Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Sandy Springs GA Menu

4.6

(450+ Reviews)

$Bakery

9" Pies 4" Pies Pie Pops! (NEW)2" pre-sorted pies 4 inch Pie for a Year 9 inch Pie for a Year Cookies

9" Pies
- 9" Granny's Apple
  Granny smith apples covered in brown sugar, butter, and spice, packed to peak into our crust and topped with our house made apple crumble.
  $37.00
- 9" Nanny's Pecan
  This Southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust. Voted “Best Pecan Pie” by Taste of the South for a reason.
  $37.00
- 9" I-40
  Named for Interstate 40, this pie connects people and hearts. It’s a twist on pecan pie and our best-seller. We fill the bottom of our signature shortbread crust with pecans, pour on velvety pecan pie filling, top it off with shredded coconut and chocolate chips, and then bake to perfection.
  $37.00
- 9" Chewy Chocolate Chip
  Like chocolate chip cookies? You’ll love this rich and gooey pie. Brown sugar, chocolate chips and vanilla combined and baked into a buttery shortbread crust.
  $37.00
- 9" Southern Custard
  Smooth, mild, and sweet, our buttermilk filling is like a cross between a chess pie and a sugar cookie. Simply delicious.
  $37.00
- 9" Key Lime
  Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling. We top this beauty with a generous border of our handmade whipped cream cheese topping and a citrus glaze.
  $37.00
- 9" Chocolate Cream
  This classic favorite is filled with thick and rich and chocolate cream , and topped with lightly sweetened fresh whipped cream, and garnished with chocolate shavings. (Available in Gluten Friendly)
  $37.00
- 9" Peanut Butter Cream
  A heartwarming pie that feels like home. Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust.
  $37.00
- 9" Coconut Cream
  Rich, creamy, and made the old fashioned way, our Coconut Cream Pie is reminiscent of the flavors of summer. Coconut custard is cooked, poured into our shortbread crust and toped with our baked Italian meringue. Another one of pies voted “Best of” by Taste of the South magazine.
  $37.00
- 9" GF Nanny's Pecan
  Our classic Nanny's Pecan pie, baked in a gluten-friendly crust.
  $40.00
- 9" GF I40
  Our best-selling favorite pecan pie with chocolate chips and coconut, baked in a gluten-friendly shortbread crust.
  $40.00
- 9" GF Chocolate Cream
  9 " Gluten - Friendly Chocolate Cream *** Must Order 24 hrs ahead ***
  $40.00
- 9" Snickerdoodle
  This pie is filled with a soft cinnamon sugar cookie base and baked in our shortbread crusts. Topped lightly with a subtle cinnamon sugar icing.
  $37.00
- 9" Lemon Icebox
  Add a little sunshine to your day with this refreshing blend of tangy citrus and sweet creamy filling in our buttery graham cracker crust. Of course, it wouldn't be complete without our signature, whipped cream cheese topping. Pretty and perfect for your Spring table
  $37.00
4" Pies
- 4" Pie Pack
  $27.50
- Dozen 4" Mini-Pies
  Pick and choose a variety of 12 mini pies! Price includes an automatic discount of $6!
  $84.00
- 4" Granny's Apple
  Passed down for generations, this pie harkens back to a simpler time and family traditions. Sliced apples are mixed with a perfect blend of sugar and spice before being covered with a generous brown sugar topping that bakes up to a delightful top crust.
  $7.50
- 4" Nanny's Pecan
  This Southern favorite is a perfect blend of toasted pecans and gooey filling enveloped in our buttery shortbread crust. Voted “Best Pecan Pie” by Taste of the South for a reason.
  $7.50
- 4" I-40
  Named for Interstate l- 40, this pie connects people and hearts. It’s a twist on pecan pie and our best-seller. We fill the bottom of our signature shortbread crust with pecans, pour on velvety pecan pie filling, top it off with shredded coconut and chocolate chips, and then bake to perfection.
  $7.50
- 4" Chewy Chocolate Chip
  Chocolate chip cookie dough filling baked into a buttery shortbread crust! Brown sugar, butter, chocolate chips and vanilla combine to create an irresistible pie that will take you back to a time when milk and cookies were shared after school with a friend.
