Butterly Bakeshop Menu

4.6

(125+ Reviews)

$Bakery

Customer Favorites Cookies Cakes Cupcakes Bars and Individual Dessert Cake By the Slice Beverages

Customer Favorites
Our most frequently ordered and highly rated selections.
- Birthday Cake Slice
  Vanilla bean Funfetti cake, vanilla bean buttercream.
  $10.50
- Chocolate Cupcake
  Our decadent chocolate cupcake.
  $3.75
- Vanilla Cupcake
  Our Tahitian vanilla bean cupcake.
  $3.75
- Banana Pudding
  Pint full of the Quintessential summer dessert
  $12.00
- S'mores
  Double chocolate cookie and graham cracker and toasted marshmallow.
  $4.50
- Red Velvet Cupcake
  Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting.
  $4.00
- Chocolate Chunk
  Our signature chocolate chunk cookie is a customer favorite.
  $4.50
- GF Lemon Cupcake
  GF Vanilla bean cupcake, lemon curd, lemon buttercream
  $4.25
- GF Oatmeal Cranberry
  Chewy and crunchy. Impossible to tell our signature oatmeal cranberry cookie is gluten free.
  $4.50
- Vegan GF Chocolate Chip
  Vegan and GF wist to our classic Chocolate chunk
  $5.50
Cookies
- Chocolate Chunk
  Our signature chocolate chunk cookie is a customer favorite.
  $4.50
- Butter Pecan
  Butterful cookie studded with pecans and rounded with faint notes of espresso.
  $4.50
- Vegan Birthday Cake Cookie
  Birthday Cake Cookie with a vegan twist
  $5.99
- S'mores
  Double chocolate cookie and graham cracker and toasted marshmallow.
  $4.50
- Nutella Cookie
  Double chocolate Nutella cookie, fleur de sel.
  $6.50
- GF Oatmeal Cranberry
  Chewy and crunchy. Impossible to tell our signature oatmeal cranberry cookie is gluten free.
  $4.50
- Vegan GF Chocolate Chip
  Vegan and GF wist to our classic Chocolate chunk
  $5.50
Cakes
- Birthday Cake
  Funfetti cake, Vanilla Bean Buttercream
  $37.50
- Brooklyn Blackout Cake
  Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
  $40.00
- Strawberry Dream Cake
  Vanilla Bean Cake, cream cheese frosting, strawberry compote, vanilla bean buttercream
  $40.00
- Lemon Blueberry Cake
  Vanilla Bean cake, Lemon buttercream , Blueberry compote
  $40.00
Cupcakes
- Vanilla Cupcake
  Our Tahitian vanilla bean cupcake.
  $3.75
- Blackout Cupcake
  Chocolate cupcake, chocolate pudding filling, Chocolate buttercream, chocolate drizzle and pearls
  $4.50
- Chocolate Cupcake
  Our decadent chocolate cupcake.
  $3.75
- GF Dulce De Leche Cupcake
  GF vanilla bean cupcake studded with butterscotch chips, dulce delete buttercream
  $4.50
- Red Velvet Cupcake
  Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting.
  $4.00
- GF Lemon Cupcake
  GF Vanilla bean cupcake, lemon curd, lemon buttercream
  $4.25
- Vegan Cookies and Cream Cupcake
  Chocolate Cupcake topped with Cookies and Cream Frosting!
  $4.25
Bars and Individual Dessert
- Carrot Loaf Mini
  Our signature carrot cake topped with our luscious cream cheese frosting.
  $7.99
- Brownie Cheesecake
  Brownie and cheesecake swirled together, truly match made in heaven.
  $7.99
- Chocolate Mousse Cake Jars
  Decadent chocolate mousses layered with our divine chocolate cake.
  $10.99
- Fudgy Brownies
  Rich fudgy brownies topped with decadent chocolate ganache.
  $7.99
- Red Velvet Whoopie Pie
  Red Velvet Cakey Cookie, Cream Cheese frosting
  $7.99
- Apple Pie Cheesecake
  Apple pie and cheesecake in one bite, quintessential NY dessert!
  $7.99
- French Macarons Classic Collection
  Pack of 6 Vanilla, chocolate, coffee, pistachio, raspberry, creme brulee
  $22.00
- Banana Pudding
  Pint full of the Quintessential summer dessert
  $12.00
Cake By the Slice
- Brooklyn Blackout Cake Slice
  Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
  $11.50
- Birthday Cake Slice
  Vanilla bean Funfetti cake, vanilla bean buttercream.
  $10.50
- Lemon Blueberry Cake Slice
  Vanilla bean cake, lemon buttercream, blueberry compote
  $11.50
- Strawberry dreamCake Slice
  Vanilla bean cake, cream cheese frosting, strawberry compote, vanilla bean buttercream
  $11.50
Beverages
- Bottled Water
  $1.99