guaranteed to satisfy the hearty appetite. Sorry - when we're out, we're out - and we Do run out
- NY StripThis one's for the experienced steak eater$34.00
- FiletSheer heaven in the most tender cut of beef$29.00
- PorterhouseCombines the rich flavor of a strip with the tenderness of a filet$36.00
- Bone-In RibeyeWell marbled and bone-in for peak flavor, deliciously juice$38.00
- Half Rack Of Ribs To Any Entree$10.00
- Four Breaded Jumbo Shrimp$10.00
- Sliced Sautéed Mushrooms$3.00
- Sauteed Onions$2.00
- Bynum's Sweet Bourbon Glaze
- Garlic Butter And/Or Truffle Butter
- Bleu Cheese Encrusted
- Parmesan Horseradish Encrusted
- Baked Potatoloaded $2 extra
- Steak Friesloaded $3 extra
- Saffron Rice
- Broccoli
- Surf & TurfOur 7 oz filet paired with an 8 oz sweet warm water lobster tail from Madagascar
- Peppercorn Encrusted SalmonDelicious 8 oz Atlantic salmon rolled in spices and crushed peppercorns, then baked$20.00
- Breaded ShrimpEight succulent shrimp fried to a golden brown$19.00
- Parmesan Encrusted TilapiaTilapia coated in bread crumbs and shredded parmesan cheese, sauteed to perfection$20.00
- SwordfishA rich and meaty steak charbroiled and served with drawn butter$24.00
- Lobster^Sweet warm water lobster from Madagascar served with hot drawn butter, starting at 8oz and going up to at least 24oz
- Chicken ParmesanBoneless chicken breast breaded In our homemade batter and served over pasta with marinara sauce & parmesan cheese$21.00
- Roasted Chicken^A juicy, slow-roasted half chicken that's so good, you'll think we stole your Grandma's recipe! Crispy outside and fall-off-the-bone-tender inside, it's sure to be your new favorite, served with soup, salad and one side$19.00
- Chicken Fettuccini AlfredoGrilled all white meat chicken breasts tossed with fettuccini noodles, heavy cream, garlic, dry vermouth, grated parmesan cheese and served with a side of garlic toast, Matt's special recipe, Fabulous$21.00
- TenderloinGrilled or breaded pork tenderloin - the best Indy has to offer$11.00
- Bynum's ClubThinly sliced smoked hickory ham and oven roasted turkey on toasted thick sliced sourdough bread, topped with crisp lettuce, crispy bacon strips and Bynum's chipotle mayo - Sure to be the best club in town$11.00
- Chicken BreastBoneless chicken grilled to perfection, choose Cajun spices, zesty bleu cheese, or Bynum's homemade barbecue sauce$9.00
- Bleu Cheese BurgerHalf pound chopped steak with bleu cheese dressing$10.00
- Chicken ParmesanBreaded chicken with parmesan cheese and marinara on a toasted hoagie bun$11.00
- Chicken SaladOur special blend of chicken, fruits and nuts served on a fresh croissant$10.00
- Bynum's Signature Steakburger^Half pound chopped steak with mozzarella cheese and mushrooms$10.00
- Bynum's Smokehouse BurgerHalf pound burger with American cheese and smoked bacon$11.00
- Blackened Prime Rib^Slow roasted prime rib, blackened with Cajun spices and grilled to order$14.00
- Beef TipsMouth-watering chunks of filet grilled to order$16.00
- Chopped SteakFresh ground filet grilled to order, great with sauteed mushrooms and onions$14.00
- Roast Beef & CheddarThinly sliced prime rib baked in a hoagie and topped with melted cheddar cheese$15.00
- Bynum's CoffeeFresh brewed coffee with hot cocoa, topped with whipped cream and creme de menthe$3.00
- CoffeeReg or Decaf$1.50
- Hot Tea$2.50
- Iced Tea$2.50
- Sweet Tea$2.50
- Milk$2.50
- Fruit JuiceOrange, Cranberry$3.00
- Dasani Water$2.00
- Coke$2.50
- Diet Coke$2.50
- Mello Yello$2.50
- Mr. Pibb$2.50
- Sprite$2.50
- Lemonade$2.50
- Sprecher Brewery'sGourmet Grape Soda and Root Beer$3.25
Desserts
- NY Style Cheesecake
- Crème Brulee
- Chocolate Suicide
- Carrot Cake
- Fudge Brownie Cheesecake
- Homemade Cobblers
- Homemade Carmel Apple Cheesecake
- Belgian Chocolate Cheesecake
Menu Gallery
Menu Gallery
Menus may not be up to date.