  $7.50
- 4" Lemon Ice box
  Lemon Icebox (9") Avail. thru 4/22: Add a little sunshine to your day with its refreshing blend of tangy citrus and sweet creamy filling in our buttery graham cracker crust. Of course, it wouldn’t be complete without our signature, cream cheese whipped cream topping.
  $7.50
- 4" Southern Custard
  Smooth, mild, and sweet, our buttermilk filling is like a cross between a chess pie and a sugar cookie. Simply delicious.
  $7.50
- 4" Key Lime
  Our house made graham cracker crust is filled with our perfectly balanced key lime filling. We top this beauty with a generous border of our handmade whipped cream cheese topping and a citrus glaze.
  $7.50
- 4" Peanut Butter Cream
  A heartwarming pie that feels like home. Peanut butter and cream cheese are sweetened and whipped into a rich filling that is set into an Oreo cookie crust.
  $7.50
- 4" Chocolate Cream
  This classic favorite is filled with thick and rich and chocolate cream , and topped with lightly sweetened fresh whipped cream, and garnished with chocolate shavings. (Available in Gluten Friendly)
  $7.50
- 4" Coconut Cream
  Rich, creamy, and made the old fashioned way, our Coconut Cream Pie is reminiscent of the flavors of summer. Coconut custard is cooked, poured into our shortbread crust and toped with our baked Italian meringue. Another one of pies voted “Best of” by Taste of the South magazine.
  $7.50
- 4" GF Nanny's Pecan
  4" Gluten Free Nanny's Pecan. Must order 24 hours ahead**
  $9.00
- 4" GF I-40
  **Must order 24 hours ahead**
  $9.00
- 4" Snickerdoodle
  This pie is filled with a soft cinnamon sugar cookie base and baked in our shortbread crusts. Topped lightly with a subtle cinnamon sugar icing.
  $7.50
Pie Pops! (NEW)
- Chewy Chocolate Pie Pop (single)
  Bite sized chewy chocolate chip pies, half dipped in milk chocolate or white chocolate and served on a stick with the fun of a lollipop.
  $3.75
- Chewy Chocolate Pie Pop (half dozen)
  Bite sized chewy chocolate chip pies, half dipped in milk chocolate or white chocolate and served on a stick with the fun of a lollipop.
  $20.00
2" pre-sorted pies
1/2 2" COUNTER pre-assorted 2-inch pies $18.00 please provide 24 hour notice you get two of each flavor of key Lime .chocolate cream . and peanut Butter Cream packaged...
- 1 Dozen 2” Party Pies
  *Please provide a 24 hour notice before the desired pick-up to ensure we have the needed time to package and prepare your order Only flavors available are pecan, I-40, chewy chocolate, Key Lime, Peanut Butter Cream, and Chocolate Cream. You can mix and match quantities.
  $29.50
- 2 Dozen 2" Party Pies
  *Please provide a 24 hour notice before the desired pick-up to ensure we have the needed time to package and prepare your order Only flavors available are pecan, I-40, chewy chocolate, Key Lime, Peanut Butter Cream, and Chocolate Cream. You can mix and match quantities.
  $59.00
4 inch Pie for a Year
- 4 inch
  1 year of 4" pies (1 per month). A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life!
  $85.00
9 inch Pie for a Year
- 9 inch
  1 year of 9" pies (1 per month). A sweet & unique gift for the pie lovers in your life!
  $375.00
Cookies
- Cloud Cookies
  Introducing our newest addition to the Buttermilk Sky pie shop line up, dropped straight from Heaven, our Cloud Cookies. These pecan shortbread cookies are lovingly handmade and finished with a generous amount of powdered sugar. Packaged in a delicate layer of two dozen cookies per box, these treats are sure to please!
  $15.00
- White Vanilla Dozen
  White Vanilla Cookies
  $12.00
- White Vanilla Half Dozen
  White Vanilla Cookies
  $6.50
- Custom Color Thumbprint Cookies (5 Dozen- 48 Hr Notice!!)
  **Must have 48 hour notice** Pick your own custom color for your thumbprint cookies. Please list what color in the special instructions. The flavor will be our vanilla shortbread with vanilla icing with a minimum of 5 dozen thumbprint cookies.
  $50.00
- Lemon Dozen ( Seasonal
  $12.00