Butterly Bakeshop Menu

4.6
(125+ Reviews)
$Bakery
  • Customer Favorites

    Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
    • Birthday Cake Slice

      Vanilla bean Funfetti cake, vanilla bean buttercream.
      $10.50
    • Chocolate Cupcake

      Our decadent chocolate cupcake.
      $3.75
    • Vanilla Cupcake

      Our Tahitian vanilla bean cupcake.
      $3.75
    • Banana Pudding

      Pint full of the Quintessential summer dessert
      $12.00
    • S'mores

      Double chocolate cookie and graham cracker and toasted marshmallow.
      $4.50
    • Red Velvet Cupcake

      Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting.
      $4.00
    • Chocolate Chunk

      Our signature chocolate chunk cookie is a customer favorite.
      $4.50
    • GF Lemon Cupcake

      GF Vanilla bean cupcake, lemon curd, lemon buttercream
      $4.25
    • GF Oatmeal Cranberry

      Chewy and crunchy. Impossible to tell our signature oatmeal cranberry cookie is gluten free.
      $4.50
    • Vegan GF Chocolate Chip

      Vegan and GF wist to our classic Chocolate chunk
      $5.50
  • Cookies

    • Chocolate Chunk

      Our signature chocolate chunk cookie is a customer favorite.
      $4.50
    • Butter Pecan

      Butterful cookie studded with pecans and rounded with faint notes of espresso.
      $4.50
    • Vegan Birthday Cake Cookie

      Birthday Cake Cookie with a vegan twist
      $5.99
    • S'mores

      Double chocolate cookie and graham cracker and toasted marshmallow.
      $4.50
    • Nutella Cookie

      Double chocolate Nutella cookie, fleur de sel.
      $6.50
    • GF Oatmeal Cranberry

      Chewy and crunchy. Impossible to tell our signature oatmeal cranberry cookie is gluten free.
      $4.50
    • Vegan GF Chocolate Chip

      Vegan and GF wist to our classic Chocolate chunk
      $5.50
  • Cakes

    • Birthday Cake

      Funfetti cake, Vanilla Bean Buttercream
      $37.50
    • Brooklyn Blackout Cake

      Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
      $40.00
    • Strawberry Dream Cake

      Vanilla Bean Cake, cream cheese frosting, strawberry compote, vanilla bean buttercream
      $40.00
    • Lemon Blueberry Cake

      Vanilla Bean cake, Lemon buttercream , Blueberry compote
      $40.00
  • Cupcakes

    • Vanilla Cupcake

      Our Tahitian vanilla bean cupcake.
      $3.75
    • Blackout Cupcake

      Chocolate cupcake, chocolate pudding filling, Chocolate buttercream, chocolate drizzle and pearls
      $4.50
    • Chocolate Cupcake

      Our decadent chocolate cupcake.
      $3.75
    • GF Dulce De Leche Cupcake

      GF vanilla bean cupcake studded with butterscotch chips, dulce delete buttercream
      $4.50
    • Red Velvet Cupcake

      Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting.
      $4.00
    • GF Lemon Cupcake

      GF Vanilla bean cupcake, lemon curd, lemon buttercream
      $4.25
    • Vegan Cookies and Cream Cupcake

      Chocolate Cupcake topped with Cookies and Cream Frosting!
      $4.25
  • Bars and Individual Dessert

    • Carrot Loaf Mini

      Our signature carrot cake topped with our luscious cream cheese frosting.
      $7.99
    • Brownie Cheesecake

      Brownie and cheesecake swirled together, truly match made in heaven.
      $7.99
    • Chocolate Mousse Cake Jars

      Decadent chocolate mousses layered with our divine chocolate cake.
      $10.99
    • Fudgy Brownies

      Rich fudgy brownies topped with decadent chocolate ganache.
      $7.99
    • Red Velvet Whoopie Pie

      Red Velvet Cakey Cookie, Cream Cheese frosting
      $7.99
    • Apple Pie Cheesecake

      Apple pie and cheesecake in one bite, quintessential NY dessert!
      $7.99
    • French Macarons Classic Collection

      Pack of 6 Vanilla, chocolate, coffee, pistachio, raspberry, creme brulee
      $22.00
    • Banana Pudding

      Pint full of the Quintessential summer dessert
      $12.00
  • Cake By the Slice

    • Brooklyn Blackout Cake Slice

      Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
      $11.50
    • Birthday Cake Slice

      Vanilla bean Funfetti cake, vanilla bean buttercream.
      $10.50
    • Lemon Blueberry Cake Slice

      Vanilla bean cake, lemon buttercream, blueberry compote
      $11.50
    • Strawberry dreamCake Slice

      Vanilla bean cake, cream cheese frosting, strawberry compote, vanilla bean buttercream
      $11.50
  • Beverages

    • Bottled Water

      $1.99

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1

Menu Photos

  • Menu 1
Loading...

Know a great happy hour or special for this location?

People Also Viewed

First Cook
First Cook
3.8
(83 Reviews)
Chinese
Orange Grill
Orange Grill
4.4
(701 Reviews)
Fine dining, Bar, Japanese
Skyline Billiards & Bar
Skyline Billiards & Bar
4.5
(334 Reviews)
Bar, Restaurant
China Moon Open Kitchen
China Moon Open Kitchen
3.9
(169 Reviews)
Chinese
La Casa Bella
La Casa Bella
4.4
(1,061 Reviews)
Italian, Pizza
Uncle Louie G's
Uncle Louie G's
4.3
(79 Reviews)
Ice cream shop
Bake City Bagels
Bake City Bagels
4.3
(97 Reviews)
Bagel shop
Zinger Halal Express
Zinger Halal Express
4.5
(702 Reviews)
Halal
Love & Delicious Deli
Love & Delicious Deli
4.0
(27 Reviews)
Deli, Mexican
Draft Barn
Draft Barn
4.5
(463 Reviews)
Bar

(929) 276-3617

263 Prospect Park W, Brooklyn, NY 11215


© 2025 Checkle, Inc

Privacy

Terms