By the Way Bakery Menu

4.6
(300+ Reviews)
$$Bakery
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Amy Cake

      a delightful little bundt cake with sprinkles inside and out
      $7.15
    • Schnibbles Mini Cake

      an over-the-top Devil’s food chocolate chip mini cake, for chocolate lovers only
      $7.15
    • The M Cupcake

      vanilla batter with chocolate frosting
      $5.50
    • Lemon Poppy Seed Cake

      Its spiral shape gives it a donut-like crust.
      $6.60
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies - Bag of 6

      like your favorite aunt used to make. Okay, maybe a little better - 6 cookies
      $16.50
    • Black & White Cupcake

      Devil's food cake with vanilla chiffon filling and frosting
      $5.50
    • Vanilla with Chiffon Cupcake

      vanilla batter with vanilla frosting
      $5.50
    • Almond Cookies - Bag of 6

      our award-winning cookie, with a crunchy exterior and a moist center - 6 cookies
      $16.50
    • Blueberry Muffin

      a cake-like muffin that's bursting with plump blueberries - 1 muffin
      $5.50
    • Whoopie Pie

      sweet, creamy filling sandwiched between two chocolatey cake-like cookies
      $8.25
  • Layer Cakes

    • Black & White - 6 inch

      Devil's food cake with vanilla chiffon filling and frosting - serves 6 to 10
      $55.00
    • Classic Chocolate - 6 inch

      moist cocoa-based chocolate cake and decadent chocolate frosting - serves 6 to 10
      $55.00
    • Coconut Cloud - 6 inch

      coconut layers with dreamy white frosting covered in coconut chips - serves 6 to 10
      $55.00
    • Sprinkle Cake - 6 inch

      an all vanilla layer cake covered in multicolored nonpareils
      $55.00
    • The M Cake - 6 inch

      vanilla layers with chocolate frosting inside and out - serves 6 to 10
      $55.00
  • Specialty Cakes

    • Chocolate Truffle Torte

      With deep chocolate flavor and a creamy texture.
      $49.50
    • Lemon Poppy Swirl

      A charming spiral-shaped bundt, it has just the right balance of tart and sweet.
      $44.00
  • Mini Cakes

    • Amy Cake

      a delightful little bundt cake with sprinkles inside and out
      $7.15
    • Lemon Poppy Seed Cake

      Its spiral shape gives it a donut-like crust.
      $6.60
    • Schnibbles Mini Cake

      an over-the-top Devil’s food chocolate chip mini cake, for chocolate lovers only
      $7.15
    • Whoopie Pie

      sweet, creamy filling sandwiched between two chocolatey cake-like cookies
      $8.25
    • Almond Spiral

      with a delicate crumb and a light orange glaze
      $7.15
  • Cupcake

    • Black & White Cupcake

      Devil's food cake with vanilla chiffon filling and frosting
      $5.50
    • Vanilla with Chiffon Cupcake

      vanilla batter with vanilla frosting
      $5.50
    • The M Cupcake

      vanilla batter with chocolate frosting
      $5.50
  • Bags of Cookies

    • Almond Cookies - Bag of 6

      our award-winning cookie, with a crunchy exterior and a moist center - 6 cookies
      $16.50
    • Biscotti Bag

      perfect for dipping in your morning coffee - 10 cookies
      $16.50
    • Chocolate Chip Cookies - Bag of 6

      like your favorite aunt used to make. Okay, maybe a little better - 6 cookies
      $16.50
    • Coconut Pecan Chewies - Bag of 6

      the coconut macaroon meets the chocolate chip cookie - 6 cookies
      $18.15
    • Fudge Brownie Cookies - Bag of 6

      a crispy-chewy-chocolatey treat - 6 cookies
      $16.50
  • Sweet Treats

    • Almond Cookie

      Our award-winning cookie, with a crunchy exterior and a moist center - 1 cookies
      $2.75
    • Chocolate Chip Cookie

      Like your favorite aunt used to make. Okay, maybe a little better - 1 cookie
      $3.03
    • Coconut Pecan Chewy Cookie

      The chocolate chip cookie meets the coconut macaroon - 1 cookie
      $3.30
    • Creme Puff

      our version of a donut hole filled with creamy custard - 1 puff
      $4.13
    • Fudge Brownie Cookie

      A crispy-chewy-chocolatey treat - 1 cookie
      $3.03
    • Linzer Tart

      the classic Linzer cookie filled with ruby-red raspberry jam - 1 cookie
      $4.13
    • Raspberry Bar

      luscious raspberry jam in a shortbread crust - 1 bar
      $6.60
  • Muffins

    • Blueberry Muffin

      a cake-like muffin that's bursting with plump blueberries - 1 muffin
      $5.50
    • Chocolate Chip Cinnamon

      With a brown sugar-based crumb topping.
      $5.50
    • Seasonal Scone

      golden on the outside, tender on the inside, as a scone should be - 1 scone
      $6.05
  • Snacks & more

    • Mo Mix Chocolate Hazelnut

      it will remind you of your favorite chocolaty spread
      $8.75
    • Mo Mix Coconut Almond

      like a tropical getaway in a bag
      $8.75
    • Mo Mix Pecan Chai

      a beautifully balanced blend of exotic spices
      $8.75
    • Baxter's Biscuits

      because your pup deserves gluten-free treats, too
      $6.55
  • Bread

    • Seeded Rustic Loaf

      a petite loaf with chia, flax, pumpkin, sesame, and sunflower seeds
      $17.00

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
  • Menu 2
  • Menu 3
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?


(212) 877-0806

2440 Broadway, New York, NY 10024


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms